Articulations of Southeast Asian Religious Modernisms: Islam in Early 20th Century Cambodia & Cochinchina

  • Noseworthy, William B. (University of Wisconsin-Medison)
  • Received : 2016.12.04
  • Accepted : 2017.06.08
  • Published : 2017.06.30

Abstract

This article is about the emergence of Islamic modernism among Cham Muslim communities in Cambodia and Cochinchina during the early 20th century. Based on a combined critical reading of existing scholarship, historicized first-hand anthropological accounts, as well as archival sources from the National Archives of Cambodia and the Vietnam National Archives II, it argues accounts of modernists in these sources were either (1) cast through a French colonial reading of a Buddhist state lens and (2) cast through a Malay lens, based upon the Kaum Muda/Kaum Tua divide. First, it proceeds with a historical explanation of the emergence of Islam and the discourse used to describe Muslim communities in Vietnamese, French, and Cham language sources. Then, it turns the narrative toward an examination of the emergence of the "Kaum Muda" or "New Group" of reformist-minded modernist Muslims in early 20th century Cambodia. Delineating the networks of these intellectuals as they stretched across the border through Cochinchina, also highlights a pre-existing transnational element to the community, one that well predates current discussions of twenty-first-century transnationalism. Through a combination of the study of multiple language sources and historical methods, the article highlights the importance of polylingualism in the study of the history of Muslims in Southeast Asia.

Keywords

References

  1. NAC Box 138. RSC No. 1347. Classification S. 41; S. 9. Autopsie de cadavres des Morts Chams.
  2. NAC Box 438. Old code: M 441. Older Code: M 632. Originally from the Central Library of Cambodia, no. 3079 (December 26, 1924). Gouverment General de l'Indochine: Direction de l'Instruction Publique: Decisions regarding the hours of Primary Superieur Franco-Indigene Education and Secondary Franco-Indigene education.
  3. NAC Box 653. RSC File No. 7668. (1901-27). Classification: F. 941. Correspondance relative aux pagodes et mosquees dans la province de Battambang [Correspondance related to the Pagodas and Mosques in the Province of Battambang].
  4. NAC Box 745. RSC File 8465. Classification R. 29. (1934) Fermeture des ecoles Malaisies clandestines situees a Phnom Penh [Closure of Clandestine Malay Schools located in Phnom Penh].
  5. NAC Box 811. RSC File 9200. (1905-11). Tribunal correctionnel de Battambang: affaire judiciaire de vol commis par trois Malais [Criminal Court of Battambang: A Criminal Case of Theft Committed by Three Malays].
  6. NAC Box 2968. RSC File 25968. Classification: F99. (1918-19). Residence de Kompong Chhnang. AS de la nomination des chefs pour les mosquees Cham [Residence of Kampong Chnnang: On the Subject of the Appointment of Heads of Cham Mosques].
  7. NAC Box 3052. RSC File 27641. Classification: C.012. OR no. 74 (September 10, 1929). Relevant de ses fonctions d'Oknha Reachea Pheak Koey, Montrey Changvang Nong Chef de mosquee Cham du khum de Khleang Sbek nord, Khand de Ponhea Lu, Kandal [Royay Ordanance no. 74 (September 10, 1929). [Falling under the functions of the Oknha Reachea Pheak Koey, Montrey Changvang Nong, head of the Cham Mosque, khum Kleang Sbek north, khand Ponhea Lu, Kandal].
  8. NAC Box 3310. RSC File 30285. Classification F. 99. AM. N. 158. (October 24, 1924). Nommant le sieur Kim-Man chef de mosquee Cham de Svai-Chrum, srok de Khasach-Kandal (Kandal) [Naming Mr. Kim Man, Chief of the Cham Mosque of Svoai-Chrum, srok Khasach-Kandal (Kandal)].
