Journal of Korean Society of Transportation (대한교통학회지)

Korean Society of Transportation (대한교통학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Practical Interpretation and Source of Error in Traffic Assignment Based on Korea Transport Database(KTDB)

KTDB 기반 노선배정의 예측오차 원인과 분석결과 해석

  • KIM, Ikki (Department of Transportation and Logistics Engineering, Hanyang University)
  • 김익기 (한양대학교 교통물류공학과)
  • Published : 2016.10.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study reviewed factors and causes that affect on reliability and accuracy of transportation demand forecasting. In general, the causes of forecasting errors come from variety and irregularity of trip behaviors, data limitation, data aggregation and model simplification. Theoretical understanding about the inevitable errors will be helpful for reasonable decision making for practical transportation policies. The study especially focused on traffic assignment with the KTDB data, and described the factors and causes of errors by classifying six categories such as (1) errors in input data, (2) errors due to spacial aggregation and representation method of network, (3) errors from representing values for variations of traffic patterns, (4) errors from simplification of traffic flow model, and (5) errors from aggregation of route choice behavior.

이 연구에서는 교통수요예측의 신뢰성에 영향을 미치는 요소와 원인을 검토하였다. 통행의 다양성과 불규칙성, 입력자료 한계, 자료의 집합화, 모형의 단순화가 포괄적 의미에서 교통예측 오차원인이 된다. 또한 불가피하게 존재하는 예측 오차의 이론적 배경을 정확히 규명함으로써 예측결과를 실무적 정책결정에 활용할 시에 합리적 판단을 하는데 도움이 되도록 하였다. 본 연구에서는 특히 노선배정모형의 예측 오차의 요인에 초점을 두고, KTDB 자료기반 분석오차를 6개 항목으로 나누어 설명하였다. 즉, (1) 입력 자료의 오차, (2) 공간 집합화와 네트워크 표현방식에 따른 오차, (3) 교통패턴 변동에 대한 대푯값 설정에 따른 오차, (4) 교통류모형 단순화에 따른 오차, (5) 노선선택 행태 집합화에 따른 오차로 구분하여 설명하였다.

Keywords

References

  1. Anas A. (1982), Residential Location Markets and Urban Transportation: Economic Theory, Econometrics, and Policy Analysis With Discrete Choice Models, Academic Press.
  2. Bar-Gera H. (2002), Origin-Based Algorithm for the Traffic Assignment Problem, 36(4), Transportation Science.
  3. Bar-Gera H., Boyce D. (2003), Origin-based Algorithms for Combined Travel Forecasting Models, 37, Transportation Research B.
  4. Ben-Akiva M., Lerman S. (1985), Discrete Choice Analysis: Theory and Application to Travel Demand, The MIT Press.
  5. Boyce D. E., Janson B. N., Eash R. W. (1981), The effect on Equilibrium Trip Assignment of Different Link Congestion Functions, 15A, Transportation Research A.
  6. Branston. D. (1976), Link Capacity Function: A Review, 10, Transportation Research, 223-236. https://doi.org/10.1016/0041-1647(76)90055-1
  7. Dial R. B. (2006), A Path-based User-equilibrium Traffic Assignment Algorithm That Obviates Path Storage and Enumeration, 40, Transportation Research B.
  8. Douglas A. A., Lewis R. J. (1970), Transportation Generation Techniques, November, Traffic Engineering & Control, 362-365.
  9. Douglas A. A., Lewis R. J. (1970), Transportation Generation Techniques: 2. Zonal Least-squares Regression Analysis, December, Traffic Engineering & Control, 428-431.
  10. Douglas A. A., Lewis R. J. (1971), Transportation Generation Techniques: 3. Household Least-squares Regression Analysis, January, Traffic Engineering & Control, 477-479.
  11. Douglas A. A., Lewis R. J. (1971), Transportation Generation Techniques: 4. Category Analysis and Summary of Trip Generation Techniques, February, Traffic Engineering & Control, 532-535.
  12. Easa S. (1991), Traffic Assignment in Practice: Overview and Guidelines for Users, Journal of Transportation Engineering, 117(6), 602-623. https://doi.org/10.1061/(ASCE)0733-947X(1991)117:6(602)
  13. Hall F. L., Hurdle V. F., Banks J. H. (1992), Synthesis of Recent Work on the Nature of Speed-Flow and Flow-Occupancy (or Density) Relationships on Freeways, Transportation Research Record 1365.
  14. Horowitz A. J. (1993), Reference Manual: Quick Response System II for Windows, Version 3.6, AJH Associates, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
  15. Jayakrishnan R., Tsai W. T., Prashker J. N., Rajadhyaksha S. (1994), Faster Path-based Algorithm for Traffic Assignment, Transportation Research Record 1443.
  16. Kanafani A. (1983), Transportation Demand Analysis, McGraw Hill Book.
  17. Kang S. M., Kwon Y.S., Park C.H. (2000), A Development of a Path-Based Traffic Assignment Algorithm Using Conjugate Gradient Method, J. Korean Soc. Transp., 18(5), Korean Society of Transportation, 99-107.
  18. Kim I. K. (1997), Theoretical Comparison of O-D Trips and P-A Trips in Travel Demand Analysis, J. Korean Soc. Transp., 15(1), Korean Society of Transportation, 45-62.
  19. Kim I. K. (2006), Reconsideration on Calibration and Forecasting Procedure for Transportation Demand Analysis, Transportation Technology and Policy, 3(1), Korean Society of Transportation, 87-106.
  20. Kim J. Y., Kim J. Y., Park S. J., Lee S. J. (2015), Analysis of Convergence Level and Exit Criteria on Traffic Assignment Algorithms, 14(1), The Journal of The Korea Institute of Intelligent Transport Systems.
  21. Manheim M. L. (1979), Fundamentals of Transportation Systems Analysis, 1(Basic Concepts), The MIT Press.
  22. Ortuzar J. D., Willumsen L. G. (2011), Modelling Transport, 4th Edition, John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
  23. Regueros A., Prashker J., Mahalel D. (1993), Equilibrium Assignment Method for Pointwise Flow-Delay Relationship, Transportation Research Record 1413.
  24. Sheffi Y. (1985), Urban Transportation Networks: Equilibrium Analysis With Mathematical Programming Methods, Prentice-Hall Inc.
  25. Slavin H., Brandon J., Rabinowicz A. (2006), An Empirical Comparison of Alternative User Equilibrium Traffic Assignment Methods, Association for European Transport and Contributors.
  26. Spiess H., Florian M. (1989), Optimal Strategies: A New Assignment Model for Transit Network, 23B(2), Transportation Research B, 83-102.
  27. Stoper P. R., Meyburg A. H. (1975), Urban Transportation Modeling and Planning, Lexington Books.
  28. Suh S. D. (1990), Study on Validation of Highway Capacity Function in South Korea, Transportation Studies, The Korea Transport Institute, Sejong, South Korea.
  29. Suh S. D. (1991), Highway Capacity Function and Congestion Cost, Transportation Information, 62, The Korea Transport Institute, Sejong, South Korea.
  30. US DOT (1983), UTPS Highway Network Development Guide, U.S. Department of Transportation, January.
  31. Washington S. P., Karlaftis M.G., Mannering F. L. (2003), Statistical and Econometric Methods for Transportation Data Analysis, A CRC Press Company, 121-141, 155-167.