Journal of Korean Society of Rural Planning (농촌계획)

Korean Society of Rural Planning (한국농촌계획학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

An Empirical Study of the Mediating Effect of Governance in Relationship between Resident Participation and Rural Community Design Project Performance - Focused on the Case of Utturu Village -

주민참여와 농촌 마을만들기 사업성과의 관계에서 거버넌스의 매개효과 실증분석 - 제주 웃뜨르권역 사례를 중심으로 -

  • Received : 2015.01.26
  • Accepted : 2015.03.19
  • Published : 2015.03.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

As rural development projects, mostly carried out in a top-down development method in the past came to take a bottom-up development method in earnest, entering the 2000s, resident participation became an essential element of a rural community design project, to the extent that it can influence the success or failure of a rural community design project. It is taken for granted that rural residents independently participate in community design projects, but as they are accustomed to various subsidy projects carried out by the government and become increasingly aging, it is not easy to induce their spontaneous participation in farming areas with such problems. Especially, to prevent the distrust between administrative agencies and residents from serving as an obstacle in the residents' spontaneous participation, it is necessary to construct horizontal governance among the village residents, administrative agencies and the group of experts supporting for the project. This study attempted to verify the mediating effect of governance in the relationship between resident participation and the performance of the rural community design project based on this problem recognition, and for this purpose, the results of a survey with residents in Utturu Village, Hangyeong-myeon, Jeju-si, which was completed by carrying out a comprehensive rural development project, the typical bottom-up community design project was used for an empirical analysis. The results of the study can provide implications for setting directions, establishing strategies and constructing governance of rural community design projects in the future, and especially, it can be said that this study has academic significance in that governance is recognized as an important variable related to the project performance.

