Development of a Simple Evaluation Questionnaire for Screening the Dietary Patterns of Overweight Young Adults

20대 성인의 과체중 식생활 패턴과 간이평가표 개발

  • 박영숙 (순천향대학교 응용과학부 식품영양학전공) ;
  • 이정원 (충남대학교 소비자생활정보학과)
  • Published : 2002.10.01

Abstract

A study was performed to develop as a screening tool, the Simple Evaluation Questionnaire for screening Overweight Dietary Patterns in people in their 20's. We used the data from the 20 to 29 year old subjects who participated in the three surveys: the health behavior survey, the dietary habit survey and the food intake survey - as part of the National Health and Nutrition Survey of 1998. The 1,493 adults were classified into two body fatness groups, that of normal (including the underweight) , and the overweight (including the obese) on the basis of their relative body weight (RBW). When comparing general variables between the two groups, significant differences (11 variables) were found in gender, sadness/depression state, stress level, age, number of diseases, age when overweightedness started, maximum body weight, sleep length, presently a smoker, everyday smoking habits, number of alcoholic drinks in the past month, and the number of alcoholic drinks when dunk, as well as snacking frequency and fatty food consumption. There were significant differences between the two groups in the three variables of daily soup/kuk, pan fried fish/meat/poultry and cooked fish paste/ham/dried squid in terms of cooked food intake, and 11 variables of food size, cooked rice, stews, vegetables and kimchi at breakfast, panfried foods and beverage/teas at lunch, cooked rice and stews (liquid) at dinner, cooked fish paste/ham/dried squid at snacks and cooked fishpaste/ham/dried squid at snack between lunch and dinner. In terms of raw food intake, we observed significant differences (8 variables) in daily food intake and grains, grains/vegetables/fishes (shellfish) at breakfast, meat at lunch and milt at snack after dinner. After developing questions with indicators and analyzing the indicators by logistic regression analysis using 34 variables, including these 33, plus eating-out frequency, we chose 10 questions for the simple evaluation of dietary patterns for the overweight category, in order to give each one point each. Among them we assigned an additional point to one question and two points to another question. The average scores of the overweight and normal groups, as shown by the questionnaire developed, were 5.97 $\pm$ 2.36 and 7.36 $\pm$ 2.21, respectively. A score of seven points was selected as the cut-off point. We examined the sensitivity, specificity and positive predictive value of the questionnaire to the results of 49.3%,75.4% and 68.8%, respectively. The total score categorized as an overweight dietary pattern was 30.2%.

Keywords

References

  1. Akin JS, Guilkey DK, Popkin BM, Fanelli MT (1986): Cluster analysis of food consumption patterns of older Americans. J Am Diet Assoc 86(5): 616-624
  2. Campbell MK, Kelsey KS (1994): The PEACH survey: A nutrition screening tool for use in early intervention programs. Am J Diet Assoc 94 (10): 838-839
  3. Chang HS, Kim MR (1999): A Study on Dietary Status of Elderly Koreans with Ages. J Korean Soc Food Sci Nutr 28 (1): 265-173
  4. Dwyer JT (1991): Screening older American' nutritional health: Current practices and future possibilities. Nutrition Screening Initiative, Washington, DC
  5. Farchi (1989): J Am Diet Assoc 95 (4): 489-490
  6. Kim HK (1998): Nutrition screening at nutrition clinic in Japan. Autumn Symposium Proceeding of Korean Society for Community Nutrition, Seoul
  7. Kim HR (1996): Provisional National Nutrition Targets and Strategies for Health Promotion of Koreans. Korean J Community Nutrition 1(2) : 161-177
  8. Kim KN, Hyun TS, Lee JW (2000): Development of a simple screening test for identifying Korean elderly at risk of undernutrition. Korean J Communiy Nutrition 5 (3): 475-483
  9. Korean Bureau for Agricultural Improvement (1988): Self-Checklist of Dietary Health. Study team for agricultural home improvement
  10. Lahmann PH, Kumanyika SK (1999) : Attitude about health and nutrition are more indicative of dietary quality in 50-75 year old women than weight and appearance concerns. Am J Diet Assoc 99(4): 475-476 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-8223(99)00118-2
  11. Lee JW, Lee MS, Kim JH, Son SM, Lee BS (1998) : Nutritional Assessments, Kyomunsa Co, Seoul
  12. Lee JW, Kim KE, Kim KN, Hyun TS, Hyun WJ, Park YS (2000) : Evaluation of the validity of a simple screening test developed for identifying Korean elderly at risk of undernutrition. Korean J Nutrition 33 (8): 864-872
  13. Millen B, Quatromoni P, Copenhafer D, Demissie S, O'horo C, D'agostino R (2001): Validation of a dietary pattern approach for evaluating nutritional risk: The Framingham Nutrition Studies. Am J Diet Assoc 101: 187-194
  14. Nieman D, Butterworth D, Nieman C (1992): Nutrition. WC Brown Publishers, Dubuque
  15. Park YS, Han JR, Lee JW, Kim JH, Koo JO, Kim JH, Yoon JS (2002) : Developing a simple evaluation questionaire for screening over-weight-type dietary pattern for 30-49 year old adults. Korean J Comm Nutrition 7 (4): 495-505
  16. Posner BM, Jette AM, Smith KW, Miller DR (1993): Nutrition and health risks in the elderly; The nutrition screening initiative. Am J Public Health 83 (7): 972-978
  17. Sahyoun N, Jacques P, Dallal G, Russell RM (1997) : Nutrition Screening Initiative checklist may be a better awareness/educational tool than a screening one. J Am Diet Assoc 97: 760-764 https://doi.org/10.1016/S0002-8223(97)00188-0
  18. Schlenker ED (1998) : Nutrition for aging. WCB/McGraw-Hill Publishing, Singapore
  19. Spangler AA, Eigenbrod JS (1995) : Field trial affirms value of DETERMINE-ing nutrition-related problems of free-living elderly. J Am Diet Assoc 95 (4): 489-490
  20. Tucker K, Dallal GE, Rush D (1992): Dietary patterns of elderly Boston-area residents defined by cluster analysis. J Am Diet Assoc 92: 1487-1491
  21. Wardlaw G, Insel P, Seyler M (1994) : Contemporary nutrition-issues and insights. Mosby Books Inc.
  22. Wirfalt AKE, Jeffery RW (1997): Using cluster analysis to examine dietary patterns: Nutrient intakes, gender, and weight status differ across food pattern clusters. J Am Diet Assoc 95 (4): 489-490
  23. 熊澤召子 . 板本原子 (1975) : Nutrition Guidance. Research Center of Medical Nutrition, Tokyo