The Korean Journal of Air & Space Law and Policy (항공우주정책ㆍ법학회지)

Korea Society of Air & Space Law and Policy (한국항공우주정책·법학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Comparative Review of the Satellite Remote Sensing

위성원격탐사에 관한 비교법적 고찰

  • Kim, Young-Ju (Department of International Trade, Daegu University)
  • Received : 2019.11.30
  • Accepted : 2020.03.20
  • Published : 2020.03.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The regulation of satellite remote sensing is generally included with the scope of statutes governing outer space activities. But not all states opted for dedicated satellite remote sensing regulation. The decision whether to do so depends in part on the specific capabilities of national satellite remote sensing programs. Five states that have dedicated statutes governing operations with remote sensing data are the United States, with its developed Landsat regime (the Land Remote Sensing Policy Act of 1992, LRSPA), Canada, with its Remote Sensing Systems Act, Germany, with its Satellite Data Securities Protection Act (SatDSiG), France, with its Law on Space Operations (LOS), Japan, with its Act on Ensuring Appropriate Handling of Satellite Remote Sensing Data. The major purpose of this article is to shed light on some legal issues surrounding remote sensing activities by comparative review. The paper analyzes international conventions or soft law and national law and policies relating to satellite remote sensing. It also offers some implications and suggestions for regulations of satellite remote sensing operations and satellite data.

본 논문에서는 위성원격탐사의 제도적 정비와 향후 입법 과정에서의 사전 참고로서 이와 관련한 법적 문제들을 검토해 보았다. 위성원격탐사와 관련해서는 광범위한 법적 논점들이 제기될 수 있으나, 본 논문에서는 위성원격탐사에 관한 운용규제와 위성데이터의 거래규제 문제들에 논의의 중심을 두고, 우리법상의 본격적인 입법론적 방안을 위한 선행 연구로서, 비교법적 검토를 시도하였다. 먼저 위성원격탐사와 관련한 국제우주법 체제를 우주조약 체제와 UN원격탐사원칙으로 구분하여 개관하였고, 위성원격탐사에 관한 주요국의 입법례를 살펴보았다. 입법 연혁에 따라 미국, 캐나다, 독일, 프랑스, 일본의 순서로 각 법규들의 성립 배경과 구체적인 입법적 구조 및 주요 내용 등을 구체적으로 분석해 보았다. 이후, 비교법적 검토를 토대로, 위성원격탐사 법제 정비와 관련한 몇 가지 논점들을 상정하여, 시사점 내지 개별적인 의견 등을 제시하였다. 2020년 현재까지 '국내 입법'으로 위성원격탐사에 관한 법제 정비를 시도한 국가들로는 미국, 캐나다, 독일, 프랑스, 일본이 유일하다. 이들 국가들은 자체적인 위성 운용시스템과 위성데이터보호에 관한 입법적 체계를 마련하여, 위성원격탐사에 관한 법률적 규율을 실시하고 있다. 우리나라도 2010년부터 '천리안 위성'을 운용하며 해양·기상 관측을 행하고 있는 위성원격탐사 수행국이라 할 수 있는데, 아직 그와 관련한 법제는 몇 가지의 정부 훈령을 제외하고는 마련되지 않은 상황이다. 그러나 위성데이터의 활용 플랫폼이 큰 폭으로 변화하고 있고, 소형 관측위성의 개발도 고려할 수 있는 지금, 데이터에 대한 접근성과 활용도는 향후 큰 폭으로 상승할 것이다. 이러한 점들을 고려할 때, 우리나라에서도 관측위성시스템과 위성데이터를 종합적으로 관리할 수 있는 입법 추진이 필요할 것으로 보인다. 특히 국가안보와 정보보안의 측면에서도 위성데이터에 대한 일정한 보급규제가 제도적으로 필요할 것이다.

Keywords

References

  1. 김종복, 신우주법, 한국학술정보, 2011.
  2. 김영주, "위성원격탐사에 관한 상사법적 쟁점", 기업법연구 제33권 제4호, 한국기업법학회, 2019. 12.
  3. 김한택, 우주법, 와이북스, 2016.
  4. 서영득, "미국의 지상원격탐사 통제제도", 항공우주법학회지 제20권 제1호, 한국우주법학회, 2005. 6.
  5. 宇賀克也, 逐条解説 宇宙二法(弘文堂, 2019).
  6. 宇賀克也, 宇宙活動法における損害賠償制度の検討 ジュリスト1506号(有斐閣, 2017).
