A Qualitative Meta-analysis on Oriental Medicine Clinical Research for Stroke

뇌졸중에 관한 한의학 임상연구의 질적 메타분석

  • 진수희 (경희대학교 한의과대학 경혈학교실, 경북대학교 대학원 보건학과) ;
  • 임사비나 (경희대학교 한의과대학 경혈학교실) ;
  • 박히준 (경희대학교 한의과대학 경혈학교실) ;
  • 이성국 (경북대학교 의과대학 예방의학교실)
  • Published : 2003.06.01

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to integrate the therapeutic effects of Oriental medicine for stroke in clinical research published in Korea from 1991 to 2000. In the preliminary study, clinical studies on Oriental medical therapy for stroke in Korea were collected. Since it was inadequate to integrate the results of the papers, qualitative meta-analysis was conducted on them. In age distribution of occurrence, the most frequent age was sixties followed by seventies, fifties, forties, and thirties. Sample size was minimum 42 persons, maximum 473 persons. Papers including single therapy were noted in 50.1 %. Among those, herbal medicine was noted in 30%, while acupuncture, physical treatment, and moxibustion was noted in 6.7%. Including more than two therapies were noted in 49.1 %, Among those, herbal medicine was noted in 80%, acupuncture in 20%, physical treatment in 13%, western and oriental medicine in 30%. Papers including control group were noted in 13% and description of scale for the evaluation of treatment effect was 80%. Papers including objectification of scales for the evaluation of therapeutic effects were noted in 26.7% and described follow-up period were noted in 13%. Papers including statistical analysis were noted in 26.7% and calculated p-value was noted in. 13.3%. Papers including design of longitudinal study were noted in 86.7%. Case-control studies were noted in 13.3%. Randomization and blinding were noted in each 0%. These results suggest that followings are required for the improvement of quality of clinical research in Oriental medicine; obvious description of treatment method, objectification of scales for the evaluation of therapeutic effects, adequate research design, randomization and blinding.

