Journal of Korea Trade

Korea Trade Research Association (한국무역학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Comparative Study on the Application of the Force Majeure Clause in International Commercial Contracts between Korea and English in the Era of COVID-19

  • Byung-Chan Lee (Department of Physical Education, Sichuan Agricultural University) ;
  • Nak-Hyun Han (Department of International Trade and Logistics, Kyungnam University)
  • Received : 2022.09.30
  • Accepted : 2022.11.04
  • Published : 2022.11.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Purpose - This paper analyzes all possible issues that need to be considered in case disputes occur with regard to force majeure in international commercial contracts through the comparative study between English and Korean during COVID-19. Design/methodology - This paper belongs to the field of explanatory legal study, which aims to explain and test whether the choice of law is linked to the conditions that occur in the reality of judicial practice. The juridical approach involves studying and examining theories, concepts, legal doctrines, and legislation that are related to the problem. Findings - English law does not permit general economic impracticability to qualify as a valid force majeure event. If a party asserts that they were prevented from performing the contract, the courts will examine this strictly. Many commercial contracts in a broad range of sectors and industries are chosen by parties to be governed by English law. With COVID-19, there have been discussion of parties being released from performance as a result of force majeure. Meanwhile, under Korean law, a force majeure event should be unforeseeable and beyond a party's control. Since COVID-19 is a known event for future contracts, to avoid the risk that a similar situation in the future is deemed foreseeable and under a party's control, parties must ensure that such a risk is properly addressed in a contract. Therefore, it is necessary to have a new clause to cover a pandemic. Originality/value - In light of the ongoing unexpected and uncertain economic impacts COVID-19 is expected to bring to the world, it is anticipated that companies will experience an increased number of claims involving force majeure around the world, including English and Korea. As such, taking proactive steps to assess the applicable legal principles, including the concept of force majeure of contract, will help companies be prepared for the financial or legal implications of COVID-19. In this regard, it would be advisable for companies and businesses to take specific actions.

