A Comparative Study on the Houses of Richard Meier and Mario Botta

리챠드 마이어 주택과 마리오 보타 주택의 비교 연구

  • 김용립 (상명대학교 디자인학과 실내디자인)
  • Published : 2006.10.31

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to compare the houses of Richard Meier and those of Mario Botta to identify the features of their houses. To identify the features of their houses through comparison, it was most important to understand the influences of their masters on them. Based on the lessons they learned from their masters, their houses were compared and analyzed. The findings were as follows. First, both their houses illustrated the principle and language of Le Corbuiser. They extended the principle and language of Le Corbuiser with their own thoughts and ideas and applied those to their houses. Second, the difference between their houses arose from the influence of Louis Kahn and Carlo Scarpa on Botta and the influence of Mies van der Roeh on Meier. Botta who was taught by Kahn and Scarpa was able to develop his expressive and heavy style of brick house, while Meier who was influenced from Mies was distinguished for his cold, transparent, sleek and contemporary style of house. Third, they both showed outstanding abilities to integrate the principles and languages of their masters in their own creative ways, when developing their own styles of houses. While Volume of Corbuiser, skills and languages of Kahn and Scarpa were put together in Botta's house, the Corbuiser's feature of sectional variety and the Mies' feature of sleek and transparency were overlapped in Meier's house. Fourth, while new expression shown in Botta's house was achieved in the process of integrating the languages of Kahn and Scarpa, new expression shown in Meier's house was created mostly in the process of taking and applying materials and languages from contemporary times.

Keywords

References

  1. Cappellato, Gabriele ed., Mario Botta/ Light and Gravity, Munich: Prestel, 2003
  2. Green, Lisa J. ed., Richard Meier/ Architect 2, New York: Rizzoli International Publications, 1991
  3. Green, Lisa J. ed., Richard Meier/ Architect 3, New York: Rizzoli International Publications, 1999
  4. Green, Lisa J. ed., Richard Meier/ Buildings and Projects 1979-1989, London: Academy Editions, 1990
  5. Jodidio, Philip, Richard Meier, Koln,: Benedikit Taschen Verlag 1995
  6. Ockman, Joan ed., Richard Meier/ Architect, New York: Rizzoli International Publications, 1984€
  7. Pizzi, Emilio ed., Mario Botta/ The Complete Works, Vol.1, Zurich: Artemis, 1993
  8. Pizzi, Emilio ed., Mario Botta/ The Complete Works, Vol.2, Basel: Birkhauser, 1994
  9. Rykwert, Joseph, Louis Kahn, New York: Harry N. Abrahams, 2001
  10. Sacchi, Luisa ed., Mario Botta/ Architectural Poetics, New York : Universe, 2000
  11. White, Elizabeth ed., Richard Meier/ Architect 4, New York: Rizzoli International Publications, 2004
  12. Black, Peter, 현대건축의 거장/ 르 꼬르뷰제, 윤정섭 역, 서울: 건우사, 1993
  13. Blaser, Werner, 미스 반 데어 로에, 송춘식 역, 서울: 대우출판사, 1983
  14. Boesiger, W. and Stonorow, O. ed., Le Corbusier, 8 Vols., 르꼬르부 지에 작품연구회 편역, 서울: 집문사, 1991
  15. Dal Co, Francesco, Mario Botta, 김홍기 역, 서울: 기문당, 1992
  16. 서경원 ed., Pro Architect 20/ Mario Botta, 서울: 건축 세계사, 2000
  17. Architectural Monographs, Mies van der Rohe, 이민 역, 서울: 공간도 서, 1989
  18. A+U, Carlo Scarpa, 장성수 역, 서울: 태림문화사, 1988
  19. A+U, Louis I. Kahn/ 착상과 의미, 이강훈 역, 서울: 도서출판 갑을, 1985
  20. A+U, Mario Botta, 편집부 편역, 서울: 집문사, 1997
  21. GA Architect 3, Mario Botta, Tokyo: A.D.A. Edita, 1984
  22. GA Document Extra, Richard Meier, Tokyo: A.D.A. Edita, 1997
  23. Pro Architect 20, Mario Botta, 서울: 건축세계사, 2000
  24. 김용립, 리챠드 마이어의 주거공간에 관한 연구, 실내디자인 제13호 1997
  25. 김용립, 마리오 보타 주택특성에 관한 고찰, 실내디자인 제17호, 1998
  26. 정금화, Le Corbusier의 주거 디자인요소에 관한 연구/ Villa Savoye를 중심으로, 석사학위논문, 홍익대학교 환경대학원, 1988