Korean Management Science Review (경영과학)

The Korean Operations Research and Management Science Society (한국경영과학회)
권호 표지

A Study of IT Environment Scenario through the Application of Cross Impact Analysis

교차영향분석의 작용을 통한 국내 IT 환경 시나리오에 대한 연구

  • Published : 2004.11.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Scenario analysis for strategic planning, unlike most forecasting methods, provides a qualitative, contextual description of how the present will evolve into the future. It normally tries to identify a set of possible futures, each of whose occurrence is plausible but not assured. In this paper, we propose the use of Cross Impact Analysis(CIA) approach for scenario generation about the future of Korean IT environments. In this analysis, we classified IT environments into technical, social, legislative, and economic factor. And various variables and events were defined in each factor. From the survey collected from IT related experts, we acquire probability of occurrence and compatibility estimates of every possible pairs of events as input. Then 2 phase analysis is used in order to choice events with high probability of occurrence and generate scenario. Finally, after CIA using Monte Carlo simulation, a detail scenario for 2010 was developed. These scenario drawn from the CIA approach is a result considered by cross impacts of various events.

Keywords

References

  1. 권철신，조근태，강일중，'상호영향형 계획대체안 수목구조체의 개발', '한국경영과학회/ 대한산업공학회 춘계공동학술대회 초록집', (2001), pp.152-155
  2. 권철신，조근태，강일중, ‘R&D 계획시스템 대체안의 설정을 위한 상호영향형 SAT의 적용 모형’, ‘한국경영과학회/대한산업공학회 춘계공동학술대회 초록집’, (2001), pp.747-754
  3. 기획예산처, '국가재정운용계획 수립에 본격 착수', 2003, 4
  4. 김준배, '불황기，e비즈니스 전망 : 올해가 진정한 e비 즈니 스 개화기', 한국전자거래진흥원뉴스레터(eBizKorea), 2004，2
  5. 산업자원부, '2004년도 산업정보화촉진시행계획(안)', 2003, 12
  6. 산업자원부, '20041년 e-비즈니스 정책방향'，2004, 1
  7. 임명환, ‘디지털 경제와 IT 기술혁신, 한국전자통신연구원’, 연구보고서, 2004， 4
  8. 전국경제인연합회, ‘국내 500대 기업 e-비즈니스 인덱스 조사보고서', 2002, 11
  9. 정보통신정책연구원, ‘정보통신산업 중장기 시장전망(2003-2008)’, 연구보고서， 2003, 12
  10. 정보통신부, '정보화촉진기금 존치 평가 보고서'，2004，4
  11. 정보통신부, ‘IT분야 신성장동력 추진전략 보고회’，2004，6
  12. 조근태，권철신, '기술예측에의 적용을 위한 상호영향분석법의 이론적 고찰 : 한계와 연구방향', '기술혁신연구', 9권，제1호(2001)pp.95-120
  13. 한국전산원, '해외 정보화 통계 동향분석'，연구보고서，2003，12
  14. 한국전산원，'미래 IT 환경 및 영향요인', 2004, 5
  15. 한국전산원, '국제 정보화 지수 분석 및 시사점'，연구보고서，2004, 6
  16. 한국전자통신연구원 정보화기술연구소, '국내 정보통신산업'，연구보고서，2003, 3
  17. 한국전자통신연구원，'2003 정보통신 기술산업 전망(2003-2007)', 연구보고서， 2003, 4
  18. 한국전자통신연구원，'정보통신 서비스 및 기술발전 전망'，2003，4
  19. 한국전자통신연구원，'정보통신 기술 . 산업전망'，2004，5
  20. 한국정보통신산업협회，'정보통신산업통계집', 2002, 6
  21. Asan, U, C.E. Bozdag and S. Polat, 'A Fuzzy Approach to Qualitative Cross Impact Analysis,' Omega, Vol.32(2004), pp. 443-458
  22. Blanning, R.W. and B.A Reinig, 'Cross impact analysis using group decision support systems : an application to the future of Hong Kong?,' Futures, Vol.31(1999), pp.39-56
  23. Brauers, J. and M. Weber, 'A New Method of Scenario Analysis for Strategic Planning,' journal of Forecasting, Vol.7(1988), pp.31-47
  24. Bunn, D.W. and M.M. Mustafaoglu, 'Forecasting Political Risk,' Management Science, Vol.24(1978), pp.1557-1567
  25. Cairns, G., G. Wright, R. Bradfield, K. van der Heijden and G. Burt, 'Exploring Egovernment Futures Through the Application of Scenario Planning,' Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Vol.71 (2004), pp.217-238
