Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회지)

The Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analyzing the Design Competition Entries for the Hoehyeon Section of Namsan from a Perspective of the Historic Urban Landscape

남산 회현자락 설계 공모 출품작에 대한 역사도시경관적 분석

  • Received : 2015.06.23
  • Accepted : 2015.07.14
  • Published : 2015.08.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study analyzed the characteristics of the entries at the design competition for the Hoehyeon section of Namsan from a perspective of the Historic Urban Landscape and made suggestions from them. Hoehyeon, located at the foot of Namsan, is the most changing site in the park and Seoul City Wall. Recent excavation of the old city walls of the Joseon Era has uncovered evidence of the Japanese occupation period, making it a site where park facilities in modern and contemporary history coexist. The frame analysis has been made by the concept of the Historic Urban Landscape, the methods of approach, specialists' discussion and the guidelines of the competition. The entries were analyzed by classification of the understanding of the spatiality and cultural diversity, the recognition of the periodic layers of time, and the design implementation, the preservation, the park plan, and the future management plan. From a perspective of an Historic Urban Landscape, this study has found that each entry placed priority on the objects for preservation and suggested creative involvement and comprehensive designs for the preservation and the park plan through the understanding of the spatiality and cultural diversity and the reflection of the periodic layers of time in the designs. This study provided two implications. Firstly, there was a possibility for new recognition and the methods of approach for preservation and development. Secondly, the basic plan for the Historic Landscape should be established through research and mapping for the preservation and management of objects in Seoul having valuable historic variability. Further study for resident participation and the process by network from public to private should be taken. This study looks forward to the consideration of the direction for the design plans of places with historic and cultural value.

본 연구는 남산 회현 자락 설계 공모에서 수상한 작품을 역사도시경관 관점으로 분석하여, 각 설계안의 역사도시경관 접근 특성을 분석하고, 한계와 시사점을 도출했다. 회현 자락은 남산에서 한양도성과 공원의 변화가 가장 많은 장소로서 최근 발굴을 통해 조선시대의 성곽 유구와 일제 강점기의 흔적이 확인된 바 있으며, 근 현대의 공원 시설이 공존하는 대상지다. 역사도시경관 개념과 접근 방법, 전문가 논의, 현상 공모 지침서를 토대로 분석의 틀을 도출하여, 분석 항목으로 장소성과 문화다양성의 이해, 시간적 층위의 인식과 설계 구현, 보존과 공원 이용 방법, 향후 관리 방안으로 구분하여 출품작을 분석했다. 연구 결과, 역사도시경관 관점에서 볼 때 각 출품작은 장소성과 문화 다양성을 이해하고, 시간적 층위를 독창적인 방식으로 설계에 반영하고 있다는 점을 확인했다. 보존 대상에 대한 우선 순위를 선정하여 창의적인 개입 방법을 제시하고 있으나, 보존과 이용이라는 상반된 개념을 통합하는 면에서는 보다 실효성 있는 대안이 요구된다. 연구의 시사점으로 보존과 개발에 대한 새로운 인식과 접근 방식에 대한 가능성을 확인했으며, 역사적 층위가 중첩된 서울의 가치 있는 대상지의 보존과 관리를 위해서는 조사와 맵핑을 통한 역사경관 기본 계획이 수립될 필요가 있다. 본 연구에서 제외된 지역 주민 참여, 민관 네트워크에 의한 프로세스에 대해서는 향후 연구가 확대되어야 한다. 본 연구가 앞으로 역사문화적 가치가 큰 대상지의 설계에 방향을 제고해 줄 것을 기대한다.

