Some Issues on China General Aviation Legislation

中國通用航空立法若干問題研究

  • Shuang, Luan (Air Law and Space Law Institute, School of Law, Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics in China)
  • 란상 (중국남경항공항천대학법학원, 항공법여공간법연구소)
  • Received : 2016.12.06
  • Accepted : 2016.12.28
  • Published : 2016.12.30

Abstract

General aviation and air transport are two wings of the civil aviation industry. Chinese air transport is developing rapidly, and has become the world second air transport system only second to US since 2005. However, Chinese civil aviation is far behind the world average level, and cannot meet requirements of economic construction and social development. The transition and structural adjustment of Chinese economy provide the general aviation with a unprecedented broad market. The prospect of general aviation is promising and anticipated. The development of general aviation industry needs the legislative supports, and the current legislative conditions of Chinese general aviation are undoubtedly far behind the realistic requirements. Accelerating the legislation in Chinese general aviation industry requires scientific legislation concept. First, Legislation must promote development of general aviation industry. The general aviation will serves as a Chinese emerging industry that boosts domestic demand, promotes employment and expedite domestic economic development. We should, based on both the concept of promoting the industrial development of general aviation and national industrial planning, enact and rectify relative laws and regulations. And we should also straighten out the relationship between aviation security and industrial development and promote the revolution of low-altitude airspace management in an all-round way, in order to improve the utilization rate of airspace resources, classify and establish airspace, simplify examination and approval procedure and intensify operation management. In addition, what we should do is to expedite the infrastructure layout construction, guide the differentiated but coordinated development of general aviation industries in various areas, establish a united supervision mechanism of general aviation, redistrict the responsibilities of Chinese Air Control Agency and set up legislation, law enforcement and judicial systems with clarified institutions, clear positioning and classified responsibilities, so as to usher in a new era of the legislative management of Chinese general aviation industry. Second, shift the focus from regulations to both regulations and services. Considering the particularity of the general aviation, we should use American practices for reference and take into account both regulation and service functions when enacting general aviation laws. For example, we should reduce administrative licensing and market supervision, and adopt "criteria" and "approval" management systems for non-commercial and commercial aviation. Furthermore, pay attention to social benefits. Complete social rescuing mechanism through legislation. It should be clarified in legislation that general aviation operators should take the responsibilities of, and ensure to realize social benefits of environmental protection and ecological balance .Finally, rise in line with international standards. Modify Chinese regulations which is inconsistent with international ones to remove barriers to international cooperation. Specify basic legislative principles. One is the principle of coordination. Realize coordination between the civil aviation and general aviation, between military aviation and civil aviation, and among departments. Two is the principle of pertinence. The general aviation has its own rules and specialties, needing to be standardized using specialized laws and regulations. Three is the principle of efficiency. To realize time and space values of general aviation, we should complete rules in aerospace openness, general aviation airport construction, general aviation operations, and regulation enforcement. Four is the principle of security. Balance the maximum use of resources of Chinese airspace and the according potential threats to Chinese national interests and social security, and establish a complete insurance system which functions as security defense and indemnificatory measure. Establish a unified legal system. Currently, the system of Chinese general aviation laws consists of national legislation, administrative laws and regulations and civil aviation regulations (CAR). Some problems exist in three components of the system, including too general content, unclear guarantee measures, incomplete implementation details, and lacking corresponding pertinence and flexibility required by general aviation regulations, stringency of operation management and standards, and uniformity of standards. A law and regulation system, centered on laws and consisting of administrative laws regulations, industrial regulations, implementation details, industrial policies and local laws and regulations, should be established. It is suggested to modify the Civil Aviation Law to make general aviation laws complete, enact the Regulations of General Aviation Development, and accelerate the establishment, modification and abolition of Chinese general aviation laws to intensify the coordination and uniformity of regulations.

