• Title/Summary/Keyword: 비판적 의견

Search Result 92, Processing Time 0.024 seconds

Prostate Imaging Reporting and Data System (PI-RADS) v 2.1: Overview and Critical Points (전립선영상 판독과 자료체계 2.1 버전: 개요와 비판적인 의견)

  • Chan Kyo Kim
    • Journal of the Korean Society of Radiology
    • /
    • v.84 no.1
    • /
    • pp.75-91
    • /
    • 2023
  • The technical parameters and imaging interpretation criteria of the Prostate Imaging Reporting and Data System version 2 (PI-RADS v2) using multiparametric MRI (mpMRI) are updated in PI-RADS v2.1. These changes have been an expected improvement for prostate cancer evaluation, although some issues remain unsolved, and new issues have been raised. In this review, a brief overview of PI-RADS v2.1 is and several critical points are discussed as follows: the need for more detailed protocols of mpMRI, lack of validation of the revised transition zone interpretation criteria, the need for clarification for the revised diffusion-weighted imaging and dynamic contrast-enhanced imaging criteria, anterior fibromuscular stroma and central zone assessment, assessment of background signal and tumor aggressiveness, changes in the structured report, the need for the parameters for imaging quality and performance control, and indications for expansion of the system to include other indications.

Alternative Ideas of Publicness in Contemporary Public Art: Focusing on the Artworks of Freee Art Collective (동시대 공공미술의 대안적 공공성: 프리이 예술 콜렉티브를 중심으로)

  • Lim, Shan
    • The Journal of the Convergence on Culture Technology
    • /
    • v.7 no.3
    • /
    • pp.197-202
    • /
    • 2021
  • This paper focuses on the situation in which, as pluralistic democracy spreads globally from the mid-20th century, the concept of publicness, the reason for the existence of traditional public art, is not limited to the physicality of occupying public space or the conditions for creation by public funds, but is seeking a new direction and examine the social significance of these changes. For this purpose, the main body of this paper analyzes the major public art projects of Freee Art Collective who were active in the UK in the early 2000s. Freee performed various public art projects in which individuals constituting a community critically reflect on political, social, and economic issues related to public goods and provide a discourse space for democratic discussion. Their practice suggested a methodology for socially-engaged public art that resists the "Third Way" cultural policy of the New Labour administration. Therefore, this paper argues that Freee's public art seeks alternatives to publicness in that it allows one to resistively think about problematic aspects of hegemonic cultural production of neoliberal cultural policy that pursues political consensus and social harmony. This research about Freee's public art would be significant in that it can serve as an opportunity for critical reflection on the contemplative form and public role of contemporary public art.

The Checking the Validity of 'Nongak' and 'Pungmul', and Objection to the Criticism of 'Nongak' ('농악(農樂)'과 '풍물(風物)'의 타당성 검토와 '농악(農樂)' 비판에 대한 반론)

  • Kim, Jeong Heon
    • Korean Journal of Heritage: History & Science
    • /
    • v.42 no.4
    • /
    • pp.96-111
    • /
    • 2009
  • This essay is a study aimed at rationality and utility of two terms, 'Nongak' and 'Pungmul'. I examined how the terms have been today, by diachrony based on review of historical material. I tried to secure the historical context and basis about my argument, quoting many historical material from Korea Dynasty period, Joseon Dynasty period and the colonial period of the imperial Japan during 1910-45 to today. I examined many objective arguments about the 'Nongak', and pointed out the mistake of the objective argument. And I examined the means and rationality of the terms, 'Nongak', 'Pungmul', 'Pungmulgut', 'Pungmulnory'. The 'Pungmul' has been used as the means of instrument for a long time from Joseon Dynasty period. It is only rational using as the means of instrument but as the means of Performance of Nongak considering the historical legitimacy. The 'Pungmul' is Sino-Korean word, not korean native letter. The Pungmulgut means the 'ritual by Pungmul', so it can be recognized the rationality, but have a weak point that it is a neologism being made by some intellectuals in 1980s. In addition to, it is not used im performing field. 'Pungmulnory' has a limit to call the Nongak as a synthetic art. 'Nongak'means a synthetic art that farmers who were absolute majority in agrarian society of Korea have made and developed. So I conclude that 'Nongak'is the best rational term.

