Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.7780/kjrs.2021.37.5.1.6

Topographic Factors Computation in Island: A Comparison of Different Open Source GIS Programs  

Lee, Bora (Warm-Temperate and Subtropical Forest Research Center, National Institute of Forest Science)
Lee, Ho-Sang (Warm-Temperate and Subtropical Forest Research Center, National Institute of Forest Science)
Lee, Gwang-Soo (Warm-Temperate and Subtropical Forest Research Center, National Institute of Forest Science)
Publication Information
Korean Journal of Remote Sensing / v.37, no.5_1, 2021 , pp. 903-916 More about this Journal
Abstract
An area's topography refers to the shape of the earth's surface, described by its elevation, slope, and aspect, among other features. The topographical conditions determine energy flowsthat move water and energy from higher to lower elevations, such as how much solar energy will be received and how much wind or rain will affect it. Another common factor, the topographic wetness index (TWI), is a calculation in digital elevation models of the tendency to accumulate water per slope and unit area, and is one of the most widely referenced hydrologic topographic factors, which helps explain the location of forest vegetation. Analyses of topographical factors can be calculated using a geographic information system (GIS) program based on digital elevation model (DEM) data. Recently, a large number of free open source software (FOSS) GIS programs are available and developed for researchers, industries, and governments. FOSS GIS programs provide opportunitiesfor flexible algorithms customized forspecific user needs. The majority of biodiversity in island areas exists at about 20% higher elevations than in land ecosystems, playing an important role in ecological processes and therefore of high ecological value. However, island areas are vulnerable to disturbances and damage, such as through climate change, environmental pollution, development, and human intervention, and lacks systematic investigation due to geographical limitations (e.g. remoteness; difficulty to access). More than 4,000 of Korea's islands are within a few hours of its coast, and 88% are uninhabited, with 52% of them forested. The forest ecosystems of islands have fewer encounters with human interaction than on land, and therefore most of the topographical conditions are formed naturally and affected more directly by weather conditions or the environment. Therefore, the analysis of forest topography in island areas can be done more precisely than on its land counterparts, and therefore has become a major focus of attention in Korea. This study is focused on calculating the performance of different topographical factors using FOSS GIS programs. The test area is the island forests in Korea's south and the DEM of the target area was processed with GRASS GIS and SAGA GIS. The final slopes and TWI maps were produced as comparisons of the differences between topographic factor calculations of each respective FOSS GIS program. Finally, the merits of each FOSS GIS program used to calculate the topographic factors is discussed.
Keywords
Free Open Source GIS; Topographic factors; DEM; TWI; Slope; Island forest;
Citations & Related Records
연도 인용수 순위
  • Reference
1 Sorensen, R., U. Zinko, and J. Seibert, 2006. On the calculation of the topographic wetness index: evaluation of different methods based on field observations, Hydrology and Earth System Sciences, 10(1): 101-112.   DOI
2 Tarboton, D.G., 1997. A new method for the determination of flow directions and upslope areas in grid digital elevation models, Water Resources Research, 33(2): 309-319.   DOI
3 Travis, Michael R., Gary H. Elsner, Wayne D. Iverson, and Christine G. Johnson, 1975. VIEWIT: computation of seen areas, slope, and aspect for land-use planning (Vol. 11), U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D.C, D.C, USA.
4 Kopecky, M., M. Macek, and J. Wild, 2021. Topographic Wetness Index calculation guidelines based on measured soil moisture and plant species composition, Science of The Total Environment, 757: 143785.   DOI
5 Hutchinson, M.F. and J.C. Gallant, 1999. Representation of terrain, Geographical Information Systems, 1: 105-124.
6 Wie, G.J., H.S. Yun, S.G. Kang, and I.G. Kang, 2009. Study on the Method of Extracting Unregistered Islands using LiDAR Data, Journal of Korean Society for Geospatial Information System, 17(3): 109-114 (in Korean with English abstract).
