Browse > Article
http://dx.doi.org/10.5765/jkacap.2013.24.3.109

Broken Mirror or Unbroken Mirror? : An Investigation for Mirror Neuron Dysfunction of the Autism Spectrum Disorder  

Son, Jung-Woo (Department of Psychiatry, Chungbuk National University Hospital)
Ghim, Hei-Rhee (Department of Psychology, Chungbuk National University)
Publication Information
Journal of the Korean Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry / v.24, no.3, 2013 , pp. 109-123 More about this Journal
Abstract
The discovery of the mirror neuron system (MNS) is one of the most important neuroscientific achievements in the 20th century. Some researchers had reported that MNS dysfunction was discovered in autism spectrum disorders (ASD). Finally, the 'broken mirror' theory of ASD was announced in the mid 2000's. According to this theory, ASD cannot simulate the mind and behavior of others due to MNS dysfunction; therefore, they cannot imitate the behaviors and empathized with the mind of others. However, ASD does not always show imitation problems. The researchers who have criticized the 'broken mirror' theory proposed the 'social top-down response modulation (STORM)' theory. On STORM theory, the medial prefrontal cortex or temporo-parietal junction, brain areas related with mentalising, might modulate MNS according to social context. We compared the strengths and weaknesses of each theory.
Keywords
Mirror Neuron; Autism Spectrum Disorder; Broken Mirror Theory; Social Top-Down Response Modulation;
Citations & Related Records
Times Cited By KSCI : 2  (Citation Analysis)
연도 인용수 순위
1 Han IJ. Mirror neurons, empathy, and moral education. Kor J Philos Edu 2010;41:521-548.
2 Jang D. Recent studies on mirror neurons: focusing on imitation and empathy. Commun Korean Inst Inf Sci Eng 2012;30:43-51.   과학기술학회마을
3 Jeong JW. Social cognition and morality: mirror neuron and empathy as a necessary condition of morality. Stud Philos East West 2012;63:175-197.   DOI
4 Lee SY, Lee MH, Bae SS, Lee KS, Gong WT. The effects of action observation and motor imagery of serial reaction time task (SRTT) in mirror neuron activation. Korean Soc Phys Med 2010;5:395-404.   과학기술학회마을
5 Lee MK, Kim JM. The mirror neuron system and action observation training: implications for stroke rehabilitation. Korean J Neural Rehabil 2011;1:51-62.
6 Kim TH, Moon SW. Social function in autism spectrum disorders. Korean J Psychopathol 2011;20:29-34.
7 Gallese V, Fadiga L, Fogassi L, Rizzolatti G. Action recognition in the premotor cortex. Brain 1996;119(Pt 2):593-609.   DOI   ScienceOn
8 Rizzolatti G, Fadiga L, Gallese V, Fogassi L. Premotor cortex and the recognition of motor actions. Brain Res Cogn Brain Res 1996;3: 131-141.   DOI   ScienceOn
9 Iacoboni M, Woods RP, Brass M, Bekkering H, Mazziotta JC, Rizzolatti G. Cortical mechanisms of human imitation. Science 1999; 286:2526-2528.   DOI   ScienceOn
10 Iacoboni M, Molnar-Szakacs I, Gallese V, Buccino G, Mazziotta JC, Rizzolatti G. Grasping the intentions of others with one’s own mirror neuron system. PLoS Biol 2005;3:e79.   DOI   ScienceOn
11 Rizzolatti G, Fabbri-Destro M, Cattaneo L. Mirror neurons and their clinical relevance. Nat Clin Pract Neurol 2009;5:24-34.
