A Study on the Evaluating Indicators of the Level of Deterioration in High-rise and high-density Apartments

고층고밀 아파트단지의 노후도 평가지표 개발

  • 조성희 (부산대학교 주거환경학과) ;
  • 이태경 (부산대학교 주거환경학과)
  • Published : 2009.08.25

Abstract

High-rise and high-density apartment complexes have been built and supplied on a large scale in the 1st period of the New Town project in metropolitan areas since the late 1980s. Now It has become necessary to improve those apartment complexes, which have serious deterioration problems for aging more than about 20 years accompanying simultaneity and a large scale. The purpose of this research is to develop the evaluating indicators to measure the level of deterioration of apartments inclusively and practically in order to regenerate apartments as sustainable residential environments. This study is composed of the following four parts; (a) establishing the conceptual model of evaluation of apartment deterioration, (b) selecting evaluation items, (c) constituting evaluation measurement, and(d)weighting evaluation indicators. First, deterioration of apartments was conceptualized by physical. social, and economical aspects in terms of sustainable development and proposed the conceptual model of hierarchy structure of evaluation of apartment deterioration by literature reviews. Second, evaluating items were selected based on literature reviews of existing indicators and preceding studies about apartments of Korea and foreign countries. The evaluating indicators were identified as a total of 77 evaluating items which were composed of three dimensions and 9 attributes on the basis of the conceptual model. They cover comprehensive scope of the apartment such as unit, building, complex, and site. Third, as the measurement, the 5 point ordinal scale measure was suggested. The evaluating measurement including measure standards, measure methods, and measure contents were developed by each evaluating items. Lastly, the weighting of evaluating indicators was analyzed by AHP method conducted by survey on the expert group. Items were identified as high contributors or low contributors. The weighting of these items could suggest several evaluations according to the situation. The evaluation of the level of deterioration can be done by both total evaluation and a specific field of evaluation. In addition, it is easy to grasp deteriorated attributes or dimensions by providing a radar and bar chart showing evaluation results. These evaluating indicators could be a useful tool to grasp actual methods for the regeneration of apartments.

Keywords

References

  1. G. Baird et al. (1996), Building Evaluation Techniques, MaGraw-Hill
  2. Peter Roberts (2000), The Evolution, Definition, and Purpose of Urban Regeneration, Urban Regeneration (a handbook)
  3. UK DETR (2007), HQ Version 4, Housing Corporation
  4. 國土交通省住宅局住宅生産課(2007), 新築住宅の住宅性能表示制度ガイド 住宅性能表示制度(平城 19年)
  5. IBEC(2004, 2008), CASBEE-Technical Manual
  6. 최무현.현택수(1998), 도심 소규모 노후아파트의 주거환경개선 방안연구, 건설교통부
  7. 한국시설안전기술공단(2000), 재건축 판정을 위한 평가방안, 건설교통부
  8. 건설교통부.환경부(2002), 친환경건축물 인증제도
  9. 건설교통부(2006), 주택성능등급표시제도
  10. 임창일(1998), 노후고층아파트 재건축의 방향에 관한 연구, 서울대학교 박사학위논문, 34-42
  11. 최상희(2005), 서울시 노후 공동주택 재생 결정 방안 연구, 서울대학교 박사학위논문, 17-31
  12. Kim, K. B. (2002), Towards Sustainable Neighborhood Design, Ph.D. Dissertation, Cardiff Univ.
  13. 민병호.임상돈.도건효(1991), 건물 노령화의 이해와 대책, 대한건축학회지 건축, 35(1), 65-66
  14. 문홍길(1995), 재생의 주거환경적 의미, 대한건축학회지 건축, 39(7), 12-16
  15. 김수암(2009), 장수명 주택 활성화를 위한 제도 방향, 대한건축학회지 건축, 53(2), 24-25
  16. 강민정.김주현.하재명(2008), 도심재생을 위한 도심 상업지역의 노후도평가지표개발, 대한건축학회논문집, 24(2), 227-234
  17. 김선숙.김광우.양인호(2004), 공동주택 거주성능 평가 모델 개발에 관한 연구, 대한건축학회 논문집, 20(9), 265-272
  18. 김재익(1998), 주거만족도 구성요인의 가격추정에 관한 연구, 대한국토도시계획학회논문집 국토계획, 33(2), 105-117
  19. 서붕교(2000), 노후 공동주택의 재생시스템 구축을 위한 연구, 한국실내디자인학회 논문집, 23, 92-94
  20. 오덕성.염인섭(2008), 지속가능한 자원절약형 도시재생 프로젝트에 관한 연구, 대한건축학회논문집, 24(1), 174-175
  21. 이춘호(1997), 수도권 신도시 거주자 주거환경 만족도 분석 연구, 한국도시행정학회논문집 도시행정학보 10권, 63-80
  22. 임상돈.유완(1992), 아파트 노후화 평가모형, 대한국토도시계획학회논문집 국토계획, 27(4), 140-141
  23. 제해성.이재혁.홍수진(2006), 초고층 공동주택의 삶의 질에 근거한 주거환경지표 체계화 연구, 대한건축학회 논문집, 22(8), 89-96
  24. 조성희.강혜경(2000), 주거환경 구성요소에 대한 거주자들의 태도에 관한 연구, 한국주거학회논문집, 11(1), 45-56
  25. 조성희.이태경.오덕성(2009), 1기 신도시 고층고밀 아파트단지의 재생을 위한 개발현황 분석에 관한 연구, 한국생태환경건축학회 논문집, 9(2), 17-26
  26. 허영숙.조성희(1994), 부산지 집합주택계획의 기본방향 설정을 위한 거주후 평가, 대한건축학회 논문집, 10(1), 61-72
  27. 현택수.이병태(2006), 노후공동주택의 거주성능 평가에 관한 사례연구, 한국주거학회논문집, 17(2), 77-85
  28. 조성희.이태경(2008), 아파트 노후도 평가지표 개발을 위한 기초연구, 한국주거학회 춘계학술대회논문집 19, 225-230