Journal of Intelligence and Information Systems (지능정보연구)

Korea Intelligent Information System Society (한국지능정보시스템학회)
권호 표지

A Neural Network Approach to Compare Predictive Value of Accounting Versus Market Data

신경망 접근법을 이용한 회계자료와 시장자료의 미래예측력 비교

  • Published : 2004.06.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This research compares the use of accounting data versus market data in the prediction of bankruptcy. Comparison is made through neural networks so that prediction accuracy is model-independent. Results of this study indicate that both market and accounting data provide useful information on corporate bankruptcies. Interestingly, using market and accounting information together can achieve substantial gain in prediction accuracy.

기업파산예측에 대한 기존연구는 회계자료를 통해 추출한 재무비율 (부채비율, 이자상환율 등)을 이용한 분석에 의존하였다. 본 논문은 기업파산을 예측함에 있어서 자본시장자료를 이용한 정보가 어떠한 유용성을 지니는지를 분석하고, 자본시장자료와 회계자료 간의 상대적 우월성을 비교하였다. 비교분석을 행함에 있어서 신경망 접근법을 이용함으로써 모형 의존성을 회피하고자 하였다. 실증분석결과에 의하면 자본시장자료와 회계자료 모두 기업파산을 예측하는데 유용한 정보를 제공하고 있으며, 어느 자료가 상대적으로 우월하다고 유의하게 단정할 수는 없었다. 하지만 자본시장자료와 회계자료를 함께 사용하여 정보를 추출하면 어느 한 자료만에 의존하는 경우에 비해 월등한 예측력 향상을 도모할 수 있음을 알 수 있었다. 이 결과는 회계자료에만 의존해 온 기업파산연구에 대해 자본시장자료에 좀더 관심을 기울일 필요가 있음을 시사한다.

