Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회지)

The Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analysis of Satisfaction on Alley Garden's Components through Urban Regeneration - Focused on Bisan 2·3-dong in Daegu Metropolitan City -

도시재생사업에 따른 골목정원 구성요소의 만족도 분석 - 대구광역시 비산 2·3동을 대상으로 -

  • Jang, Cheol-Kyu (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, Graduate School of Kyungpook National University) ;
  • Hwang, Myeong-Lan (Dept. of Environmental Landscape Architecture, Graduate School of Agriculture and Bio-Convergence, Kyungpook National University) ;
  • Shin, Jae-Yun (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, Graduate School of Kyungpook National University) ;
  • Jung, Sung-Gwan (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, Kyungpook National University)
  • 장철규 (경북대학교 대학원 조경학과) ;
  • 황명란 (경북대학교 농업생명융합대학원 환경조경학전공) ;
  • 신재윤 (경북대학교 대학원 조경학과) ;
  • 정성관 (경북대학교 조경학과)
  • Received : 2017.08.28
  • Accepted : 2017.12.18
  • Published : 2017.12.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study analyzed the opinions of residents for desirable urban regeneration and suggested an improvement plan for alley environments. This study conducted a questionnaire survey of the residents living in Alley Garden of Bisan 2,3-dong, Daegu Metropolitan City. In the analysis of the importance and satisfaction of Alley Garden components, items related to a safe, cleanly environment such as 'Lighting facility installation', 'Sewage and waste disposal' and 'CCTV installation' had a high level of importance. It was also found that items improved by the Residential Environment Improvement Project and Alley Garden such as 'Lighting facility installation', 'Quantity of herbaceous flowers' and 'Kinds of herbaceous flowers' had a high level of satisfaction. The IPA results showed that items such as 'Empty house maintenance', 'Rest facilities such as benches and pergolas', 'Space for resident interaction' and 'Public parking lot' had a high level of importance, but had a low level of satisfaction, which suggests that they should be improved by priority. As a result of factor analysis, Alley Garden components were classified into four factors: 'Safety and cleanliness', 'Greenness', 'Exchange and convenience facility' and 'Aesthetics renewal'. Based on this classification, a regression analysis was conducted regarding the effects of the four factors on overall satisfaction. Results showed that all four factors had a significant influence on the overall satisfaction and that 'Aesthetics renewal' and 'Safety and cleanliness', respectively showing levels of significance at 0.274 and 0.235, were highly influential to overall satisfaction. Therefore, it was concluded that spaces for resident interaction and rest facilities should be preferentially installed to improve the environment of alleys. For the improvement of the overall satisfaction of alley environments, it was also concluded that residents should be encouraged to engage in activities such as sculpture installation and mural drawing, along with the introduction of safety bells and crime prevention environment design and the implementation of alley beautification projects.

본 연구는 바람직한 도시재생 방안으로서 지역 주민의 의견을 수렴 분석하고, 골목환경의 개선방안을 제시하고자 대구광역시 비산 2 3동 골목정원 조성지역의 주민을 대상으로 설문조사를 실시하였다. 연구결과를 살펴보면, 골목정원 구성요소의 중요도 및 만족도 분석에서는 '조명시설 설치', '하수 및 쓰레기 처리', 'CCTV 설치' 등 안전하고 청결한 환경과 관련된 항목들이 높은 중요도 값을 가지며, '조명시설 설치', '초화류의 양', '초화류의 종류' 등 주거환경 개선사업의 시행과 골목정원 조성으로 개선된 항목들의 만족도가 높은 것으로 분석되었다. IPA 분석결과, '빈집 정비', '벤치, 파고라 등 휴게시설', '주민교류 공간', '공용주차장' 등의 항목들이 중요도는 높지만 만족도가 낮아 중점개선이 필요한 항목으로 나타났다. 다음으로 요인분석을 통해서 골목정원 구성요소들이 '안전 및 청결성', '녹음성', '미관정비', '교류 및 편의시설' 등 4개 요인으로 유형화되었다. 이를 토대로 4개 요인이 전체 만족도에 미치는 영향을 회귀분석한 결과, 4개의 요인 모두 전체 만족도에 유의미한 영향력을 가지며, '미관정비'와 '안전 및 청결성'이 각각 0.274, 0.235로 영향력이 큰 것으로 나타났다. 따라서 골목환경 개선을 위해서는 주민교류 공간 및 휴게시설 설치가 우선적으로 필요할 것으로 판단된다. 또한, 골목환경의 전체 만족도를 높이기 위해 조형물 설치, 벽화 그리기 등과 같은 활동에 주민 참여를 유도하고, 안전벨, 범죄예방, 환경설계 등의 도입과 골목미화 활동이 필요할 것으로 사료된다.

