A Study on Accuracy of Environmental Reporting in Korean Major Dailies

국내 중앙 일간지 환경보도의 정확성에 관한 연구

  • 안종주 (서울대학교 보건대학원)
  • Published : 2002.03.01

Abstract

Generally, inaccurate reports on environmental issues occur due to various factors. The purpose of this study was to find out a way to enhance accuracy of environmental reporting. So the reporters' career and college major had been compared to the accuracy of their articles. The by-lined environmental articles in nine dailies published in 1991 were checked. Results of this study were as follows. (I) Inaccuracy rate in environmental articles was 54.2%. Inaccuracies appeared 1.7 times per an article, while the average frequency of inaccuracies in overall articles was 0.9 time. (2) Errors in the articles consist of 65.8% of subjective inaccuracies and 34.2% of subjective inaccuracies. They derive from the false usage of terminology(15.8% ),misquotation(14.5%), incorrect statistics(13%), exaggeration(13%), inaccurate title(7.9%), and false comparison(5%). (3) Inaccuracy rate by the type of articles was 66.7% in columns, 60% in feature stories, 54.5% in-depth stories, 40.9% in straight news, respectively. (4) Inaccuracy rate by the specific field was shown 71.4% in environmental impacts assessment, 52.5% in water pollution, 37.5% in waste management, and 35.7% in air pollution. (5) According to the result of chi-square test analysis, there were no statistically significant differences of inaccuracy rate and of subjective, and objective inaccuracies relevant to the period of reporters' career covering environmental reporting and the nature of articles, and college major.

Keywords

References

  1. 차배근 : 오보의 발생원인과 정정의 책임, 신문과 방송. 제223호, 한국언론연구원, 4-18, 1989
  2. 임병국 : 한국 일간신문의 오보와 그 구제에 관한 연구. 경희대 대학원 박사학위 논문, 11-14, 1991
  3. Greenberg, B.S. and Tannenbaum, P. H. : Communicator Performance under Cognitive Stress. Journalism Quarterly, Spring, 169-178, 1962
  4. Berry, F.C., Jr. : A Study of Accuracy in Local News Stories of the three Dailies. Joumalism Quarterly, Vol.3, 482-490,1967
  5. Singletary M. W, : How Editors view Accuracy in News Reporting. Journalism Quarterly, Winter, 786-789, 1977
  6. Lawrence, G. C., and Grey, D. R. : Subjective Inaccuracies in Local News Reporting. Journalism Quarterly, Winter, 753-757,1964
  7. 신문과 방송. 11,7-8,1989
  8. Charnley, M. : Preliminary Notes on a Study of Newspaper Accuracy. Journalism Quarterly, 13, 394-401, 1936
  9. Brown, C. A.: Majority of Readers give Newspapers for accuracy. Editor & Publisher, Feb, 1965
  10. Tankard, J. W. et al. : News Source Perceptions of Accuracy of Science Coverage, Journalism Quarterly, 51, 219-224, 1977
  11. Pulford, D. L. : Follow-up Study of Newspaper Accuracy, Journalism Quarterly, 53, 119-121, 1976 https://doi.org/10.1177/107769907605300119
  12. 한국언론연구원 : 신문보도의 정확성. 1-65, 1984
  13. 최윤희 : 보건커뮤니케이션의 연구경향과 문제점. 신문연구 통권 제54호, 관훈클럽, 1992