Journal of the Korean earth science society (한국지구과학회지)

The Korean Earth Science Society (한국지구과학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Qualitative Meta-analysis on Students' Understanding of Earth Science Concepts from the Perspective of Collective PCK: Focusing on the Concepts of Greenhouse Effect, Global Warming, and Climate Change

집단적 PCK 관점에서 학생들의 지구과학 개념 이해에 대한 질적 메타 분석: 온실 효과, 지구 온난화, 기후변화 개념을 중심으로

  • Kwon Jung Kim (Department of Science Education, Kangwon National University) ;
  • Eui Seon Choi (Department of Science Education, Kangwon National University) ;
  • Ho Jun Kim (Department of Science Education, Kangwon National University) ;
  • Jae Yong Park (Department of Science Education, Seoul National University of Education) ;
  • Ki Young Lee (Department of Science Education, Kangwon National University)
  • 김권중 (강원대학교 과학교육학과) ;
  • 최의선 (강원대학교 과학교육학과) ;
  • 김호준 (강원대학교 과학교육학과) ;
  • 박재용 (서울교육대학교 과학교육과) ;
  • 이기영 (강원대학교 과학교육학과)
  • Received : 2024.06.04
  • Accepted : 2024.06.30
  • Published : 2024.06.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

In this study, a qualitative meta-analysis was conducted on research papers on earth science education to derive knowledge of students' understanding of specific science topics-greenhouse effect, global warming, and climate change-within the context of collective Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK). Twenty-two research papers addressing students' alternative conceptions (misconceptions) about these topics were selected and analyzed for their respective definitions, causes (mechanisms), and impacts. Semantic network analysis and a mental model framework were applied to synthesize the findings. The meta-analysis revealed several key insights: (1) Regarding the greenhouse effect, students often used the terms "greenhouse effect" and "global warming" interchangeably, lacked knowledge about the types of greenhouse gases, and misunderstood their roles. They commonly associated the greenhouse effect with environmental pollution or changes in the ozone layer, failing to recognize its relation to the heat balance between the surface and atmosphere. (2) Concerning global warming, students confused it with sea level rise and linked it to pollution, ozone layer changes, and glacier melting. They understood global warming as a disruption of the heat balance between the surface and atmosphere but had misconceptions about its environmental impacts. (3) In terms of climate change, students used the term interchangeably with global warming, weather change, and climate anomalies. They associated climate change with atmospheric pollution and ozone layer depletion but misunderstood its environmental impacts. As result, three mental models-categorical, mechanistic, and hierarchical misconceptions-were identified as collective PCK. The implications for enhancing earth science teachers' PCK were discussed based on these findings.

본 연구에서는 지구과학 교육 연구 논문들을 대상으로 질적 메타 분석을 통해 집단적 PCK (cPCK) 중 '특정 과학 주제(온실 효과, 지구 온난화, 기후변화)에 대한 학생 이해 지식'을 도출하고자 하였다. 이를 위해 온실 효과, 지구 온난화, 기후변화에 대한 학생 대체 개념(오개념)과 관련된 지구과학 교육 연구 논문 22편을 선정하여 각각의 정의, 원인(매커니즘), 그리고 영향에 대하여 분석하였다. 분석 결과를 종합하기 위해 언어 네트워크 분석, 정신모형틀을 적용하였다. 연구 결과는 다음과 같다; (1) 온실 효과에 대한 학생들의 개념 이해를 메타 분석한 결과, 온실 효과와 지구 온난화를 같은 의미로 사용하는 것으로 분석되었으며, 온실 기체의 종류를 제한적으로 알고 있고, 온실 기체의 역할을 이해하지 못하는 것으로 나타났다. 또한 온실 효과의 발생을 환경오염이나 오존층의 변화와 관련지어 생각하고, 지표-대기의 열수지 평형과 온실 효과를 관련짓지 못하는 것으로 분석되었다. (2) 지구 온난화에 대한 학생들의 개념 이해를 메타 분석한 결과, 지구 온난화를 해수면 상승과 같은 의미로 사용하는 것으로 분석되었으며, 지구 온난화의 발생을 환경오염, 오존층의 변화, 빙하의 융해와 관련지어 생각하고, 지표-대기의 열수지 평형이 깨져 지구 온난화가 나타나는 것으로 이해하고 있었다. 또한 지구 온난화가 환경에 미치는 영향을 잘못 알고 있는 것으로 분석되었다. (3) 기후변화에 대한 학생들의 개념 이해를 메타 분석한 결과, 기후변화를 지구 온난화, 기상 변화, 기상 이변과 같은 의미로 사용하는 것으로 분석되었으며, 기후변화의 발생을 대기오염, 오존층의 파괴와 관련지어 생각하는 것으로 분석되었다. 또한 기후변화가 우리 생활과 환경에 미치는 영향을 잘못 알고 있는 것으로 분석되었다. 이에 대한 분석 결과를 언어 네트워크 분석을 통해 종합한 결과, 집단적 PCK로서 3가지 정신모형(범주적 오해, 기제적 오해, 위계적 오해)을 표현할 수 있었다. 이와 같은 연구 결과를 바탕으로 지구과학 교사 PCK 개발을 위한 함의를 논의하였다.