Keywords

References

  1. Ahn, J. S.(2014) Regeneration of Urban Village through Using Shared Space: Focusing on Sansae-Village, Eunpyeong-gu, Seoul. MS Dissertation, Seoul National University, Korea.
  2. Cho, J. K., C. T. Hyun, Y. S. Yoon, R. Z. Jin and Y. W. Cha(2012) Risk factor classification and weight estimation for urban regeneration project. Korea Journal of Construction Engineering and Management 13(4): 89-99. https://doi.org/10.6106/KJCEM.2012.13.4.089
  3. Choi, G. C.(2008) An Study on the Effects of Pattern Language in a Revitalization of the Old Downtown Area. MS Dissertation, Hanyang University, Korea.
  4. Daegu Metropolitan City(2016) 2025 Urban Renewal Report.
  5. Daegu Metropolitan City(2017) Daegu Statistical Annual Report in 2016.
  6. Gwak. Y. G.(2017) A Study on the Analysis of Importance on Residential Garden Components. MS Dissertation, Hanyang University, Korea.
  7. Ha, C. H., H. J. Kwak and H. S. Kim(2013) A study on utilization and making vegetable garden of vacant land and deserted house in deteriorated low-rise residential area for neighborhood regeneration: Focused on no-song low-rise residence district in Jeonju. Journal of The Urban Design Institute of Korea 14(6): 81-93.
  8. Ha, Y. S.(2016) An analytical study on the relationship between urban regeneration evaluation and civic consciousness: With a focus on mediation effect of maul satisfaction. Journal of Public Society 6(4): 121-155. https://doi.org/10.21286/jps.2016.11.6.4.121
  9. Hammitt, W. E., M. D. Bixer and P. Francis(1996) Going beyond Important performance analysis to analyze the observance- influence of park impact. Journal of Park and Recreation Administration 14(1): 45-62.
  10. Han, R. Y.(2011) A Study on the Evaluation of Pedestrian Environment in the Seoul Green Parking Project. MS Dissertation, The University of Seoul, Korea.
  11. Heo, S. Y and T. H. Moon(2011) Spatial analysis of the difference between real crime and fear of crime. Journal of the Korean Association of Geographic Information Studies 14(4): 194-207. https://doi.org/10.11108/kagis.2011.14.4.194
  12. Jang, C. K., N. Ning, S. G. Lee and S. G. Jung(2016) A study on the improvement of Sincheon waterfront using the ISA. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 44(1): 1-15. https://doi.org/10.9715/KILA.2016.44.1.001
  13. Jang, K. S.(2016) A study on promotion of urban regeneration program: Focusing on the experiences in the operation of Jeonju testbed project. Public Land Law Review 76: 25-44.
  14. Jang. W. J. and S. B. Moon(2010) A study on possibility of social enterprise as a main participant in urban renaissance: Based on the analysis of the importance of business links. Journal of the Korean Cadastre Information Association 12(2): 45-69.
  15. Jeon, H. M.(2000) A Study on the Evaluation of Housing Environment Improvement Project: Focus on the Physical Improvement Effect and Residents' Satisfaction. MS Dissertation, Chonnam National University, Korea.
  16. Jeon. J. H.(2006) To Build with Garden: Based on Garden Concept of Luis Barragn. MS Dissertation, Kyonggi University. Korea.
  17. Jeon, W. S., N. D. Kim and H. Y. Hwang(2008) Project themes and promotions of community building with resident participation. Journal of The Urban Design Institute of Korea 9(4): 131-148.
  18. Jeong, D. H., K. Han, J. H. Lee and H. D. Jang(2012) Study on renewal direction of deteriorated hillside neighborhoods: Focused on the pre-redevelopment zone in Seoul metropolitan region. Journal of Urban Policies 3(1): 45-63.
  19. Jeong, J. H., T. O. Yoon, S. A. Sung and H. Y. Hwang(2015) Analysis on the effect of urban-regeneration market revitalization programs: Focused on Joong-ang dong, Cheongju. The Geographical Journal of Korea 49(1): 15-25.
