Journal of the Korean Society of Systems Engineering (시스템엔지니어링학술지)

The Korean Society of Systems Engineering (한국시스템엔지니어링학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

An Effective Analysis and Management of Technical Risk to Turn-key based Plant Construction Contracts using Systems Engineering

시스템엔지니어링을 이용한 턴키방식 플랜트 건설계약의 기술적 위험요인 효과적 분석 및 관리

  • Hong, Dae Geun (POSTECH Graduate School of Engineering Mastership(GEM)) ;
  • Byun, Hee Chul (POSTECH Graduate School of Engineering Mastership(GEM)) ;
  • Suh, Suk-Hwan (POSTECH Graduate School of Engineering Mastership(GEM))
  • 홍대근 (포항공과대학교 엔지니어링대학원) ;
  • 변희철 (포항공과대학교 엔지니어링대학원) ;
  • 서석환 (포항공과대학교 엔지니어링대학원)
  • Published : 2014.12.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

In the bidding stage of turn-key based plant construction contracts, owners provide design and performance basis for contractors instead of giving design drawing. To win the bid for a plant construction, the contractors should be obliged to satisfy and ensure owners'requirements such as design and performance basis in a plant construction project, In other words, owners imposes technical risk of the design to the contractors by specifying responsibility for the analysis and verification of the plant construction. Thus, it is very important that contracters make accurate and realistic basic design plan in a short period of time. To deal with such a situation, we propose a systems engineering approach for the analysis and management of the technical risk. Specifically, we first: 1) Analyzes technical risk related with the plant design information for the bidders, followed by 2) Developing stakeholder requirements for the basic engineering design, and 3) System requirements for dealing with technical risk. Also, in this paper, we proposed converting method from MOE(Measure of Effectiveness) to MOP(Measure of Performance) in the risk analysis. To show the effectiveness of the proposed method, we carried out a case study.

Keywords

References

  1. Choi, M.K. and Son, S.S., A Comparative Study on the Orgalime's General Conditions for Turnkey Contracts and FIDIC's Silver Book, Journal of Korean Research Institute of International Commerce and Law, Vol.23. pp.129-153, 2002.
  2. FIDIC(The International Federation of Consulting Engineers), Conditions of Contract for EPC Turnkey Projects(Silver Book), International Federation of Consulting Engineering. 1999.
  3. Helmus, F.P., Process Plant Design - Project Management from Inquiry to Acceptance. KGaA, Weinheim, Wiley VCH, pp.13-36, 2008.
  4. ICAK(International Contractors Association of Korea), Information Service, Advice & Support, http://www.icak.or.kr/sta/sta_0101.php, access time: 2014.10.13. am 10:00.
  5. Ki, W.W., Kim, J.P., Hong, D.G. and Suh, S.H., A study on Application of Systems Engineering Technical Process to FEED in Plant construction Industry - focused on a case of Environmental plant, Journal of the Korea Society of Systems Engineering, Vol.9, No.2, pp.37-54, 2013. https://doi.org/10.14248/JKOSSE.2013.9.2.037
  6. Kim, H.J., An Analytical Study on Contractual Issues and Risk Allocation in Design-Build and Turnkey, Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea, Vol.26, No.8, pp.79-86, 2010.
  7. Kim, K.O. and Kim, D.H., A Study on Some Issues of Business and Law in relation to ICC Model Turnkey Contract - Focusing on ICC Model Contract for Turnkey Supply of Industrial Plant, Journal of Korean Research Institute of International Commerce and Law, Vol.54. pp.191-211, 2012.
  8. Kim, S.M., A Study on Risk Analysis and Relevant Measures for the Successful Performance in Overseas Construction Projects - Including Case Analysis on A Overseas Construction Project, Journal of Korean Research Institute of International Commerce and Law, Vol.50. pp.215-250, 2011.
  9. Kim, S.Y., Cha, J.M., Kim, J.P., Suh, S.H., Sur, H.W., A Systems Engineering Approach to FEED Work Process Development for Refinery Plant, Journal of the Korea Society of Systems Engineering, Vol.10, No.1, pp.1-16, 2014.
  10. Koh, H.S., Risk Analysis of Contractual Provisions for EPC/Turnkey Projects : Contractor's Liability Position, Master thesis, Pohang University of Science and Technology, 2014.
  11. MOLIT(Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport), Current state of amount of order for overseas construction project, http://http://korealand.tistory.com/4089 access time: 2014.10.13. am 10:00.
  12. Noble, P.J., Process Plant Construction - A Handbook for Quality Management, West Sussex, UK, Wiley & Blackwel pp.1-10, 2009.
  13. Oh, W.S. and Kim, Y.I., A Case Study on the Limitations of the Choice of Law caused by Internationally Mandatory Rules in Entering into the Turn-Key Contracts, Journal of Korean Research Institute of International Commerce and Law, Vol.54. pp.145-166, 2012.
  14. Oh, W.S. and Lee, K.O., A Study on the Practical Suggestions in the Contract for the Turnkey Supply of an Industrial Plant - Focused on the Commentary of ICC Model Contract, Journal of Korean Research Institute of International Commerce and Law, Vol.53. pp.3-29, 2012.
  15. Yoo, H.S. and Lee, J.H., Plant Engineering and Project Management, Koera Institute of Plant Engineering and Construction, Seoul, Korea, 2009.