DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Research on prescription candidates for Parkinson's disease in 『Dongeuibogam』

『동의보감(東醫寶鑑)』에 수록된 파킨슨병 치료 처방(處方) 후보군 선별 연구

  • Hwang, Min-Seob (Division of Humanities and Social Medicine, School of Korean Medicine, Pusan National University) ;
  • Park, Hye-Jin (Division of Humanities and Social Medicine, School of Korean Medicine, Pusan National University) ;
  • Kim, Si-Won (Division of Humanities and Social Medicine, School of Korean Medicine, Pusan National University) ;
  • Baek, Jin-Ung (Division of Humanities and Social Medicine, School of Korean Medicine, Pusan National University)
  • 황민섭 (부산대학교 한의학전문대학원 인문사회의학부) ;
  • 박혜진 (부산대학교 한의학전문대학원 인문사회의학부) ;
  • 김시원 (부산대학교 한의학전문대학원 인문사회의학부) ;
  • 백진웅 (부산대학교 한의학전문대학원 인문사회의학부)
  • Received : 2017.11.29
  • Accepted : 2018.01.23
  • Published : 2018.02.28

Abstract

Objectives : This study aims to sort out prescription candidates for four major symptoms of Parkinson's disease from Korean traditional medical publication, "Dongeuibogam". Methods : Medical terms related to four major symptoms of Parkinson's disease were primarily selected from "Dongeuibogam". Prescriptions that include at least one or more medical terms which are selected above were classified by the four major symptoms of Parkinson's disease, and finally analyzed to sort the most effective candidates. Results & Conclusions : 1. There are 18 medical terms in efficacy ($ch{\grave{i}}$ $z{\grave{o}}ng$, $j{\bar{u}}$ $lu{\acute{a}}n$, $j{\bar{i}}ng$${\check{u}}$ $ju{\check{a}}n$($ju{\check{a}}n$, $qu{\acute{a}}n$) $lu{\acute{a}}n$, $j{\bar{i}}ng$${\check{u}}$ $lu{\acute{a}}n$($lu{\acute{a}}n$) $t{\grave{o}}ng$, $j{\bar{i}}n$ $lu{\acute{a}}n$, $j{\bar{i}}n$ $t{\grave{i}}$, $sh{\check{o}}u$ $zh{\grave{e}}n$, $y{\acute{a}}ng$ $sh{\check{o}}u$, $lu{\acute{a}}n$ $j{\acute{i}}$, $lu{\acute{a}}n$ $b{\grave{i}}$, $r{\grave{o}}u$ $r{\acute{u}}n$, $zh{\grave{a}}n$ $di{\grave{a}}o$, $zh{\grave{a}}n$ $y{\acute{a}}o$, $zh{\grave{i}}$ $z{\acute{u}}$, $ch{\grave{e}}$ $t{\grave{o}}ng$, $ch{\bar{o}u}$ $ch{\grave{e}}$, $f{\bar{e}}ng$ $ch{\grave{u}}$, $ch{\grave{u}}$ $nu{\grave{o}}$) related to tremor, one of four major symptoms of Parkinson's disease. 2. There are 9 medical terms in efficacy ($qi{\acute{a}}ng$ $j{\acute{i}}$, $qi{\acute{a}}ng$ $zh{\acute{i}}$, $qi{\acute{a}}ng$ $t{\grave{o}}ng$, $j{\bar{u}}$ $j{\acute{i}}$, $j{\bar{i}}n$ $j{\acute{i}}$, $sh{\bar{e}}n$ $qi{\acute{a}}ng$, $lu{\acute{a}}n$ $j{\acute{i}}$, $y{\bar{a}}o$ $j{\acute{i}}$ $qi{\acute{a}}ng$, $xi{\grave{a}}ng$ $qi{\acute{a}}ng$) related to rigidity, one of four major symptoms of Parkinson's disease. 3. 38 prescription candidates (jiaweishouxingyuan, jiaweilonghusan, gehuajiexingtang, qiangfutang, qianghuoxuduantang, dawugongsan, duhuojishengtang, mahuangzuojingtang, fangfengbaizhumulitang, fangfengtongshengsan, baizhutang, buxinwan, fulingtang, binsusan, xieqingwan, sanbitang, shengdiqinliantang, shujinbaoansan, xingxiangsan, xiaotanfulingwan, shengjunwan, shenmizuojingtang, wuyaoshunqisan, yuzhenwan, wenjingyiyuantang, yiziqingjinsan, ziyinningshentang, shaoyaogancaotang, dingtongsan, zhushazhijiasan, cangzusan, chuanxiongfulingtang, tiedanyuan, choubaowan, duomingsan, xuanhusuosan, xuefengtang, huoluodan) were selected for tremor, one of the four major symptoms of Parkinson's disease. 4. 21 prescription candidates (qianghuoshengshitang, guizhiqianghuotang, guizhifuzitang, jiuweiqianghuotang(qianghuochonghetang), xiongzhixiangsusan, daqianghuotang, mahuangguizhitang, muguajian, fuzilizhongtang, shenzhusan, lianqiaobaidusan, yuzhensan, niuhuangjinhudan, renshenbaidusan, shaoyaogancaotang, jiuzhumuguazhou, cangzusan, shenxiangtianmatang, xiangjiaosan, xuefengtang, huishousan) were selected for rigidity, one of the four major symptoms of Parkinson's disease. 5. The results in this study ought to be verified by subsequent studies and clinical trials.

