DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Aesthetic Symbolism in Lewis Mumford's Architectural Criticism

루이스 멈퍼드의 건축비평에서 미적 상징의 문제

  • Received : 2015.10.16
  • Accepted : 2017.02.03
  • Published : 2017.02.28

Abstract

One of the essential characteristics of Lewis Mumford's architectural criticism is the coherent emphasis on symbolism. Such emphasis stems from his understanding of city and humanity in the context of civilization: first, that the architecture symbolizes institutions of urban civilization; second, that the technical aspect of human nature should be balanced with its artistic aspects. Mumford believed that each architectural type requires an appropriate symbolic expression corresponding to its purpose and that a new symbolic expression, in a new cultural context, should replace the conventional expression. He took symbolism for an intuitional expression, and read multi-layered meanings of architecture: 'practical function' by way of rational reason and 'symbolic function' by way of intuition. He pursued a balance between practicality and beauty to rectify the situation of modern civilization, in which symbolism, the expression of its intuitional aspect, is in crisis. Ultimately, for Mumford, the essential task of architectural critic is of the interpretation of symbolism, aiming at the correspondence and communication between the architect(artist)'s intuition and critic(interpreter)'s via the media of symbol. The critic can play some privileged role of interpreting even symbols unintended by the architect. The ideal architectural critic, after all, would be the one who is able to understand the city, technology and human beings in the perspective of civilization and to interpret the architect's artistic expression in its highest form through intuition. Mumford established himself as such a critic and evaluated the status of aesthetic accomplishment of his contemporary architecture and technological civilization, giving emphasis on the artistic practice in architecture as a solution.

Keywords

References

  1. 김상환, 니체, 프로이트, 맑스 이후: 현대 프랑스철학의 쟁점, 창비, 서울, 2002
  2. 김종달.한동희.나중규, 죽음에 이르는 도시: 루이스 멈포드의 제도론과 기술, 한국지역개발학회지, 27권, 4호, 2015.11., 1-14쪽
  3. 박홍규, 메트로폴리탄 게릴라: 박홍규의 루이스 멈퍼드 읽기, 텍스트, 서울, 2010
  4. 박현숙, 장자의 기술관: 루이스 멈포드의 기술철학 관점에서, 동양예술, 32권, 2016.8., 136-160쪽
  5. 신지영, 도시 문화에 대한 위상학적 이해 -멈포드, 슈뢰드 등의 사회이론과 들뢰즈의 철학적 토대, 도시인문학연구, 3권, 2호, 2011, 175-202쪽
  6. William T. Cotton, The Eutopitect: Lewis Mumford as a Reluctant Utopian, Utopian Studies, Vol.8, No.1, 1997, pp.1-18
  7. Benedetto Croce, 크로체의 미학: 표현학과 일반 언어학으로서의 미학(원제: Estetica come scienza dell'espressionee linguistica generale), 이해완 역, 예전사, 서울, 1994
  8. David R. Weimer, Lewis Mumford and the Design of Criticism, Arts & Architecture, Sep. 1962
  9. Martin Filler, Lewis Mumford: the Making of an Architecture Critic, Architectural Record, v.170, no.5, Apr. 1982, pp.116-123
  10. David R. Hill, Lewis Mumford's Ideas on the City, Journal of the American Planning Association, Vol.51, No.4, Autumn 1985, pp.407-421 https://doi.org/10.1080/01944368508976830
  11. Lewis Mumford, Architecture as a Home for Man: Essays for Architectural Record, ed. Jeanne M. Davern, Architectural Record Books, New York, 1975
  12. Lewis Mumford, Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture & Civilization, Norton, NewYork, 1924
  13. Lewis Mumford, The Culture of Cities, 1938
  14. Lewis Mumford, 유토피아 이야기(원제: The Story of Utopias), 박홍규 역, 텍스트, 서울, 2010
  15. Lewis Mumford, 예술과 기술(원제: Art and Technics), 박홍규 역, 텍스트, 서울, 2011
  16. Lewis Mumford, 인간의 전환(원제: Transformations of Man), 박홍규 역, 텍스트, 서울, 2011
  17. Lewis Mumford, 기술과 문명(원제: Technics and Civilization), 문종만 역, 책세상, 서울, 2013
  18. Lewis Mumford, 루이스 멈퍼드 건축비평선: 뉴요커 스카이라인 칼럼 1947-1956(원제: From the Ground Up: Observations on Contemporary Architecture, Housing, Highway Building, and Civic Design), 서정일 역, 한길사, 서울, 2014
  19. Lewis Mumford, Roots of Contemporary American Architecture: a Series of ThirtySeven Essays Dating from the MidNineteenth Century to the Present, Reinhold, New York, 1952
  20. Shari Sabeti, 'Plain Living' and 'High Thinking': Lewis Mumford's NewYork Sky Lines, The Cambridge Quarterly, Vol.29, No.2, 2000, pp.175-180 https://doi.org/10.1093/camqtly/29.2.175
  21. Kenneth R. Stunkel, Understanding Lewis Mumford: a Guide for the Perplexed, Edwin Mellen Press, Lewiston, New York, 2004
  22. Robert Wojtowicz, Lewis Mumford and American Modernism: Eutopian Theories for Architecture and Urban Planning, Cambridge University Press, New York, 1996
  23. Robert Wojtowicz, Sidewalk Critic: Lewis Mumford's Writings on NewYork, Princeton Architectural Press, New York, 1998