Piping Failure Frequency Analysis for the Main Feedwater System in Domestic Nuclear Power Plants

  • Published : 2004.02.01

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to analyze the piping failure frequency for the main feedwater system in domestic nuclear power plants(NPPs) for the application to an in-service inspection(ISI), leak before break(LBB) concept, aging management program(AMP), and probabilistic safety analysis(PSA). First, a database was developed for piping failure events in domestic NPPs, and 23 domestic piping failure events were collected. Among the 23 events, 12 locations of wall thinning due to flow accelerated corrosion(FAC) were identified in the main feedwater system in 4 domestic WH 3-loop NPPs. Two types of the piping failure frequency such as the damage frequency and rupture frequency were considered in this study. The damage frequency was calculated from both the plant population data and damage(s) including crack, wall thinning, leak, and/or rupture, while the rupture frequency was estimated by using both the well-known Jeffreys method and a new method considering the degradation due to FAC. The results showed that the damage frequencies based on the number of the base metal piping susceptible to FAC ranged from $1.26{\times}10^{-3}/cr.yr\;to\;3.91{\times}10^{-3}/cr.yr$ for the main feedwater system of domestic WH 3-loop NPPs. The rupture frequencies obtained from the Jeffreys method for the main feedwater system were $1.01{\times}10^{-2}/cr.yr\;and\;4.54{\times}10^{-3}/cr.yr$ for the domestic WH 3-loop NPPs and all the other domestic PWR NPPs respectively, while those from the new method considering the degradation were higher than those from the Jeffreys method by about an order of one.

Keywords

References

  1. USNRC, 'Pipe Cracking Experience in LWR', NUREG-0679 (1980)
  2. USNRC, 'Investigation and Evaluation of Cracking Incidents in Piping in PWR', NUREG-0691 (1980)
  3. USNRC, 'Erosion/Corrosion-Induced Pipe Wall Thinning in US NPPs', NUREG-1344 (1989)
  4. EPRI, Nuclear Reactor Piping Failures at US Commercial LWRs : 1961 - 1997, EPRI TR-110102 (1998)
  5. USNRC, Bulletin 87-01 'Thinning of Pipe Walls in Nuclear Power Plants' (1987)
  6. USNRC, Generic Letter 89-08, 'Erosion/Corrosion-Induced Pipe Wall Thinning' (1989)
  7. USNRC, 'Incorporating Aging Effects into Probabilistic Risk Assessment - A Feasibility Study Utilizing Reliability Physics Models', NUREG/CR-5632 (1999)
  8. USNRC, Rate of Initiating Events at U.S. Nuclear Power Plants : 1987 - 1995 NUREG/CR-5250 (1998)
  9. American Society of Mechanical Engineer, ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Sec. XI, Rules for In-Service Inspection of Nuclear Power Plant Components (1998)
  10. S. Y. Choi and Y. H. Choi, Development of OPDE Database, 2002 Fall Conference of KNS, Yong-Peong (2002)
  11. S. Y. Choi and Y. H Choi, Piping Failure Analysis in Domestic Nuclear Safety Piping System, 2003 Spring Conference of KSME, Pusan (2003)
  12. Horowitz et. al., A New Parameter in FAC Modeling, PVP Conference (1998)
  13. ASME, Class 1 Components, ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Sec. III NB (1998)
  14. ASME, Code Case N-597, Requirements for Analytical Evaluation of Pipe Wall Thinning, (1998)
  15. OECD/NEA, OECD Piping Failure Data Exchange(OPDE) Project Terms and Conditions for Project Operation(2002)
  16. Battelle/PRCI, Development of Alternative Failure Criterion for Res. Strength (1999)
  17. Y. J. Kim et al, Integrity Evaluation of Thinned Piping Using Limit Load Method, KINS/RR-133 (2002)