Journal of the Korean Dietetic Association (대한영양사협회학술지)

The Korean Dietetic Association (대한영양사협회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analysis of TQM-based HACCP System and Safety Management Performance in Middle and High School Foodservice Operations - Seoul, Gyeonggi, Incheon, Kangwon and Chungcheong Areas in Korea -

중.고등학교 급식 운영특성에 따른 종합적 품질경영(TQM)에 근거한 HACCP 시스템 활동 및 위생관리 수행수준 분석 -서울, 경기, 인천, 강원, 충청지역 중.고등학교를 중심으로-

  • Received : 2010.11.16
  • Accepted : 2011.01.11
  • Published : 2011.02.02
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The following study was taken in the Seoul, Gyeonggi, Incheon, Kangwon, and Chungcheong areas to analyze the performance levels of safety management by characteristics of school foodservice. The following results were obtained from a survey conducted on 2,271 middle and high school dietitians in 808 schools. Out of the 808 schools surveyed, 513 schools (63.5%) were self-operated and 295 schools (36.5%) were managed by a contract. Regarding the performance level of the hygiene duties, contract-managed schools were rated as 4.02 points while self-operated schools were rated relatively higher (4.16 points). The self-operated schools had an average score of 3.60 points for the TQM-based HACCP system, and the areas that scored lower than the average were strategies, human resources, data and analysis. The average score of the contract-managed schools was 3.42 points, and such areas as leadership, human resources, data and analysis, and customer satisfactory level scored below the average. For the analysis of CCP performance level, the contract-managed schools scored 4.28 points while self-operated schools scored 4.34 points. Overall, the hygiene duties, CCP performance level, and TQM-based HACCP system performance of the contracted schools were lower than those of the self-operated schools. Therefore, it is advised that the contract-managed schools consider new measures to strengthen their performance level for improved safety of school foodservice.

