Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases

The Korean Academy of Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases (대한결핵및호흡기학회)
권호 표지

The Medico-Legal and Ethical Problems of Withholding / Withdrawing of Futile Life-Sustaining Mechanical Respirator treatment

연명(延命)치료적 인공기계호흡요법의 보류(保留)/중지(中止)를 전후한, 법의학적 및 윤리적 문제들과 그 대처방안

  • Published : 2005.03.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The first and the longest criminal indictment case of Korean medico-legal battle, so called BORAMAE Hospital Incident, was finally on its end by Korean Supreme Court's decision on June 24, 2004, after 7 years long legal dispute via Seoul District Court and Seoul Superior Appeal Court's decision. Boramae Hospital case was the first Korean legal case of Withdrawing Life-sustaining treatment of mechanical respirator on 58 years old Extradural Hematoma victim who was on Respirator under Coma after multi-organ failure postoperatively(APACHE II score: 34-39). Two physicians who have involved patient's care and had helped to make discharge the Near-death patient to home after repeated demand of patient's wife, due to economic reason, were sentenced as homicidal crime. This review article will discuss the following items with the review of US cases, Quinlan(1976), Nancy Cruzan(1990), Barber (1983), Helen Wanglie(1990), Baby K (1994) and Baby L cases, along with Official Statement of ATS and other Academic dignitaries of US and World.: [1] Details of Boramae Hospital incident, medical facts description and legal language of homicidal crime sentence. [2] The medical dispute about the legal misinterpretation of patient's clinical status, regarding the severity of the victim with multi-organs failure on Respirator under coma with least chance of recovery, less than 10% probability. [3] Case study of US, of similar situation. [4] Introduction of ATS official Statement on Withdrawing/ Withholding Life sustaining treatment. [5] Patient Autonomy as basic principle. [6] The procedural formality in Medical practise for keeping the legitimacy. [7] The definition of Medical Futility and its dispute. [8] Dying in Dignity and PAS(Physician Assisted Suicide)/and/or Euthanasia [9] The Korean version of "Dying in Dignity", based on the Supreme Court's decision of Boramae Hospital incident (2004.6.24.) [10] Summary and Author's Note for future prospects.