12 Thioux M, Gazzola V, Keysers C. Action understanding: how, what and why. Curr Biol 2008;18:R431-R434.   DOI   ScienceOn
13 de Lange FP, Spronk M, Willems RM, Toni I, Bekkering H. Complementary systems for understanding action intentions. Curr Biol 2008;18:454-457.   DOI   ScienceOn
14 Carr L, Iacoboni M, Dubeau MC, Mazziotta JC, Lenzi GL. Neural mechanisms of empathy in humans: a relay from neural systems for imitation to limbic areas. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2003;100: 5497-5502.   DOI   ScienceOn
15 Cochin S, Barthelemy C, Lejeune B, Roux S, Martineau J. Perception of motion and qEEG activity in human adults. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1998;107:287-295.   DOI   ScienceOn
16 Uddin LQ, Iacoboni M, Lange C, Keenan JP. The self and social cognition: the role of cortical midline structures and mirror neurons. Trends Cogn Sci 2007;11:153-157.   DOI   ScienceOn
17 Williams JH, Whiten A, Suddendorf T, Perrett DI. Imitation, mirror neurons and autism. Neurosci Biobehav Rev 2001;25:287-295.   DOI   ScienceOn
18 Oberman LM, Hubbard EM, McCleery JP, Altschuler EL, Ramachandran VS, Pineda JA. EEG evidence for mirror neuron dysfunction in autism spectrum disorders. Brain Res Cogn Brain Res 2005; 24:190-198.   DOI   ScienceOn
19 Babiloni C, Carducci F, Cincotti F, Rossini PM, Neuper C, Pfurtscheller G, et al. Human movement-related potentials vs desynchronization of EEG alpha rhythm: a high-resolution EEG study. Neuroimage 1999;10:658-665.   DOI   ScienceOn
20 Pineda JA, Allison BZ, Vankov A. The effects of self-movement, observation, and imagination on mu rhythms and readiness potentials (RP’s): toward a brain-computer interface (BCI). IEEE Trans Rehabil Eng 2000;8:219-222.   DOI   ScienceOn
21 Dapretto M, Davies MS, Pfeifer JH, Scott AA, Sigman M, Bookheimer SY, et al. Understanding emotions in others: mirror neuron dysfunction in children with autism spectrum disorders. Nat Neurosci 2006;9:28-30.   DOI   ScienceOn
22 Théoret H, Halligan E, Kobayashi M, Fregni F, Tager-Flusberg H, Pascual-Leone A. Impaired motor facilitation during action observation in individuals with autism spectrum disorder. Curr Biol 2005; 15:R84-R85.   DOI   ScienceOn
23 Ramachandran VS, Oberman LM. Broken mirrors: a theory of autism. Sci Am 2006;295:62-69.
24 Ramachandran VS, Hubbard EM. Synaesthesia-a window into perception, thought and language. J Conscious Stud 2001;8:3-34.
25 Oberman LM, Ramachandran VS. The simulating social mind: the role of the mirror neuron system and simulation in the social and communicative deficits of autism spectrum disorders. Psychol Bull 2007;133:310-327.   DOI   ScienceOn
26 Happé FGE. Understanding minds and metaphors: insights from the study of figurative language in autism. Metaphor Symb Act 1995; 10:275-295.   DOI   ScienceOn
27 Hirstein W, Iversen P, Ramachandran VS. Autonomic responses of autistic children to people and objects. Proc Biol Sci 2001;268: 1883-1888.   DOI   ScienceOn
28 Brang D, Ramachandran VS. Olfactory bulb dysgenesis, mirror neuron system dysfunction, and autonomic dysregulation as the neural basis for autism. Med Hypotheses 2010;74:919-921.   DOI   ScienceOn
