DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Development of an Objective Softness Evaluation Method and Its Standardization for Hygiene Paper

위생용지 부드러움의 객관적 평가 방법 개발 및 표준화

  • Ko, Young Chan (SCAP-Tech Consulting) ;
  • Park, Jong-Moon (Departments of Forest Product & Engineering, College of Agriculture, Life & Environment Sciences, Chungbuk National University) ;
  • Moon, Byoung-Geun (Korea Conformity Laboratories)
  • Received : 2015.09.14
  • Accepted : 2015.10.16
  • Published : 2015.10.30

Abstract

Softness is considered one of the most important attributes of hygiene paper such as tissue and towel. Being subjective in nature, however, softness attribute has been generally believed to be impossible to evaluate using objective methods. Hallmark in his pioneering work proposed that tissue subjective softness should be mainly consisted of the bulk softness component and surface softness component. The bulk softness component can be determined by tensile stiffness; the surface softness component by surface tester. The surface friction turns out far more important than the surface roughness in determining the surface softness component. It cannot be too much emphasized that both results of the tensile stiffness and the surface friction should depend on measuring conditions such as an instrument used, sample sizes (e.g., basis weight, length, and width) and operating conditions of the instrument (e.g., gauge length, cross-head speed, size of stylus, and its scanning speed). This indicates that a direct comparison of the test results would be impossible or misleading unless they have been tested under the identical conditions. This may explain why the standard objective test method for tissue softness has not been available at present.

Keywords

References

  1. Ramasubramanian, M. V., Physical and mechanical properties of towel and tissue, In Handbook of Physical Testing of Paper, Mark, R.E. (ed.), Marcel Dekker, Inc., pp. 661-698 (2002).
  2. Hallmark, H., Evaluation of tissue paper softness, Tappi Journal 66(2):97-99 (1983).
  3. Ampulski, R. S., Sawdai, A. H., Spendel, W., and Weinstein, B., Methods for the measurement of the mechanical properties of tissue paper, 1991 International Paper Physics Conference Proceedings, TAPPI Press, Atlanta. p. 18 (1991).
  4. Spendel, W. U., Soft tissue paper containing non-cationic surfactant. U.S. Patent 4,959,125, Procter & Gamble Company, September 25 (1990).
  5. Kim, J.-J., Softness Properties of Fabric-like Tissue, Ph.D. Thesis, North Carolina State University (1992).
  6. Dwiggins, J. H., Harper, F. D., Schilz, G. A., Schuh, B. J., Heath, M. S., and Oriaran, T. P., Soft bulky multi-ply product and method of making the same, U.S. Patent 6,365,000, Fort James Corporation, April 2 (2002).
  7. Dwiggins, J. H., Harper, F. D., Schilz, G. A., Schuh, B. J., Heath, M. S., and Oriaran, T. P., Soft bulky multi-ply product and method of making the same, U.S. Patent 6,558,511, Fort James Corporation, May 6 (2003).
  8. Kawabata, S., The Standardization and Analysis of Hand Evaluation, 2nd ed., The Textile Machinery Society of Japan, p. 97 (1980).
  9. Kawabata, S. and Niwa, M., Fabric performance in clothing and clothing manufacture, Journal of the Textile Institute 80(1):19-50 (1989). https://doi.org/10.1080/00405008908659184
  10. Yokura, H., Kohno, S., and Iwasaki, M., Objective hand measurement of toilet paper, 31st Textile Tech. Symposium, The Textile Machinery Society of Japan, Osaka, pp. 185-190 (2002).
  11. Harper, F. D., Oriaran, T. P., and Litvay, J. D., Soft bulky single-ply absorbent paper having a serpentine configuration, U.S. Patent 6,372,087, Fort James Corporation, April 16 (2002).
  12. Beuther, P. D., Molded wet-pressed tissue, US 8,257,551, Kimberly Clark Worldwide, Inc., September 4 (2012).

Cited by

  1. Principles of developing physical test methods for disposable consumer products vol.34, pp.1, 2015, https://doi.org/10.1515/npprj-2018-0029