  7. 小塚荘一郎= 佐藤雅彦(編), 宇宙ビジネスのための宇宙法入門(第2版)(有斐閣, 2015).
  8. 小塚荘一郎= 青木節子, 宇宙2法の背景と実務上の留意点 NBL 1090号(商事法務, 2017).
  9. 小塚荘一郎= 横山経通, 衛星リモートセンシング事業と情報法 NBL 1127号(商事法務, 2018).
  10. 佐藤耕平, 衛星リモートセンシング記録の適正な取扱いの確保に関する法律(衛星リモセン法)の概要について ジュリスト 1506号(有斐閣, 2017).
  11. 行松泰弘, 人工衛星等の打上げ及び人工衛星の管理に関する法律(宇宙活動法)の概要について ジュリスト 1506号(有斐閣, 2017).
  12. 新谷美保子, 衛星リモートセンシング法の概説と衛星データ活用の未来 NBL 1109号(商事法務, 2017).
  13. 宇宙政策委員会, 宇宙産業ビジョン2030 (日本内閣府, 2017).
  14. 内閣府宇宙開発戦略推進事務局, 宇宙2法(人工衛星等の打上げ及び人工衛星の管理に関する法律、衛星リモートセンシング記録の適正な取扱いの確保に関する法律) の制定について NBL 1093号(商事法務, 2017).
  15. 内閣府宇宙開発戦略推進事務局, 衛星リモセン法における装置.記録に係る基準等と 衛星リモートセンシングデータの利活用の推進に関する基本的考え方について (日本内閣府, 2017).
  16. 内閣府宇宙開発戦略推進事務局, 宇宙二法の成立を踏まえた今後の宇宙産業振興のための環境整備について (日本内閣府, 2016).
  17. 内閣官房宇宙開発戦略本部事務局, 我が国及び海外のリモートセンシングの現状と動向 (日本内閣官房, 2009).
  18. Phillipe Achilleas, French Remote Sensing Law, 34 J. Space L. 1(2008).
  19. Eleonora Ambrosetti, Remote Sensing from Outer Space: Its Significance and Problems from a Third World Perspective, 17 N.Y.U. J. Int'l L. & Pol. 1(1984).
  20. Setsuko Aoki, Japanese Law and Regulations concerning Remote Sensing Activities, 36 J. Space L. 335(2010).
  21. Clemens Arzt, Use of Satellite Imagery in Legal Proceedings, 24 Air & Space L. 195(1999).
  22. John C. Baker, Kevin M. O'Connell & Ray Williamson eds., Commercial Observation Satellites: At the Leading Edge of Global Transparency(RAND, 2001).
  23. Michel Bourely, Legal Problems Posed by the Commercialization of Data Collected by the European Remote Sensing Satellite ERS-1, 16 J. Space L. 129(1988).
  24. Timothy J. Brennan & Molly K. Macauley, Remote Sensing Satellites: A Framework for Policy Assessment, 4 L. Computer & Artificial Intell. 233(1995).
  25. James B. Campbell & Randolph H. Wynne, Introduction to Remote Sensing 162-166 (5th eds., Guilford Press, 2011).
  26. Carl Q. Christol, Remote Sensing in an Era of Global Warming, in Legal Aspects of Satellite Applications: Navigation and Remote Sensing, 50 Proc. on L. Outer Space 405(2007).
  27. Carl Q. Christol, Hurricanes and Remote Sensing, in Session 2: Legal Aspects of Disaster Management, 49 Proc. on L. Outer Space 90(2006).
  28. Carl Q. Christol, Remote Sensing and International Space Law, 16 J. Space L. 21 (1988).
  29. Carl Q. Christol, 1986 Remote Sensing Principles: Emerging or Existing Law, in The United Nations and Legal Problems of Remote Sensing, 30 Proc. on L. Outer Space 268(1987).
  30. Carl Q. Christol, The Modern International Law of Outer Space Law(Pergamon Press, 1982).
  31. Emilio Chuvieco & Alfredo Huete, Fundamentals of Satellite Remote Sensing: An Environmental Approach(2nd ed., CRC Press, 2016).
  32. Charles M. Dalfen, The International Legislative Process: Direct Broadcasting and Remote Earth Sensing by Satellite Compared, 10 Can. Y.B. Int'l L. 186(1972). https://doi.org/10.1017/S0069005800000102
  33. Gennady M. Danilenko, Principles Relating to Remote Sensing of the Earth from Space: Territorial Sphere of Application, 30 Proc. on L. Outer Space 289(1987).