29 Barsalou LW. Perceptual symbol systems. Behav Brain Sci 1999;22: 577-609; discussion 610-660.
30 Martineau J, Cochin S, Magne R, Barthelemy C. Impaired cortical activation in autistic children: is the mirror neuron system involved? Int J Psychophysiol 2008;68:35-40.   DOI   ScienceOn
31 Nishitani N, Avikainen S, Hari R. Abnormal imitation-related cortical activation sequences in Asperger’s syndrome. Ann Neurol 2004;55:558-562.   DOI   ScienceOn
32 Martineau J, Andersson F, Barthelemy C, Cottier JP, Destrieux C. Atypical activation of the mirror neuron system during perception of hand motion in autism. Brain Res 2010;1320:168-175.   DOI   ScienceOn
33 Enticott PG, Kennedy HA, Rinehart NJ, Tonge BJ, Bradshaw JL, Taffe JR, et al. Mirror neuron activity associated with social impairments but not age in autism spectrum disorder. Biol Psychiatry 2012;71:427-433.   DOI   ScienceOn
34 Cattaneo L, Fabbri-Destro M, Boria S, Pieraccini C, Monti A, Cossu G, et al. Impairment of actions chains in autism and its possiblerole in intention understanding. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2007;104: 17825-17830.   DOI   ScienceOn
35 Rogers SJ, Pennington BF. A theoretical approach to the deficits in infantile autism. Dev Psychopathol 1991;3:137-162.   DOI
36 Hamilton AF. Reflecting on the mirror neuron system in autism: a systematic review of current theories. Dev Cogn Neurosci 2013;3: 91-105.   DOI   ScienceOn
37 Williams JH, Whiten A, Singh T. A systematic review of action imitation in autistic spectrum disorder. J Autism Dev Disord 2004;34: 285-299.   DOI   ScienceOn
38 Buccino G, Vogt S, Ritzl A, Fink GR, Zilles K, Freund HJ, et al. Neural circuits underlying imitation learning of hand actions: an eventrelated fMRI study. Neuron 2004;42:323-334.   DOI   ScienceOn
39 Rizzolatti G, Fabbri-Destro M. Mirror neurons: from discovery to autism. Exp Brain Res 2010;200:223-237.   DOI   ScienceOn
40 Hari R, Salmelin R. Human cortical oscillations: a neuromagnetic view through the skull. Trends Neurosci 1997;20:44-49.   DOI   ScienceOn
41 Klin A, Jones W, Schultz R, Volkmar F, Cohen D. Visual fixation patterns during viewing of naturalistic social situations as predictors of social competence in individuals with autism. Arch Gen Psychiatry 2002;59:809-816.   DOI
42 Southgate V, Hamilton AF. Unbroken mirrors: challenging a theory of Autism. Trends Cogn Sci 2008;12:225-229.   DOI   ScienceOn
43 Hobson RP, Lee A. Imitation and identification in autism. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1999;40:649-659.   DOI   ScienceOn
44 Rogers SJ, Bennetto L, McEvoy R, Pennington BF. Imitation and pantomime in high-functioning adolescents with autism spectrum disorders. Child Dev 1996;67:2060-2073.   DOI   ScienceOn
45 Rogers SJ, Hepburn SL, Stackhouse T, Wehner E. Imitation performance in toddlers with autism and those with other developmental disorders. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 2003;44:763-781.   DOI
46 Bird G, Leighton J, Press C, Heyes C. Intact automatic imitation of human and robot actions in autism spectrum disorders. Proc Biol Sci 2007;274:3027-3031.   DOI   ScienceOn
47 Aldridge MA, Stone KR, Sweeney MH, Bower TGR. Preverbal children with autism understand the intentions of others. Dev Science 2000;3:294-301.   DOI   ScienceOn
48 Carpenter M, Pennington BF, Rogers SJ. Understanding of others’ intentions in children with autism. J Autism Dev Disord 2001;31: 589-599.   DOI   ScienceOn
49 Hamilton AF, Brindley RM, Frith U. Imitation and action understanding in autistic spectrum disorders: how valid is the hypothesis of a deficit in the mirror neuron system? Neuropsychologia 2007; 45:1859-1868.   DOI   ScienceOn
50 Hamilton AF. Emulation and mimicry for social interaction: a theoretical approach to imitation in autism. Q J Exp Psychol (Hove) 2008;61:101-115.   DOI   ScienceOn
51 Bekkering H, Wohlschlager A, Gattis M. Imitation of gestures in children is goal-directed. Q J Exp Psychol A 2000;53:153-164.   DOI
52 McIntosh DN, Reichmann-Decker A, Winkielman P, Wilbarger JL. When the social mirror breaks: deficits in automatic, but not voluntary, mimicry of emotional facial expressions in autism. Dev Sci 2006;9:295-302.   DOI   ScienceOn
53 Kilner JM, Paulignan Y, Blakemore SJ. An interference effect of observed biological movement on action. Curr Biol 2003;13:522- 525.   DOI   ScienceOn
54 Wang Y, Hamilton AF. Social top-down response modulation (STORM): a model of the control of mimicry in social interaction. Front Hum Neurosci 2012;6:153.
