• 제목/요약/키워드: historiography and critical history

검색결과 9건 처리시간 0.03초

근대건축의 역사 서술에 대한 비판적 검토 (A Critical Review on the Historiography of Modern Architecture)

  • 강혁
    • 건축역사연구
    • /
    • 제24권1호
    • /
    • pp.29-40
    • /
    • 2015
  • This study is on historiography of Modern Architecture since its beginning to present. As a critical review of the history of the writing history of Modern Architecture, this study tends to be a meta-history and criticism of historical text. This study try to analyse historiographical project of Modern architecture at specific phase since the beginning of modern architecture. The historiography of Modern architecture shows that writing a history is making a discourse of Modern architecture as a imaginative representation to define and justify Modernism in architecture. The analysis of canonic text since early 20th century proves that the history of writing history of Modern architecture played a critical role not only to shape of our ideal but the practice of architecture with a ideology construction in retrospect. With a name of truth or morality they made myths about the modernity in architecture. So we can find deep 'Hagelean Unconscious' in writing history of Modern architecture not even the first generation of historians but the second generation who were influenced by earlier writer in spite of their intention of revision and overcoming, which is in itself the key concept of Hegel's philosophy of History. Under this kind of 'operative' discourse our view point of Modern architecture were confined and the historiography of Modern architecture itself was narrowly defined as a kind of melodrama that a few architect and work of art matters. The rise of critical history fundamentally has changed the way of seeing and writing the history of Modern architecture. but it has also a new kind of dilemma as regard to writing history and involving practice. This review of historiography traces the texts of historians as like Pevsner, Giedion, Banham, Rowe, Tafuri, Frampton, and Curtis relating to different discours making. When we consider Benjamin's famous concept of constellation, writing history necessarily is a kind of montage making in time and we always need to recognize the historicity of historiography.

건축사학에서 헤겔적 유산에 관한 연구 (A Study on Hegel's Influence in Architectural Historiography)

  • 강혁
    • 건축역사연구
    • /
    • 제25권1호
    • /
    • pp.47-57
    • /
    • 2016
  • The purpose of this paper is to review and analyse the influence of Hegel on architectural historiography. With the point of view that Hegel is the origin of architectural history, this study try to find out how Hegel's philosophy and aesthetics deeply influenced the principle and method of architectural historiography. As a kind of meta-history Hegel's idealism played a important role in the interpretation of architecture and its historiography. We can call it Hegelian legacy and it gave a determinant idea in the discours of architecture, especially Modernism. With a critical view point this study tries to reveal the mythical character of the premise and hypothesis of Hegel's historicism and also reviews its positive aspects in the history of writing architectural history. Today Hegelian thinking in architectural historiography is seriously criticized and considered as a old way of writing history. But this study tries to find a possibility to recognize the contemporary architectural situation with Hegel's concept of universal history. The return of Hegel necessarily does not mean the idea of totality and universality in practice as like in Modernism, but to widen the recognition in contemporary practice and historiography.

한국 언어학의 정체성에 대한 인식론적 성찰 (A Cognitive Approach to the identity of Korean Linguistics)

  • 김성도
    • 인문언어
    • /
    • 제5권
    • /
    • pp.7-36
    • /
    • 2003
  • In this paper I am arguing in favour of more vigilance on the part of the Korean linguistics' melieu and, if deemed necessary, a more solid epistemological foundation of the Korean Linguistics. The purpose of this work consist in providing some epistemological inquiry on the major orientations and tendencies which are manifested in the reception of western linguistic theories. I might call this point of view as a critical approach to the philosophy and history of Korean linguistics. In the first section, I gave a short description of the model of the linguistic historiography which can be applied to the history of the Korean linguistics. In the second section, I am concerned with the comparative epistemology of the development of linguistic ideas produced in the West and East. In the final section, I made some critical reflections on the limits of Korean linguistics.