Keywords

Acknowledgement

이 논문은 2022년 대한민국 교육부와 한국연구재단의 인문사회분야 중견연구자지원사업의 지원을 받아 수행된 연구임(NRF-2022S1A5A2A01038760)

References

  1. Baek, N.K., 2003, Pre-service elementary teachers' concepts of the greenhouse effect, ozone layer depletion, and acid rain. Journal of Environmental Science, 12(4), 367-373. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.5322/JES.2003.12.4.367
  2. Berg, T. and Brouwer, W., 1991, Teacher awareness of student alternate conceptions about rotational motion and gravity. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 28(1), 3-18. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.3660280103
  3. Byun, S.G., and Jang, M.D., 2015. Understanding of the greenhouse effect by sixth grade elementary school students. Elementary Science Education, 34(4), 434-446. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.15267/keses.2015.34.4.434
  4. Cho, H.H., 2015, Driver's alternative science conception. Kyoyookgwahaksa, Gyeonggi, Korea. (in Korean)
  5. Choi, M.Y., and Han, J.Y., 2014. Survey on high school students' conceptual understanding of acid rain, ozone layer, and greenhouse effect. Journal of Science Education Research, 29(2), 59-72. (in Korean)
  6. Clauset, A., Newman, M. and Moore, C., 2004. Finding community structure in very large networks. Physical Review E, 70, 066111.
  7. Cochran-Smith, M., and Lytle, S., 1999. Relationships of knowledge and practice: Teacher learning in communities. Review of Research in Education, 24, 249-305. https://doi.org/10.2307/1167272
  8. diSessa, A.A., 1993. Toward an epistemology of physics. Cognition and Instruction, 10, 105-225. https://doi.org/10.1080/07370008.1985.9649008
  9. diSessa, A.A., and Sherin, B.L., 1998, What change in conceptual change? International Journal of Science Education, 20(10), 1155-1191. https://doi.org/10.1080/0950069980201002
  10. Dogan, S., Pringle, R., and Mesa, J., 2015. The impacts of professional learning communities on science teachers' knowledge, practice and student learning: a review. Professional Development in Education.
  11. Dong, H.K. and Sim, J.H., 2013, An analysis of students' response types to constructed items concerning the 'green effect' in PISA 2006, The Journal of Yeolin Education, 21(2), 209-232. (in Korean)
  12. Gil, J. H., and Song, S. C., 2012. Elementary school students' understanding of climate change. Energy and Climate Change Education, 2(2), 125-132. (in Korean)
  13. Gil, J.H., and Song, S.C., 2012. Elementary school students' conceptual understanding of global warming. Journal of Biological Education, 40(4), 421-428. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.15717/bioedu.2012.40.4.421
  14. Gong, D.Y., 2008. Analysis of secondary students' perceptions of climate change for climate change education. Master's thesis, Ewha Womans University. (in Korean)
  15. Han, S., and Jeong, J.W., 2014. High school students' preconceptions on the causes and consequences of climate change. Journal of Science Education Research, 38(2), 430-442. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.21796/jse.2014.38.2.430
  16. Hargreaves, A., 2000. Four ages of professionalism and professional learning. Teachers and Teaching: History and Practice, 6, 151-182 p. https://doi.org/10.1080/713698714
  17. Hong, J.H., 2020. Study in conceptual understanding of preliminary teachers about the earth radiative equilibrium. Master's thesis, Kongju National University. (in Korean)
  18. Hong, J.Y., 2021. Pre-service biology teachers' perceptions of global warming, greenhouse effect, ozone layer depletion, and acid rain. Energy and Climate Change Education, 11(2), 165-173. (in Korean)
  19. Jang, M.D., 2015. Pre-service elementary teachers' understanding of key concepts related to the greenhouse effect. Elementary Science Education, 34(1), 15-31. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.15267/keses.2015.34.1.015
  20. Je, G.Y., and Ahn, H.S., 1999. Analysis of students' concepts about the greenhouse effect. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education, 19(4), 585-594. (in Korean)
  21. Jeong, S.I., and Yoo, E.J., 2021. Middle school students' understanding of radiative balance, greenhouse effect, and global warming revealed through heat budget data interpretation. Journal of the Korean Earth Science Society, 42(6), 770-788. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.5467/JKESS.2021.42.6.770
  22. Jones, M., Gardner, G., Robertson, L., and Rober, S. (2013). Science professional learning communities: Beyond a singular view of teacher professional development. International Journal of Science Education, 35(10), 1756-1774. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2013.791957