55 Heyes C. Causes and consequences of imitation. Trends Cogn Sci 2001;5:253-261.   DOI   ScienceOn
56 Heyes C. What's s ocial a bout s ocial learning? J Comp Psychol 2012;126:193-202.   DOI   ScienceOn
57 van Baaren RB, Holland RW, Steenaert B, van Knippenberg A. Mimicry for money: behavioral consequences of imitation. J Exp Soc Psychol 2003;39:393-398.   DOI   ScienceOn
58 Chong TT, Cunnington R, Williams MA, Mattingley JB. The role of selective attention in matching observed and executed actions. Neuropsychologia 2009;47:786-795.   DOI   ScienceOn
59 Chartrand TL, Bargh JA. The chameleon effect: the perceptionbehavior link and social interaction. J Pers Soc Psychol 1999;76: 893-910.   DOI
60 van Baaren RB, Holland RW, Kawakami K, van Knippenberg A. Mimicry and prosocial behavior. Psychol Sci 2004;15:71-74.   DOI   ScienceOn
61 Bourgeois P, Hess U. The impact of social context on mimicry. Biol Psychol 2008;77:343-352.   DOI   ScienceOn
62 Wang Y, Newport R, Hamilton AF. Eye contact enhances mimicry of intransitive hand movements. Biol Lett 2011;7:7-10.   DOI   ScienceOn
63 Van Overwalle F, Baetens K. Understanding others' actions and goals by mirror and mentalizing systems: a meta-analysis. Neuroimage 2009;48:564-584.   DOI   ScienceOn
64 Frith CD, Frith U. The neural basis of mentalizing. Neuron 2006; 50:531-534.   DOI   ScienceOn
65 Bahn GH. From attachment theory to mentalization: historical background and clinical implication. Psychoanalysis 2013;24:9-20.
66 Brass M, Ruby P, Spengler S. Inhibition of imitative behaviour and social cognition. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 2009;364: 2359-2367.   DOI   ScienceOn
67 Spengler S, von Cramon DY, Brass M. Resisting motor mimicry: control of imitation involves processes central to social cognition in patients with frontal and temporo-parietal lesions. Soc Neurosci 2010;5:401-416.   DOI
68 Ingersoll B, Schreibman L, Tran QH. Effect of sensory feedback on immediate object imitation in children with autism. J Autism Dev Disord 2003;33:673-683.   DOI   ScienceOn
69 Spengler S, Brass M, Kühn S, Schütz-Bosbach S. Minimizing motor mimicry by myself: self-focus enhances online action-control mechanisms during motor contagion. Conscious Cogn 2010;19:98-106.   DOI   ScienceOn
70 Wang Y, Ramsey R, de C Hamilton AF. The control of mimicry by eye contact is mediated by medial prefrontal cortex. J Neurosci 2011; 31:12001-12010.   DOI   ScienceOn
71 Ingersoll B. The effect of context on imitation skills in children with autism. Res Autism Spectr Disord 2008;2:332-340.   DOI   ScienceOn
72 Cook JL, Bird G. Atypical social modulation of imitation in autism spectrum conditions. J Autism Dev Disord 2012;42:1045-1051.   DOI
73 Grecucci A, Brambilla P, Siugzdaite R, Londero D, Fabbro F, Rumiati RI. Emotional resonance deficits in autistic children. J Autism Dev Disord 2013;43:616-628.   DOI   ScienceOn
74 Spengler S, Bird G, Brass M. Hyperimitation of actions is related to reduced understanding of others’ minds in autism spectrum conditions. Biol Psychiatry 2010;68:1148-1155.   DOI   ScienceOn
75 Marsh LE, Hamilton AF. Dissociation of mirroring and mentalising systems in autism. Neuroimage 2011;56:1511-1519.   DOI   ScienceOn
76 Oberman LM, Ramachandran VS, Pineda JA. Modulation of mu suppression in children with autism spectrum disorders in response to familiar or unfamiliar stimuli: the mirror neuron hypothesis. Neuropsychologia 2008;46:1558-1565.   DOI   ScienceOn
77 Pellicano E, Burr D. When the world becomes ‘too real’: a Bayesian explanation of autistic perception. Trends Cogn Sci 2012;16:504-510.   DOI   ScienceOn