  • PDF

디자인사 연구의 역사 -대표적인 디자인 역사 저술을 중심으로- (A Historiography on Design History Studies in Korea -Critical Review on Canonical Design History Books in Korea-)

  • 채승진;신현봉
    • 디자인학연구
    • /
    • 제17권4호
    • /
    • pp.365-374
    • /
    • 2004
  • 비교적 새로운 역사 분야라는 이유로 또한 다양한 인공물과 그 디자인과 제조, 유통과정에서 비롯되는 주제의 다양성에 따라 디자인사 연구는 상당히 도전적인 분야로 인식되고 있다. 그러나 같은 이유로 디자인사는 스스로 연구의 한계와 난점을 드러내고 있다. 사료의 무한정한 다양성도 문제로 들 수 있다. 근대적 생산기술의 도입에 따라 디자인 대상으로서 인공물의 증가는 생물 다양성의 수백 배를 넘었으며 여전히 기하급수적 증가 일로에 있다. 이는 디자인 역사가가 이 모든 것들을 다루기에는 현실적으로 불가능함을 뜻한다. 둘째, 이러한 인공물의 엄청난 증폭 현상은 최근 170년간의 특수한 현상으로서 이 기간을 하나의 역사 연구 단위로 보기에는 너무 짧고, 또한 현재에도 진행 중이기 때문에 수평 비교를 위한 거시적 안목의 설정이 불가능하다는 것이다. 따라서 이에 대한 객관적인 역사 평가 역시 내리기 어렵다는 점이다. 셋째, 디자인사의 연구 대상인 ‘디자인은 많은 경우 분야와 대상을 동시에 나타내어 그 구분이 어렵다. 즉 디자인은 디자인 행위, 혹은 디자인제(작)품 등의 뜻으로 복합적으로 쓰임으로써 디자인사가 정교히 서술할 만한 주제로 정리되지 못하고 있다. 본 연구는 이런 문제 의식에 기초하여 우리나라에 간행된 여러 디자인사 연구서를 비교 검토함으로써 역사 연구 일반의 체계적 기술을 위한 기초를 마련하고자 한다.

  • PDF

만프레도 타푸리의 이데올로기 비판 독해를 위한 이중의 문맥 (Doble Contexts for Reading Manfredo Tafuri's Criticism of Ideology)

  • 박정현
    • 건축역사연구
    • /
    • 제25권2호
    • /
    • pp.21-30
    • /
    • 2016
  • Autonomia movement that emerged in Italy in the 1960s from workerist (operaismo) communism gives historical and discursive context to Manfredo Tafuri's famous criticism of ideology. His thesis on the death of architecture was a radical criticism of Keynesian intervention which was a strategy to cope with the Great Depression. For him, this capitalist development had taken away ideological prefiguration from architecture. At least Tafuri's this early intellectual phase was formed in the wake of magazine Contrapiano and Antonio Negri's influence. Tafuri almost entirely adapted Negri's thought on the importance of capitalist innovation that was uncovered by Keynes, Schumpeter, and Manheim and the periodization in modern history. When we read Tafuri's text with this concrete context, we can avoid being plunged into his abstruseness. On the other hand, 1980's Korea cannot understand Tafuri comprehensibly. 1980's situation to struggle to acquire democracy prescribed only one mode of reception of Tafuri's historiography in Korea. Tafuri's so-called pessimist view point could not satisfy student activists. They want to take intellectual means to sustain student movement and to secure political dynamics of protest. But at the same time they have anxiety to understand tafuri's thesis that they consider ad a critical theory for Korean Architecture. Double contexts of Tafuri's criticism of ideology bring to light to historicize both Tafuri's historiography itself and reception of his text in Korea.