  20. Jin, H. S.(2012) The meaning of maeul mandeulgie and urban regeneration in the view of pu.lic. Review of Architecture and Building Science 56(6): 66-70.
  21. Jung. S.(2003) Ally Design as Community Space. MS Dissertation, Konkuk University. Korea.
  22. Jung, S. G., K. J. Moon and K. J. Yoo(2015) A survey study on resident participation in the development of urban regeneration project: Concentrated on the Sanbok-doro renaissance urban regeneration area in Busan. Journal of The Regional Association of Architectural Institute of Korea 17(5): 31-39.
  23. Kim, A. L., J. H. Koo and J. L. Lee(2013) Environment improving projects : Focused on the project of Yonnam-dong. Journal of the Korean Housing Association 24(6): 103-110. https://doi.org/10.6107/JKHA.2013.24.6.103
  24. Kim, D. C. and W. Y. Choi(2013) Study on selection attributes of fishing experience villages for the revitalization of eco experience tourism. Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 41(6): 29-42. https://doi.org/10.9715/KILA.2013.41.6.029
  25. Kim, D. H.(2015a) Analysis of Residents' Satisfaction in the Urban Regeneration Using Village Art Project: Focused on Gamcheon Cultural Village, Hwasun Sung-an Village and Sinse-dong Mural Village. MS Dissertation, Younsei University. Korea.
  26. Kim, G. H.(2015b) The Effect of Local Participation Regeneration Project on The Elderly's Project and Residential Satisfaction: A Case of the Jang-Su Maeul, Seongbuk-Gu, Seoul. MS Dissertation, Hanyang University. Korea.
  27. Kim, H. C.(2003) The cognition of the decline in urban center and the approach of urban regeneration: The case of Daejeon metropolis. Journal of the Korean Urban Management Association 16(2): 79-99.
  28. Kim, H. C.(2013) Critical review on the conceptual scope and policy institution process in the Korean context of urban regeneration. Journal of the Korean Urban Management Association 26(3): 1-13.
  29. Kim, H. J.(2011) The regeneration policy in connection with historic and cultural assets in local small city. Journal of the Korean Regional Development Association 23(4): 123-148.
  30. Kim, I. J.(2008) A Study on the Decline of Cheonan City Center due to New Urban Development Projects. MS Dissertation, The University of Seoul. Korea.
  31. Kim, K. S.(2014) The effect of urban regeneration on the village satisfaction and community spirit of the citizens of Seoul. Journal of Public Society 4(1): 66-92.
  32. Kim, K. Y.(2016a)An Analytical Study on the Urban Regeneration in Changwon and Proposals to Improve the Projects. Ph.D Dissertation. Gyeongsang National University, Korea.
  33. Kim, M. J. and J. S. Jeong(2011) A study on the planning consideration for the realization of sustainable housing: In the aspect the residents' opinions at the pilot project 'Livable City Making' in Busan. Journal of the Korean Housing Association 22(4): 103-112. https://doi.org/10.6107/JKHA.2011.22.4.103
  34. Kim, M. K.(2016b) A Study on Residential Satisfaction and Settlement of Touristified Residence after Village Regeneration: Focused on Ehwa Village, MS Dissertation, Hanyang University. Korea.
  35. Kong, K. Y.(2006) Evaluation of leisure activity using the IPA method. Korean Journal of Tourism Research 20(3): 285-303.
  36. Korea Planning Association(2008) Urban Development, Seoul: Bosunggak.
  37. Kwon, D. H.(2003) A Study on the Revitalization of Center City in Local Cities: Case Study on Jeon-ju City. MS Dissertation, Chonbuk National University. Korea.
  38. Lee, B. D. and J. S. Shim(2012) A study on regeneration of derelict urban areas throughout resident's participation: Focusing on the comparison of case studies from Japan, England and the US. Journal of the Korean Cadastre Information Association 14(2): 183-206.
