DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analysis of Consulting Reports on Defect Disputes in Apartment Building

  • Received : 2013.06.22
  • Accepted : 2013.08.20
  • Published : 2013.10.20

Abstract

The main processes involved in a defect dispute are consulting, reviewing, and finally judging as an arbiter. This process of defect consulting produces a defect consulting report, but business practices and standards of judgment will differ among consultants, and have many problems. This study reviews the structure of a defect consulting report and considers the structure's problem, which is that it is not standardized. To achieve this, data of sixteen defect consulting report were collected involving defect lawsuit cases before or after 2010. The structure and index of the defect consulting reports were then reviewed, and the results are as follows. As for a structure based on fourteen index, there are suitable that judge a outline, a cost estimate data and a consulting work item by a consulting standard. Furthermore, analysis by each common parts and private parts is considered as appropriate about consulting items and estimate by standard. However, consulting item in construction progress and responsibility period for security that related on a cause and a responsibility of defect need to complement. Meanwhile, the first thing of issues are connected a defect consulting is urgent a standardization for a defect type.

Keywords

References

  1. Pak JM, Kim OK, Kim JL. Revitalization of the Conciliation System for Defect Disputes Related to Apartment Buildings. Journal of the Korea Institute of Building Construction. 2011 Jun;11(3):208-20. https://doi.org/10.5345/JKIC.2011.06.3.208
  2. Choi JH, Park JM, Seo DS, Jo JH, Park KW, Kim OK. A study on legal issues about defect repair claim on apartment building. Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea (Structure & Construction). 2009 Oct;25(11):147-53.
  3. Seoul south district court. Case-No.2007 gahap10079. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul south district court; 2008.09.19. Korean.
  4. Yoo BH. A basic process of construction consulting and consulting case of ice thermal storage system. Korean Journal of Air-Conditioning and Refrigeration Engineering. 2007 Jul;36(11):15-22.
  5. Yoon JY. Improvement for optimizing and specializing on deciding of construction lawsuit. The Justice (Journal of Korean Legal Center). 2009 Dec;114:6-46.
  6. Kim BS, Park JM, Kim OK, Seo DS. Improvement Plan on Appraisal System of Defect Disputes about Cracks on Apartment Buildings. Proceedings of the Korea Institute of Building Construction; 2011 May 20; Busan, Korea. Busan (Korea): the Korea Institute of Building Construction; 2011. p. 185-6
  7. Lee SC. A Study on Solution for Improvement and Case Analysis of Inspective Business in Defects of Apartment Buildings [dissertation]. [Changwon (Korea)]: Kyungnam University; 2011. 170 p.
  8. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2012 gahap 5908. Korea, Suwon (Korea): Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2012.12. Korean.
  9. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2012 gahap 2503. Korea, Suwon (Korea): Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2012.11. Korean.
  10. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011 na 22407. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul high court; 2012.06. Korean.
  11. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011 gahap 135900. Korea, Seou (Korea)l:Seoul central district court; 2013.01. Korean.
  12. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011 gahap 38023. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul central district court; 2012.02. Korean.
  13. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011 gahap 18099. Korea, Suwon (Korea): Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2012.08. Korean.
  14. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2011 gahap14660. Korea, Suwon (Korea): Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2012.11. Korean.
  15. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010 gahap 94231. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul central district court; 2012.01. Korean.
  16. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010 gahap22936. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul central district court; 2012.02. Korean.
  17. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010 gahap 4672. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul central district court; 2010.12. Korean.
  18. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010 gahap 2065. Korea, Daegu (Korea): Daegu district court in Pohang part; 2012.05. Korean.
  19. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010 gahap 770. Korea, Suwon (Korea): Suwon district court in Sungnam part; 2012.06. Korean.
  20. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2010 gahap 1215. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul central district court; 2011.03. Korean.
  21. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2009 gahap 103191. Korea, Seoul (Korea): Seoul central district court; 2010.06. Korean.
  22. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2007 gahap 14076. Korea, Incheon (Korea): Incheon district court; 2010.11. Korean.
  23. Construction consulting report. Case-No.2007gahap 5406. Korea, Busan (Korea): Busan district court; 2008.03. Korean.

Cited by

  1. Improvement Plans on Defect Consulting Report in an Apartment Building through Analyzing on Formal Index and Quantitative Index vol.14, pp.3, 2014, https://doi.org/10.5345/JKIBC.2014.14.3.195