  34. Paul Stephen Dempsey, National Laws Governing Commercial Space Activities: Legislation, Regulation, & Enforcement, 36 Nw. J. Int'l L. & Bus. 1(2016).
  35. Hamilton DeSaussure, Remote Sensing Satellite Regulation by National and International Law, 15 Rutgers Computer & Tech. L.J. 351(1989).
  36. Hamilton DeSaussure, Remote Sensing: The Interaction of Domestic and International Law, in The United Nations and Legal Problems of Remote Sensing, 30 Proc. on L. Outer Space 295(1987).
  37. Hamilton DeSaussure, Remote Sensing by Satellite; What Future for an International Regime, 71 Am. J. Int'l L. 707(1977). https://doi.org/10.2307/2199582
  38. I. H. Ph. Diederiks-Verschoor, Current Issues in Remote Sensing, 5 Mich. YBI Legal Stud. 305(1984).
  39. Michael S. Dodge, Earth Observation and the Needs of the Many: the Future Structure of International Disaster Relief and Disaster Management, 39 Annals Air & Space L. 355(2014).
  40. Frans G. von der Dunk & Fabio Tronchetti eds., Handbook of Space Law(Edward Elgar Pub., 2015).
  41. Frans G. von der Dunk, Private Enterprise and Public Interest in the European 'Spacescape': Towards Harmonized National Space Legislation for Private Space Activities in Europe(Leiden University, 1998).
  42. William Emery & Adriano Camps, Introduction to Satellite Remote Sensing: Atmosphere, Ocean, Land and Cryosphere Applications(Elsevier, 2017).
  43. Harry Feder, The Sky's the Limit - Evaluating the International Law of Remote Sensing, 23 N.Y.U. J. Int'l L. & Pol. 599(1991).
  44. Clemens A. Feinaeugle, The UN Principles on Remote Sensing and the Gats: Conflicts or Peaceful Co-Existence, in Legal Aspects of Satellite Applications: Navigation and Remote Sensing, 50 Proc. on L. Outer Space 369(2007).
  45. Stefano Ferretti ed., Space Capacity Building in the XXI Century(Springer, 2020).
  46. Jose Monserrat Filho, A Remote Sensing Convention for the Advancement of Space Law, in Legal Aspects of Applications and Private Space Activities, 46 Proc. on L. Outer Space 63(2003).
  47. Annette Froehlich & Vincent Seffinga eds., National Space Legislation: A Comparative and Evaluative Analysis(Springer, 2018).
  48. Joanne Irene Gabrynowicz, One Half Century and Counting: The Evolution of U.S. National Space Law and Three Long-Term Emerging Issues, 4 Harv. L. & Pol'y Rev. 405(2010).
  49. Joanne Irene Gabrynowicz, The Perils of Landsat from Grassroots to Globalization: A Comprehensive Review of US Remote Sensing Law with A Few Thoughts for the Future, 6 Chi. J. Int'l L. 45(2005).
  50. Joanne Irene Gabrynowicz, The Promise and Problems of the Land Remote Sensing Policy Act of 1992, 9 Space Pol'y 319(1993). https://doi.org/10.1016/0265-9646(93)90043-9
  51. Allison F. Gardner, Environmental Monitoring's Undiscovered Country: Developing A Satellite Remote Monitoring System to Implement the Kyoto Protocol's Global Emissions-Trading Program, 9 N.Y.U. Envtl. L.J. 152(2000).
  52. Karen Geer, The Constitutionality of Remote Sensing Satellite Surveillance in Warrantless Environmental Inspections, 3 Fordham Envtl. L. Rep. 43(1991).
  53. Paul Gibson, Introductory Remote Sensing Principles and Concepts(Routledge, 2000).
  54. Thomas Gillon, Regulating Remote Sensing Space Systems in Canada - New Legislation for a New Era, 34 J. Space L. 19(2008).
  55. Harald Ginzky, Satellite Images as Evidence in Legal Proceedings relating to the Environment- A US Perspective, 25 Air & Space L. 114(2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1008734323071
  56. Stephen Gorove, Developments in Space Law: Issues and Policies(Springer, 1991).
  57. Brian D. Green, Space Situational Awareness Data Sharing: Safety Tool or Security Threat?, 75 A.F. L. Rev. 39(2016).
  58. David A. Greenburg, Third Party Access to Data Obtained via Remote Sensing: International Legal Theory versus Economic and Political Reality, 15 Case W. Res. J. Int'l L. 361(1983).
