The Mother Goddess of Champa: Po Inâ Nâgar

  • Received : 2015.02.15
  • Accepted : 2015.05.01
  • Published : 2015.06.30

Abstract

This article utilizes interdisciplinary methods in order to critically review the existing research on the Mother Goddess of Champa: Po Inâ Nâgar. In the past, Po Inâ Nâgar has too often been portrayed as simply a "local adaptation of Uma, the wife of Śiva, who was abandoned by the Cham adapted by the Vietnamese in conjunction with their conquest of Champa." This reading of the Po Ina Nagar narrative can be derived from even the best scholarly works on the subject of the goddess, as well as a grand majority of the works produced during the period of French colonial scholarship. In this article, I argue that the adaption of the literary studies strategies of "close reading", "surface reading as materiality", and the "hermeneutics of suspicion", applied to Cham manuscripts and epigraphic evidence-in addition to mixed anthropological and historical methods-demonstrates that Po Inâ Nâgar is, rather, a Champa (or 'Cham') mother goddess, who has become known by many names, even as the Cham continue to re-assert that she is an indigenous Cham goddess in the context of a majority culture of Thành Mẫu worship.

Keywords

References

  1. Anonymous. nd. Dalakal Nao Magru. Manuscript from Dharbhan Po Dam's private collection. Read: Fall, 2012.
  2. Anonymous. nd. Dalikal Po Anit. Manuscript from Dharbhan Po Dam's private collection. Read: Fall, 2012.
  3. Anonymous. nd. Da Lakal Po Rome Angan Ja Saot [The Dalikal of Po Rome When He Was Called Ja Saot]. Manuscript from Dharbhan Po Dam's private collection. Read: Fall, 2012.
  4. Anonymous. nd. Dalakal Po Kuk. Manuscript from Ja Tu di Hamu Liman's private collection. Read 2014. Photographed: 2013.
  5. Anonymous. nd. Damnuy Po Inu Nagar. Manuscript from Dharbhan Po Dam's private collection. Read: Fall, 2012.
  6. Hop Ai. 1885. Ariya Po Pareng. 430-450 in Inrasara. 2006. Ariya: Truong Ca Cham. TP. Ho Chi Minh, Viet Nam: Van Nghe [Arts Press].
  7. Dai Nam Nhat Thong Chi: Tap 1. (2012). (DNNTC). Ban dich moi cua Hoang Van Lau In lan thu nhat. Lao Dong: TP Ho Chi Minh.
  8. Aymonier, Etienne. 1890. Legendes Historiques Des Chames [Historical Legends of the Cham]. Excursions et reconnaissances, XIV (32): 145-206.
  9. Aymonier, Etienne. 1891. Les Tchames et Leurs Religion. Editeur: Ernest Leroux. Paris, France: EFEO.
  10. Best, Stephen & Sharon Marcus. 2009. Surface Reading: An Introduction. Representations (Fall): 1-21.
  11. Blood, Dorris. 1981. Aspects of Cham Culture. In Notes from Indochina on Ethnic Minority Cultures. Summer Institute of Linguistics (SIL)-Museum of Anthropology Publication. No. 6, Dallas, Texas.
  12. Boisselier, Jean. 1963. Le Statuaire de Champa: recheres sur les cultes et l'iconographie. EFEO 54: Paris, France.