Keywords

References

  1. Alvarez RJ (1994): Management total quality in food service. Food Technol 48(9):140-151
  2. Cho KW (2006): A study on TQM performance of foodservice manager in institutional foodservice. Masters degree thesis. Gyeongsang National University. pp.26-59
  3. Cho KW, Suh EH, Yoon JY (2007): Relationship between TQM performance and organizational culture of dietitians in institutional foodservice. Korean J Food Culture 22(2):191-200
  4. Cho KW, Yoon JY (2006): TQM performance and job satisfaction of dietitians in institutional foodservices. Korean J Community Nutr 11(6):750-760
  5. Choi SH (2001): The survey of dieticians' perception on obstacles in implementing HACCP system for school foodservice operations. Masters degree thesis. Yonsei University. pp.20-50
  6. Chong YK (1998): Evaluation of TQM performance and organizational management effectiveness for foodservice and clinical nutrition servicemanagement in hospital settings. Thesis (doctoral)- University of Missouri- Columbia. Human Nutrition. pp.12-22
  7. Chong YK, Kwak TK (2000): Perceived performance of sanitary management of school food service managers in the seoul area. Korean J Community Nutr 5(1):100-108
  8. Goh YK (2006): Ways to improve school foodservice sanitation through haccp performance evaluations conducted in Seoul. Masters degree thesis. Chungang University. pp.2-5
  9. Han JH, Yi NY, Hong WS (2009): Identifying the effect of personal, foodservice and organizational characteristics on foodservice managers' Job satisfaction by the contract management company scale. Korean J Community Nutr 14(2): 216-228
  10. Jeon HJ, Joo NM (2002): Foodservice management. Kyomunsa. Gyeonggi. pp.14-59
  11. Kang DH (2007): Development of new HACCP model for school foodservice based on the safety evaluation. Degree of Doctor. Gyeongsang National University. pp.1-9
  12. Kang KS (2004): Quality management TQC.TQM. Pakyoungsa. Seoul. pp.19-31
  13. Kim GM (2009): Analysis of sanitary management status and performance based on HACCP system in school foodservice - Seoul. Masters degree thesis. Dongguk University. pp.1-4
  14. Kim GM, Lee SY (2008): A study on the sanitation management status and barriers to HACCP system implementation of school foodservice institutions in Seoul metropolitan area. Korean J Community Nutr 13(3):405-417
  15. Kim GM, Lee SY (2009a): Analysis of the school foodservice facilities & sanitary education -Seoul, Gyeonggi, Kangwon and Choongchung areas in Korea. Korean J Community Nutr 14(5):576-589
  16. Kim GM, Lee SY (2009b): Factors related to sanitary management performance based on HACCP system in school foodservice: Seoul, Gyeonggi, Kangwon and Choongchung areas in Korea. Korean J Community Nutr 14(6):817-830
  17. Kim HY, Kim HJ (2000): A study for the quality control of food served by contracted management in high school foodservice centre. J Fd Hyg Safety 15(4):304-314
  18. Kim JE (1997): The application of HACCP model to the development of the sanitation management tools for quality control of foodservice establishment. Masters degree thesis. Sookmyoung Woman's University. pp.77-74
  19. Kim KS (2002): A study on HACCP in the TQM perspective. Masters degree thesis. Pukyong National University. pp.4-68
  20. Kim MK (2005): A study on employees' knowledge and implementation of HACCP system in school foodservice. Masters degree thesis. Yeungnam University. pp.25-59
  21. Kim SH, Lee KA, Yu CH, Song YS, Kim WK, Yoon HR, Kim JH, Lee JS, Kim MK (2004): Elementary, middle and high school teachers' opinions of school foodservice programs. Korean J Nutr 37(8):701-711
  22. Koh MS, Jung LH, Lee JO (2004): Performance status of sanitary management of school food service in the Jeonnam area. Korean J Human Ecology 7(1):51-67
  23. Kwak TK, Lee KM, Chang HJ, Kang YJ, Hong WS, Moon HK (2005): Analysis of critical control points through field assessment of sanitation management practices in foodservice establishments. Korean J Food Cookery Sci 21(3):290-300
  24. Kwak TK, Lyu ES, Lee HS, Hong WS, Chang HJ (2007): Foodservice management. Shinkwang Publishing Co. Seoul. pp.335-343
  25. Kwak TK, Park SH, Kang YJ, Ryu K, Hong WS, Jang HJ, Moon HK, Kim SH, Park SJ (1999): Application of HACCP on school foodservice and operation of sanitary management, Research Report of Ministry of Education Science and Technology pp.1-9.
  26. Kwon MH (2001): Assessments of TQM-based sanitation management practices for the implementation of HACCP system in hospital foodservice operations. Masters degree thesis. Yonsei University. pp.23-46
  27. Lee JH (2005): Verification of the HACCP system in school foodservice operations, and efficacy of personal hygiene management practices and sanitization of fresh vegetables. Masters degree thesis. Yonsei University. pp.6-30
  28. Lee JS, Kwak DK, Kang YJ (2003): Development of the hospital foodservice facility evaluation tools based on the general HACCP-based sanitation standards and guidelines. Korean J Food Cookery Sci 19(3):339-353
  29. Lee KE, Lee HS (2005): Influences of school food Service dietitians' job satisfaction and perception of barriers to HACCP implementation on food sanitation/safety management performance in Gyeongbuk Province. J Korean Diet Assoc 11(2):179-189
  30. Lim JH (2001): Analysis of sanitation management in hospital food and nutrition servece departments to adopt the TQMHACCP system. Masters degree thesis. Catholic University. pp.35-40
  31. Ministry of Education Science and Technology (2009): Available from http://www.mest.go.kr//mskor/inform/info_data/welfare/1215652_8479.jsp. Accessed September 9
  32. Ministry of Education Science and Technology (2004): School foodservice sanitary management guide book. Seoul. pp.70-93
  33. Ministry of Education Science and Technology (2006a): Available from http://www.mest.go.kr/web/1121/ko/board/view.do?bbsId=159&boardSeq=7579. Accessed December 10
  34. Ministry of Education Science and Technology (2006b): School foodservice total improvement countermeasure (2007-2011). Sunmyung Publishing Co. Seoul. pp.13-38
  35. Moon HK, Jean JY, Lyu ES (2004): Assessment of hygiene knowledge and recognition on job performance levels for HACCP implementation for dieticians and employees at contract foodservices. J Korean Diet Assoc 10(3):261-271
  36. Park SH, Lim YH (2005): A study on the sanitary management of school foodservice operations in Daejeon and Chungnam. Korean J Community Nutr 10(2):234-242
  37. Snyder OP (1995): HACCP-TQM for retail and food service operations. In: HACCP in Meat, Poultry and Fish Processing. Advances in Meat Research Series. Vol. 10. Pearson AM, Dutson TR, eds. Blackie Academic and Professional, London, Glasgow, Weinnheim, New York, Tokyo, Melbourne, Madras. pp.230-299
  38. Tenner AR, DeToro IJ (1992): Total quality management. Addison-Wesley Publishing Company Inc. Massachusetts. pp.4-17
  39. Webb NB, Marsden JL (1995): Relationship of the HACCP system to total quality management. In: Advances in Meat Research-Volume 10. HACCP in Meat, Poultry and Fish Processing. Pearson AM, Dustion TR, eds. London, Blackie Academic & Professional
  40. Yoon MY (2004): A study on implementation of hazard analysis and critical control point (HACCP) system in schools foodservice operations -pohang area-. Masters degree thesis. Yeungnam University. pp.49-64