콜린 로우의 건축론 -그의 자유주의와 형식자적 입장- (A Study on the theory, history and criticism of Colin Rowe - A Criticism of his Liberalism and Formalist Approach -)

  • 강혁
    • 건축역사연구
    • /
    • 제17권1호
    • /
    • pp.7-28
    • /
    • 2008
  • Colin Rowe was an important historian, theorist and critic in Modern architecture. His significance in Modern architectural history lies in not only historiography which has changed our view of Modernism but deep theoretical involvement in practice. This study is a critical review and analysis on his formalist approach in Architecture. With a view that his position of formalist has indispensible relationship with liberalism from K. Popper's critical rationalism, this study try to show how his philosophical background has an influence upon his way of seeing architecture, history, form, urbanism, and meaning, etc. And this study also try to explain why the principle of architecture as an autonomous discipline which is the main point of view in Rowe's criticism has been so successful and influential. This study also explain what is the possibility and limitation of Rowe's formalist approach and way of reading buildings. His intelligent way of formal analysis can give us new understandings of how the form generates and the process of design goes on. Furthermore it guide us a new horizon of architecture as a language game. Since his early writings showed both side of formalist approach in architecture and it didn't changed a lot. We can understand his 'Collage City' was a his final answer to his formalist way of making architecture and urbanism. we can estemate it as a utopia without utopianism and an ideology without ideological color.

  • PDF

리티 판의 다큐멘터리 <우리의 모국 프랑스>에 나타난 아카이브 활용 양상과 역사서술 방식 (Rithy Panh's Practices on Archive Images and Methods of Historiography in La France est notre patrie)

  • 유지수
    • 한국엔터테인먼트산업학회논문지
    • /
    • 제13권8호
    • /
    • pp.209-221
    • /
    • 2019
  • 리티 판 감독의 2015년 작 다큐멘터리 <우리의 모국 프랑스 La France est notre patrie>는 시각적 구성에 있어 아카이브 이미지와 무성영화에서 차용한 인터타이틀을 사용하고, 청각적으로는 음악과 효과음을 주로 한 외재적 음향에 기대고 있는 파운드 풋티지 영화이다. 감독은 프랑스 식민지배하에 놓인 동남아시아와 아프리카 지역에서 19세기 말부터 20세기 초기 영화역사와도 궤적을 같이하는 시기에 촬영된 이미지를 발굴하여 재구성한다. 본 논문은 캄보디아 크메르 루주 대학살의 생존자인 감독의 기억과 역사 인식이 아카이브를 통해 영화와 맺는 실천적 관계를 고찰한다. 또한 벤야민의 역사적 몽타주와 변증법적 이미지 개념을 적용하고, 무엇보다 영화가 제시하는 중층적 시점에 주목하여 <우리의 모국 프랑스>가 구현하는 역사서술 방법을 분석한다. 이를 통해 이 영화의 구성적 특이성이 어떻게 자기반영성에 충실한 에세이 영화를 추동하며, 대항기억의 담론을 일으켜 메타역사로서 관객을 복합적 사유의 문턱으로 인도하는가 밝히고자 한다.

우리 서양건축사 교육의 반성 - 담론으로서 '서양건축사'를 해체하기 위하여 - (For the Deconstruction of the History of Western Architecture as a Discourse - A Reflection on the Education of the Architectural History in Korea -)

  • 강혁
    • 건축역사연구
    • /
    • 제20권6호
    • /
    • pp.57-76
    • /
    • 2011
  • This study is on the pedagogical convention of architectural history in Korea, especially that of Western Architecture. Recent institutional change in architectural school in Korea has caused overall restructuring of academic program. In spite of extension in the field of history there was no progress of method and way of thinking. There is no change in the point of view to see the western architecture and its history as a unique and specialized phenomenon in the civilization of mankind. Because of no recognition about for what, for whom, and how to, and because of orientalism, the cultural position of western architectural history and its narrative was not asked. With the help of post-colonialism, de-constructivism and critical historiography this paper tries to show the fundamental premise of western architectural history as a myth and show its prejudice as not being justifiable. The background of the discourse there has been a representation effect with regard to knowledge as a power. we need to escape from this kind of cognitional frame With the analysis of the its premise and narrative we can find it is a historical construct that was made in the age of imperialism. In fact it has a lot of false information and problematic point of view. The Identity and originality of western architecture and its history has no logical reason or foundation if we think that it depends on the difference and comparison with other civilization. For example the explanation of its historical origin western architecture has big difference with Islamic architecture in spite of the resemblance each other. This paper try to show several reasons that discourse of western architectural history can not be survived any longer. So we need to reconstruct new pedagogy with deconstruction for the students of non western, or Korean students. Because it has important effect to see and think about architecture and its history.

