DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

The Tactical review of the Battle of Tsushima - with focus on disposition & maneuver, and damage control -

쓰시마 해전의 전술적 재조명 - 배진과 기동, 손상통제를 중심으로 -

  • Received : 2018.11.30
  • Accepted : 2018.12.26
  • Published : 2018.12.31

Abstract

The Russo-Japanese War(1904-1905) in the early 20th century greatly influenced the international politics in Northeast Asia and the destiny of both countries. There are many studies on the cause of the outbreak and its effect on the Korean peninsula. The victory and defeat of the battle of Tsushima also the subject of research by renowned scholars and navy officers. Many previous studies have analyzed the process of engagement. However, There was a lack of research that analyzed at the tactical level of naval commanders. Therefore, this study tries to review the battle of Tsushima in terms of tactical level, that is formation, maneuvering, damage control. Naval operations at sea with many variables are not always done as planned. The intuitive judgement and readiness have had a decisive impact on victory and defeat. The analysis of the naval warfare on the basis of formation, maneuvering, and damage control makes the cause of the win more clearly. The conclusion of the this study can be summarized in five ways. First, victory would be achieved through the suppression of the beginning. The destiny of the Tsushima battle was determined by an 1 hour after first firing. The Japanese fleet caught fire by paralyzing the command and control capabilities of the Russian fleet. Second, the Japanese fleet's power was superior to the Russian fleet. In general, Japan and Russia had similar powers, and Admiral Togo's "T crossing tactics" decisively contributed the victory. However, when compared to the weapon system level, formation and maneuvering, Japan was much more dominant. Third, people realized that one side to be annihilated in the battle between similar powers after the Tsushima battle. The common perception before the Battle of Tsushima was that the battle ship would not sunken, and that the result of wiping out was difficult. However, there is s time for one sided victory and defeat depending on the early suppression nad the destruction of the command and control ability. Fourth, it is the importance of damage control ability. The main cause of the Russian fleet's loss of command and control ability was thick smoke from fire, and maneuverability was greatly deteriorated due to coal overload. In this way, importance is still valid after more than 100 tears. Fifth, the area of uncertainty. In the navy battles, one or two shots of clear firing in the beginning and small misconception and minor mistakes decide win or loss. Ultimately, this area of fortune can be linked to mindset of the commander. I hope this research will be help to naval researchers and naval commanders at the sea.

Keywords

References

  1. 강성학, 시베리아 횡단열차와 사무라이, 러일전쟁의 외교와 군사전략 (서울: 고려대학교 출판부, 1999).
  2. 강성학, 전쟁神과 군사전략 (서울: 리북, 2012).
  3. 김태준, "쓰시마해전 승패에 대한 분석," 한용섭 편, 군사사 연구총서 제 4집 (서울: 국방부 군사편찬연구소, 2004).
  4. 로스뚜노프(Loseuttunopeu) 저, 김종헌(옮김), 러일전쟁사(서울: 건국대학교 출판부, 2004).
  5. 박광용, 역사를 전환시킨 해전과 해양개척인물 (서울: 해상왕장보고기념사업회, 2008).
  6. 심헌용, 한반도에서 전개된 러일전쟁 연구 (서울: 국방부 군사편찬연구소, 2011).
  7. 심헌용, "러일전쟁 최후의 해상전투, '동해해전' 재구성,"군사 제97호(2015).
  8. "세계사의 결정적 순간들 제 10화 - 대한해협 해전," 월간조선 2004년 11월호.
  9. 율리시스 그랜트(R.G Grant) 저, 조학제(옮김), 해전 3,000년 (계룡: 해군본부, 2012).
  10. 이정수, 대해전 (서울: 공옥, 2011).
  11. 일본 해군군령부(日本 海軍軍令部) 저, 해군본부(옮김), 명치 37,38년 해전사 하권 (계룡: 해군본부, 2006).
  12. 웨인 휴스(Wayne Hughes) 저, 조덕현(옮김), 해전사 속의 해전 (서울: 신서원, 2009).
  13. 콘스탄틴 플레샤코프(Constantine Pleshakov) 저, 표완수.황의방(옮김), 짜르의 마지막 함대 (서울: 도서출판 중심, 2003).
  14. 크레이그 페인(Craig M. Payne) 저, 강정석(옮김), 해군 무기체계의 원리 (서울: 한티미디어, 2015).
  15. 허홍범, 세계를 움직인 해전의 역사 (서울: 지성사, 2008).
  16. A. T. Mahan, Naval Strategy (Cambridge: The Cambridge University Press, 1911).
  17. John Keegan, The Price of Admiralty (Washington: U.S. Naval War College, 1989).
  18. J.N. Westwood, Witness of Tsushima (Tokyo: Sophia University Press, 1970).
  19. Julian S. Corbett, Maritime Operations in the Russo-Japanese War (1904-1905), vol.2(Annapolis : Naval Institute Press, 1994).
  20. Kazushige Todaka, "Nihonkai kaisen ni teiji wa nakatta", Chou Koran (1991. 6. 1.).
  21. N.J.M Cambell, "The battle of Tsu-shima," Warship, vol.2, 1978.
  22. 네이버 무기백과사전, "줌월트급구축함," http://www.m.terms,naver.com/entry.nhn?docld=5682261&cid=60344&categoryld=60344(검색일: 2018년 9월 10일).
  23. 아르메셀의 쓰시마 해전 분석, http://armishel.tistory.com/26(검색일 : 2018년 9월 22일)
  24. Gene Slover, "Naval Ordnance and Gunnery," http://www.eugeneleeslover.com/ARMOR-CHAPTER-XII-A.htm(검색일 : 2018년 9월 12일)