Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology

The Korean Society of Mechanical Engineers (대한기계학회)
권호 표지

A Parametric Study of Sheet Metal Denting Using a Simplified Design Approach

  • Jung, Dong-Won (Department of Mechanical Engineering, Cheju National University)
  • Published : 2002.12.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

In the interest of improved automotive fuel economy, one solution is reducing vehicle weight. Achieving significant weight reductions will normally require reducing the panel thickness or using alternative materials such as aluminum alloy sheet. These changes will affect the dent resistance of the panel. In this study, the correlation between panel size, curvature, thickness, material properties and dent resistance is investigated. A parametric approach is adopted, utilizing a "design software" tool incorporating empirical equations to predict denting and panel stiffness for simplified panels. The most effective time to optimize an automotive body panel is early in its development. The developed design program can be used to minimize panel thickness or compare different materials, while maintaining adequate panel performance.

Keywords

References

  1. Alaniz, C. L. and Borchelt, J. E., 1991, 'Study of Parameters that Affect Body Panel Performance Predictions,' SAE Paper No. 910289
  2. Belytschko, T., Lin, J. I. and Tsay, C., 1984, 'Explicit Algorithms for the Non-Linear Dynamlcs of Shells,' Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, Vol. 42, pp.225-251 https://doi.org/10.1016/0045-7825(84)90026-4
  3. Belytschko, T. and Tsay, C., 1983, 'A Stabilization Procedure for the Quadrilateral Plate Element with One-Point Quadrature,' International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, Vol. 19, pp.405-419 https://doi.org/10.1002/nme.1620190308
  4. Burley, C. E. and Niemeier, B. A., 1977, 'Denting Properties of Aluminum Autobody Components,' SAE Technical Paper No. 770199
  5. Burley, C. E., Niemeier, B. A. and Koch, G. P., 1976, 'Dynamic Denting of Autobody Panels,' SAE Technical Paper No. 760165
  6. Chavali, R. and Song, W., 1996, 'Coupling Forming and Denting Simulations for Automotive Closure Panels'
  7. Chen, C. H., Rastogi, P. K. and Horvath, C. D., 1993, 'Effects of Steel Thickness and Mechanical Properties on Vehicle Outer Panel Performance: Stiffness, Oil Canning Load and Dent Resistance,' Proceedings IBEC '93, International Body Engineering Conference, pp. 26-32
  8. Chen, K. K. and Salamie, P. A., 1984, 'A Mathematical Model for Calculating the Dent Initiation Loads at the Door Centers,' SAE Paper No. 841201
  9. DiCello, J. A. and George, R. A., 1974, 'Design Criteria for the Dent Resistance of Auto Body Panels,' SAE Technical Paper No. 740081
  10. Ekstrand, G. and Asnafi, N., 1998, 'On Testing of the Stiffness and the Dent Resistance of Autobody Panels,' Materials and Design 19 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0261-3069(98)00028-4
  11. Johnson Jr., T. E. and Schaffnit, W.O., 1973, 'Dent Resistance of Cold-Rolled Low-Carbon Steel Sheet,' SAE Paper No.730528
  12. Kohmura, S. and Urbanek, J., 1977, 'Dent Resistance of Aluminum Alloy Sheets,' Alcan International Ltd., KRDC Report, KR-77/044
  13. Krupitzer, R. P. and Harris, R. P., 1992, 'Improvements in the Dent Resistance of Steel Body Panels,' SAE Technical Paper No. 920243
  14. Lohwasser, A. K. and Mahmood, H. F., 1979, 'Surface Panel Oil Canning Anlysis-Theoretical Development,' Technical Memorandum, No. 9611, Chrysler Corp
  15. Mahmood, H. F., 1981, 'Dent Resistance of Surface Panel and Slam Area,' SAE Technical Paper No. 810099
  16. Mahmood, H. F. and Malik, D., 1978, 'Dent Resistance of Surface Panel and Slam Area,' Technical Memorandum, No. 8023, Chrysler Corp.
