Sensitivity Analysis of Wind Resource Micrositing at the Antarctic King Sejong Station

남극 세종기지에서의 풍력자원 국소배치 민감도 분석

  • Kim, Seok-Woo (Wind Energy Research Group, Korea Institute of Energy Research) ;
  • Kim, Hyun-Goo (Wind Energy Research Group, Korea Institute of Energy Research)
  • 김석우 (한국에너지기술연구원 풍력발전연구단) ;
  • 김현구 (한국에너지기술연구원 풍력발전연구단)
  • Published : 2007.12.30

Abstract

Sensitivity analysis of wind resource micrositing has been performed through the application case at the Antarctic King Sejong station with the most representative micrositing softwares: WAsP, WindSim and Meteodyn WT. The wind data obtained from two met-masts separated 625m were applied as a climatology input condition of micro-scale wind mapping. A tower shading effect on the met-mast installed 20m apart from the warehouse has been assessed by the CFD software Fluent and confirmed a negligible influence on wind speed measurement. Theoretically, micro-scale wind maps generated by the two met-data located within the same wind system and strongly correlated meteor-statistically should be identical if nothing influenced on wind prediction but orography. They, however, show discrepancies due to nonlinear effects induced by surrounding complex terrain. From the comparison of sensitivity analysis, Meteodyn WT employing 1-equation turbulence model showed 68% higher RMSE error of wind speed prediction than that of WindSim using the ${\kappa}-{\epsilon}$ turbulence model, while a linear-theoretical model WAsP showed 21% higher error. Consequently, the CFD model WindSim would predict wind field over complex terrain more reliable and less sensitive to climatology input data than other micrositing models. The auto-validation method proposed in this paper and the evaluation result of the micrositing softwares would be anticipated a good reference of wind resource assessments in complex terrain.

Keywords

References

  1. 김석우, 경남호, 극한환경에서의 소형풍력발전 실증운전, 한국태양에너지학회 논문집, 26권, 4호, pp. 25-30, 2006
  2. 김석우, 김현구, 남극 세종기지의 전산유동해석에 의한 풍력자원평가, 한국태양에너지학회 논문집, 27권, 3호, 2007
  3. 배재성, 장문석, 주영철, 윤정은, 경남호, 남극 세종기지의 풍력자원 분석, 한국태양에너지학회 논문집, 25권, 3호, pp. 53-60, 2005
  4. Albrecht, C. AND Klesitz, M., Three-Dimensional Wind Field Calculation Above Orographic Complex Terrain in Southern Europe, European Wind Energy Conference, Athens, 2006
  5. Berge, E., Gravdahl, A. R., Schelling, J., Tallhaug, L. and Undheim, 0., Wind in Complex Terrain: A Comparison of WAsP and Two CFD- Models, European Wind Energy Conference, Athens, 2003
  6. Bowen, A. J. and Mortensen, N. G., WAsP Prediction Errors Due to Site Topography, Risoe National Lab., Risoe-R-995, 2004
  7. Ishihara, T., Yamaguchi, A. and Fujino, Y., A Nonlinear Model for Predictions of Turbulent Flow Over Steep Terrain, World Wind Energy Conference, Berlin, 2002
  8. Jackson, P. S. and Hunt, J. C. R. Turbulent Wind Flow Over a Low Hill, Quart. J. Roy. Met. Soc., Vol.101, pp. 929-955, 1975 https://doi.org/10.1002/qj.49710143015
  9. Kim, H. G., Test of WindSim for the Wind Flow with Recirculation, WindSim User Meeting, Tonsberg, 2007
  10. Llombart, A., Mallet, A., Burillo, N., Alvarez, O., Talayero, A., Influence of Orography on Wind Resource Assessment Programs, European Wind Energy Conference, Milano, 2007
  11. Llombart, A., Talayero, A., Mallet, A., Telmo, E., Performance Analysis of Wind Resource Assessment Programs in Complex Terrain, Int'l Conference on Renewable Energies and Power Quality, 2006
  12. Martin, S., Simulation of Wind Profiles with WindSim/Phoenics, WindSim User Meeting, Tonsberg, 2007
  13. McKay, D. C., Dealing with Uncertainty: Wind Resource Assessrrent, Evironmental Finance Workshop, Toronto, 2005
  14. Moreno, P., Calbo, J., Pozo, M and Gravdahl, A. R, Micro-Scale Effects Over the Wind: Modeling Flow Around Buildings with WmdSim-Phoenics, European Wind Energy Conference, Athens, 2006
  15. Steinbach, E., Comparison of Measured Wind ProfIles with WindSim Calculations, WindSim User Meeting, Tonsberg, 2007
  16. Watson, G., Doublas, N., Hall, S., Comparison of Wind Flow Models in Complex Terrain, World Renewable Energy Congress, 2005
  17. Wood, N., The Onset of Separation in Neutral, Turbulent Flow over Hills, Boundary-Layer Meteorol., Vol.76, pp. 137-164, 1995 https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00710894