Keywords

References

  1. 한국역학회지 v.15 no.1 한국에서의 심혈관계 질환의 변천양상 서일;지선하;김일순
  2. 사망원인 통계연보 통계청
  3. 대한한의학회지 v.18 no.2 급성 뇌경색 환자의 Brain-CT 소견과 Barthel ADL을 이용한 예후에 관한 고찰 이원철
  4. 대한한의학회지 v.17 no.1 중풍임상자료에 대한 통계적 분석방법연구 강효신;권영규;박찬국;신양규;김상철
  5. 경희한의대논문집 v.4 중풍에 관한 임상적 연구 신진영;구본홍
  6. 경희대논문집 v.8 중풍에 관한 임상적 연구 이인선;장인규
  7. 경희대논문집 v.19 no.1 급성기 중풍환자의 한방치료효과에 관한 임상적 관찰 강성길;김영석
  8. 동서의학 v.23 no.4 중풍발생에 영향을 미치는 요인- 서울시내 일부 한방병원 입원환자를 중심으로- 권준철;류규수;유왕근
  9. 대한한의학회지 v.17 no.1 뇌졸중의 진단에 대한 TCD의 활용 박세기;강명석;전찬용;박종형
  10. 대한한의학회지 v.15 no.2 졸중풍 후유증에 의한 운동장애 환자의 치료를 위한 통용방으로서 황금탕과 보양완오탕의 효과에 관한 비교 연구 김동웅
  11. 대한한의학회지 v.12 no.2 중풍환자의 언어장애에 관한 임상적 고찰 김홍익;신길조;조기호;김영석;배형섭;이경섭
  12. 대한한의학회지 v.18 no.1 뇌졸중 후 견관절 수부 증후군의 적외선 체열촬영을 위한 임상적 관찰 이상훈;이윤호
  13. QRB v.16 no.2 Development of practice parameters by physician organization Kelly JT;Swartwout JT
  14. Clinical Practice Guideline American College of Physicians
  15. J Clin Oncol. v.13 The practice guidelines development cycle ; a conceptual tool for practice guidelines development and implementation Browman GP;Levine MN;Mohide EA;Hayward RSA;Pritchard KI;Gafni A
  16. Ann Intern Med. v.127 no.9 Quantitative synthesis in Systemic Reviews Joseph L;John PA;Christopher HS
  17. 예방의학회지 v.32 no.2 예방의학회지를 중심으로 한 예방의학 연구의 동향과 연관련 논문의 질적 메타분석 김춘배;이정애;박종구;손석준
  18. Epidemiology -The Logic of Modern Medicine Meta-analysis in medicine Jenicek M.
  19. 메타분석법 송혜향
  20. Control Clin Trials v.2 no.1 A method for assessing the quality of a randomized control trial Chalmers TC;Smith H Jr;Blackburn B;Silverman B;Schroeder B;Reitman D; Ambroz A
  21. Control Clin Trials v.17 Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trial: Is blinding necessary? Jadad AR;Moore RA;Carrol D
  22. 대한한방내과학회지 v.10 no.1 뇌졸중(腦卒中)에 관한 임상통계적 연구 윤진구;조기호;김영석;이경섭
  23. 대한의학협회지 v.34 no.7 문헌고찰과 아울러 본 뇌혈관질환의 추이 이학중;위봉애;박옥규;강정채;신영기;이시래;박요한;박의현;박영춘;유원상;이영;유언호;정문성;지영구;양인석;김진욱;박원;이홍순
  24. 예방의학과 공중보건 예방의학과 공중보건 편집위원회
  25. A Step-By-Step Guide to Clinical Trials Mulay;Marilyn, R.N.;M.S., Ocn.
  26. 대한한의학회지 v.16 no.1 풍의 병리적 의미규명과 중풍의 원인 및 치료에 대한 동서의학적 비교 김세길
  27. 대한한방내과학회지 v.18 no.2 중풍진단의 표준화방안 연구 신현기;박세기;김동우;전찬용;한양기;박종형
  28. Clinical Practice Guidelines
  29. 임상약리학회지 v.4 no.1 뇌혈전증 환자에서의 Triflusal(DisgrenR)의 혈소판응집 억제효과와 안전성에 관한 임상연구 권순억;안진영;유병우;박상섭;노재규
  30. 대한신경과학회지 v.11 no.1 만성신부전에서 발생한 뇌졸중에 관한 임상적 연구 김광수;박성파;임정근;이동욱;이상도;박영춘;박성배;김현철
  31. 원본동의보감 허준
  32. 뇌졸중 환자의 경직에 대한 전침 및 구료법의 치료효과 황연주
  33. 대한한의학회지 v.14 중풍환자의 반신마비 회복도에 대한 임상적 관찰 고성규;조기호;김영석;배형섭;이경섭
  34. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. v.69 Motor Assessment Scale for Stroke Patients concurrent Validity and Interater Reability Poole JL;Whitney SL
  35. Arch. Neurol. v.46 Interrater Reability of NIH Stroke Scale Goldstein LB;Bertels C;Davis JN
  36. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. v.64 Preceding Barthel ADL Score at 6 months after an acute stroke Wade DT;Skillberk CE;Hewew RL
  37. Arch. Phys. Med. Rehabil. v.60 Outcome of comprehensive medical rehabilitation Measurement by PULSES profile and the Barthel Index Granger CV;Albrecht GL;Hamilton BB
  38. 대한한의학회지 v.7 no.1 뇌졸중 환자의 기능평가법에 대한 연구 고성규;고창남;황기호
  39. BMJ. v.302 no.11 Critical appraisal of published research: introductory guidelines Fowkes FGR;Fulton PM
  40. Ann Rev Resp Dis. v.41 Methodologic Guidelines for Systemic Reviews of Randomized Clinical Trials in Health Care form the Postdam Consultation on Meta-analysis Cook DJ;Sackette DL;Spitzer WO