A Study on Cultural Value Creation in Animal Festivals (동물 이용 축제의 문화적 가치 생성 연구)

  • Kwon, Jaehyun
    • The Journal of the Korea Contents Association
    • /
    • v.21 no.1
    • /
    • pp.185-195
    • /
    • 2021
  • This study is to criticize whether festivals as cultural activities form cultural values by questioning about the animal cruelty in Korean festivals. Changes in the social awareness of animals and the viewpoint that shifted from human-centered thinking to values of the environment and life served as an opportunity to look back on animals. This study looked at festivals using animals in Korea and especially analyzed the four major animal festivals that have been criticized. A qualitative study method interpreting opinions, evaluations, alternatives, and arguments of cultural tourism and animal rights experts was implemented by conducting interviews with experts of cultural tourism and animal rights, who have conflicting views about animal festivals. The primary topic of discussion is a sharp criticism that 'sales of products based on innocence' is a commercialized cultural value. The expression that 'wrongful traditions do not need to be protected' is an escape from the customary memory of traditions that do not create cultural values. The act of stopping the long malpractice of traditional animal violence is the very act of creating 'cultural values.'

The Influence of the Ideological Tendency of the Press on the Theme and the Tone of the Press Related with New Media Policy (언론의 정치적 성향이 뉴미디어 정책 관련 사설의 의제 및 보도 태도에 미치는 영향)

  • Hong, Juhyun;Kim, Kyung-Hee
    • The Journal of the Korea Contents Association
    • /
    • v.17 no.3
    • /
    • pp.162-177
    • /
    • 2017
  • This study explores how the media covered the new media agenda in the process of the diffusion of new media and what the press's attitude about new media policy is according to the relationship between the press and the government based on the political tendency. For this, this study conducted network analysis. The agreement of political tendency between the press and the government is important variable to decide the attitude of the press about the new media policy. Under the conservative government, the conservative press supported the new media policy, however the opposite opposed it Even if opinion page can take an important role in the process of public opinion, the tone pf editorial page on the new media policy differs from its political tendency. It costs tremendous investment in introducing new media, journalists have judge.

Differences in Creative Personality and Environment between Higher-Level and Lower-Level Students in Scientific Creativity (창의 성향, 환경, 과정, 산물의 상관 분석 및 과학 창의성 상·하위 학생의 창의 성향과 환경의 차이)

  • Kim, Minju;Lim, Chaeseong
    • Journal of Korean Elementary Science Education
    • /
    • v.41 no.2
    • /
    • pp.395-417
    • /
    • 2022
  • This study aims to analyze the correlation of creative personality, environment, process, and product as related to scientific creativity for different levels of elementary school students. We evaluated 105 fifth graders' responses to two tests: i) the scientific creativity test for creative process and product and ii) the self-report test for creative personality and environment. In the self-report test, creative personality comprises cognitive and affective personality, and creative environment constitutes home and school environments. To attain a deeper understanding of phenomena that cannot be explained by a quantitative analysis, interviews were conducted with four students who had the highest scores in creative product and four students who had the lowest scores in creative product while having higher-than-average scores in creative process. First, correlation of creative personality and environment were not significant. Second, in the interviews, students who had the highest scores in scientific creativity had common characteristics, namely, the ability to endure current difficulties to achieve future success and the propensity to listen to other people's ideas critically. Third, students who had the highest scores in creativity hailed from families that respected their opinions, whereas students with the lowest scores belonged to families that disregarded or neglected their opinions. Finally, this study specifies the criteria that should be considered for affective and environmental aspects of scientific creativity education.

On the Standard Taxonomic System of Science and Technology (과학기술 표준분류의 결정문제)

  • Lee Cho-Sik
    • Journal of Science and Technology Studies
    • /
    • v.2 no.1 s.3
    • /
    • pp.1-38
    • /
    • 2002
  • Recently KISTEP(Korea Institute of Science and Technology Evaluation and Planning) held an open forum for examining 'the Manuscript of National Science and Technology Standard Taxonomic System'. I submitted my opinion letter to the forum because I thought that the matter of setting the standard taxonomic system for Science and Technology is so closely related to the research concern of STS that it needs checking from the viewpoint of STS. This paper primarily focuses on making a criticism of and constructing an alternative to the mamuscript, but it goes so far as to ground the matter upon the STS viewpoint. I propose that we interpret an open forum related to science and technology as an example case of the community of inquiry. Further I try, standing in the context of learning to form a model of doing STS interdisciplinary research. In the context of decision I point out the problem with the 'scale' principle involved in categrizing criteria of the taxonomic system and argue that the problem leads to omitting STS from National Science and Technology Standard Taxonomic System although STS takes up science and technology themselves as its research concern proper. In the context or teaming I seek to set up a typical case study or STS. One of the typical STS research tasks is trying to construct a positive alternative to as well as make a criticism of a given suggestion, for clearer alternatives will, in him, provoke sharper criticisms or safer acceptances. I hope that the model in this paper will exemplify such an alternating procedure of criticism and acceptance.