  39. Lee, B. D. and J. U. Dong(2005) A study on the improvement projects of resident environment in the poor residence for low income families in inner city. Journal of Korea Community Development Society 30(2): 91-103.
  40. Lee. B. O.(2012) Representation of Placeness for Documentation. MS Dissertation, Kyungpook National University. Korea.
  41. Lee, H, R.(2005) A Study on the Importance and Performance of Banquet Service in Hotels. MS Dissertation, Daegu University. Korea.
  42. Lee, J. D.(2015) A Study on the Development of Assessment Index for Urban Regeneration Project and Governance Relations: Focused on Changwon and Jeonju Test-bed. Ph.D Dissertation. Gyeongsang National University. Korea.
  43. Lee, J. H. and J. H. Song(2009) A study on the method of urban catalyst for urban regeneration: Focused on urban catalytic projects in Milwaukee, United States. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea Planning & Design 25(1): 233-244.
  44. Lee, S. M., W. S. Kim and J. A. Kim(2015) Statistical Analysis for Social Sciences Using SPSS, Paju: Hanulbooks.
  45. Lee, W. K., S. H. Jung and N. S. Ji(2013) Characteristics and activity types of neighborhood-making communities: Focusing on the cases of Incheon neighborhood-making networks. The Geographical Journal of Korea 47(4): 427-442.
  46. Lim, B. H., K. H. Lee and N. S. Ji(2015) A comparative study on the residential environment satisfaction and the influential factors on the residential improvement project district and the housing redevelopment project district in Daejeon metropolitan area. Journal of the Korean Urban Management Association 28(1): 31-51.
  47. Martila. J. A. and J. C. James(1977) Importance-performance analysis. Journal of Marketing 41(1): 77-79. https://doi.org/10.2307/1250495
  48. Min. H. S.(2011) Maintenance of the unique characteristics of alleys in the downtown of Seoul: Focused on the inner block area of Jongno-3ga. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea Planning & Design 27(2): 145-156.
  49. Oh. K. S. and J. H. Song(2013) Physical environmental elements in alleys causing fear of crime for women: Focused on the redevelopment district. Journal of Community Safety and Security by Environmental Design 4(3): 31-57.
  50. Park, C. B. and D. S. Oh(2004) A study on the policies and institutions for downtown regeneration of foreign country. Journal of Korea Planning Association 39(5): 25-38.
  51. Park, K. O., J. M. An, Y. B. Lee and A. Y. Cha(2016) Sustainable regeneration ways of the deteriorated downtown residential area: Focused on 'Mural Village', Suamgol in Cheongju. Journal of Human Ecology 20(2): 91-101.
  52. Park, S. H., H. S. Chun and S. J. Jeon(2009) Participatory governance analysis in community planning: An institutional approach. Journal of Korea Planning Association 44(3): 207-220.
  53. Rho, H. J.(2001) Surveying and Statistical Analysis by SPSS, Seoul: Hyungseul Publishing Co.
  54. Roberts, P., H. Syker and R. Granger(2016) Urban Regeneration: A Handbook. London: SAGE Publications Ltd.
  55. Rou. Y. J. and D. G. Cho(2015) A study on comparing traditional garden and modern garden for developing garden culture of Korea. Journal of the Korea Institute of Spatial Design 10(5):113-124.
  56. Song, H. J.(2007a) The Study for Analyzing a Declining Reason and a Reviving Plan of Downtown. MS Dissertation, Dongshin University. Korea.
  57. Song, S. Y.(2007b) A Study on the Analysis of the Causes of Declining and the Plan for the Urban Regeneration of Non Growing Type Cities in Korea. Ph.D Dissertation. Kangwon National University. Korea.
  58. Won, J. H. and H. S. Kim(2012) Factors affecting the evaluation of the resident-participatory community design: Focused on the residents' perception about 'the pilot project of human town in Seoul'. Journal of the Urban Design Institute of Korea 13(6): 55-68.
  59. www.daegu.go.kr
  60. www.dgs.go.kr
  61. www.law.go.kr