DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Meta-regression Analysis of the Variables Associated with the Job Satisfaction of Kindergarten Teachers

유치원교사의 직무만족과 관련된 변인에 대한 메타회귀분석

  • 문동규 (삼육보건대학교 아동보육과)
  • Received : 2016.08.31
  • Accepted : 2016.12.08
  • Published : 2016.12.31

Abstract

This study seeks to verify the effect size of the variables relating to job satisfaction through a meta-analysis focusing on previous papers over the last 20 years that have examined the job satisfaction of kindergarten teachers and verified the trend by publication year through a meta-regression analysis. The study results are as follows. First, the results demonstrated that the total effect size of the variables relating to kindergarten teachers was large. Second, the organization's internal variable and organization's external variable groups, except for the individual characteristics variable group, showed a large effect size at similar levels. Third, the status of teachers in the individual characteristics variable group showed a meaningfully large effect size and the interpersonal relationship variable in organization's internal variable group showed a relatively larger effect size than the organizational climate variable did. Finally, the results of the verification of the trend by publication year showed that job satisfaction increased for all variables, except for the individual characteristics variable in more recent publications. This study highlights the imperative of making every effort to improve the organization's internal and external environment. In particular, measures to reduce job stress and work load are required. Furthermore, the atmosphere that is devoted to the teaching profession and teacher efficacy is important.

본 연구는 유치원교사의 직무만족과 관련하여 지난 20여년 간 국내에서 이루어진 석 박사 학위논문과 학술지 논문을 중심으로 직무만족 관련변인에 대한 효과크기를 메타분석을 통해 검증하였고, 출판연도에 따른 변화추이를 살피기 위해 메타회귀분석을 활용하였다. 메타분석과 메타회귀 분석 결과 다음의 결과를 얻을 수 있었다. 첫째, 유치원교사의 직무만족관련 변인들의 전체효과크기는 유의미한 큰효과크기를 보인 것으로 나타났다. 둘째, 유치원교사의 직무만족관련 변인군 간의 효과크기는 유의미한 효과를 보이지 않은 개인특성변인군을 제외한, 직무특성변인군, 조직내면적변인군, 조직외면적변인군 모두 비슷한 수준에서 유의미한 큰효과크기를 보인 것으로 나타났다. 셋째, 각 변인군 별 주목할 만한 결과는, 개인특성변인군에서 큰효과크기 가진 것으로 나타난 직위변인을 제외 한 근무경력, 연령, 교육 정도 등의 연인들이 유의미하지 않은 것으로 나타났으며, 조직내면적변인군에 있어 조직 내 대인관계요인이 조직 내 풍토요인보다 상대적으로 높은 효과크기를 보인 것으로 나타났다는 점이다. 마지막으로, 출판연도에 따른 효과크기 변화추이를 검정 결과, 개인특성변인군을 제외한 직무특성변인군, 조직내면적변인군, 조직외면적변인군은 최근 출판물에 가까울수록 직무만족도가 높아지는 것으로 나타났다. 본 연구 결과 주목할 만한 시사점은, 조직내외부적 환경 개선을 위한 노력이 가장 시급하다는 점이며, 특허 직무상 받게 되는 스트레스와 행정적 업무 부담 동을 줄이기 위한 방안 그리고 교사효능감과 교직에 대해 헌신할 수 있는 분위기 조성이 무엇보다 필요하다는 점이다.