7 Ballerine, C., 2017. Topographic Wetness Index Urban Flooding Awareness Act Action Support, Will & DuPage Counties, Illinois, Illinois State Water Survey, Champaign, IL, USA.
8 Beven, K.J. and M.J. Kirkby, 1979. A physically based, variable contributing area model of basin hydrology, Hydrologic Science Bulletin, 24: 43-69.   DOI
9 Zevenbergen, L.W. and C.R. Thorne, 1987. Quantitative analysis of land surface topography, Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 12(1): 47-56.   DOI
10 Huang, Y.-H., C.-C. Wu, and Y. Wang, 2011. The Influence of Island Topography on Typhoon Track Deflection, Monthly Weather Review, 139(6): 1708-1727.   DOI
11 Jeon, C.-H., H.-K. Won, S.-Y. Lee, Y.-O. Seo, C.-S. Kim, H.-S. Jeon, J.-H. Cheon, J.-O. Kwon, E.-M. Kim, S.-H. Kang, and C.-W. Kang, 2018. Research on Classification and Ecological Information Construction by Characteristic Analysis on Insular Forests, National Institute of Forest Science, Korea, Research Report, 763: 5-6.
12 McDonald, R.I. and D.L. Urban, 2004. Forest edges and tree growth rates in the North Carolina piedmont, Ecology, 85: 2258-2266.   DOI
13 Kopecky, M. and S. Cizkova, 2010. Using topographic wetness index in vegetation ecology: does the algorithm matter?, Applied Vegetation Science, 13: 450-459.   DOI
14 Medail, F., 2017. The specific vulnerability of plant biodiversity and vegetation on Mediterranean islands in the face of global change, Regional Environmental Change, 17(6): 1775-1790.   DOI
15 Bohner, J. and T. Selige, 2006. Spatial prediction of soil attributes using terrain analysis and climate regionalization, In Boehner, J., McCloy, K.R., Strobl, J. (Ed.), SAGA - Analysis and Modelling Applications, Goettinger Geographische Abhandlungen, Goettingen, 115: 13-28.
16 Franklin, J., 2002. Enhancing a regional vegetation map with predictive models of dominant plant species in chaparral, Applied Vegetation Science, 5(1): 135-146.   DOI
17 Grabs, T., J. Seibert, K. Bishop, and H. Laudon, 2009. Modeling spatial patterns of saturated areas: a comparison of the topographic wetness index and a dynamic distributed model, Journal of Hydrology, 373: 15-23.   DOI
18 Hengl, T., C.H. Grohmann, R.S. Bivand, O. Conrad, and A. Lobo, 2009. SAGA vs GRASS: a comparative analysis of the two open source desktop GIS for the automated analysis of elevation data, Proc. of Geomorphometry 2009, Zurich, CH, Aug. 31- Sep. 2, pp. 22-27.
19 Kopecky, M., M. Macek, and J. Wild, 2021. Topographic Wetness Index calculation guidelines based on measured soil moisture and plant species composition, Science of The Total Environment, 757: 143785.   DOI
20 Lee, H.-S., C.-S. Hyun, S.-Y. Jung, K.-S. Lee, 2020. Importance-Satisfaction Analysis of Forest Projects for Forest Management Strategy in the Island Area - Focused on Wido Island in Buangun, Jeollabuk-do -, Korean Journal of Forest Economics, 27(1), 21-33 (in Korean with English abstract).   DOI
21 Muscarella, R., S. Kolyaie, D.C. Morton, J.K. Zimmerman, and M. Uriarte, 2020. Effects of topography on tropical forest structure depend on climate context, Journal of Ecology, 108 (1): 145-159.   DOI
22 Olaya, V.F., 2004. A gentle introduction to SAGA GIS, The SAGA User Group eV, Gottingen University, Gottingen, Germany, p. 208.