Keywords

References

  1. The Korean Movement Disorder Societ. 101 stories of Parkinson's disease that patients and caregivers want to know. Seoul. BeomMunEducation. 2015:1-5.
  2. Saquta Manabu original work, KH Jo trans. Parkinson's disease is treated this way. Seoul. Liscom. 2014:48-73.
  3. Baik JS. Treatment of Parkinson's disease. Drug information. 2007;33(4):24-25.
  4. Saquta Manabu original work, KH Jo trans. Parkinson's disease is treated this way. Seoul. Liscom. 2014:48-73.
  5. Bhidayasiri R, Truong DD. Motor complications in Parkinson disease: clinical manifestations and management. Journal of Neuroscience. 2008;266(1-2):204-215.
  6. Byeong-Jun Park. A Research on 7 Cases of the Treatment Process for Patients with Idiopathic Parkinson's Disease or Parkinsonism. Journal of Oriental Neuropsychiatry. 2009;20(30):283-295.
  7. Ji-young Ha, et al.. The Effect of Manual Acupuncture Therapy on Symptoms of the Patients with Idiopathic Parkinson's Disease. Journal of Korean Oriental Medicine. 2003; 24(3):172-183.
  8. Sang-min Park, et al.. Literature Review on Parkinson's Disease in Oriental Medicine. The Journal of Korean Acupuncture & Moxibustion Society. 2004;21(1):202-210.
  9. Jae-chul Yang, et al.. A Clinical Study about the Effects of Soshiho-tang on a Case of Parkinson's Disease with Pontine Infarction. Journal of Korean Oriental Medicine. 2007; 28(2):34-43.
  10. G Zhang, et al.. Effectiveness of traditional chinese medicine as an adjunct therapy for Parkinson's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2015. 10(3). e0118498. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0118498.
  11. Jin-won Kim, et al.. A case of tremor in Parkinson's disease treated with Korean medicine. The Journal of Korean Oriental Internal Medicine. 2006;27(4):954-961.
  12. HM Wang, et al.. Effectiveness of Bushen Huoxue Granule (补肾活血颗粒) on 5-serotonin and norepinephrine in the brain of Parkinson's disease patients with depressive state. Chinese Journal of Integrative Medicine. 2014 Dec; 20(12):944-948. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11655-014-2029-6
  13. Young-Eun Lee. Three Case Reports of Postural Instability and Gait Difficulty in Parkinson's Disease Patients Treated with Korean and Western Medicine. Korean Journal of Acupuncture. 2014;31(1):40-47. https://doi.org/10.14406/acu.2014.008
  14. Toosizadeh N, et al.. Does Integrative Medicine Enhance Balance in Aging Adults Proof of Concept for the Benefit of Electroacupuncture Therapy in Parkinson's Disease. Gerontology. 2014.
  15. Dong-Woo Lee, Jin-Ung Baek. A study on analyzing the terms describing anti-aging effects in Dongeuibogam to propose the methodology for selecting medicinal herbs related to anti-aging effects. The Journal of Korean Medical Classics. 2014:27(2).
  16. Seung Bin Pae, Byeong Cheol Yun, Jin Ung Baek. Anti-aging herbal formulae in Dongeuibogam : Identification of candidates by text mining. The Journal of Korean Medical Classics. 2015:28(4).
  17. Jeong Ah Lyu, Jin Ung Baek. Anti-aging Joobang(酒方)s in Dongeuibogam : Identification of candidates by text mining. The Journal of Korean Medical Classics. 2015;28(2):47-80. https://doi.org/10.14369/skmc.2015.28.2.047
  18. MJ Choi, et al.. Establishment of a comprehensive list of candidate anti-aging medicinal herb used in Korean medicine by text mining of the classical Korean medical literature, "Dongeuibogam", and preliminary evaluation of the anti-aging effects of these herbs. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2015. Article ID 873185.
  19. ME Pak, et al.. Studies on medicinal herbs for cognitive enhancement based on the text mining of Dongeuibogam and preliminary evaluation of its effects. Journal of Ethnopharmacology. 2016;179:383-390. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jep.2016.01.006
  20. SB Pae, et al.. Cognitive-Enhancing Herbal Formulae in Korean Medicine: Identification of Candidates by Text Mining and Literature Review. Journal of alternative and complementary medicine. 2016;22(5):413-418. https://doi.org/10.1089/acm.2015.0257
  21. BC Yun, et al.. An Analysis of the Combination Frequencies of Constituent Medicinal Herbs in Prescriptions for the Treatment of Stroke in Korean Medicine: Determination of a Group of Candidate Prescriptions for Universal Use. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2016. Article ID 2674014.
  22. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012.
  23. List of medical term in efficacy. Available from: URL: http://www.koreantk.com/ktkp2014/prescription/list-by-index.page
  24. List of medical term in efficacy. Available from: URL: http://www.koreantk.com/ktkp2014/prescription/list-by-index.page
  25. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:282.
  26. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:786.
  27. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1209.
  28. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1161.
  29. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:851.
  30. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1058.
  31. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:851.
  32. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:849.
  33. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1108.
  34. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1039.