  17. Montgomery, J. and Brooks, A., 1994, 'Influence of Geometry on Outer Panel Dent Resistance as Demonstrated Through FEA,' Proceedings IBEC '94, International Body Engineering Conference, September 26-29, Detroit, Michigan, pp.85-89
  18. Neimeier, B. A. and Burley, C. E., 1978, 'Hailstone Response of Body Panels-Real and Simulated,' SAE Paper No. 780398
  19. Rolf, R. L., Sharp, M. L. and Stroebel, H. H., 1976, 'Structural Characteristics of Aluminum Body Sheet,' SAE Technical Paper No. 770200
  20. Sabbagh, M. A., Chavali, R. N. and Montgomery, J. S., 1995, 'Quasi-Static Dent Depth Simulation Usin Non-Linear FEA,' Proceedings IBEC '95, International Body Engineering Conference, pp.87-90
  21. Sakai, H., Saito, K. and Tsukada, H., 1983, 'Stiffness and Dent Characteristics of Body Outer Surface Panel-Finite Element Analysis and Experiment,' Int. J. of Vehicle Design, Vol. 4, No.1, pp. 13-22
  22. Shi, M. F. and Wilczynski, J. S., 1993, 'Potential Weight Savings Versus Dent Resistance Performance of High Strength Steel Body Panels,' Proceedings IBEC '93, International Body Engineering Conference, pp. 37-43
  23. Shi, M. F., Brindza, J. A., Michel, P. F., Bucklin, P., Belanger, P. J. and Prencipe Jr., J. M., 1997, 'Static and Dynamic Dent Resistance Performance of Automotive Steel Body Panels,' SAE Paper No. 970158
  24. Shi, M. F., Meuleman, D. J., Alaniz, C. L. and Zurdosky, S. J., 1991, 'An Evaluation of the Dynamic Dent Resistance of Automotive Steels,' SAE Paper No. 910287
  25. Shi, M. F., Meuleman, D. J., Alaniz, C. L. and Zurdosky, S. J., 1991, 'Pre-Strain Effects on Static Dent Resistance of Automotive Steels,' SAE Paper No. 910288
  26. Steel, T. N., 1991, 'Bake Hardening Steel Application Study-Key Factors of Dent Resistance Impovement' SAE Technical Paper No. 910291
  27. Swenson Jr., W. E. and Traficante, R. J., 1982, 'The Influence of Aluminum Properties on the Design, Manufacturability and Economics of an Automotive Body Panel,' SAE Paper No. 820385
  28. Thomas, D., Hodgins, R. B., Worswick, M. J., Oddy, A. S., Gong, K., Finn, M., 1999, 'FEM Technique for Static & Dynamic Dent Modelling of Aluminum,' Proceedings of Numisheet' 99-Volume 1, Gelin, J. C. and Picart, P., Eds., pp.367-372
  29. Thomas, D., Hodgins, R. B., Worswick, M. J., Oddy, A. S., Gong, K., Finn, M., 1999, 'FEM Technique for Static & Dynamic Dent Modelling of Aluminum,' Proceedings of Numisheet' 99-Volume 1, Gelin, J. C. and Picart, P., Eds., pp.367-372
  30. Thorburn, H. J., 1994, 'Comparitive Tests of Stiffness and Dent Resistance on Aluminum and Steel Fenders,' Proceedings IBEC '94, International Body Engineering Conference, September 26-29, Detroit, Michigan, pp. 105-112
  31. Vadhavkar, A. V., Fecek, M. G., Shah, V. C. and Swenson, W. E., 1981, 'Panel Optimization Program (POP),' SAE Paper No. 810230
  32. Van Veldhuizen, B., Kranendonk, W. and Ruifrok, R., 1995, 'The Relation Between the Curvature of Horizontal Automotive Panels, the Panel Stiffness and the Static Dent Resistance,' Proceedings IBEC '95, International Body Engineering Conference, pp. 62-70
  33. Vreede, P. T., Tamis, P. J. and Roelofsen, M. E., 1995, 'The Influence of Material Properties and Geometry on Dynamic Dent Resistance: Experiments and Simulations,' Proceedings IBEC '95, International Body Engineering Conference, pp. 79-86
  34. Vreede, P. T., Tamis, P. J., Roelofsen, M. E., 1995, 'The Influence of Material Properties and Geometry on Dynamic Dent Resistance : Experiments and Simulations,' IBEC
  35. Werner, M. F., 1993, 'Finite Element Simulation of Steel Body Panel Performance for Quasi-Static Dent Resistance,' Proceedings IBEC '93, International Body Engineering Conference, pp.33-36