23 SAGA GIS (System for Automated Geoscientific Analyses Geographic information system), http://www.sagagis.org/en/index.html, Accessed on May. 31, 2021.
24 Cho, K.J., 2020. Realization of Forest Welfare through Ecological Restoration of Island Forests on the Southwest Coast based on Reference Ecosystem, Namdo Culture Research, 41: 245-275 (in Korean with English abstract).   DOI
25 Bi, H., X. Li, M. Guo, X. Liu, J. Li, 2006. Digital Terrain Analysis Based on DEM, Frontiers Forestry in China, 1(1): 54-58.   DOI
26 Bohner, J., R. Koethe, O. Conrad, J. Gross, A. Ringeler, and T. Selige, 2002. Soil Regionalisation by Means of Terrain Analysis and Process Parameterisation, European Soil Bureau, Research Report No. 7, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, pp. 213-222.
27 Bock, M., J. Bohner, O. Conrad, R. Kothe, and A. Ringeler, 2007. XV. Methods for creating Functional Soil Databases and applying Digital Soil Mapping with SAGA GIS, JRC Scientific and technical Reports, Office for Official Publications of the European Communities, Luxembourg, pp. 149-189.
28 Conrad, O., B. Bechtel, M. Bock, H. Dietrich, E. Fischer, L. Gerlitz, J. Wehberg, V. Wichmann, and J. Bohner, 2015. System for Automated Geoscientific Analyses (SAGA) v. 2.1.4, Geoscientific Model Development, 8(7): 1991-2007   DOI
29 Echiverri, L. and S.E. Macdonald, 2019. Utilizing a topographic moisture index to characterize understory vegetation patterns in the boreal forest, Forest Ecology and Management, 447: 35-52.   DOI
30 Fang, H., B. Ji, X. Deng, J. Ying, G. Zhou, Y. Shi, L. Xu, J. Tao, Y. Zhou, C. Li, and H. Zheng, 2018. Effects of topographic factors and aboveground vegetation carbon stocks on soil organic carbon in Moso bamboo forests, Plant and Soil, 433(1): 363-376.   DOI
31 Heerdegen, R.G. and M.A. Beran, 1982. Quantifying source areas through land surface curvature and shape, Journal of Hydrology, 57(3-4): 359-373.   DOI
32 Graham, R., 2006. Factors of soil formation: Topography, In R. Scalenghe (Author) & G. Certini (Ed.), Soils: Basic Concepts and Future Challenges, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom, pp. 151-164.
33 GRASS GIS (Geographic Resources Analysis Support System Geographic Information System), 2012. Grass Development Team, Geographic Resources Analysis Support System Software, Open Source Geospatial Foundation Project (http://grass.osgeo.org), Accessed on May. 31, 2021.
34 Horn, B.K.P., 1981. Hill shading and the reflectance map, Proceedings of the IEEE, 69(1): 14-47.   DOI
35 Mattivi, P., F. Franci, A. Lambertini, and G. Bitelli, 2019. TWI computation: a comparison of different open source GISs, Open Geospatial Data, Software and Standards, 4(1): 1-12.   DOI
36 Krieger, G., A. Moreira, H. Fiedler, I. Hajnsek, M. Werner, M. Younis, and M. Zink, 2007. TanDEM-X: A satellite formation for high-resolution SAR interferometry, IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 45(11): 3317-3341.   DOI
37 Costa-Cabral, M.C. and S.J. Burges, 1994. Digital Elevation Model Networks (DEMON): A model of flow over hillslopes for computation of contributing and dispersal areas, Water Resources Research, 30(6): 1681-1692.   DOI
38 Lee, H.-S., B.-K. Choi, S.-Y. Jung, C.-S. Hyun, S.-M. Choi, H.-M. Kang, 2020. The Analysis of the Economic Impacts of Eco-tourism in Island - Focus on Pung-Do in the Ansan City District -, The Journal of Korean Island, 32(4): 147-164 (in Korean with English abstract).   DOI