  26. DTI, International Benchmarking Study, Feb., 2004
  27. Duperrin, J.C. and M. Godet, 'SMIC 74-A Method for Constructing and Ranking Scenarios,' Futures, Vol.7(1975), pp.302-312 https://doi.org/10.1016/0016-3287(75)90048-8
  28. Fontela, E., 'Industrial Application of Crossimpact Analysis,' Long Range Planning, Vol.9(1976), pp.29-33
  29. Gartner, Global PC Forecast: Post-Terrorist- Attack Scenarios, Forecast Analysis, Oct. 2001
  30. Gartner Dataquest, Market Databook, Market Statistics, each year
  31. Gartner Dataquest, Wireless LAN Equipment : Worldwide, 2001-2007, Nov. 2002
  32. Georgantzas, N.C. and W. Acar, ScenarioDriven Planning : Learningto Manage Strategic Uncertainty, Quorum Books, 1995
  33. Goldfarb, D.L. and W.R. Huss, 'Building Scenarios for An Electric Utility,' Long Range Planning, Vol.21(1988), pp.78-85
  34. Gordon, T.J. and H. Hayward, 'Initial Experiments with the Cross-Impact Method of Forecasting,' Futures, Vol.1(1968), pp. 100-116
  35. Gordon, T.J., H.S. Becker and H. Gerjuoy, Trend-Impact Analysis: A New Forecasting Tool, The Futures Group, Glastonbury, CT., 1974
  36. Hahn, S.H., Risk Based Go/No Go Decision Making Model for International Construction Projects: The Cross Impact Analysis Approach, Ph.D. Thesis, Dept. of Civil, Environment, and Architectural Engineering, University of Colorado, 1999
  37. Honton, E.J., G.S. Stacey and S.M. Millet, Future Scenarios: The BASICS Computational Method, Battelle, Columbus Division, Ohio, July 1985
  38. Huss, W.R. and E.J. Honton, 'Alternative Methods for Developing Business Scenarios,' Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Vol.31(1987), pp.219-238
  39. Huss, W.R. and E.J. Honton, 'Scenario Planning-What Style Should You Use?,' Long Range Planning, Vol.20(1987), pp.21-29
  40. Ishikawa, M., M. Toda, S. Mori and Y. Kaya, 'An Application of the Extended Cross Impact Method to Generating Scenariosof Social Change in Japan,' Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Vol.18(1980), pp.217-233
  41. Krauth, J., H. Duin and A. Schimmel, 'A Comparison of Tools for Strategic Simulation and Scenario Generation with Special Emphasis on 'Soft Factor',' Simulation Practice and Theory, Vol.6(1998), pp.23-33
  42. Millet, S.M., 'Battelle's Scenario Analysis of a European High-Tech Market,' Planning Review, Vol.20(1992), pp.20-23
  43. OECD, ICT Diffusion to Business: Peer Review-Korea, May 2004
  44. Reed Electronics Research Quadrant House, Yearbook of World Electronics Data, 2002
  45. Sapia, B., 'SEARCH(Scenario Evaluation and Analysis through Repeated Cross Impact Handling) : A New Method for Scenario Analysis with An Application to the Videotel Service in Italy,' International journal of Forecasting, Vol.11(1995), pp.113-131
  46. Slaughter, R.A., 'Assessing the Quest for Future Knowledge: Significance of the Quick Environmental Scanning Technique for Futures,' Futures, Vol.22(1990), pp.153- 166
  47. Turoff, M., 'An Alternative Approach to Cross-Impact Analysis,' Tedmdogical Forecasting and Social Change, Vol.3(1972), pp.309-339
  48. Wack, P., 'Scenarios: Shooting the Rapids,' Harvard Business Review, Vol.63 (1985), pp.139-150
  49. Wissema, J.G. and J. Benes, 'A Cross- impact Case Study : The Dutch Construction Sector,' Futures, Vol.12(1980), pp.394-404