  9. NAC Box 3310. RSC File 30380. Classification: F. 99. AM. N. 53 (April 17, 1934). Nommant les sieurs Hadji-Salai-Man et Hadji-Sam-Sou respectivement chef (Prea mekemaven 6 pans de dignite) et sous-chef de mosquee cham de Naparat-Botoum-Bochantrea de Vat Dangker (Battambang) [Ministerial Order no. 53 April 17, 1934: Appointing Mr. Hadji Salai Man and Mr. Hadji Sam Sou, respectively, to the Chief (Preah Mekemavan with 6 stripes of dignity) and Senior Assistant of the Cham Mosque in Naparat Botoum Bochantreah of Wat Dangker (Battambang)].
  10. NAC Box 3674. RSC File 35468 (1937). Classification F. 74. Circulaire du RSC au sujet d'une enquete pour determiner si les habitants designes sous le nom de "Malais" sont en realite des Chams [A circular note regarding a survey to determine whether or not the people designated as "Malays" are in reality Cham].
  11. Goucoch divers. 2995. 1933. Note sur l'affaire de la mosquee de Saigon, Commissariat de la Police des Ports de Saigon, Cholon [Note on the case of the mosque of Saigon, Commissariat Police Reports of the Ports of Saigon and Cholon].
  12. Ho So 3001. 1951. To trinh cua Phu Thu hien Trung Viet ve tinh hinh chinh tu, hanh chanh, kinh te, xa hoi cua cac lang Cham thuoc tinh Ninh Thuan [Report of the Government Premiers of Central Vietnam regarding the general situation, administrative, economics, and social circumstances of all the Cham villages in the province of Ninh Thuan].
  13. Ho So 31692. 1964-75. Tu ngay 25/02/1958 den ngay 24/4/1975. Ve hoat dong cua Hiep hoi Cam Hoi giao [From 25/02/1958 to 04/24/1975. On the activities of the Association of Cham Islam].
  14. Abaza, Mona. 1998. Southeast Asia and the Middle East: Al-Manar and Islamic Modernity. From the Mediterranean to the China Sea: Miscellaneous Notes. Claude Guillot, Denys Lombard and Roderich Ptak, eds. 93-112. Wiesbaden.
  15. Ali, Zakaria. 1991. Notes on the Islamic Art of Champa. In Actes de la Conference Internationale sur le Campa et le Monde Malais. Paris: ACHPI: 123-35.
  16. Aymonier, Etienne. 1900. Le Cambodge: Le Royaume Actuel [Cambodia: The Current Kingdom]. Paris: EFEO vol. 1, Ernest LeRoux.
  17. Aymonier, Etienne. 1893. The History of Tchampa: The Cyamba of Marco Polo, Now Annam or Cochin China [translated from French]. The Imperial and Asiatic Quarterly Review and Oriental and Colonial Record VI (11)
  18. Aymonier, Etienne. 1891. Les Tchames et leurs Religions [The Chams and their Religions]. Paris: Ernest Leroux, EFEO.
  19. Aymonier, Etienne. 1890. Legendes Historiques Des Chames. [Historical Legends of the Cham]. Excursions etreconnaissances, 14 (32): 145-206.
  20. Ba Trung Phu. 2008. Bani Islam Cham in Vietnam. Islam at the Margins: The Muslims of Indochina. Omar Faouk and Hiroyuki Yamamoto, eds. 24-34. Kyoto, Japan: Center for Integrated Area Studies, Kyoto University.
  21. Aymonier, Etienne. 2006. The Cham Bani of Vietnam. The American Journal of Islamic Social Sciences, 23 (3): 126-33.
  22. Blengsi, Bjorn. 2009. Muslim Metamorphosis: Islamic education and Politics in Contemporary Cambodia. Making Modern Muslims: The Politics of Islamic Education in Southeast Asia. Robert W. Hefner, ed. 172-204. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai'i Press.
  23. Bruckmayr, Philipp. 2013. Between Institutionalized Syncretism and Official Particularism: Religion among the Chams of Vietnam and Cambodia. Rituale als Ausdruck von Kulturkontakt: "Synkretismus" zwischen Negation und Neudefinition; Akten der interdisziplinaren Tagung des Sonderforschungsbereiches "Ritualdynamik". Conference in Heidelberg, 3-5. December 2010 (published 2013): 11-42.
