A Comparative Analysis of Field and Slide Survey on Subjective Image of the Nightscape

야경의 주관적 이미지에 관한 현지평가와 슬라이드평가의 비교분석

  • Published : 2007.04.30

Abstract

Despite of many supportive research to the usefulness of slide evaluation on environment of outdoor lighting, study method of using slides have provoked many discussions of its manifestation of reality of field conditions. This study aims to compare the results of slide survey with that of field survey. Distant view and short range view of nightscape of Seoul were selected. Field measurement of luminance and chromaticity were conducted and questionnaire survey were conducted. Frequency analysis, T-test, factor analysis were conducted. Results shows that distant view and short range view of field survey have better visual atmosphere than slide survey. In addition, slide survey on distant view shows lowest values. Difference between field survey and slide survey on distant view is much bigger than the results of short range view.

Keywords

References

  1. 김정태 외, "역사적 건축물의 야간 경관조명 실태조사", 대한건축학회논문집(계획계), Vol.15, N0.12, pp.221-231, 1999.12
  2. 이진숙, 유재연, 김병수, "야간경관조명의 조명방식에 따른 평가 특성분석", 대한한건축학회논문집, Vol.20, No.2, pp.185-192, 2004.02
  3. 김정태, 심인보, "광선반 채광시스템의 시각적 성능평가", 한국생태환경건축학회논문집, Vol.6 No.2, pp.3-10. 2006.06
  4. 최안섭, 장수정, 오은숙, 김영욱, "공간구문론을 활용한 아파트 가로조명계획에 관한 연구", 대한건축학회논문집(계획계). Vol.21, N0.5, pp.189-196, 2005.05
  5. 임승빈, 경관분석론, 서울대학교출판부, 2003.01
  6. Hyun Tae AHN, Ki Hoon MOON, Yoon Seok CHOI, Subjective Responses on Nightscape of Korea", Proceeding of International Conference URBAN NIGHTSCAPE 2006, Athens, pp.180-182, 2006.09
  7. Russel P. Leslie, The Outdoor Lighting Pattern Book, McGraw-Hill, 1996