Keywords

References

  1. Jorde-Bloom, P. Factor Influencing Overall Job Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment in Early Childhood Work environment. Journal of Research in Childhood Education, 3(2) : pp. 107-122, 1989. DOl: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/02568548809594933
  2. Hwang, Hea-Ik, Tak, Jeong Hwa, Hong, Sung-Hee, "Impact of Resilience, Teacher Efficacy, and Job Satisfaction on Happiness in Early Childhood Teachers", Research of Early Childhood Education, 48(3) : pp. 271-293, 2016.
  3. Kim, Hye-Jin, Son, You-Jin, Jun, Yun-Sook, "An Analysis on the Effect of Trust in Teachers and Director on Job Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment of Kindergarten teachers", Journal of Future Early Childhood Education, 23(1): pp. 201-217, 2016.
  4. Jang, Yeong-Suk, "The effects of Public and Private Kindergarten Teachers' empowerment and Job satisfaction on Their Commitment to Teaching", The Journal of Korea Open Association for Early Childhood Education, 15(4) : pp. 159-179, 2015.
  5. Choi, Jin-young, Kim, Yeong-hee . Kim, Dae-kwang, "Effects of Workplace Social Support on Turnover Intention of Childcare Center &Kindergarten Teachers : The Mediating of Emotional Burnout, and Job Satisfaction", Journal of Early Childhood Education & Educare Welfare, 19(4): pp. 573-593, 2015.
  6. Kim, Jeoung-Ran, "Job Satisfactions According to a Developmental Stage and Concerns Performance as a Elementary School-affiliated Kindergarten Teacher" Duksung Women's University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2000.
  7. Mun, Byung-Hwan, Cho, Eun-Jung, "A Study of the Relations among Early Childhood Teacher's Variables Empowerment and Job Satisfaction", Holistic Education, 19(2): pp. 21-39, 2015.
  8. Kim, Hyun-Sook, "The Relationship between Emotional Leadership of the Director of Public Kindergarten Perceived by the Kindergarten Teachers, the Development of their Professionalism, and their Job Satisfaction", Changwon National University Graduate School, Master's degree, 2015.
  9. Kwon, Sung-Min, "The Effect of Social Support of Kindergarten and Preschool Teachers on Job Stress, Job Satisfaction, Burnout and Turnover Intention", Open early childhood education research, 16(5): pp. 313-333, 2011.
  10. Cho, Chung-Dai, Kang, Kyung-Seok, "The Structural Relationship among Private Kindergarten Director's Emotional Leadership, Kindergarten Teacher's Emotional Intelligence, Teacher's Efficacy, and Job Satisfaction", Journal of Learner-Centered Curriculum and Instruction, 16(4): pp. 741-767, 2016.
  11. Seo, Eun-Hee, "The Relationship between Job Satisfaction, Organizational Commitment and Turnover Intention of Kindergarten Teachers", Catholic University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2000.
  12. Song, Mi-Jeoung, "Verification of the Relationship between Organizational Health and Psychological Empowerment that Affects Job Satisfaction of Kindergarten Teachers : Job Stress as a Mediating Effect", Journal of Early Childhood Education, 19(6): pp. 157-176, 2015.
  13. Lee, Gyeong-Su, "Job Stress and Job Satisfaction in Kindergarten Teachers", Kumoh National Institute of Technology University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2015.
  14. Kim, Sun Jae, "A Study on the Job Stress and Job Satisfaction of the Public Kindergarten Teacher's". Suwon University Graduate School of Industry and Business Administration, Master's degree, 2002.
  15. Cho, Yu Na $\cdot$ Choi, Yun Yi $\cdot$ Kang, Seong Hee, "A Study on the Mediating Effect of Kindergarten's Organization Culture in the Relationship between Kindergarten Teacher's Job Stress and Job Satisfaction", Journal of Future Early Childhood Education, 18(2): pp. 177-199, 2011.
  16. Yang, Se-Ja, "An Influence of Teachers'job Satisfaction by Changeable Leadership of a Kindergarten Principal", GangNam University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2008.
  17. Choi, Jeong-Seon, Kim, Hee-Soo, "Kindergarten Teacher Job Satisfaction: Self-consciousness and Job Stress as Predictors", The Journal of Korea Open Association for Early Childhood Education, 19(5): pp. 741-767, 2014.
  18. Kim, Ji-Young, "Relationships between Job Satisfaction and Participation in Decision-Making by Kindergarten Teachers", Pukyong National University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2010.
  19. Lee, Geum-Ran, "A Comparative Study on the Self-Efficiency and Job-Satisfaction of the Kindergarten Teachers between Korea and China", Changwon National University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2014.
  20. Lee, Joo-Ryung, "The Effect of Social Support and Teacher Efficacy on Job Satisfaction of Teachers in Private Kindergartens", Dong-A University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2015.