  23. Kim, S.C., 2007. Teachers' professional development processes in the cooperative learning association of Korea. Master's thesis, Sungkyunkwan University. (in Korean)
  24. Kim, S.C., and Yang, J.H., 2007. New possibilities for teaching culture through autonomous teacher research groups: Focusing on the background and motivations for participation. Korean Education, 34(3), 51-74. (in Korean)
  25. Kim, Y.R., and Choi, A.R., 2019a. Understanding of scientific inquiry developed by beginning science teachers in professional learning community. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education, 39(2), 221-232. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.30916/KERA.57.1.221
  26. Kim, Y.R., and Choi, A.R., 2019b. Inquiry-based science instruction perceived by beginning science teachers in a professional learning community. Journal of the Korean Chemical Society, 63(5), 360-375. (in Korean)
  27. Kim, Y.H. and Kim, Y.J., 2016, Social network analysis, Pakyoungsa. (in Korean)
  28. Kuk, D.S., 2003. Analysis of 10th grade science textbooks as a cause of misconceptions about the greenhouse effect. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education, 23(5), 592-598. (in Korean)
  29. Kwak, Y.S., 2004, Korean fifteen-year-olds' alternative conceptions on the greenhouse effect revealed in PISA test result. The Korean Association for Science Education, 23(5), 592-598. (in Korean)
  30. Kwak, Y.S., 2015. Exploring the developmental stages of teacher learning communities. Curriculum and Evaluation Research, 18(2), 83-104. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.29221/jce.2015.18.2.83
  31. Kwak, Y.S., and Kim, J.Y., 2016. Characteristics and challenges of Korean teacher learning communities. Curriculum and Evaluation Research, 19(1), 179-198. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.29221/jce.2016.19.1.179
  32. Kwak, Y.S., Baek, K.S., Lee, M.S., Min, J.W., and Kim, Y., 2013. Strategies to enhance teachers' capacity for school-level curriculum organization and operation. Korean Institute for Curriculum and Evaluation Research Report RRC 2013-7. (in Korean)
  33. Kwak, Y.S., Kim, J.Y., Hwang, P.A., Baek, J.M., Seo, Y.S., and Jung, S.S., 2015. Strategies to enhance teachers' capacity for school-level curriculum organization and operation (III) - Development and implementation of teacher learning community models. Korean Institute for Curriculum and Evaluation Research Report RRC 2015-4. (in Korean)
  34. Kwak, Y.S., Lim, S.Y., Min, J.W., Baek, I.H., and An, S.H., 2014. Strategies to enhance teachers' capacity for school-level curriculum organization and operation (II). Korean Institute for Curriculum and Evaluation Research Report RRC 2014-9. (in Korean)
  35. Lee, K.Y., and Park, J.Y, 2017. Exploring a Learning Progression for Integrated Process Skills in Earth Science Inquiry. Journal of the Korean Earth Science Society, 38(3), 222-238 p. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.5467/JKESS.2017.38.3.222
  36. Lee, K.Y., 2008, Pre-Service Teachers' Understandings on Earth Science Concept needed for an Integrated Approach: Exploring Mental Models about Eclipse Phenomena by Analyzing Phenomenological Primitives and Facets. Journal of the Korean Earth Science Society, 29(4), 352-362 p. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.5467/JKESS.2008.29.4.352
  37. Lee, H.W., 2014. Action research on the building of professional learning communities through the learning community system. Master's thesis, Seoul National University. (in Korean)
  38. Lee, J.S., Park, H.K., and Jeong, C., 2011. Elementary and middle school students' perceptions of global warming and climate change. Journal of Science Education Research, 35(2), 274-282. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.21796/jse.2011.35.2.274
  39. Lee, S.K., and Shin, M.K., 2017. School Sceince Education Discourse. Bookshill. (in Korean)
  40. Lee, S.S., 2014. Content analysis of academic papers using language network analysis methods. Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management, 31(4), 49-68. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.3743/KOSIM.2014.31.4.049
  41. Lee, S.Y, Jho, H.K. and Lee, B.W., 2021, Literacy survey of high school students on climate change - Focusing on climate change scientific concepts -. Energy and Climate Change Education, 11(3), 273-285. (in Korean)