Keywords

References

  1. 楊惠, 郝秀輝 : 航空法通論, 中國政法大學出版社, 2009
  2. 董念清 : 航空法判例与學理硏究, 群衆出版社出版, 2001
  3. 宗蘇宁 : 中國通用航空産業發展現實与思考, 航空工業出版社, 2014.
  4. 耿建華, 王 霞等 : 通用航空槪論, 航空工業出版社, 2013.
  5. 呂世論, 現代西方法學流派 (上冊) , 中國大百科全書出版社, 1999年
  6. 羅斯科.龐德, 沈宗灵譯, 通過法律的社會控制, 商務印書館, 2010年
  7. 杰里.A. 艾肯伯格, 陳静娴譯, 美國通用航空法 : 法規解析与應用, 航空工業出版社, 2014
  8. 山東省科學技術協會編, 通用航空發展問題与思考, 北京航空航天大學出版社, 2015
  9. 康斯坦丁諾斯.逹拉馬凱迪斯, 基蒙.P. 維拉范尼斯, (德) 雷斯.A. 皮爾著 謝海斌等譯, 无人机融入國家空域系統, 國防工業出版社, 2015
  10. 史永胜, 王霞, 耿建華, 通用航空運營与管理, 航空工業出版社, 2007
  11. 張娜, 王靜, 通用航空發展硏究, 中國鐵道出版社, 2013
  12. John J. Sheehan, 王霞, 朱蓬杰, 覃睿譯, 公務航空運營与管理, 航空工業出版社, 2006
  13. 王霞, 陳兆鵬, 韓莎莎, 通用航空的基石-FBO, 航空工業出版社, 2014
  14. 弗斯霍爾(Verschoor-Diederiks), 趙維田譯, 航空法簡介, 中國對外翻譯出版公司, 1987
  15. ALEXANDER T. WELLS, AIR TRANSPORTATIONA MANAGEMENT PERSPECTIVE (2d ed. 1984).
  16. Industry, NASA, the FAA, and Universities Join Forces to Revitalize the General Aviation Industy, AGATE FLIER, Aug. 1994
  17. Dick Koenig, Learn to Program, in General Aviation: Building for the Future on its Strengths & Diversity, 4TH ANNUAL FAA GENERAL AVIATION FORECAST AND CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS111 (1994)
  18. Jennifer L. Anton, A Critical Evaluation of the General Aviation Revitalization Act of 1994, AIR L. & COM. (1998)
  19. Thomas H. Kister, General Aviation Revitalization Act: Its' Effect on Manufacturers, 65 DEF. COUNS. J. (1998)
  20. Scott E. Tarry & Lawrence J. Truitt, Rhetoric and Reality: Tort Reform and the Uncertain Future of General Aviation, 61 J. AIR L. & COM. (1995).
  21. William L. Oliver, Jr. & Michael G. Jones, Repose Statute Helps Revitalize an American Industry: the General Aviation Revitalization Act of 1994 (GARA), AVIATION Q. (1997)
  22. General Aviation Manufacturers Association, Five Year Results: A Report to the President and Congress on the General Aviation Revitalization Act (1999) [hereinafter "Five Year Results"].
  23. 王鳳珍 : 完善我國通用航空法律法規体系的思考, 中國民航飛行學院學报, 2012年第5期.
  24. 欒爽 : 英美模型飛机規制及其啓示, 航空模型, 2016年第2期
  25. 刁偉民 : 中國通用航空法律制度及其完善, 北京航空航天大學學报(社會科學版), 2009年第2期
  26. 欒爽 : 中國无人机立法回顧与前瞻, 无人机, 2016年第1期
  27. 高啓明 : 美國通用航空産業發展的經驗剖析及啓示, 西安航空學院學报, 2013年 第6期.
  28. 毛振華:通用航空借鑒國外經驗, 中外企業文化, 2012年第7期
  29. 張健等 : 低空開放對空管的影響及對策分析, 中國民航飛行學院學报, 2012年第 3期.
  30. International Civil Aviation organization (ICAO); http://www.icao.int
  31. www.caac.com.cn