DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Comparative Study of the Humidifier Disinfectant Disaster and Minamata Disease

가습기살균제 참사와 미나마타병 사건의 비교 고찰

  • Choi, Yeyong (Special Investigation Commission on Humidifier Disinfectants & 4.16 Sewol Ferry Disasters) ;
  • Lee, Inhyun (Special Investigation Commission on Humidifier Disinfectants & 4.16 Sewol Ferry Disasters)
  • 최예용 (가습기살균제사건과 4.16세월호참사 특별조사위원회) ;
  • 이인현 (가습기살균제사건과 4.16세월호참사 특별조사위원회)
  • Received : 2019.08.05
  • Accepted : 2019.08.19
  • Published : 2019.08.31

Abstract

Objectives: Minamata disease was an environmental health disaster of worldwide notoriety that occurred in Japan. The acknowledged patients total roughly 3,000, and the relieved victims currently include 77,099 cases. Still, many cases await acknowledgment or relief. The humidifier disinfectant issue is an environmental health catastrophe that took place in Korea. Over 9.98 million products spanning 43 brands of humidifier disinfectant have been sold and 835, cases have been recognized to date as relevant victims by the government. So far, 2,144 cases have been relieved by the fund of the producing companies. Four million consumers and 560,000 victims are estimated. Finding hints as to how to develop solutions in terms of fact-finding and prevention are the objectives of this study. Methods: Fields visits, interviews, and workshops as well as reference reviews have been conducted. A comparison was attempted to show the similarities and differences between the two disasters on 38 items. Results: Apparent similarities in the two disasters are the failure of industrial safety measures and governmental safety systems as well as relief systems for the victims. No comprehensive investigation was performed for all of the affected areas in Japan and all of the consumers in Korea. Both governments have tried to hide the faults and responsibilities of the companies and minimize the scale of the victims. Only after the government was changed through a general election did the new governments apologize and attempt to find political and social solutions through special relief laws. Conclusions: Over the process of each event, in the beginning, debates took place regarding the cause and the heath damages involved. For both, medical and toxicological relations are the keys while afterward finding a social solution became the subsequent issue.

Keywords

References

  1. Citizen's Center for Environmental Studies, Committee for Environment and Health, Hurt the Environment then Pain the Human Body, Seoul: Nanam; 2004
  2. Workshop proceedings, 2019, No More Minamata Disease and No More Humidifier Disinfectant Disaster
  3. Choi Y. Questions and Answers about the Humidifier Disinfectants Disaster as of February. J Environ Health Sci. 2017; 43(1): 1-22.
  4. Kumamoto Daily newspaper, 1st August 1954
  5. Harada M. Minamata Lecture; Social Welfare Research Institute of Kumamoto Gakuen University, 2004
  6. Saito H. Methylmercury Poisoning in Niigata; Bungeisha; 2018
  7. Kyouritsu Neurology and Rehabilitation Clinic. About Minamata disease. Available: http://www.kyouritsu-cl.com/explanation/history.php#page02 [accessed 24 June 2019].
  8. Kumamoto University Library. Minamata disease related materials. http://www.lib.kumamoto-u.ac.jp/suishin/minamata/thesis/index.html [accessed 2 July 2019].
  9. Yano S., Tai A., Hisano A., Matsuyama A., Yano K., Tada A., H. et al. Characteristics of Grain Size Distribution of Suspended Solids in Minamata Bay. Proceedings of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers. 2012; 68(2): I961-I965.
  10. Nozawa A. An Environemntal Socialogical Study on the Relationship between Compensation Payment for Pollution Sufferers and Social Welfare Services for People with Disability: Focusing on the Conditions for Independence and Support for the Congenital and Infantile Minamata Disease Patients [Doctoral dissertation]. [Tokyo]: Meiji Gakuin University; 2015
  11. Symposium proceedings, 2013, Seeking Full Relief for All Minamata Disease Victims, Japan Federation of Bar Associations Human Rights Commission Pollution Measures Environment Conservation Commiittee
  12. Harada M., Tajiri M., Yamashita Y. Environmental Pathography-An epidemiologic method based on Environmental pollution. Bulletin of Social Medicine. 2009; 26(2): 53-73.
  13. Asaoka M. Sixty Years Ago "Minamata Disease" Testimony: Literature Review on Organic Mercury Poisoning. Journal of Kumamoto Psychiatric Association. 1988; 54: 3-16.
  14. Ishihara Nobuo, Bibliographical Study of the Toxicity of Organic Mercury Compounds-In Relation to the Identification of Causal Substance of Minamata Disease. Japanese Journal of Hygiene. 2011; 66(4): 746-749. https://doi.org/10.1265/jjh.66.746