Keywords

References

  1. An, C. H.(2013) Analysis of Resident Satisfaction Degree in the Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project. Hanyang University Doctoral thesis.
  2. An, S. Y.(2013) A Study on the Factors Influencing to Resident Satisfaction in Rural Village Making. Kyungnam University Doctoral thesis.
  3. An, Z. H.(2008) Rural Tourism Village Building and Residents' Participation. Chonnam National University Doctoral thesis.
  4. Bang, G. H.(2008) A Study on the Promoting Methods to Build Resident-oriented Village Project. Mokpo National University Master's thesis.
  5. Bang, H. Y.(2003) A Study on the Application of Regional Heritage and Community Design for Rural Activation. Chongju University Doctoral thesis.
  6. Baron, R. M., Kenny, D. A.(1986) The moderator - mediator variable distinction in social psychological research : Conceptual, strategic and statistical considerations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (51).
  7. Chai, J. H.(2010) Analysis on the Economic Accomplishment and Spill-Over Effect of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project. Chonnam National University Doctoral thesis.
  8. Cho, J. S.(2009) Performance and Problem Analysis of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project. Journal of Korean Society of Rural planning 15(4).
  9. Cho, S. J.(2004) Finding of Rural Amenity Resources (RAR) and Development of Site-Applied RAR Planning Techniques with Community Participation Model. Rural Resource Development Institute of Rural Development Administration.
  10. Choi, H. D.(2009) A Study of Residents' Participations in Rural Tourism and Their Perception of Tourism Impacts on Their Communities. Kyonggi University Master's thesis.
  11. Choi, H. Y.(2009) A Study on the Effect of Support Factors in Green Tourism on Business Performance. Kwandong University Doctoral thesis.
  12. Hur, J. Y.(2009) A Study on the Residents' Participation and Satisfaction Levels for the Integrated Rural Village Development Project. Yeungnam University Master's thesis.
  13. Jin, Y. H., Ryu, S. H., Cho, P. K., Kim, J. B., Kwon, Y. S.(2007) Making the Livable City by Citizen Participation : Case Study of Korea. Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements.
  14. Joo, K. R.(2004) The Furtherance Direction of Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project. Rural and Environmental Engineering Journal (82).
  15. Keiko Torigoe(鳥越けい子)(1997) 環境社會學の理論と實踐. 有斐閣.
  16. Kim, D. K.(2011) A Study on Residents'Attitude of Participation in their Residential Neighborhood Improvement. Journal of Korea Planners Association 46(3).
  17. Kim, J. H.(2009) A Study on structuring Agricultural Governance and the roles of Local Council. Chonbuk National University Master's thesis.
  18. Kim, N. D.(2006) Types and Characteristics of Community Building with People. Chungbuk National University Master's thesis.
  19. Kim, N. J., Moon, S. M.(2007) The Development of Performance Evaluation Model Using BSC. Journal of Tourism Sciences 31(3).
  20. Kim, T. D.(2014) Comparative Resident Satisfaction Studies between Changwon and Cheongju Regeneration Project. Chungbuk National University Master's thesis.
  21. Kim, Y., Lee, P. Y., Kim, N. R., Jeong, K. S.(2008), A Study of Characteristics and Evaluation on Community Building Governance. Journal of Korean Urban Management Association 21(3).
  22. Ko, C. S.(2003)Reflection and The Direction of The Jeju Regional Development Policy at The Turn : Critical Reflection on The Advance Value of Jeju Development. Gak Publishers.
  23. Ko, J. H., Ji, Y. D.(2002) "The Roles of Several Mediators and Moderators Between Pornography and Rape Myth", The Korea Journal of Youth Counseling, 10(1)
  24. Kwak, H. K.(2008)Meaning and Forming Strategies of Modern Local Community, Jong-su Lee Ed. Korean Society and Community. Dasan Books.
  25. Lee, B. W.(2005) The cause and effect of residents' conflict in the rural tourism business. The University of Seoul Master's thesis.
  26. Lee, J. H.(2009) A Study on Affecting Factor-Construction of the Residents-participatory in Maeul mandeulgi. Hanyang University Master's thesis.
  27. Lee, J. H.(2013) A Case Study of Machizkurii in Japan. The Rural Revitalization Support Center / Jeju.
  28. Lee, J. J., Lee, S. M.(2003) Analysis on the Factors Motivating the Residents' Participation in Sustainable Rural Village Program. Journal of Korea Planners Association 38(3).
  29. Lee, S. G.(2007) mediation effects in Social work research. Social work Review (12).
  30. MacKinnon, D. P., Warsi, G., and Dwyer, J. H.(1995) A simulation study of mediated effect measures. Multivariate Behavior Research (30).
  31. Ministry of Security and Public Administration(2003) Study of Development of Budget Performance Management System Objectives and Indicators.
  32. Park, H. C.(2011) Rural Community Design by the Concept of Eco-museum. Chungbuk National University Doctoral thesis.
  33. Park, S. J.(2013) A Study on the Problems and Improvement at the Operation and Management Phase of the Comprehensive Rural Village Development Projects. Chonnam National University Master's thesis.
  34. Presidential Committee on Balanced National Development (2007)Balanced Development Policy Manual: Creating a Livable Region. J-PLUS AD.
  35. Shin, J. J., Song, S. H.(2010) A Study on the Relation- planning of Participants for Sustainable Community Building. Journal of The Architectural Institute of Korea Planning & Design 26(1).
  36. Shin, M. G.(2007) Relationship between the leadership style of the leader of development of rural areas perceived by residents and resident participation. Korea University Master's Thesis.
  37. Sobel, M. E. (1982) Asymptotic confidence intervals for indirect effects in structural equation models. Sociological methodology (13).
  38. Song, G. S.(1999) A Study on the Citizen Participation in Process of Regional Development. Dankook University Master's thesis.
  39. Song, H. S.(2008) A Study on the Preference Type in Residents-participatory Machizkurii. Hanyang University Master's thesis.
  40. Song, M. R., Park, S. H.(2002) Reexamination of Villagers - initiated Rural Planning and Development. Journal of Korea Planners Association 37(1).
  41. Song, M. R., Seong, J. I.(2004) Evaluation of Rural Village Development Programs and Suggestions for Participatory Village Development Model. Korea Rural Economic Institute, A research paper R482.
  42. Song, M. R., Seong, J. I.(2005) An Analysis of Relationship between the Successes and Failures of Rural Village Development Programs and Residents' Participation. Journal of The Korean Regional Development Association 17(4).
  43. Tamura, Akira(田村明).Idea of Community Buildin g, trans. Kang, H. J.(2005) Sohwa Books.
  44. Tamura, Akira(田村明).Community Building and Urban Landscape, trans. Jang, J. H., Kim, S. J.(2008) Hyungseul Publishing Networks.
  45. Yaeko Nishiyama(西山八重子)(1992) Sociology of City and Autonomy. Culture Bookstore Bakmun-sa.
  46. Yasuhiro Endo(延藤安弘) I Would Like to live such a Village, trans. Kim, C. H.(1997) Golden Bough Books.
  47. Yoo, S. G.(2007) Rural Development and The Role of Resident. Rural and Environmental Engineering Journal (94).
  48. Yoo, S. K.(2012) A Study on the Types of Resident Participation and IPA analysis of the Comprehensive Rural Village Development Project in Hampyeong area. Chonnam National University Master's thesis.

Cited by

  1. 신내생발전전략 관점을 통한 마을공동체 활성화 요인에 관한 연구 -박근혜 정부 시기의 중앙부처 사업을 중심으로- vol.31, pp.2, 2015, https://doi.org/10.21026/jlgs.2019.31.2.377
  2. 성장단계별 마을공동체 사업의 성과에 대한 영향요인 분석: ICA 프레임워크를 통한 단계별 비교분석을 중심으로 vol.26, pp.2, 2015, https://doi.org/10.17089/kgr.2019.26.2.006