Journal of the Korean Society of Marine Environment & Safety (해양환경안전학회지)

The Korean Society of Marine Environment and safety (해양환경안전학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Estimation of Maximum Outward Heel Angle During Turning of Pure Car and Truck Carriers

자동차운반선 선회 중 최대 횡경사각 추정에 관한 연구

  • Hyeok-beom Ju (Division of Cadet Training, Mokpo National Maritime University) ;
  • Deug-bong Kim (Division of Navigation Information System, Mokpo National Maritime University)
  • 주혁범 (국립목포해양대학교 승선실습과정부) ;
  • 김득봉 (국립목포해양대학교 항해정보시스템학부)
  • Received : 2024.03.25
  • Accepted : 2024.06.27
  • Published : 2024.06.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The height of large car and truck carriers from the keel to the wheel house is 44 ~ 46 m, and as the car-carriers increases in size, it exhibits the 'top heavy' characteristic, where the upper section is heavier than the lower section. This study aims to estimate the maximum outward heel angle of the Golden Ray car-carrier (G-ship) during turning maneuvers for accident investigation and the prevention of similar accidents. The theoretically calculated maximum outward heel is 7.5° (at 19 kn, rudder angle 35°) with a GM of +3.0 m or higher, and 16.7° with a GM of +1.85 m. Meanwhile the experimentally modified maximum outward heel is 10.5° (at 19 kn, rudder angle 35°) with a GM of +3.0 m or higher, and 23.3° with a GM of +1.85 m. The G-ship is maneuvered during an accident at a speed of 13 kn, at starboard rudder angle of 10° to 20°, it changes course from 038°(T) to 105°(T) based on the instructions of the on-board pilot. At this time, the maximum outward heel is estimated to be between 7.8° and 10.9° at the port side, which is 2.2 times higher than the normal outward heel. In the IS code, cargo ships are required to exhibit a minimum GoM of +0.15 m or more. The maneuvered G-ship exhibits a GoM of +1.72 m. It is not maneuvered because it fails to satisfy the international GoM criteria and because its GoM is insufficient to counteract the heeling moment during the maneuver. This study is performed based on accident-investigation results from the Korea Maritime Safety Tribunal and the USCG.

초대형 자동차운반선(LCTC)의 높이는 선저에서 조타실까지 약 44~46m에 이르며, 자동차운반선이 대형화될수록 상부 무게가 하부 무게보다 무거운 중두선의 특징을 가진다. 이 연구는 선회 중 전도한 자동차운반선 골든 레이호(G호)의 최대 외방경사각을 추정하여 사고 원인 규명과 유사사고 방지에 목적이 있다. 이론식으로 계산된 최대 외방경사각은 GM이 +3.0m 이상 상황에서 7.5°(19kn, 타각 35°), GM이 +1.85m인 상황에서 16.7°였다. 실험에 의한 수정식으로 계산한 최대 외방경사각은 GM이 +3.0m 이상 상황에서 10.5°(19kn, 타각 35°), GM이 +1.85m인 상황에서 23.3°를 보였다. G호는 전도사고 당시 도선사의 지시에 따라 속력 13kn, 우현 타각(10°→20°)을 사용하여 침로 038°(T)에서 105°(T)로 변침 중이었다. 이 때 최대 외방경사각은 좌현으로 7.8° 내지 10.9°로 추정된다. 평상 시 외방경사각보다 2.2배 높은 수치이다. 화물선의 최소 GoM은 IS coded에서 +0.15m 이상을 요구하고 있다. 전도된 G호도 +1.72m GoM을 확보하고 있었다. GoM에 대한 기준 미달이 전도의 원인이 아니라, 선회 중 횡경사 모멘트에 대응할 수 있는 충분한 GoM을 확보하지 않아 전도된 것이다. 이 연구는 중앙해양안전심판원과 USCG의 사고 조사 결과를 뒷받침한다.

Keywords

References

  1. BMA(2002), Report of the Investigation into the Collision Between Kariba and Tricolor Near the North East Bound Dover Traffic Separation Scheme on 14th Dec. 2002, pp. 7-32.
  2. BMA(2012), Report of the Investigation into the Loss of M/V Baltic Ace Following a Collision with M/V Corvus J at the North Hinder Junction Precautionary Area on the 5th, pp. 28-52.
  3. Guajardo Camps, A.(2020), Car Carrier Operational Guide and Proposal for an Optimization System, Bachelor's Thesis, Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya, pp. 10-33.
  4. HDSH(2017), Maneuvering Simulations for 7,400 Unit Roll-on Roll-off Car Carrier, DWG No. 8G-7000-007.
  5. HMD(2017a), Final Trim and Stability Booklet M/V Golden Ray, DWG No. 4A00B012, pp. 245-400.
  6. HMD(2017b), General Arrangement M/V Golden Ray, DWG No. 1G-7000-201-F.
  7. IMO(2008), Adoption of the International Code on Intact Stability(2008 IS Code), Resolution. MSC.267(85), pp. 6-16.
  8. Kang, B. S., C. H. Jung, and D. B. Kim(2020), A Study on Lashing Standards for Car Ferry Ships Sailing in Smooth Sea Areas, Journal of the Korean Society of Marine Environment & Safety, Vol. 26, No. 1, pp. 1-7. https://doi.org/10.7837/kosomes.2020.26.1.001
  9. Kinzo, I.(2013), Theory and Practice of Ship Handling, 1st Edition. Sang Hak Dang, pp. 82-88.
  10. Kim, H. B., Y. H. Lee, Y. S. Park, and G. Y. Gong(2018), A Study of Real Ship Experiments to Estimate the Heeling Angle of Passenger Type Ship when Turning, Journal of the Korean Society of Marine Environment & Safety, Vol. 24, No. 5, pp. 497-503. https://doi.org/10.7837/kosomes.2018.24.5.497
  11. KMST(2024), Ship Restoration Practical Work, www.kmst.go.kr, pp. 30-45.
  12. Lee, Y, S., C. S. Kim, and S. M. Lee(2002), A study on the Stability of a Low Freeboard Coastwise Tanker Capsized in Turning(2) - Experimental Examination of the Outward Heel Moment Induced by Flooding of Seawater onto the Deck, The Journal of Navigation and Port Research, Vol. 27, No. 5, pp. 465-471.
  13. MAIB(2016), Report on the Investigation into the Listing, Flooding and Grounding of Hoegh Osaka, Report No. 6-2016, pp. 68-70.
  14. Market.us(2023), Global Car Carrier Market 2023-2027, TechNavio, pp. 71-150.
  15. NTS(2021), Capsizing of Roll-on/Roll-off Vehicle Carrier Golden Ray, PB2021-100930, pp. 40-46.
  16. PMA(2016), Report on the Investigation of Listing and Abandoned Ship M/V "Modern Express", R-11-2016/DIAM, pp. 52-53.
  17. Rhodes, M. A.(2003), Ship Stability for Mates/Masters, 1st Edition, Seamanship International Ltd.: Scotland, pp. 219-294.
  18. Yoon, J. D.(2015), Understanding and Practical Application of Ship Handling, Sejong, pp. 29-77.