Journal of Korean Medical classics (대한한의학원전학회지)

The Society of Korean Medical Classics (대한한의학원전학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study on the Composition of Shanghanluntiaobian(傷寒論條辨)

방유집(方有執)의 『상한론조변(傷寒論條辨)』 조문(條文) 구성에 대한 고찰(考察)

  • Ahn, Jin-hee (Dept. of Korean Medicine, Graduate School, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Kim, Hye-il (Dept. of Korean Medical Classics, College of Korean Medicine, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Jeong, Chang-hyun (Dept. of Korean Medical Classics, College of Korean Medicine, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Jang, Woo-chang (Dept. of Korean Medical Classics, College of Korean Medicine, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Baik, You-sang (Dept. of Korean Medical Classics, College of Korean Medicine, Kyunghee University)
  • 안진희 (경희대학교 일반대학원 기초한의과학과) ;
  • 김혜일 (경희대학교 한의과대학 원전학교실) ;
  • 정창현 (경희대학교 한의과대학 원전학교실) ;
  • 장우창 (경희대학교 한의과대학 원전학교실) ;
  • 백유상 (경희대학교 한의과대학 원전학교실)
  • Received : 2016.01.05
  • Accepted : 2016.02.17
  • Published : 2016.02.25
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Objectives : The purpose of this study is to investigate the method of setting up logic and estimate Fang Youzhi's work through Shanghanluntiaobian. Methods : Wang Shuhe's old edition Shanghanlun and Fang Youzhi's Shanghanluntiaobian were compared and several essential provisions were analyzed and addressed the positive and negative aspects of Fang Youzhi's revising old edition Shanghanlun mixed bamboo tablets. Results : Fang Youzhi's changing Bianmaifa("辨脈法") and Pingmaifa("平脈法") and placement Bianchishiyemaizhengbingzhi chapter after Liujingbingmaizhengbingzhi for discriminating convulsion dampness summer heat stroke from febrile diseases is appropriate. Fang Youzhi's deletion Shanghanli("傷寒例") chapter that has a guiding characteristics shows his editorial policy. Fang Youzhi's addition Bianwenbingfengwenzabingmaizhengbingzhi chapter is for discriminating febrile disease from epidemic febrile disease wind warmth syndrome miscellaneous disease and it indicates Shanghanlun is a book of treatment after differentiation of syndromes containing epidemic febrile disease and miscellaneous disease. Through Fang Youzhi's revising method I can see several positive aspects. First he tried to refine the logic of the content of Shanghanlun and accord with an actual situation. Second he shows Shanghanlun is a book of treatment after differentiation of syndromes containing epidemic febrile disease and miscellaneous disease and tried to see Shanghanlun clearly. A criticism of the Preserving Old Edition Shanghanlun group could interrupt flexibility and creative thinking reading Shanghanlun and a criticism to the Sangangdingli Principles of the several exegetists is a productive criticism because medicine treats human being so it cannot be completed by a logic. Conclusions : All of these processes are Fang Youzhi's endeavour for strengthening the system and logicality of the old edition Shanghanlun and it is meaningful to show a method to read Shanghanlun to beginners.

Keywords

References

  1. Eun SM. Brief History of SanghanOnbyeong. Daejeon. Jumin. 2007. 殷晳玟. 傷寒溫病學史略. 대전. 주민출판사. 2007.
  2. Chen DS, Ceng Y, Huang ZD ed.. Maeng WJ, et al. trans.. Theories of Different Schools. Seoul. Daesung Publishing Company. 2001. 陳大舜, 曾勇, 黃政德 編. 孟雄在 외 9人 譯. 各 家學說. 서울. 대성의학사. 2001.
  3. Nanjingzhongyixueyuan ed.. Shanghanlunyishi. Shanghai. Shanghai Science and Technology Press. 1992. 南京中醫學院 編著. 傷寒論譯釋. 上海. 上海科學 技術出版社. 1992.
  4. Fang YZ. Shanghanluntiaobian (Zhongguoyixuedachengxuji vol.25). Shanghai. Shanghai Science and Technology Press. 2000. 方有執. 傷寒論條辨(中國醫學大成續集 25). 上海. 上海科學技術出版社. 2000.
  5. Moon JJ, et al. ed.. Precise Interpretation of Shanghanlun. Seoul. Publisher of Kyunghee Univ. 2000. p.256. 文濬典 外 6人 編. 傷寒論精解. 서울. 慶熙大學校 出版局. 2000. p.256.
  6. Zang QZ. Zhangqingzishanghanlun (Zhongguoyixuedacheng vol.6). Shanghai. Shanghai Science and Technology Press. 1992. 張卿子. 張卿子傷寒論(中國醫學大成六). 上海. 上 海科學技術出版社. 1992.
  7. Zang ZC. Shanghanlunzongyin (Zhangzhicongyixuequanshu). Beijing. Zhongguozhongyiyaochubanshe. 1999. 張志聰. 傷寒論宗印(張志聰醫學全書). 北京. 中國 中醫葯出版社. 1999.
  8. Chen XY. (Daziduanju) Chenxiuyuanyishuqishierzhong. Taibei. Wenguangtushuyouxiangongsi. 1964. 陳修園. (大字斷句)陳修園醫書七十二種. 臺北. 文光圖書有限公司. 1964.
  9. Ke Qin ed.. Shanghanlaisuji. Shanghai. Shanghai Science and Technology Press. 1978. 柯琴 編撰. 傷寒來蘇集. 上海. 上海科學技術出版 社. 1978.
  10. You ZJ. Shanghanguanzhuji. Shanghai. Shanghai Science and Technology Press. 1978. 尤在涇 注. 傷寒貫珠集. 上海. 上海科學技術出版 社. 1978.
  11. Yang YG. How Fangyouzhi repeatedly correcting the error. Zhongyiyaoxuebao. 1988. 2. 楊運高. 方有執是怎样錯簡重訂的. 中醫藥學報. 1988. 2.
  12. Shen MN. Roughly discuss Shanghanluntiaobian. Guangxizhongyiyao. 1983. 沈敏南. 略論 傷寒論條辨. 廣西中醫藥. 1983.
  13. Zhuo Qun. Fangyouzhi and Shanghanluntiaobian. Tianjinzhongyixueyuanxuebao. 1984. 卓群. 方有執與 傷寒論條辨. 天津中醫學院學報.1984.
  14. Jang WC. Review on argument about three planks of the triangular position. Journal of Korean Medical Classics. 2006. 19(2). 張祐彰. 三綱鼎立 論爭에 대한 소고. 대한한의학 원전학회지. 2006. 19(2).