  59. Ray Harris ed., Earth Observation Data Policy and Europe(CRC Press, 2002).
  60. Cynthia M. Hayward, Remote Sensing: Terestrial Laws for Celestial Activities, 8 B.U. Int'l L.J. 157(1990).
  61. Mahulena Hofmann, International Legal Framework of Remote Sensing in the Year 2005: Changed Conditions and Changed Needs, in IISL/ECSL Space Law Symposium 2005 Held on the Occassion of the 44th Session of the Legal Subcommittee of UNCOPUOS, 48 Proc. on L. Outer Space 498(2005).
  62. Gary L. Hopkins, Legal Implications of Remote Sensing of Earth Resources by Satellite, 78 Mil. L. Rev. 57(1977).
  63. Mahulena Hoskova, Legal Aspects of Using Remote Sensing Systems as National Technical Means of Verification, in Confidence Building and Commercial Interests in Space, 41 Proc. on L. Outer Space 89(1998).
  64. Michael R. Hoversten, U.S. National Security and Government Regulation of Commercial Remote Sensing from Outer Space, 50 A.F. L. Rev. 253(2001).
  65. Atsuyo Ito, Legal Aspects of Satellite Remote Sensing(Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2011).
  66. Atsuyo Ito, Improvement to the Legal Regime for the Effective Use of Satellite Remote Sensing Data for Disaster Management and Protection of the Environment, 34 J. Space L. 45(2008).
  67. Susan M. Jackson, Cultural Lag and the International Law of Remote Sensing, 23 Brook. J. Int'l L. 853(1998).
  68. Ram S. Jakhu ed., National Regulation of Space Activities(Springer, 2010).
  69. Ram S. Jakhu & Paul Stephen Dempsey eds., Routledge Handbook of Space Law (Routledge, 2017).
  70. Ram S. Jakhu & Aram Daniel Kerkonian, Independent Review of the Remote Sensing Space Systems Act(Institute of Air and Space Law, McGill University, Feb. 2017).
  71. Christopher C. Joyner & Daegan R. Miller, Selling Satellites: The Commercialization of LANDSAT, 26 Harv. Int'l L.J. 63(1985).
  72. Paul B. Larsen, The Oso Landslide: Disaster Management Law in the Space Age, 40 Wm. & Mary Envtl. L. & Pol'y Rev. 335(2016).
  73. Howard A. Latin, Gary W. Tennehill & Robert E. White, Remote Sensing Evidence and Environmental Law, 64 Cal. L. Rev. 1300(1976). https://doi.org/10.2307/3480040
  74. Ricky J. Lee & Sarah L. Steele, Military Use of Satellite Communications, Remote Sensing, and Global Positioning Systems in the War on Terror, 79 J. Air L. & Com. 69(2014).
  75. Aylia Licor, Satellite Remote Sensing: Commercialization of Remote Sensing - Is the Use of Satellite Derived Information for Military Purposes in Violation of the Peaceful Purposes Provision of the Outer Space Treaty, 14 ILSA J. Int'l & Comp. L. 207(2007).
  76. Francis Lyall & Paul B. Larsen, Space Law: A Treatise(Routledge, 2016).
  77. Jean-Louis Magdelenat, The Major Issues in the Agreed Principles on Remote Sensing, 9 J. Space L. 111(1981).
  78. Bruce W. Mann, First License Issued under Canada's Remote Sensing Satellite Legislation, 34 J. Space L. 67(2008).
  79. Bruce W. Mann, Drafting Legislation to Regulate Commercial Remote sensing Satellites: A How-to Guide from Canada, in Session 3: Cooperation in Space Activities with Special Focus on Remote Sensing, 49 Proc. on L. Outer Space 280(2006).
  80. Kenneth J. Markowitz, Legal Challenges and Market Rewards to the Use and Acceptance of Remote Sensing and Digital Information as Evidence, 12 Duke Envtl. L. & Pol'y F. 219(2001).
  81. D. S. Myers, United Nations Activity on Remote Sensing: Legal and Political Implications, 30 Proc. on L. Outer Space 362(1987).
  82. R. Oosterlinck, Legal Protection of Remote Sensing Data, in Space Law and Domestic Law, 27 Proc. on L. Outer Space 112(1984).
