A Study on Site Evaluation Process for Thalassotherapy Complex

해양치유단지 조성을 위한 입지평가프로세스에 관한 연구

Abstract

The objective of this study is to suggest the evaluation method, the evaluation index and items, and evaluation criteria for rational and systematic evaluation of the thalassotherapy complex site. Evaluation items and indicators are determined based on overseas cases of thalassotherapy complex, the central governments' thalassotherapy business policy, and the local governments business plan. 3 major evaluation items, 8 middle evaluation items, 5 small evaluation items and 26 evaluation indexes are selected as evaluation items. The evaluation criterion for each evaluation index is then determined. As per the evaluation process, first, weights are assigned to the evaluation items by an evaluation committee composed of experts. Secondly, each committee member assigns a weight and a score to each evaluation indicator for evaluation score calculation. This score is then multiplied by the weight of the evaluation item to determine the final score for each evaluation index. The ultimate scores of all the evaluation indexes are then added to the evaluation score of each committee member. Lastly, the arithmetic mean of the evaluation scores of all committee members becomes the final evaluation result of a site.

본 연구는 해양치유단지의 조성을 위한 입지평가에 대한 연구로서 평가항목 및 평가지표를 도출하고 평가방법을 제안하였다. 입지평가를 위한 평가항목과 평가지표를 정하기 위해 해양치유단지 해외사례를 조사하고 선행 유사사업의 입지평가사례를 분석하였다. 정부의 해양치유산업 관련 정책 및 지자체 사업계획 등을 고려하여 3개 대분류 평가항목, 8개 중분류 평가항목, 5개 소분류 평가항목, 26개 평가지표를 정하였으며 각 평가지표별 평가기준을 정하였다. 평가방법은 먼저 전문가로 구성된 평가위원회에서 평가항목별 가중치를 부여하고 다음으로 각 평가위원이 개별 평가지표에 대해 가중치와 점수를 부여하여 평가점수를 산정한다. 이 평가점수에 평가항목별 가중치를 곱하여 평가지표별 최종점수를 정하고 모든 평가지표의 최종점수들을 합하면 각 평가위원의 평가점수가 되며 평가위원들 평가점수를 산술평균하면 대상지 입지평가결과가 된다.

Fig. 1 Composition of thalassotherapy complex

Fig. 2 Site evaluation process

Fig. 3 Evaluation score calculation(for each member)

Table 1 Major thalassotherapy complexes in France

Table 2 Major Thalassotherapy complexes in Germany

Table 3 Major Thalassotherapy complexes in Japan

Table 4 Site evaluation of tourist leisure complex

Table 5 Site Evaluation of advanced medical complex

Table 6 Direction of site evaluation

Table 7 Evaluation items and index

Table 8 ‘Business Preparation’ evaluation standard

Table 9 ‘Cooperation’ evaluation standard

Table 10 ‘Understanding promotion’ evaluation standard

Table 11 ‘Resident Agreement Rate’ evaluation standard

Table 12 Living weather index

Table 13 Index quantification process

Table 14 Health weather index

Table 15 ‘Access to water' evaluation standard

Table 16 Water quality index

Table 17 ‘Facilities linked to Thalassotherapy’ evaluation standard

Table 18 ‘Utilized resources’ evaluation standard

Table 19 ‘Proven resources’ evaluation standard

Table 20 ‘Seawater resource & salinity’ evaluation standard

Table 21 ‘Mineral/Biological resource’ evaluation standard

Table 22 ‘Thalassotherapy Industry’ evaluation standard

Table 23 ‘Harmful Facility’ evaluation standard

Table 24 Evaluation steps

Table 25 Relative scoring

Table 26 Example of evaluation score calculation