  35. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1061.
  36. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:297.
  37. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1047.
  38. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:849.
  39. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:397.
  40. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1047.
  41. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:319.
  42. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1036.
  43. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1735.
  44. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:839.
  45. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:851.
  46. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:849.
  47. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1041, 1045.
  48. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:580.
  49. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1131.
  50. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:578.
  51. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:286.
  52. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1106.
  53. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1054.
  54. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1059.
  55. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:747.
  56. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1047.
  57. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1046.
  58. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:287.
  59. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1027.
  60. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:754.
  61. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1684.
  62. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1053.
  63. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:728.
  64. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1432.
  65. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:357.
  66. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1074.
  67. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1091.
  68. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1069.
  69. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:746.
  70. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:727.
  71. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1136.
  72. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1158.
  73. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1488.
  74. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1058.
  75. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1026.
  76. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1091.
  77. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1106.
  78. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:830.
  79. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:747.
  80. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1739.
  81. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1059.
  82. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:1684.
  83. Heo J original work. Laboratory of medical classics trans.. New paralled translation text of Dongeuibogam. Beobin publisher. Seoul. 2012:728.
  84. Kenneth W.Lindsay, Ian Bone, Geraint Fuller original work. KW Lee trans. Clinical Neurology(5th edition). Seoul. BeomMunEducation. 2013:493-499.
  85. Kenneth W.Lindsay, Ian Bone, Geraint Fuller original work. KW Lee trans. Clinical Neurology(5th edition). Seoul. BeomMunEducation. 2013:1-5.
  86. Schapira AH. Science, medicine, and the future: Parkinson's disease. BMJ. 1999;318(7179):311-314.
  87. Hubert H. Updates in the medical management of Parkinson's disease. medical grand rounds. Cleveland clinic journal of medicine. 2012;79(1):28-35. https://doi.org/10.3949/ccjm.78gr.11005
  88. Ota Takafumi, et al.. Effects of Shakuyaku-Kanzo-to on Extrapyramidal Symptoms During Antipsychotic Treatment. Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacol. 2015;35(3):304-307. https://doi.org/10.1097/JCP.0000000000000312
  89. B Pae, et al.. Cognitive-Enhancing HerbalFormulae in Korean Medicine: Identificationof Candidates by Text Mining and LiteratureReview. Journal of alternative and complementarymedicine. 2016;22(5):413-418. https://doi.org/10.1089/acm.2015.0257
  90. SB Pae, et al.. Cognitive-Enhancing Herbal Formulae in Korean Medicine: Identification of Candidates by Text Mining and Literature Review. Journal of alternative and complementary medicine. 2016;22(5):413-418. https://doi.org/10.1089/acm.2015.0257
  91. ME Pak, et al.. Studies on medicinal herbs for cognitive enhancement based on the text mining of Dongeuibogam and preliminary evaluation of its effects. Journal of Ethnopharmacology. 2016;179:383-390. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jep.2016.01.006
  92. BC Yun, et al.. An Analysis of the Combination Frequencies of Constituent Medicinal Herbs in Prescriptions for the Treatment of Stroke in Korean Medicine: Determination of a Group of Candidate Prescriptions for Universal Use. Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. 2016.
  93. Min Jae Kim. Evaluation of neuroprotective effect of Shuanghe-tang based on Dongeuibogam analysis using ischemic stroke mice model. 2017:Master's dissertation in Pusan National University