  21. Jo, Do-Hyon, "Analysis of Variables Related with Kindergarten Organization on the Job Satisfaction of Kindergarten Teachers", Won-kwang University Graduate School of Education, Doctoral's degree, 2014.
  22. Lee, Hyo-Im, "Relationships between Job Satisfaction and Participation in Decision-Making by Kindergarten Teachers", Chungnam National University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2008.
  23. Choi, Hee-ju, "The Effect of Kindergarten Teacher's Conflict Management Types and Work-related Stress on Job Satisfaction," Hanyang University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2011.
  24. Han, Kum-Ok, " A Study on the Kindergarten Teachers' Job Satisfaction and Stress in the Rural and Urban Area", Chonbuk National University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2003.
  25. Choi, Eun-Jin, "Research on Job Satisfaction and Self-efficacy of Kindergarten Nursery School Teacher", Daejeon University Graduate School of Management and Public Administration, Master's degree, 2008.
  26. Tak, Soo-Yeon, Yoo, Mi-Lim, "Perception of Teaching Profession and Factors Influencing Occupational Satisfaction among Preschool Teachers", Korean Journal of Child Education and Care, 10(4): pp. 147-166, 2010.
  27. Ryu, Da-Young, ".A Study on the Relations between Kindergarten Teachers' Turnover Reasons and their Work Enviromnent and Job Satisfaction", HanKuK University of Foreign Studies Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2011.
  28. Oh, Su-jin, "Effects of the Motivations of Choosing the Teaching Profession on Job Ability and Job Satisfaction in Public Kindergarten Teachers", Gyeongin National University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2011.
  29. Park, Hyun Jung, "Study on the Relationship between Teachers' Job Stress and Job Satisfaction in Public Kindergarten", Kyong-gi University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2000.
  30. Kim, Young-Su, "The Relationship between Kindergarten Teacher's Working Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment", Won-kwang University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 2012.
  31. Smith, F.J, "Trends in Job-related Attitude of Managerial and Professional Employees", Academy of Management Journal, 4(54) pp. 212-243, 1997.
  32. McCormick & Tiffin, "Industrial psychology. Englewood Cliffs", Nj: Prentice-Hall, pp. 298-299, 1974.
  33. Hung, H. W, "Kindergarten Teacher Job Satisfaction and The need for Continuing Education in Southern Taiwan". Unpublished doctorial dissertation, University of South Dakata, California, 2001.
  34. Holy & Miskel, "Educational Administration 2nd ed.," New York : Random House, 1982.
  35. Bently, R R, & Rempel, A. M., "Manual for the Purdue Teacher Opinionnaire(PTO)". West Lafayette, lN: PurdueResearch Foundation, 1970.
  36. Na, Jeong-Suk, "Studies on Job Satisfaction of Kindergarten Teachers in Korea", Chung-Ang University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 1982.
  37. Chung, Kum-Ja, Kim, Mi-Jeong, "The Influence of Kindergarten Teacher's Self-esteem on Job Satisfaction", Korean Journal of Special Education, 48(3): pp. 271-293, 2013.
  38. Suk, Eun-jo, Shin Seong-Cheol "A Study on Job Satisfaction, Jobstress and Intention to Leave the Job of a Kindergarten Teacher" Journal of Daegu Health University, 27: pp. 1-19, 2007.
  39. Kim, Jung-Hee, Moon. Hyuk-Jun "Variables Affecting Public and Private Kndergarten Teachers' Commitment to their Institutions" Journal of Child, 26(5): pp. 307-332, 2007.
  40. Shin, Hyun-Joo, "A Study on the Job Satisfaction of the Early-Childhood Education Teachers", Ewha Womans University Graduate School of Education, Master's degree, 1995.
  41. Cohen, J., "Statistical Power Analysis for The Behavioral Sciences(2nd ed.)". Hillsdale, NJ; Erlbaum, 1988.
  42. Duval, S. J. & Tweedie, R L., "Trim and Fill: A Simple Funnel-plot-based Method of Testing and Adjusting for Publication Bias in Meta-analysis", Biometrics, 56: pp. 455 -463, 2000. DOl: http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.0006-341X.2000.00455.x
  43. Orwin, R G., "A Fail-safe N for Effect Size in Meta-analysis", Journal of Educational Statistics, 8: pp. 157-159, 1983. DOl: http://dx.doi.org/10.3102/10769986008002157
  44. Byun, Mi-Hee, "A Meta-Analysis of Day Care Center Teacher's Job Satisfactions", The Korea Association of Child Care and Education, 36: pp. 95-117, 2016.
  45. Moon, Dong-Kyu, Kim, Yeong-Hee, Hur-Eun-Kyoung, "A Meta-Regression Analysis on Related Variables of The Child-care Teacher's Job Satisfaction", Early Childhood Education Research &Review), 16(1): pp. 213-234, 2012.
  46. Kim, Se-Gon, Woo, Kyung-Ae, "A Study on Determining Factors Causing Private Kindergarten Teachers to Transfer", Journal of Children's Education, 17(2): pp. 265-286, 2013.
  47. Park, Jong-Hyeon, Shin, Na-Ri, "Effects of Job Satisfaction and Ego-Resilience on Turnover Intention of Child Care Teachers", Research of Child Policy, 7(1): pp. 88-105, 2013.