Keywords

References

  1. Journal of Finance v.23 no.2 Financial Ratios,Discriminant analysis and the prediction of corporate bankruptcy Altman,E.I.
  2. Journal of banking and finance v.1 no.1 Zeta analysis-A new model to identify bankruptcy risk of corporations Altman,E.;R.Handelman;R.Narayanan
  3. Journal of management studies v.25 Bankruptcy prediction-An investigation of cash flow based models Aziz,A.;D.Emanuel;G.Lawson
  4. Neural Network Time Series Forecasting of Financial Markets Azoff,M.
  5. Journal of Accounting,Auditing & Finance v.7 no.3 Bankruptcy prediction using quartely financial statement data Baldwin,J.;W.Glenzen
  6. Journal of Accounting Research v.6 no.2 Market prices,financial ratios,and the prediction of failure Beaver,W.
  7. Neural Networks for Economic and Financial Modeling Beltratti,A.;S.Margarita;P.Terna
  8. Federal Reserve Board Supervision and Regulation Letters SR 96~17 Supervisory guidance for credit derivatives Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System Division of Banking Supervision and Regulation
  9. Federal Reserve Board Supervision and Regulation Letters SR 97~18 Application of market risk capital requirements to credit derivatives Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System Division of Banking Supervision and Regulation
  10. Journal of Econometrics v.41 no.1 An econometric analysis of the bank credit-scoring problem Boyes,W.;D.Hoffman;S.Low
  11. Journal of Finance v.38 no.2 The behavior of common stocks of bankrupt firms Clark,T.;Weinstein,M.
  12. Financial Management v.9 no.2 An Empirical comparison of bankruptcy prediction models Collins,R.
  13. Neural Network Study DARPA
  14. Journal of Derivatives v.2 no.3 Credit risk derivatives Das,Sanjiv
  15. Journal of Accounting Research v.10 no.1 A discriminant analysis of predictors of business failure Deakin,E.
  16. Journal of Finance v.40 no.2 Does the stock market overreact? DeBondt,W.F.;R.Thaler
  17. Journal of Finance v.42 no.2 Further evidence on investor overreation and stock market seasonality DeBondt,W.F.;R.Thaler
  18. Federal Reserve Board Working Paper Credit derivatives in banking:Useful tools for loan risk management? Duffee,G.;C.Zhou
  19. Journal of Finance v.47 no.1 The cross-section of expected returns Fama,E.;French,K.
  20. Current state of the art implications for assessments of capital adequacy Credit risk models at major U.S.banking institutions Federal Reserve System Task Force on Internnal Credit Risk Models
  21. Statement of Financial Accounting Concepts No.2 Stamford,CT:FASB Financial Accounting Standards Board
  22. Accounting Review v.59 no.4 Earnings releases,anomalies, and the behavior of securities returns Foster,G.;Olsen,C.;Shevlin,T.
  23. Journal of Lending & Credit Risk Management v.80 no.7 Considerations in measuring the credit risk in derivatives Gilbert,J.;L.Cherniavsky
  24. Journal of the Operation Research Society v.47 no.2 Estimating missing values using neural networks Gupta,A.;M.Lam
  25. Neural Networks:A Comprehensive Foundation Haykin,S.
  26. International Journal of Forecasting v.10 no.1 Artificial neural networks for forecasting and decision making Hill,T.;Marquez,L.;O'Connor;M.W.Remus
  27. Scientific America v.267 Genetic algorithms:Computer programs that "evolve"in ways that resemble natural selection can solve complex problems even their creators do not fully understand Holland,J.
  28. Journal of Business v.62 no.3 Testing for nonlinear dependence in daily foreign exchange rates Hsieh,D.
  29. Journal of Financial and Qunatitative Analysis v.28 no.1 Implications of nonlinear dynamics for financial risk management Hsieh,D.
  30. Financial Analysts Journal v.57 no.5 Default parameter estimation using market prices Jarrow,R.
  31. Journal of Finance v.50 no.1 Pricing derivatives on financial securities subject to credit risk Jarrow,R.;S.Turnbull
  32. Journal of Management Information Systems v.16 no.1 Expert,linear models, and nonlinear models of expert decision making in bankruptcy prediction Kim,C.;R.McLeod
  33. Intelligent Systems in Accounting,Finance and Management v.6 no.1 Ordinal pairwise partitioning(OPP) approach to neural networks training in bond rating Kwon,Y.;Han;I.L.Lee
  34. Journal of Finance v.50 no.5 Contrarian investment,extrapolation, and risk Lakonishiok,J.;Shleifer,A.;Vishny,R.W.
  35. Intelligent Systems in Accounting,Finance and Management v.6 no.1 Predicting Bond ratings using neural networks:A comparison with logistic regression Maher,J.;T.Sen
  36. The Financial Review v.33 no.2 An empirical comparison of bankruptcy models Mossman,E.;G.Bell;M.Swartz;H.Turtle
  37. Economic Review(Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City) v.81 no.2 Credit derivatives:New financial instruments for controlling credit risk Neal,R.
  38. Credit derivatives:Guidelines for national banks Office of the Comptroller of the Currency(OCC)
  39. Journal of Accounting Research v.18 no.1 Financial ratios and the probabilistic prediction of bankruptcy Ohlson,J.A.
  40. International Journal of Intelligent Systems in Accounting,Finance and Management v.7 no.3 Using neural networks to predict corporate failure O'Leary,D.E.
  41. Decision Sciences v.23 no.4 Neural networks:A new tool for predicting thrift failures Salchenberger,M.;M.Cinar;A.Lash
  42. The Neural Network FAQ 2002 Sarle,W.
  43. Derivatives Strategy 1997a;Credit Derivatives Supplement Building the credit derivatives infrastructure Spinner,K.
  44. Derivatives Strategy 1997b;Credit Derivatives Supplement Pricing models for credit derivatives Spinner,K.
  45. Management Science v.38 no.7 Managerial application of neural networks:The case of bank failure predictions Tam,K.;M.Kiang
  46. ORSA Journal on Computing v.4 no.4 Feedforward neural nets as models for time series forecastings Tang,Z.;P.Fishwick
  47. Businessweek Investor Cash-Flows Hocus-Pocus Tergesen,A.
  48. Expert Systems with Applications v.17 Neural networks in business:a survey of applications(1992-1998) Velido,A.;Lisboa,PJG;Vanghan,J.
  49. Journal of Lending & Credit Risk Management v.79 no.11 Measuring and managing credit portfolio risk:Part Ⅰ:Modeling systemic default risk Wilson,T.
  50. Decision Support Systems v.19 no.4 Neural network applications in business. A review and analysis of the literature(1988-95) Wong,B.K.;Bodnovich,T.A.;Selvi,Y.
  51. Decision Support Systems v.11 no.5 Integrating artficial neural networks with rule-based expert systems Yoon,Y.;T.Guimaraes;G.Swales