Continuation and Rebirth: A Study on the Changing Mechanism of Customary Law - Based on the fieldwork on the main ethnic minority areas in South China

续造与重生:习惯法变迁机制研究 --基于南方主要少数民族聚居区的田野调查

  • Chen, Hanfei (Capital University of Economics and Business)
  • Received : 2017.09.02
  • Accepted : 2017.09.21
  • Published : 2017.09.30

Abstract

From the field survey of the main ethnic minority areas in the south China, it is found that political, economic, cultural and natural environmental changes are the main reasons leading to the change of customary law. The power mechanism of the customary law change include the three aspects, such as the promotion of country elite, the dominance of grassroots government, and the daily demands of the villagers, which promote the change of customary law alone or together. Through the application of customary law, the country elites can adjust and refine the rules of customary law in order to make out the new customary law and promote its development. In the current pattern of rural governance, grassroots self-government is actually the "official supervision of people's autonomy". The executive power of the grassroots government often intervene the practice of customary law and other informal rules. This is another mechanism of customary law change. Customary law arises from the practice of the daily life of the villagers. If the villagers think that the norms of customary law cannot meet the actual needs of daily life practice, the customary law will be promoted in the form of collective consultation. This is the most important dynamic practice mechanism of customary law change. Transformation and abandonment are the two ways to change customary law. No matter what kind of change does not lead to the demise of the customary law system, the demise of the customary law is only an outdated result, which is made by the universality, nature and objectivity of customary law. The procedure of customary law change is the process of continuation and rebirth about customary law. The result of the change is to produce the new customary law of keeping pace with the times, and the customary law will be presented with new content and form after the change. The continuation of customary law means the inheritance of traditional customary law, but it is based on the transformation of traditional customary law. The rebirth of customary law means that the traditional customary law is completely discarded. But it will produce new customary law rules and be based on the needs of social life practice. Customary law occupies a pivotal position in the normative system and the national law cannot be replaced. The purpose of customary law change will let the customary rules better adapt to the development of modern society, adjust the social relations more reasonably and better meet people's needs of production and life, which is decided by the character of customary law.

Keywords

References

  1. Stephan Feuchtwang & Wang Mingming. (2001). Grassroots charisma: four local leaders in China, Routledge: Lodnon and New York.
  2. 曹义荪,高其才. (2010). 当代中国物权习惯法--广西金秀六巷瑶族"打茅标" 考察报告. 政法论坛. Vol.1
  3. 常丽霞.(2013). 藏族牧区生态习惯法文化的传承与变迁研究--以拉卜楞地区为中心.兰州大学博士学位论文.(学位论文)
  4. 陈寒非. (2015). 巫蛊,信仰与秩序的形成--以湘西乡"中蛊"现象为中心 的考察.广西民族研究. Vol.3.
  5. 戴双喜,巴音诺尔. (2010). 论牧区以"羊"为"等价物"的交易习惯--兼论民 事习惯与交易习惯之结构层次关系. 法学杂志. Vol.11.
  6. 高其才,罗昶. (2012). 尊重与吸纳:民族自治地方立法中的固有习惯法--以《大瑶山团结公约》订立为考察对象. 清华法学. Vol.2.
  7. 高其才. (2007). 现代化进程中的瑶族"做社"活动--以广西金秀郎庞为例.民 族研究. Vol.2.
  8. 高其才. (2008). 瑶族习惯法.清华大学出版社. 北京.
  9. 高其才. (2008). 中国习惯法论(修订版).中国法制出版社. 北京.
  10. 高其才主编. (2012). 当代中国的社会规范和社会秩序--身边的法.法律出版社. 北京.
  11. 高其才主编. (2011). 当代中国民事习惯法.法律出版社. 北京.
  12. 龚艳,尚海涛. (2012). 论习惯法的历史变迁机制--基于山东省H村的调研.甘肃 政法学院学报. Vol.6.
  13. 郭剑平. (2012). 侗款的变迁及其与侗族地区纠纷解决机制研究.现代法学. Vol.5.
  14. 哈贝马斯. (1999). 公共领域的结构转型.曹卫东等译.学林出版社.南京.
  15. 韩立收. (2012). "查禁"与"除禁":黎族"禁"习惯法研究.上海大学出版社. 上海.
  16. 胡恒. (2015). 皇权不下县?--清代县辖政区与基层社会治理.北京师范大学出版社. 北京.
  17. 黄宗智. (1999). 中国的"公共领域"与"市民社会"?--国家与社会间的第三领域.程农译,邓正来校//邓正来, J.C.亚历山大编. (1999). 国家与市民社会:一种社会理论的研究路径.中央编译出版社. 北京.
  18. J.C.亚历山大编. (1999). 国家与市民社会:一种社会理论的研究路径.中央编译出版社. 北京.
  19. 克利福德, 格尔茨. (1999). 文化的解释.韩莉译.译林出版社. 南京.
  20. 克利福德, 吉尔兹. (1998). 地方性知识:事实与法律的比较透视.邓正来译//梁治平主编.(1998).法律的文化解释(增订本).三联书店. 北京.
  21. 李瑶. (1995). 巫蛊方术之祸.广西民族出版社.南宁.
  22. 梁治平. (1996). 清代习惯法:社会与国家.中国政法大学出版社. 北京.
  23. 刘新星. (2009). 从农村规范秩序的变迁看农村法制建设.中国人民大学学报. Vol.4.
  24. 牛铭实编著. (2005). 中国历代乡规民约.中国社会出版社. 北京.
  25. 裴宜理. (2014). 安源:发掘中国革命之传统.阎小骏译.香港大学出版社.香港.
  26. 石伶亚. (2009). 少数民族习惯法的功能释放与历史变迁考察--以湘西土家族,苗族自治州为例.贵州民族研究. Vol.2.
  27. 苏力. (2015). 法治及其本土资源(第三版).北京大学出版社. 北京.
  28. 特木尔宝力道. (2002).论蒙古族习惯法的几个问题.内蒙古大学学报(人文社会科学版). Vol.1.
  29. 文永辉. (2006).水族习惯法及其变迁--以贵州省三都水族自治县塘党寨为例. 民族研究. Vol.4.
  30. 肖瑛. (2014).从"国家与社会"到"制度与生活":中国社会变迁研究的视角转换. 中国社会科学. Vol.9.
  31. 谢晖. (2017). 我国习惯法研究的现状及方法自觉--序李可《习惯法:理论与方法论》. http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_65f82df70102xgzt.html.
  32. 徐晓光. (2010). "罚3个120"的适用地域及适应性变化--作为对黔东南苗族地区"罚3个100"的补充调查.甘肃政法学院学报, vol.01.
  33. 徐晓光. (2005) 从苗"罚3个100"等看习惯法在村寨社会的功能.山东大学学. Vol.03.
  34. 许章润. (2011). "习惯法"的当下中国意义//高其才主编. (2011). 当代中国民事习惯法.法律出版社. 北京.
  35. 严文强. (2008). 凉山彝族习惯法的历史流变--以案例分析为中心的研究.西南政法大学博士学位论文.
  36. 阎云翔. (2000). 礼物的流动--一个中国村庄中的互惠规则与社会网络.李春放, 刘瑜译. 上海人民出版社.上海.
  37. 杨开道. (1930). 农村领袖.世界书局. 上海.
  38. 叶英萍. (2011). 黎族习惯法研究:从自治秩序到统一法律秩序的变迁.中国政法大学博士学位论文.