  83. Nathalie Pettorelli, Satellite Remote Sensing and the Management of Natural Resources(Oxford Univ. Press, 2019).
  84. Dirk-Meints Polter, Remote Sensing and State Sovereignty, 4 J. Space L. 99(1976).
  85. Raphael Prober, Shutter Control: Confronting Tomorrow's Technology with Yesterday's Regulations, 19 J. L. & Pol. 203(2003).
  86. Ray Purdy & Denise Leung eds., Evidence from Earth Observation Satellites: Emerging Legal Issues(Martinus Nijhoff, 2012).
  87. Brenda Reddix-Smalls, Satellite Remote Sensing and Database Management: Who Owns the Digitized Information Relating to Indigenous People and Their Artifacts, 37 N.C. Cent. L. Rev. 1(2014).
  88. Margaret A. Roberts, U.S. Remote Sensing Data from Earth Observation - Law, Policy and Practice, in Legal Aspects of Sharing Benefits from the Conduct of Space Activities, 39 Proc. on L. Outer Space 105(1996).
  89. Olivier Juillet de Saint-Lager, Remote Sensing Systems: The International Dimension, in Legal Aspects of International Cooperation in Space, 26 Proc. on L. Outer Space 259(1983).
  90. Patrick A. Salin, An Overview of US Commercial Space Legislation and Policies: Present and Future, 27 Air & Space L. 209(2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016366808610
  91. Patrick A. Salin, Analysis of Several Bilateral Remote-Sensing Contracts between Satellite Operators and Ground-Stations, 1992 Int'l Bus. L.J. 219(1992).
  92. Patrick A. Salin, Proprietary Aspects of Commercial Remote-Sensing Imagery, 13 Nw. J. Int'l L. & Bus. 349(1992).
  93. Gabriella Catalano Sgrosso, Sharing of Remote Sensing Data Concerning Environmental Protection for Public Benefit, in Legal Aspects of Sharing Benefits from the Conduct of Space Activities, 39 Proc. on L. Outer Space 94(1996).
  94. Youssef Sneifer, The Implications of National Security Safeguards on the Commercialization of Remote Sensing Imagery, 19 Seattle U. L. Rev. 539(1996).
  95. Howard J. Taubenfeld, Regime for Outer Space, 56 Nw. U. L. Rev. 129(1961).
  96. Elizabeth Seebode Waldrop, Integration of Military and Civilian Space Assets: Legal and National Security Implications, 55 A.F. L. Rev. 157(2004).
  97. Jefferson H. Weaver, Lessons in Multilateral Negotiations: Creating a Remote Sensing Regime, 7 Temp. Int'l & Comp. L.J. 29(1993).
  98. J. Richard West, Copyright Protection For Data Obtained By Remote Sensing: How The Data Enhancement Industry Will Ensure Access For Developing Countries, 11 Nw. J. Int'l L. & Bus. 403(1990).
  99. Maureen Williams, The UN Principles on Remote Sensing Today, in Session 1: Legal Issues Related to New Developments in Space Applications: Navigation, Remote Sensing and GIS, 48 Proc. on L. Outer Space 2(2005).
  100. Ray A. Williamson & John C. Baker, US Remote Sensing Policies: Opportunities and Challenges, 30 Space Pol'y 109(2004).
  101. Gerd Winter, Access of the Public to Environmental Data from Satellite Remote Sensing, 6 J. Envtl. L. 43(1994). https://doi.org/10.1093/jel/6.1.43
  102. Michael Gerhard / Max Kroymann / Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd, Ein Gesetz fur die Raumfahrt: Das Neue Satellitendatensicherheitsgesetz, ZLW 57. Jg. 1/2008.
  103. Marcus Schladebach, Die Verwendung von Satellitenbildern in nationalen Gerichtsverfahren, ZLW 63. Jg. 3/2014.
  104. Elmar Wins-Seemann, Das Satellitendatensicherheitsgesetz aus Industrieller Sicht - Angemessener Rahmen fur die Kommerzielle Nutzung von Weltraumgestutzten Fernerkundungssystemen, ZLW 57. Jg. 1/2008.
  105. Jurgen Cloppenburg, Jungste Entwicklungen im U.S.-Amerikanischen Aussenwirtschaftsrecht - Die Regulierung von Hochtechnologieexporten und ihr Einfluss auf die betroffenen Wirtschaftszweige am Beispiel der amerikanischen Satellitenindustrie, ZLW 50. Jg. 4/2001.