  24. Cabaton, Antoine. 1906. Notes sur l'Islam dans l'Indochine Fracaise [Notes on Islam in French Indochina]. Revue du monde musulman, 1 (1): 129-80
  25. Durand, MP EM. 1903. Les Chams Bani. [The Cham Bani]. BEFEO III, 1: 54-63
  26. Edwards, Penny. 2007. Cambodge: The Cultivation of a Nation. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai'i Press.
  27. Farouk, Omar. 2008. The Re-organization of Islam in Cambodia and Laos. Islam at the Margins: The Muslims of Indochina. Omar Farouk and Hiroyuki Yamamoto, eds. 70-86. Kyoto, Japan: Center for Integrated Area Studies, Kyoto University.
  28. Gilquin, Michel. 2005. The Muslims of Thailand (translated by Michael Smithies). Bangkok: IRASEC and Silkworm Books.
  29. Guerin, Mathieu. 2004. Les Cams et leur 'veranda sur la Mecque'. L'Influence des Malais de Patani et du Kelantan sur les Cams du Cambodge" [The Cham and their "Veranda to Mecca." The Influence of the Malays of Patani and Kelantan on the Cham of Cambodia]. Aseanie, 14 (14): 29-67.
  30. Hoeffel, Ernest. 1932 (Not Dated in Archives). De la Condition juridique des etrangers au Cambodge [On the Legal Status of Foreigners in Cambodia]. Imprimerie of Saigon: Nguyen Van Cua. In: National Archives of Cambodia Box 437. ID: 9.512. Old Code: P. 562. Formerly held in the Buddhist Institute of Cambodia, (file not dated in archives).
  31. Houben, Vincent J. H. 2003. Southeast Asia and Islam. American Academy of Political and Social Science: 588, "Islam: Enduring Myths and Changing Realities": 149-70.
  32. Jammes, Jeremy. 2013. Se convertir et re-convertir au Ratanakiri (Cambodge). A propos du pentecotisme en context pluriethnique et plurilinguistique" [Conversion and reconversion in Ratanakiri (Cambodia). On Pentecostalism in Multi-ethnic and Poly-linguistic contexts]. Social Compass, 60(4): 471-87.
  33. Kiernan, Ben. 2010. Chams. The Encyclopedia of Islam, Third Edition. 173-80. Leiden: Brill.
  34. Manguin, Yves-Manguin. 1979. IX. Etudes Cam. II. L'Introduction de l'Islam au Campa" [IX. Cham Studies. II. The Introduction of Islam to Champa]. Bulletin de l'Ecole Francaise d'Extreme-Orient, (BEFEO) 66: 255-87
  35. Ner, Marcel. 1941. Les Musulmans de l'Indochine Francaise. [The Muslims of French Indochina]. BEFEO XLI: 151-203.
  36. Nguyen Van Luan. circa 1960. Viec Tang ma va tho cung to tien cua nguoi Cham Hoi giao o Saigon" [The Funerary Practices and Ancestral Worship of the Cham Muslims of Saigon], Tap San Van Hoa - Co Quan Nghien Cuu va Pho Thong XVIII, so 4-5 [Published by Nha Van Hoa: Phu Quoc - Vu Khanh Dac Trach Van Hoa, Saigon, Vietnam]: 39-50
  37. Noseworthy, William B. 2013. The Chams' First Highland Sovereign: Po Rome (r. 1627-1651), Asian Highlands Perspectives, 28 (December): 155-203
  38. Phan Van Dop. 1993. Ton Giao Cua Nguoi Cham o Viet Nam [The religion of the Cham in Vietnam]. Luan An Pho Tien Si Khoa Học Lich Su. [Doctoral Thesis in History] TP. Ho Chi Minh.: Chuyen nganh: Dan Toc Học. Nguoi Huong Dan Khoa Hoc: PGS. PTS. Phan Xuan Bien va PGS. PTS. Mac Duong. Vien Khoa Hoc Xa Hoi.