  42. Lim H.J, Choi, S.Y., Park, H.Y., and Yeo, S.I., 2019, Understanding of applicants for science gifted education on the phenomena and problems of global warming. Energy and Climate Change Education, 9(3), 293-301. (in Korean)
  43. Myers, C., and Simpson, D. (1998). The whole-faculty study group: Lessons learned and best practice from classroom, districts, and schools. Thousand Oaks, Corwin Press.
  44. Nelson, T., 2009. Teachers' collaborative inquiry and professional growth: Should we be optimistic. Science Teacher Education, 93(3), 548-580. https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.20302
  45. Oh, C.S., 2014. A study on the reform and diffusion process of teacher learning communities. Doctoral dissertation, Korea University. (in Korean)
  46. Oh, E.S., and Kim, H.B., 2014. Analysis of mental models of the greenhouse effect by first-year middle school students. Teacher Education, 30(1), 237-252. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.14333/KJTE.2014.30.1.237
  47. Park, C.J., 2020. Social network analysis on internal decision-making organization of public broadcasting services in Korea: Focusing on the editorial board of MBC. Seoul National University, 24-25 p. (in Korean)
  48. Park, J.Y., and Lee, G.H., 2004. Understanding Students' Conceptions in the Research on Conceptual Change in Science: from Misconception to Mental Model. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education, 24(3), 621-637 p. (in Korean)
  49. Park, K.J., and Jung, D.H., 2014. Characteristics of earth system thinking among science gifted students related to climate change. Gifted Education Research, 24(2), 271-288. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.9722/JGTE.2014.24.2.271
  50. Park, S.Y., and Lee, C.S., 2009. Where does the misconception that global warming is caused by ultraviolet rays entering through the ozone hole come from?. Field Science Education, 3(2), 133-139. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.15737/ssj.3.2.200908.133
  51. Park, W.Y., and Seo, E.J., 2021. A study on the characteristics of middle school students' risk perception types of climate change. Environmental Education, 34(1), 63-80. (in Korean)
  52. Porter, T., 2014. Professional learning communities and teacher self-efficacy. Doctoral dissertation, Georgy Fox University.
  53. Schon, D., 1983. The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action. Aldershot, Ashgate.
  54. Seo, K.H., 2009. The possibilities and limitations of teacher learning communities as an alternative approach to teacher professional development. Korean Journal of Teacher Education, 26(2), 243-276. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.24211/tjkte.2009.26.2.243
  55. Seo, K.H., 2015. Teacher learning communities: An approach for developing group professionalism. Hakjisa. (in Korean)
  56. Shim, S.Y., 2020. Exploring how a high school science teacher's understanding and facilitation of scientific modeling shifted through participation in a professional learning community. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education, 40(1), 29-40. (in Korean)
  57. Shim, Y.T., Koo, W.H., Park, Y.H., Na, K.S., Hwang, Y.J., Ha, J.M., Kim, Y., Park, Y.K., Kim, M.H., Jang, J.E., Kim, N.S., Lee, H.K., Kim, M.J., Kim, N.G., Kim, J.W., Lee, H.M., Kim, B.S., Shim, S.H., Yoon, O.K., and Lee, S.K., 2019. The theory and practice of teacher learning communities. Education Community Bet. (in Korean)
  58. Shin, G.H., and Lee, S.J., 2022. Early childhood teachers' perceptions of climate change for climate change education. Journal of Children's Media Studies, 21(1), 255-278. (in Korean) https://doi.org/10.21183/kjcm.2022.03.21.1.255
  59. Sun, W.J., 2015, A case analysis on the study of elementary mathematics lesson based on teacher learning community. Master's thesis, Korea National University. (in Korean)
  60. Vosniadou, S., 1991. Conceptual development in astronomy. In S.M. Glynn, R.H. Yeany, & B.K. Britton (Eds.). The psychology of learning science. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 149-177.
  61. Wenger, E. Mcdermott, R., and Snyder, W. (2002). Cultivating communities of practice: A guide to managing knowledge. Harvard Business Review, 78(1), 139-146.
  62. Yang, J.E., and Choi, A.R., 2020. Pedagogical content knowledge for science practice-based instruction developed by science teachers in a teacher learning community. Journal of the Korean Association for Science Education, 40(5), 565-582. (in Korean)
  63. Yoo, H.H., 2011. A survey on the knowledge and behavioral perceptions of elementary, middle, and high school students and teachers about climate change. Master's thesis, Ewha Womans University. (in Korean)