Keywords

References

  1. 대한의사협회. 연명치료중단의 정책적대토론회: 보라 매병원사건을 중심으로. 2004. 8. 25. 서울. 국회의원 회관
  2. 김건열. '보라매병원사건'의 재발방지를 위한 의료인의 대비. 의협신보 2003;3728호-3736호
  3. 김건열. '보라매병원사건'의 재발방지를 위한 의료인의 대비. 최신의학사; 2004
  4. American Thoracic Society. Withholding and with. drawing life-sustaining therapy. Am Rev Respir Dis 1991;144:726-31 https://doi.org/10.1164/ajrccm/144.3_Pt_1.726
  5. American Thoracic Society. Withholding and with. drawing life-sustaining therapy. Ann Int Med 1991; 115:478-85 https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-115-6-478
  6. 이상돈. 의료형법. 법문사; 1998
  7. 대한의사협회. 의사윤리지침내용과 실천방안 대토론회. 2004. 12. 4. 대한의사협회 중앙윤리위원회. 서울
  8. 대한의학회. 연명치료중단의 법 정책적대토론회: 보라 매병원사건을 중심으로. 2002. 3. 29. 서울
  9. 대한의학회. 안락사: 존엄사에 대한 의학적 접근. 2001 년 임상의학 심포지엄. 2001. 11. 10. 서울
  10. 대한의학회. 임종환자의 연명치료 중단에 관한 대한의 학회 의료윤리 지침 제1보. 2002
  11. Kilner JF, Cameron NM, Schiedermayer DL. Bioethics and the future of medicine: a christian appraisal. Michigan: William Beerdmans Publishing Company; 1995
  12. Luce JM, Alpers A. Legal aspects of withholding and withdrawing life support from critically ill patients in the United States and providing palliative care to them. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2000;162:2029-32 https://doi.org/10.1164/ajrccm.162.6.1-00
  13. Luce JM. Physician do not have a responsibility to provide futile or unreasonable care if a patient or family insists. Crit Care Med 1995;23:760-6 https://doi.org/10.1097/00003246-199504000-00027
  14. Luce JM. Making decision about the forgoing of life-sustaining therapy. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1997;156:1715-8 https://doi.org/10.1164/ajrccm.156.6.9705004
  15. Angell M. The case of Helga Wanglie: a new kind of 'right to die'. N Engl J Med 1991;325:511-2 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199108153250712
  16. Paris JJ, Crane RK, Peardon F. Physicians' refusal of requested treatment: the case of baby L. N Engl J Med 1990;322:1012-5
  17. Annas GJ, Arnold B, Aroskar M, Battin P, Bartels D, Beauchamp T, et al. Bioethicists' statement on the US Supream Court's Cruzan decision. N Engl J Med 1990;323:686-7 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199009063231020
  18. American Thoracic Society. Fair allocation of intensivecare unit resources. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 1997; 156:1282-301 https://doi.org/10.1164/ajrccm.156.4.ats7-97
  19. Rubenfeld GD, Randall Curtis J. End of life care in the ICU: a research agenda. Crit Care Med 2001;29: 2001 https://doi.org/10.1097/00003246-200110000-00025
  20. Carlet J, Thijs LG, Antolelli M, Cassell J, Cox P, Hill N, et al. Challenge in end-of-life care in the ICU: statement of the 5th International Consensus Conference in Critical Care: Brussels Belgium, April 2003. Intensive Care Med 2004;30:770-84 https://doi.org/10.1007/s00134-004-2241-5
  21. Clarke EB, Luce JM, Curtis JR, Danis M, Levy M, Nelson J, et al. A content analysis of forms, guidelines and other materials documenting end-of-life care in intensive care units. J Crit Care 2004;19:108-17 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrc.2004.05.001
  22. Meisel A, Snider L, Quiel A. Seven legal barries to end-of-life care: myths, realities and grains of truth. JAMA 2000;284:2495-501 https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.284.19.2495
  23. Clarke EB, Curtis JR, Luce JM, Levy M, Danis M, Nelson J, et al. Quality indicators for end-of life care in the ICU. Crit Care Med 2003;31:2255-62 https://doi.org/10.1097/01.CCM.0000084849.96385.85
  24. Haley A, Brody BA. A multi-institution collaborative policy on medical futility. JAMA 1996;276;571-4 https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.276.7.571
  25. Luce JM, Alpers A. End-of-life care: what do the American courts say? Crit Care Med 2001;29(2 Suppl): N40-5 https://doi.org/10.1097/00003246-200101000-00011
  26. Fins JJ, Solomon MZ. Communication in intensive care setting: the challenge of futility disputes. Crit Care Med 2001;29(2 Suppl):N10-5 https://doi.org/10.1097/00003246-200102001-00003
  27. Truog RD, Brett AS, Frader J. The problem with futility. N Engl J Med 1992;326:1560-4 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199206043262310
  28. The Ethic Committee of Society of Critical Care Medicine. Consensus statement of the Society of Critical Care Medicine's Ethics Committee regarding futile and other possibly inadvisable treatments. Crit Care Med 1997;25:887-91 https://doi.org/10.1097/00003246-199705000-00028
  29. Schneiderman LJ, Jecker NS, Jonsen AR. Medical futility: its meaning and ethical implications. Ann Intern Med 1990;112:949-54 https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-112-12-949
  30. Lantos JD, Singer PA, Walker RM, Gramelspacher GP, Shapiro GR, Sanchez-Gonzalez MA, et al. The illusion of futility in clinical practice. Am J Med 1989; 87:81-4 https://doi.org/10.1016/0002-9343(89)90542-1
  31. Schneiderman LJ, Jecker NS, Jonsen AR. Medical futility: response to critiques. Ann Intern Med 1996; 125:669-74 https://doi.org/10.7326/0003-4819-125-8-199610150-00007
  32. Civetta JM. Futile care or caregiver frustration?: a practical approach. Crit Care Med 1996;24:346-51 https://doi.org/10.1097/00003246-199602000-00027
  33. Tomlinson T, Brody H. Futility and the ethics of resuscitation. JAMA 1990;264:1276-80 https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.264.10.1276
  34. The cost of taking care of the elderly, the golden age. Newsweek, 2004 Dec 6; p. 40-9
  35. 한국노인과학학술단체연합회. 국제전문가회의: 고령사 회와 세계각국의 대응. 2004. 10. 29. 서울
  36. American College of Chest Physicians / Society of Critical Care Medicine. Ethical and moral guideline for the initiation, continuation, and withdrawal of intensive care. Chest 1990;97:949-58 https://doi.org/10.1378/chest.97.4.949
  37. Troug RD, Cist AF, Brackett SE, Burns JP, Curley MA, Danis M, et al. Recommendations for end-of-life in the intensive care unit. Crit Care Med 2001;29: 2332-48 https://doi.org/10.1097/00003246-200112000-00017
  38. Gostin LO. Deciding life and death in the courtroom: from quinlan to Cruzan, Glucksberg and Vacco-a brief history and analysis of constitutional protection of the 'right to die'. JAMA 1997;278:1523-8 https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.278.18.1523
  39. Burt RA. The Supream Court Speaks: not assisted suicide but a constitutional right to palliative care. N Engl J Med 1997;337:1234-6 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199710233371712
  40. Angell M. Caring for the dying: congressional mis. chief. N Engl J Med 1999;341:1923-5 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199912163412509
  41. Obe DD, Hanks G, Cherny N, Calnan K. Oxford text. book of palliative medicine. 3rd ed. Oxford Press; 2004
  42. 제랄드 드워킨, 프레이 RG, 시셀라복. 안락사 논쟁. 책 세상; 2002
  43. Downing AB. Euthanasia and the right to death, the case of voluntary euthanasia. London; 1977
  44. 김일순, 포션 N. 醫療倫理: 삶과 죽음, 그 영원한 숙제. 연세대학교 출판부; 1982
  45. 한국 카톨릭의사협회. 醫學倫理. 수문사; 1984
  46. 서울대학교 의과대학 의학교육연수원. 임상윤리학. 서울대학교 출판부; 1999
  47. Munson R. 의료문제의 윤리적 성찰. 단국대학교 출판부; 2001
  48. Berger AM, Portenoy RK, Weissman DE. Princeples & practice of palliative care & supportive oncology. 2nd ed. Lippincott William & Wilkins; 2002