  39. Phu Van Han. 2013. Van Hoa Nguoi Cham o Thanh Pho Ho Chi Minh [The Culture of the Cham people in Ho Chi Minh City]. Ho Chi Minh City: Van Hoa Dan Toc.
  40. Phu Van Han. 2005. No Luc Phat Trien va Giai Phap Nang Cao Doi Song Kinh Te va Van Hoa Cua Cong
  41. Dong Nguoi Cham TP. Ho Chi Minh" [Development efforts and measure to improve economic life and culture of the Cham community in Ho Chi Minh City]. In Doi Song Van Hoa & Xa Hoi: Thanh Pho Ho Chi Minh [Life, Culture and Society: Ho Chi Minh City]. Phu Van Han, ed. 101-10. Ho Chi Minh City: Van Hoa Dan Toc.
  42. Riddell, Peter. 2001. Islam and the Malay-Indonesian World: Transmission and Responses. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai'i Press.
  43. Sakaya [Truong Van Mon]. 2013. Tiep Can Mot So Van De Van Hoa Champa [Approaching Some Problems of Champa Culture]. Ho Chi Minh City: Tri Thuc Press.
  44. Scupin, Raymond. 2000. Cham Muslims of Thailand: A Model Moral Community.: 453-461 (Accessed Oct. 30, 2013).
  45. Scupin, Raymond. 1989. Cham Muslims in Thailand: A Haven of Security in Mainland Southeast Asia. Journal of the Institute of Muslim Minority Affairs, 10 (2): 486-491.
  46. Scupin, Raymond. 1988. Cham Muslims in Thailand. Muslims in Thailand. A. Forbes, ed. 106-09. Bihar, India: Centre for South-East Asian Studies.
  47. Stockhof, Malte. 2008. The Baweans of Ho Chi Minh City. Islam at the Margins: Muslims in Indochina. Omar Farouk and Hiroyuki Yamato, eds. Kyoto, Japan: Center for Integrated Area Studies, Kyoto University.
  48. Thanh Phan. 2013. Palei - Mot Hinh Thai Cu Tru cua cong dong Cham o Viet Nam" [Palei - an examination of residential communities of the Cham in Vietnam]. Rua Dua Bhap Ilimo Cam/Tap Chi Nghien Cuu Van Hoa Cham [Cham Cultural Studies] 1(1): 4-12.
  49. Tran Nam Tien. 2005. Thanh Duong Hoi Giao Trong Doi Song Cua Nguoi Cham Islam O TP. Ho Chi Minh. [Islamic Mosques in the life of Cham Islam in Ho Chi Minh City]. Doi Song Van Hoa & Xa Hoi: Thanh Pho Ho Chi Minh [Life, Culture and Society: Ho Chi Minh City]. Phu Van Han, ed. 127-35. Ho Chi Minh City: Van Hoa Dan Toc.
  50. Weber, Nicolas. 2013. Les Cam et les Malais du Cambodge et de Cochinchine vus par les archives colonials (1859-1954). Archipel, (85): 117-134
  51. Weber, Nicolas. 2005. Contribution a l'histoire des communautes cam en Asie du Sud-Est (Cambodge, Vietnam, Siam, Malaisie) : integration politique, militaire et economique, these de doctorat, INALCO.
  52. Zain Musa, Mohammed. 2011. History of Education among the Cambodian Cham Muslims. Jebat: Malaysian Journal of History, Politics & Strategic Studies, 38 (1): 81-104
  53. Zain Musa, Mohammed. 2008. Dynamics of Faith: Imam Musa in the Revival of Islamic Teaching in Cambodia." Islam at the Margins: The Muslims of Indochina. Omar Faouk and Hiroyuki Yamamoto, eds. 69-79. Kyoto, Japan: Center for Integrated Area Studies, Kyoto University.
  54. Zain Musa, Mohammed. 2004. Islam as Understood and Practiced by the Muslims in Indochina. Islamiyyat, 25(1): 45-60.