上海博物館蔵戦国楚竹書 《容成氏》 の古帝王帝位継承説話研究 (A Critical Study of the Legend on the Chinese Ancient Dynasty's Succession before Yao-Shun Era : Focusing on the Rongchengshi in the Shanghai Bowuguan zang Zhanguo Chuzhushu(II))

  • 李承律
    • 대순사상논총
    • /
    • 제17권
    • /
    • pp.197-225
    • /
    • 2004
  • The respective history of the Chinese Ancient Dynasties from the era of the ancient Emperors to the revolutionary era of Yin-Zhou殷周 was described in the Rongchengshi容成氏, one of the texts in Shanghai Bowuguan zang Zhanguo Chuzhushu(II)上海博物館藏戰國楚竹書(二) discovered in 1994 at an antique market in Hong Kong. Drawn from the historical explanations expressed in it, the anonymous author's own views on history could be observed as largely being composed of 'resignation'禪讓, 'usurpation'簒奪, and 'banishment/smite'放伐. Following the advent of the recently excavated bamboo slips of Rongchengshi, a careful reconsideration is urgently needed to the established interpretation on the origin of the ritual of resignation in the relevant academic circles. Because it shows us that the ritual of resignation as a way of the succession, judging from my analysis, was already realized by Nine Emperors('Rongchengshi', Zunlushi尊盧氏, Hexushi赫胥氏, Gaoxinshi高辛氏, Cangjieshi倉頡氏, Xuanyuanshi軒轅氏, Shennongshi神農氏, 渾沌氏, and Baoxishi包羲氏 and maybe the more) before the era of 'Yao-Shun'堯舜. Accordingly, the aforementioned fact, which has never been elaborated in the previous texts including the first Chinese historiography Shiji史記, is the only peculiar feature to the Rongchengshi itself. Thus, a simple but empirically important question could be raised here: Was this way of description an exceptional case, even as unaccepted in Warring States Period at that time? If then, the Rongchengshi could not but help being evaluated merely as a buried historical texts, without any influence on the ancient Chinese, along with its author. The Chu bamboo slips Tangyu zhi dao唐虞之道 from Guodian Chujian郭店 excavated in 1993, however, has a very similar content to the Rongchengshi in relevance to the historical existence of the ritual of resignation. From the sentence, expressed in Tangyu zhi dao, that "the sudden rise of 'Six Emperors'六帝 was due to the practice of resignation like the period of Yao-Shun", it could be easily presumed that the 'Six Emperors' was closely connected to the 'Nine Emperors' and maybe the more at that time. Comparing with the related extant literary texts and the excavated materials in a vigorous way, in this paper, I explore four significant questions from a more critical stand to the conventional studies. First of all, I explicate the distinctiveness of the Rongchengshi as an academically very precious materials. Secondly, and closely related to the above, I evaluate its status or significance in the history of the Chinese ancient thoughts. And thirdly, I make an endeavor to trace back to the date of its transcription. Finally, and the most crucially, I attempt to show what Schools it was originated from and what connections it had with the Schools in the acient China. In sum, some concluding remarks, having somewhat insightful and significant implications for the further studies in these issues, could be drawn from my exploration. Viewing from the historical perspective of thoughts, at first, the legend of Ancient Dynasty's Succession before Yao-Shun Era in the Rongchengshi had some interactions directly and closely with Zhangzi莊子, Muzi墨子, Guanzi管子, Xunzi荀子 and Tangyu zhi dao. Also in doing search for the unification in a transitional epoch from the late to the end of the Warring States period, the political stand of Shi士 and Ke客 was reflected in it as well as in the Tangyu zhi dao because they actively wanted to suggest the most appropriate model of the Emperor or the idealistic succession process and political realms.

  • PDF