DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Healthcare Legislation Cases in the National Assembly Petition System: Focused on Petitions to the Health and Welfare Committee of the 13th National Assembly through the 20th Assembly

국회 청원제도를 통한 보건의료 입법사례 연구: 13-20대 보건복지위원회 청원을 중심으로

  • Ryu, Chang Ug (Department of Health Care Management, Gachon University College of Social Science)
  • 류창욱 (가천대학교 사회과학대학 의료경영학과)
  • Received : 2019.10.15
  • Accepted : 2019.11.05
  • Published : 2019.12.31

Abstract

The right to petition is a classical right of the people in constitutional states, and in Korea, it is a statutory right in the Constitution, the National Assembly Law, the Petition Law, and the Local Autonomy Act. The healthcare community first made a successful petition to the National Assembly when it achieved the amendment of the Government Organization Act through a petition to the National Assembly for the independence of the Ministry of Health, and this achievement served as the basis for further petitions. Since then, the healthcare community has successfully achieved the enactment and amendment of related occupational laws through National Assembly petitions, such as the amendment of Article 41, Paragraph 7 of the former Medical Insurance Act (Korean Medical Association, 14th Assembly), enactment of the Dental Health Act (Korean Dental Association, 15th Assembly), and amendment of the Health Functional Foods Act (Korea Pharmaceutical Association, 16th Assembly). Its petition accomplishment rate is higher than the total petition accomplishment rate of the Health and Welfare Committee of the National Assembly. However, along with the overall decrease in the number of National Assembly petitions, the Korean Medical Association and Korea Pharmaceutical Association have not achieved any results through petitioning since the 16th Assembly (June 2000), and the Korean Hospital Association and Korean Nurses Association have not achieved any results through petitioning since the 17th Assembly (April 2004). Furthermore, no National Assembly petitions have been made at all for 5 years (2014-2018). The Korean Medical Association and Korea Pharmaceutical Association previously showed a high petition accomplishment rate through their accumulated experience with National Assembly petitions and vigorous policy assistance from doctors/pharmacists/nurses turned lawmakers. More specifically, healthcare organizations have achieved results by actively conducting organized activities with the National Assembly, as implemented by a national assembly director and employees, and in case of petitions for legislation, each group has established infrastructure for reviewing the relevant laws by appointing a legislative director, as well as a legal advisor and advisory counsel. Although the organization that has submitted the most petitions to the National Assembly is the Korean Hospital Association, the group with the highest petition success rate is the Korean Medical Association, which may be linked to the relatively high proportion of doctors who have become lawmakers. Furthermore, the fact that other healthcare organizations were highly interested in petitioning the National Assembly has had major implications for the petition activities of healthcare organizations.

Keywords

References

  1. Kim CS. An introduction to constitutional law. Seoul: Pakyoungsa; 1993.
  2. Yun MS, Kim BM. An introduction to constitutional law. seoul: Bubyoulge; 1996.
  3. Almond GA. Comparative politics today: a world view. Boston (MA): Little, Brown; 1974.
  4. James AR. Staffing the legislature. In: Kornberg A, Musolf LD, editors. Legislatures in developmental perspective. Durham: Duke University Press; 1971.
  5. Kwun YS. Constitutional law. Seoul: Bubmunsa; 2003.
  6. Lee YB. A study on means to revitalize the petition system of the Korean National Assembly [master's thesis]. Seoul: Yonsei University; 1998.
  7. Ploos van Armstel GJ; Association of Secretaries General of Parliaments. The right of petition. Paris: Palais-Bourbon; 1979.
  8. Kim NS. A study on petition system of the Korean National Assembly and it's improving measure [master's thesis]. Seoul: Dankuk University; 1885.
  9. Kim JD. A study on the petition procedure and its improvement trend in the National Assembly of the Republic of Korea [master's thesis]. Seoul: Seoul National University; 1984.
  10. Ree GH. A role of national assembly: focusing on petition management. Soc Sci Rev 2001;18(2):17-38.
  11. The National Assembly of the Republic of Korea. Parliamentary records page 7-8: the 35th plenary session of the first National Assembly. Seoul: The National Assembly of the Republic of Korea; 1949.
  12. The Dong-A Ilbo. The passage of a petition on the independence of the Department of Health. The Dong-A Ilbo. 1949 Feb 20; Sect. 1.
  13. Ryu CU. The politics of healthcare in South Korea. Seoul: Bookk; 2018.
  14. Park DU. A petition for the Oral Health Act was submitted to the National Assembly. Dailydental. 1998 Oct 3; Sect. 4.
  15. Dailydental. The settlement of three years of the executive branch from 1994 to 1996. Dailydental. 1996 Feb 10; Sect. 17.
  16. Choi BC, Kang HS, Kwak SK, Sohn UD. Influence for pharmacy management by health functional food after the separation of prescribing and dispensing practice. Yakhak Hoeji 2009;53(2):45-50.
  17. Che SY. Health function food is best for pharmacies: the passage of the Health Function Food Act will boost distribution. Korea Pharmaceutical Association News. 2002 Feb 27; Sect. 17.
  18. Jo DH. Drug stores are excluded from the list of reported items under the Function Food Act: the petition was introduced by National Assemblyman Kim Myung-sup. Korea Pharmaceutical Association News. 2003 Dec 26; Sect. 3.
  19. Ju YJ. The status and role of proportional representation lawmakers. Seoul: Evergreen; 1997.
  20. Harris JP. Congressional control of administration. Washington (DC): The Brookings Institution; 1964.
  21. You HL. Modern political thought and Korean acceptance. Seoul: Bubmunsa; 2009.