Journal of Nutrition and Health

The Korean Nutrition Society (한국영양학회)
권호 표지

Study on th Agreement of Food Frequency Questionnaires According to the Methods of Collecting Portion Size

섭취분량 설문형에 따른 식품섭취빈도조사법의 일치도 연구

  • 한명희 (한양대학교 가정대학 식품영양학과)
  • Published : 1995.09.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Agreement between open question and closed question on portion size of a food frequency questionnaire was assessed for the influence by the restricted choices in closed question on estimated nutrient intakes and agreement of ranking individuals. Dietary intakes of 361 subjects in a rural country, Yang-pyeung Gun were obtained using a interview method. The results are as follows ; 1) Nutrients intakes calculated from closed question on portion size were lower than those calculated from open question on portion size. 2) For most nutrients the percentage of Korean RDA were significantly lower with closed question than open question. 3) Correlation coefficient of nutrient intakes and food intakes obtained by two methods were higher than 0.6 for all nutrients and food items. 4) For each nutrient, misclassification into extreme quartiles was less than 1 percent. 5) These data indicate that closed question on portion size can provide the corresponding information as open question if food frequency questionnarie is used for the ranking of individuals.

Keywords

References

  1. 건강 통계 자료 수집 및 측정의 표준화 연구 : 식이섭취빈도 안윤옥
  2. Am J Clin Nutr v.28 A dietary method for an epidemiologic study of gastrointestinal cancer Hankin,J.H.;Rhoads,G.G.;Glober,G.A.
  3. Int J Cancer v.15 Dietary vitamin A and lung cancer Bjelke,E.
  4. N Engl J Med v.317 Dietary fat and the risk of breast cancer.(letter) Hebert,J.R.;Wynder,E.L.
  5. Nutr Cancer v.7 Dietary factors in colon cancer : International relationships. An update. McKeown-Eyssen E.;Bright-See E.
  6. Nutritional Epidemiology Food frequency methods Willett,W.C.;Willett,W.C.(ed.)
  7. Am J Epidemiol v.135 Invited Commentary;Some limitations of semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire Sempos,C.T.
  8. 한국역학회 공동 심포지움 역학연구에서 식이조사방법 : 식이조사 방법에 관한 특별 심포지움 초록 이정권
  9. Am J Epidemiol v.115 no.14 A Review of validation of dietary assessment methods Block,G.
  10. Am J Epidemiol v.122 Reproducibility and validity of a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire Willett,W.C.;Sampson,L.;Stampfer,M.J.;Rosner,B.A.;Bain,C.;Witshi,J.;Hennekens,C.H.;Speizer,F.E.
  11. Am J Epidemiol v.135 Reproducibility and validity of an expanded self-administered semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire among male health professionals Rimm,E.B.;Giovannucci,E.;Stampfer,M.J.;Colditz,G.A.;Lintin,L.B.;Willet,W.C.
  12. Am J Epidemiol v.120 Alternatives in the collection and analysis of food frequency interview data Samet,J.M.;Humble,C.G.;Skipper,B.E.
  13. Int J Epidemiol v.21 Influence of individually estimated portion size data on the validity of a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire Johneland,A.;Haraldsdottir,J.;Overvad,K.;Stripp,C.;Ewert,M.;Jensen,O.M.
  14. J Am Diet Assoc v.91 Comparison of a food frequency questionnaire using reported vs standatd portion sizes for classifying individuals according to nutrient intakes Clapp,J.A.;McPherson,R.S.;Reed,D.B.;Hsi,B.P.
  15. Am J Epidemiol v.124 Total energy intake : implications for epidemiological analyses Willett,W.C.;Stampfer,M.J.
  16. Int J Cancer v.46 Total energy intake and nutrient composition. Dietary recommendations for epidemiologists Willett,W.C.
  17. Am J Epidemiol v.137 Interpretation of energy adjustment models for nutritional epidemiology Kipnis,V.;Freedman,L.S.;Brown,C.C.;Hartman,A.;Schatzkin,A.;Wacholder,S.
  18. 한국인 암질환예방을 위한 cohort구축연구.(단행본) 서울대학교 의과대학 예방의학교실
  19. 대한예방의학회지 건강통계자료수집 및 특정의 표준화연구 식이섭취빈도 안윤옥
  20. 식품섭취 실태조사를 위한 식품 및 음식의 눈대중량 한국식품 공업협회 식품연구소
  21. 식품성분표(제 4차 개정판) 농촌진흥청 농촌 영양개선 연수원
  22. Am J Epidemiol v.119 Comparison of frequency and quantitative dietary methods for epidemiologic studies of diet and disease Chu,S.Y.;Kolonel,L.N.;Hankin,J.H.;Lee,J.
  23. '92 국민영양조사결과 보고서 보건사회부
  24. J Am Diet Assoc v.93 Reproducibility and validity of food intake measurements from a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire Feskanich,D.;Rimm,E.B.;Giovannucci,E.L.;Colditz,G.A.;Stampfer,M.J.;Litin,L.B.;Willet,W.C.
  25. J Am Diet Assoc v.87 Validation of a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire;Comparison with a 1-year diet record Willett,W.C.;Reynolds,R.D.;Cottrell-Hoehner,S.;Sampson,L.;Browne,M.L.
  26. Am J Epidemiol v.135 Author'Response to Invited Commentary : Some limitations of semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire. Rimm,E.B.;Edward,L.;Giovannucci,E.;Meir,J.;Stampfer,M.J.;Colditz,G.A.;Lintin,L.B.;Willet,W.C.
  27. Scand J Soc Med v.15 Comparison of information from a short food frequency questionnaire with a dietary history survey Jacobsen,B.J.;Knutsen,S.F.;Knutsen,R.
  28. 한국역학회지 v.16 한 농촌지역에서 식이섭취조사에 이용한 반정량빈도조사법 : 경기도 양평지역에 거주하고 있는 주민 일부를 대상으로. 김미경;이상선;최보율;신영전;조영선;안윤옥
  29. Am J Epidemiol v.127 Variability in portion sizes of commonly consumed foods among a population of women in the United States Hunter,D.J.;Sampson,M.;Stampfer,G.A.;Colditz,B.;Rosner,B.;Willet,W.C.