Keywords

References

  1. 3VB Barristers (n.d.), COVID-19 : Force Majeure, Frustration and Illegality in English Law: a Detailed Guide. Available from https://3vb.com/wp-content/uploads/old/3VB_Force_Majeure-01.pdf 
  2. Berger, K. P. and D. Behn.(2020), "Force Majeure and Hardship in the Age of Corona: A Historical and Comparative Study", McGill Journal of Dispute Resolution (2019/2020), 6(4), 79-130. 
  3. Bloomberg (2020), China LNG Force Majeure Rejected as Virus Chaos Sparks Dispute. Available from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-02-07/china-lng-force-majeurerejected-as-virus-chaos-sparks-dispute 
  4. Broom, R. and P. Brennan (2020), Invoking Force Majeure Due to COVID-19 Under English Law. Available from https://www.squirepattonboggs.com/-/media/files/insights/publications/2020/04/invoking-force-majeure-due-to-covid-19-under-english-law/invoking-force-majeure-dueto-covid-19-under-english-law.pdf 
  5. Brunner, C. (2009), Force Majeure and Hardship under General Contract Principles, Kluwer Law International. 
  6. Cho, In-Young (2020), "The Elements and Effects of Force Majeure - How Force Majeure Affects Contracts in the Time of COVID-19 -", Korean Lawyers Association Journal, 69(4), 166-211.  https://doi.org/10.17007/KLAJ.2020.69.4.005
  7. Christie, K., C. Tan and Mino Han (n.d.), When circumstances change: a comparative view of the law and ICC model clauses (International Bar Association). Available from https://www.ibanet.org/article/776f5fed-b7ff-4320-a246-7b52770fcd7a 
  8. Garner, B. A. (2019), Black's Law Dictionary (11th ed.), Thomson Reuters. 
  9. ICC(2020), ICC Force Majeure and Hardship Clauses, ICC. 
  10. Kim, Ji-Ahn (2020), "A Legal Study on Termination of Merger Agreement Based on Material Adverse Change", Business Law Review, 34(3), 367-389.  https://doi.org/10.24886/BLR.2020.9.34.3.367
  11. Kim, Kyu-Jin (2020), "Force Majeure in International Commercial Contracts", Korean Forum on International Trade and Business Law, 29(2), 1-35. 
  12. Kiraz, S. E. and E. Y. ustun (2020), "COVID-19 and force majeure clauses: an examination of arbitral tribunal's awards", Uniform Law Review, 25(4), 437-465.  https://doi.org/10.1093/ulr/unaa027
  13. Krol, S., L. Mistelis and P. Viscasillas (2020), UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG), C. H. Beck. 
  14. Kwon, Young-Joon (2021), "COVID-19 and Contract Law", Korean Journal of Civil Law, 94, 223-261.  https://doi.org/10.52554/kjcl.2021.94.223
  15. Lee & Ko (2020), COVID-19 Outbreak: Managing Legal Issues from the Korean Law Perspective (Legal500). https://www.legal500.com/developments/thought-leadership/covid-19-outbreak-managing-legal-issues-from-the-korean-law-perspective/ 
  16. Lee, Hoon (2016), "Study on Force Majeure Provisions in International Construction Contracts-with focus on FIDIC Terms and Conditions-", Korean Forum on International Trade and Business Law, 25(2), 1-27. 
  17. Lookofsky, J. (2017), Understanding the CISG, Wolters Kluwer. 
  18. Lum, N. and T. Yip (2022), Interpreting a Force Majeure clause in the face of international sanctions-the case of Mur Shipping BV v RTI Ltd provides guidance (Clyde & Co.). Available from https://www.clydeco.com/en/insights/2022/04/interpreting-a-force-majeure-clause-in-the-face-of 
  19. Mckendrick, E. (2013), Force Majeure and Frustration of Contract, CRC Press. 
  20. Miller, R. T. (2020), Material Adverse Effect Clauses and the COVID-19 Pandemic (University of Iowa Legal Studies Research Paper). Available from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3603055 
  21. Min, Joo-Hee (2021), "A Study on the Legality of Frustration and Force Majeure in the Era of COVID-19", International Commerce & Law Review, 92, 23-41.  https://doi.org/10.35980/KRICAL.2021.12.92.23
  22. Oh, Hyon-Sok (2016), "A Study on Force Majeure and Hardship in the International Sales Laws", International Commerce & Law Review, 69, 179-199. 
  23. Park, Young-Bok (2011), "Force Majeure and Hardship as Limits of Contract Liability", HUFS Law Review, 35(4), 105-129.  https://doi.org/10.17257/hufslr.2011.35.4.105
  24. Peel, E. (2021), Frustration and Force Majeure (4th ed.), Sweet & Maxwell Ltd. 
  25. Puelinckx, A. H.(1986), "Frustration, Hardship, Force Majeure, Imprevision, Wegfall der Geschaftsgrundlage, Unmoglichkeit, Changed Circumstances", J.Int'l Arb, 3(2), 47-66. 
  26. Schwartz, A. A. (2020), "Contracts and COVID-10", Stan. L. Rev., 73, 55-67. 
  27. Schwenzer, I, (2016), Commentary on the UN Convention on the International Sale of Goods (CISG), Oxford University Press. 
  28. Shin, Young-Jae and Byung-Hoon Hwang (2014), "Main Clause of M&A Contract and Legal Issue1 ; Issue of Material Adverse Change Clause", Business Finance Law, 67, 6-18. 
  29. Stephenson Harwood LLP (2022), Reliance on force majeure in the face of sanctions: MUR Shipping v RTI. Available from https://www.shlegal.com/news/reliance-on-force-majeure-in-the-face-of-sanctions-mur-shipping-v-rti 
  30. UNIDROIT (2020), Note of the UNIDROIT Secretariat on the UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts and the COVID-19 Health Crisis, UNIDROIT. 
  31. Uribe, R. M. (2011), "The Effect of a Change of Circumstances on the Binding Force of Contracts Comparative perspectives", Doctoral dissertation, Utrecht University. 
  32. WHO (2020), Novel Coronavirus(2019-nCov), Situation Report - 10. Available from https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/situation-reports/20200130-sitrep-10-ncov.pdf?sfvrsn=d0b2e480_2 
  33. Yang, Chang-Soo and Jae-Hyung Kim (2015), Civil Law I: Contract Law (2nd ed.), Parkyoungsa.