  13. Cabaton, Antoine. 1901. Nouvelles Recherces Sur Les Chams Vol. 2. Paris, France: Ecole Francaise de l'Extreme-Orient.
  14. Durand, R.P. - E.M. 1903. Le Temple De Po Rome A Phanrang [The Po Rome Temple of Phan Rang]. BEFEO, III: 597-603.
  15. Durand, R.P. - E.M. 1907. La chronique de Po Nagar. BEFEO, VII: 339-45.
  16. LaFont, P.B., Po, D. & Vija, N. 1977. Catalogue des Manuscrits Cam des Bibliotheques Francaises. Paris, France: EFEO.
  17. Le Dinh Hung & Ton Nu Khanh Trang. 2014. Than nu Thien Y A Na trong doi song cu dan vung Thuan Hoa. In ed. Vo Van Sen - Ngo Duc Thinh - Nguyen Van Len. Tin Nguong Tho Mau o Nam Bo: Ban Sac va Gia Tri. Truong Dai Hoc Khoa Hoc Xa Hoi va Nhan Van - DHQG - TP. HCM Trung Tam Nghien Cuu va Bao Ton Van Hoa Tin Nguong Viet Nam, So Van Hoa The Thao va Du Lich tỉnh An Gian. TP Ho Chi Minh, Viet Nam: NXB Dai Hoc Quoc Gia. 527-535.
  18. Inrasara. 1994. Van hoc Cham. Van hoa Dan toc hoc: Ha Noi.
  19. Majumdar, R.C. 1985 [1963[1927]]. Champa, History and Culture of Indian Colonial Kingdom in the Far East 2nd -16th Century A.D. The Inscriptions of Champa. Book III. Ins Calcuta Publisher.
  20. Marison, G.E. 1985. The Chams and Their Literature. Journal of the Malay Branch of the Royal Asiatic Society. 58(2) 45-70
  21. Monier-Williams, Sir Monier. 2005[1899]. A Sanskrit-English Dictionary. Delhi, India: Motilal. Tr. 743-744.
  22. Moussay, Gerard. et. al. 1971. Dictionaire Cam-VietnamienFrancais. Phang Rang, Vietnam: Centre Culturel Cam.
  23. Mus, Paul. 1933. L'Inde vu de l'est : cultes indiennes et indigenes a Champa. Bulletin de l'Ecole francaise d'Extreme-Orient, XXXIII.
  24. Nakamura, Rie. 1999. Cham of Vietnam: The Dynamics of Ethnicity. PhD Dissertation, University of Washington.
  25. Ngo Van Doanh. 2011 [2002]. Van Hoa Co Champa. Ha Noi: Van Hoa Dan Toc. 416-417.
  26. Nguyen The Anh. 1995[1991]. The Vietnamization of the Cham diety Po Nagar. Essays into Vietnamese Pasts. K. W. Taylor and John K Whitmore, ed. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Previously printed in the Asia Journal 2(1), The Center for Area Studies, Seoul National University.
  27. Noseworthy, William. 2014. Hinh anh nghien cuu Po Ina Nagar theo phuong phap da nganh. In ed. Vo Van Sen - Ngo Duc Thinh - Nguyen Van Len. Tin Nguong Tho Mau o Nam Bo: Ban Sac va Gia Tri. Truong Dai Hoc Khoa Hoc Xa Hoi va Nhan Van - DHQG - TP. HCM Trung Tam Nghien Cuu va Bao Ton Van Hoa Tin Nguong Viet Nam, So Van Hoa The Thao va Du Lich tỉnh An Gian. TP Ho Chi Minh, Viet Nam: NXB Dai Hoc Quoc Gia. 539-549.
  28. Parmentier, Henri. 1902. Le sanctuaire de Po Nagar Nhatrang. BEFEO 2: 17-54.
  29. Parmentier, Henri. 1906. Nouvelles notes sur le sanctuaire de Po Nagar a Nhatrang. BEFEO 6: 291-300.