Keywords

References

  1. Adam, R.(2010) Lessons from history in the conservation of historic urban landscapes, managing historic cities. World Heritage Papers 27: 81-88.
  2. Bandarin, F.(2013) The historic center and the next city: Envisioning urban heritage evolution message. 16th US/ICOMOS International Symposium.
  3. Bandarin, F. and R. Oers(2014) The Historic Urban Landscape: Managing Heritage in Urban Century. Chichester: Willy Blackwell.
  4. Benqin, T.(2013) Preservation, utilization and exhibition-Based on Nanjing City wall. Historic city and city wall. Seoul City Wall Studies 1: 134-157.
  5. Bourdaret, E.(2009) En Coree. Paju: Gulhangari.
  6. Chae, H.(2012) Proposals for Urban Conservation Based on Historic Urban Landscape Concepts -A Case Study of Seo-chon in Seoul. Master's Thesis. Seoul National University. Seoul, Korea.
  7. Chae, H.(2015) Exploring historic urban landscape as a new approach to heritage conservation. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea 31(2): 253-260. https://doi.org/10.5659/JAIK_PD.2015.31.2.253
  8. Choi, H.(2014) Excavation of research results and significance in Hoehyeon section of Namsan. 5th Seoul City Wall Academic Conference. pp.79-100.
  9. Colletta, T.(2013) Italian fortified cities in the world heritage list: Verona, Ferrara, Sabbioneta. Historic city and city wall. Seoul City Wall Studies 1: 90-133.
  10. Council of Europe(1995) Committee of Ministers. On the intergrated conservation of cultural landscape areas as part of landscape policies.
  11. Gabrielli, B.(2010) Urban planning challenged by historic urban landscape, managing historic cities. World Heritage Papers 27: 19-26.
  12. Getty Conservation Institute(2009) Historic Urban Environment Conservation Challenges and Priorities for Action.
  13. ICOMOS(1994) The Nara Document on Authenticity.
  14. ICOMOS(1996) The Declaration of San Antonio.
  15. Jokilehto, J.(2002) A History of Architectural Conservation. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.
  16. Jokilehto, J.(2010) Reflection on historic urban landscapes as a tool for conservation, managing historic cities. World Heritage Papers 27: 53-64.
  17. Kim, D.(2010) Pleasure of Wandering the City Wall. Paju: Hyohung.
  18. Kim, W.(2014) A case study of heritage conservation and maintenance. The Heritage Value of Seoul City Wall in Namsan Hoehyeon Region. 5th Seoul City Wall Academic Conference. pp.101-128.
  19. Korean National Commission for UNESCO(2012) A study for Associated Value of Tangible and Intangible Cultural Heritage on the World Heritage Convention.
  20. Lee, S.(2010) A Study on Spatial Characteristics and Change of Namsanpark. Master's Thesis. Hanyang University. Seoul, Korea.
  21. Liu, T.(2014) Conservation, Exhibition and Utilization of Xi'an City Wall and the Tang Hanguang Entrance Remains of Aska, Nara. Scientific Conservation and Creative intervention of City Walls. The 3rd International Symposium on Seoul City Wall. pp.109-146.
  22. Park, I.(2002) A Study of the History of Parks System Transformation of Seoul, Korea. Doctor's Thesis. Sangmyung University. Seoul, Korea.
  23. Rodwell, D.(2010) Historic urban landscapes: Concept and management, managing historic cities. World Heritage Papers 27, pp.99-105.
  24. Rossler, M.(2014) The UNESCO Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape. European Heritage Heads Forum.
  25. Shin, H.(2014) Conservation of Seoul City Wall in Namsan Hoehyeon Archaeological Sites. Scientific Conservation and Creative intervention of City Walls. 3rd International Symposiumon Seoul City Wall. pp.199-229.
  26. Seo, Y. and Y. Son(2013) The space use in the initial period of Namsan Park -Focus on the newspaper articles from 1883 to 1917- Journal of the Korea Institute of Traditional Landscape Architecture 31(1): 28-37.
  27. Seo, Y.(2015) Seoul Namsan as Historic Urban Landscape. Doctor's Thesis. Seoul National University. Seoul, Korea.
  28. Seoul Museum of History(2012) Seoul has the City Wall: A Special Exhibition. Exhibition Catalog.
  29. Seoul Metropolitan Government(2013a) The Guideline of Design Competition for Seoul City Wall Conservation and Development in Hoehyeon Section of Namsan.
  30. Seoul Metropolitan Government(2013b) The Submission Documents of Design Competition.
  31. Seoul Metropolitan Government(2014) The Consultation Meeting Record of Conservation and development in Hoehyeon Section of Namsan
  32. Song, I.(2013) A Value and Authenticity of Seoul CityWall. A Value and Authenticity of Seoul City Wall. 3rd Symposium on Seoul City Wall. pp.7-12.
  33. UNESCO(2003) World Heritage Cultural Landscapes 1992-2002, World Heritage Papers 6.
  34. UNESCO(2005) Vienna Memorandum on World Heritage and Contemporary Architecture-Managing the Historic Urban Landscape.
  35. UNESCO(2010) Managing Historic Cities. World Heritage Papers 27.
  36. UNESCO(2011) Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape.
  37. UNESCO(2013a) New Life for Historic Cities
  38. UNESCO(2013b) Report on International World Heritage Expert Meeting on the Mainstreaming of the Methodological Approach Related to the Recommendation on the Historic Urban Landscape in the Operational Guidelines.
  39. Veldpaus, L., A. P. Roders and B. J. F. Colenbrander(2013) Urban heritage: Putting the past into the future. The Historic Environment 4(1): 3-18. https://doi.org/10.1179/1756750513Z.00000000022
  40. Whitehand, J.(2010) Urban morphology and historic urban landscapes, managing historic cities. World Heritage Papers 27: 35-44.
  41. Gyeongseonggeolyumindanyeogso(1912) Gyeongseongbaldalsa(京城發達史).
  42. www.historicurbanlandscape.com