  • PDF

The Effect of Mathematics-Based Yungbokhap Instruction: An Analysis of Participation Structure in Small Group (수학 중심 융복합 수업에 대한 효과 분석: 학생 소집단 활동 참여구조를 기반으로)

  • Park, Mo Ra;Moon, Jong Eun;Ju, Mi-Kyung
    • School Mathematics
    • /
    • v.17 no.2
    • /
    • pp.355-376
    • /
    • 2015
  • This study aims to inspect the effect of the yungbokhap education on the development of students' mathematical competence by analyzing students' mathematical discourse in math-based yungbokhap instruction designed by Moon(2014). Specifically, this research focused on the analysis of students' participation structure. The reuslts shows that the students' competence for mathematical communication and inquiry has been improved through the instruction. In particular, the students were increasingly engaged with consensual talk. Also, in the beginning stage, the students tended to unconditionally criticize for others' mathematical opinion. Through the class participation, they gradually developed the competence to express their mathematical ideas to their peers with reasonable mathematical bases. These results suggests that the mathematics-based yungbokhap instruction has positively contributed to the improvement of students' mathematical competence. Based on the results, this paper presented implications for mathematics-based yungbokhap instrcution.

The Development and Effects of Climate Literacy Program on Elementary School Students Focused on the Keeling Curve Activities Highlighting Inquiry Process (초등학생의 기후소양 함양을 위한 프로그램 개발 및 효과 : 탐구과정이 강조된 킬링 곡선(Keeling Curve) 활동을 중심으로)

  • Son, Jun-ho
    • Journal of the Korean Society of Earth Science Education
    • /
    • v.9 no.3
    • /
    • pp.292-308
    • /
    • 2016
  • The purpose of this study was to find out the effects of climate change education program focused on the keeling curve activities highlighting inquiry process on elementary students' climate literacy. Most of the students have not been able to correctly understand just how serious phenomenon that the temperature rise of the last 100 years is. As a result, there is educational limitations in order to bring about a substantial change in the attitudes toward climate change. So the development program was applied to various questions and explored strategies in order to compare with past climate change data. The results described that 46 students in the experimental group had statistically significant effects on cognitive domain, critical thinking of affective domain and practical domain. In addition, as a result of the analysis of teachers' instructional perspectives and students interview, they supported the researcher's opinion that the developed program could help students improve the climate literacy.

The Formation Process of Scientific Knowledge for Pre-service Science Teachers through Collective Intelligence (집단지성을 활용한 예비교사들의 과학지식 형성과정 탐색)

  • Kim, Semi;Kim, Eunjin;Kim, Sung-Won
    • Journal of The Korean Association For Science Education
    • /
    • v.33 no.5
    • /
    • pp.963-980
    • /
    • 2013
  • The purpose of this study was to investigate the process of constructing pre-service teachers' scientific knowledge information through collective intelligence. We selected the 'Appropriate Technology' (A.T.) as the subject for formation of scientific knowledge. Twenty nine pre-service teachers of the course 'Scientific Thinking and Writing in Science Education' were allowed to freely post information whenever they wanted. They presented their full opinions, interacted with each other, and assessed the other' information on the website for a month. The way of posting was as follows. After one pre-service teacher had written the information about A.T. on the website, the other assessed the text and added or modified the writing. This process continued. We analyzed every writing they posted and questionnaire which contained the reason why they modified the text. The result was as follows. Pre-service teachers formed collective intelligence through four stages. First, pre-service teachers started to find the information related to the subject and they just added the information behind the other's writing. In the second stage, information was added, too. But the difference was that the information they selected carried values for having certain views. Third, they organized their writings with logical and critical thinking. Finally, they revised their overall writing. The results showed that students could develop their critical thinking and they could learn the way of communication from the process of collective intelligence. We found the forming process of knowledge by collective intelligence, and explored the various involving patterns and thinking activities in the process. Based on this research, we expect the improvement of students' logical and critical thinking through the various classes using collective intelligence.