  30. Parmentier, Henri. 1909. Inventaire Descriptif des Monements Cams de L'Annam. Paris, France : Imprimerie Nationale. 2 vols.
  31. Phan An. 2014. Tinh tich hop va dung hop trong tin nguong tho Mau cua nguoi Viet Nam Bo. In eds. Vo Van Sen - Ngo Duc Thinh - Nguyen Van Len. Tin Nguong Tho Mau o Nam Bo: Ban Sac va Gia Tri. Truong Dai Hoc Khoa Hoc Xa Hoi va Nhan Van - DHQG - TP. HCM Trung Tam Nghien Cuu va Bao Ton Van Hoa Tin Nguong Viet Nam, So Van Hoa The Thao va Du Lich tỉnh An Gian. TP Ho Chi Minh, Viet Nam: NXB Dai Hoc Quoc Gia. 13-16.
  32. Phan Dang Nhat. 2013. So sanh tuc tho than lang cua nguoi Cham va nguoi Viet Nam. Tap Chi Van Hoa Cham, No. 01: 13-17.
  33. Phan Khoang. 2001 [1967]. Viet Sử Xu Dang Trong: 1558-1777: Cuoc Nam Tien Cua Dan Toc Viet Nam. Ha Noi : Van Hoc
  34. Phan Quoc Anh. 2010. Nghi Le Vong Doi Cua Nguoi Cham Ba La Mon (Cham Ahier) o Ninh Thuan. Dai Hoc Quoc Gia Ha Noi. Ha Noi.
  35. Phan Thi Yen Tuyet. 2014. He thong nu than bien trong tin nguong tho Mau va nu than o vung bien Nam Bo. In ed. Vo Van Sen - Ngo Duc Thinh - Nguyen Van Len. Tin Nguong Tho Mau o Nam Bo: Ban Sac va Gia Tri. Truong Dai Hoc Khoa Hoc Xa Hoi va Nhan Van - DHQG - TP. HCM Trung Tam Nghien Cuu va Bao Ton Van Hoa Tin Nguong Viet Nam, So Van Hoa The Thao va Du Lich tỉnh An Gian. TP Ho Chi Minh, Viet Nam: NXB Dai Hoc Quoc Gia. 69-84.
  36. Po Dharma. 1989. Les Frontieres Du Campa (Dernier Etat Des Rechereches). In Les Frontieres Du Vietnam. Paris: Editions L'Harmattan. 128-135.
  37. Po Dharma. 1988. Etat Des Dernieres Recherches Sur La Date De L'absorption Du Campa Par Le Vietnam. In Actes du Seminaire sur le Campa. Ed.: ACHCPI. 59-70.
  38. Sakaya (Truong Van Mon). 2014. Ban Them Ve Hinh Tuong Muk Juk (Ba Den) - Mot Hoa Than cua Nu Than Po Ina Nagar, Nguoi Champa trong Tin Nguong Tho Mau cua Nguoi Viet o Nam Bo. In ed. Vo Van Sen - Ngo Duc Thinh - Nguyen Van Len. Tin Nguong Tho Mau o Nam Bo: Ban Sac va Gia Tri. Truong Dai Hoc Khoa Hoc Xa Hoi va Nhan Van - DHQG - TP. HCM Trung Tam Nghien Cuu va Bao Ton Van Hoa Tin Nguong Viet Nam, So Van Hoa The Thao va Du Lich tỉnh An Gian. TP Ho Chi Minh, Viet Nam: NXB Dai Hoc Quoc Gia. 517-526.
  39. Sakaya (Truong Van Mon). 2013. Tiep Can Mot So Van Dề Van Hoa Champa [Approaching Some Problems of Cham Culture]. Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam: Tri Thuc Press.
  40. Sakaya (Truong Van Mon). 2010. Van Hoa Cham: Nghien Cuu Va Phe Binh. TP. Hoi Chi Minh : Phu Nu.
  41. Sakaya (Truong Van Mon). 2004. Po Ina Nagar Cham- Than mẹ xu so in Ngo Duc Thinh (ed.), Dao mau va hinh thuc Shaman giao cua cac toc nguoi Viet Nam va Chau A, Nxb KHXH, Ha Noi, tr. 196-219.
  42. Schweyer, Ann Valerie. 2004. 'Po Nagar de Nha Trang' Aseanie. No. 14.
  43. Tran Kiem Hoang (Chamaliaqriya Tieng). 2011. Tri Thuc Dan Gian Cua Nguoi Raglai. Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam: Van Hoa Dan Toc.