78 Davis MH. Empathy: a social psychological approach. Boulder, CO: Westview Press;1996.
79 Brass M, Derrfuss J, von Cramon DY. The inhibition of imitative and overlearned responses: a functional double dissociation. Neuropsychologia 2005;43:89-98.   DOI   ScienceOn
80 Vogt S, Buccino G, Wohlschläger AM, Canessa N, Shah NJ, Zilles K, et al. Prefrontal involvement in imitation learning of hand actions: effects of practice and expertise. Neuroimage 2007;37:1371-1383.   DOI   ScienceOn
81 Jolliffe D, Farrington DP. Development and validation of the Basic Empathy Scale. J Adolesc 2006;29:589-611.   DOI   ScienceOn
82 Ghim HR, Son JW, Eom JS, Jung MS, Park M, Park YO, et al. Children's facial mimicry to dynamic emotional facial expressions and their emotional empathy. Korean J Cogn Biol Psychol 2012;24:433-452.   DOI
83 Dziobek I, Preissler S, Grozdanovic Z, Heuser I, Heekeren HR, Roepke S. Neuronal correlates of altered empathy and social cognition in borderline personality disorder. Neuroimage 2011;57:539-548.   DOI   ScienceOn
84 Shamay-Tsoory SG, Aharon-Peretz J, Perry D. Two systems for empathy: a double dissociation between emotional and cognitive empathy in inferior frontal gyrus versus ventromedial prefrontal lesions. Brain 2009;132(Pt 3):617-627.   DOI   ScienceOn
85 Cox CL, Uddin LQ, Di Martino A, Castellanos FX, Milham MP, Kelly C. The balance between feeling and knowing: affective and cognitive empathy are reflected in the brain’s intrinsic functional dynamics. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci 2012;7:727-737.   DOI
86 Ghim HR, Jung MS, Son JW, Park M, Eom JS, Moon E, et al. The relation of cognitive and emotional empathy to social behaviors in Korean children. Korean J Dev Psychol 2013;26:255-275.
87 Dziobek I, Rogers K, Fleck S, Bahnemann M, Heekeren HR, Wolf OT, et al. Dissociation of cognitive and emotional empathy in adults with Asperger syndrome using the Multifaceted Empathy Test (MET). J Autism Dev Disord 2008;38:464-473.   DOI   ScienceOn
88 Harari H, Shamay-Tsoory SG, Ravid M, Levkovitz Y. Double dissociation between cognitive and affective empathy in borderline personality disorder. Psychiatry Res 2010;175:277-279.   DOI   ScienceOn
89 Ritter K, Dziobek I, Preissler S, Rüter A, Vater A, Fydrich T, et al. Lack of empathy in patients with narcissistic personality disorder. Psychiatry Res 2011;187:241-247.   DOI   ScienceOn
90 Rogers K, Dziobek I, Hassenstab J, Wolf OT, Convit A. Who cares? Revisiting empathy in Asperger syndrome. J Autism Dev Disord 2007;37:709-715.   DOI
91 Blair RJ. Fine cuts of empathy and the amygdala: dissociable deficits in psychopathy and autism. Q J Exp Psychol (Hove) 2008;61: 157-170.   DOI   ScienceOn
92 Smith A. The empathy imbalance hypothesis of autism: a theoretical approach to cognitive and emotional empathy in autistic development. Psychol Record 2009;59:489-510.   DOI
93 Yuan TF, Hoff R. Mirror neuron system based therapy for emotional disorders. Med Hypotheses 2008;71:722-726.   DOI   ScienceOn
94 McGarry LM, Russo FA. Mirroring in Dance/Movement Therapy: potential mechanisms behind empathy enhancement. Art Psychother 2011;38:178-184.   DOI   ScienceOn
95 Samaritter R, Payne H. Kinaesthetic intersubjectivity: a dance informed contribution to self-other relatedness and shared experience in non-verbal psychotherapy with an example from autism. Art Psychother 2013;40:143-150.   DOI   ScienceOn
96 Santiesteban I, White S, Cook J, Gilbert SJ, Heyes C, Bird G. Training social cognition: from imitation to Theory of Mind. Cognition 2012;122:228-235.   DOI   ScienceOn
97 Lindsay CJ, Moore DW, Anderson A, Dillenburger K. The role of imitation in video-based interventions for children with autism. Dev Neurorehabil 2013;16:283-289.   DOI   ScienceOn