Korean Journal of Community Nutrition (대한지역사회영양학회지)

The Korean Society of Community Nutrition (대한지역사회영양학회)
권호 표지

Reproducibility of Nutrient Intake Estimated by Three-Day 24-Hour Dietary Recall of Middle-Aged Subjects for 6 Month Intervals

자기기록식 3일간의 24시간 회상법의 신뢰도 연구 -서울지역 중년 자원자를 대상으로-

  • 이미숙 (한남대학교 식품영양학과) ;
  • 우미경 (한남대학교 식품영양학과) ;
  • 김성애 (한남대학교 식품영양학과) ;
  • 오세인 (서일대학 식품영양학과) ;
  • 곽충실 (서울대학교 체력과학노화연구실)
  • Published : 2003.08.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study examined the reproducibility of nutrient intakes estimated by the 24-hour recall method in a prospective cohort study (Longitudinal study of aging and health monitoring of Korean elderly) of middle-aged volunteer subjects (42 males and 49 females) in the Seoul area. The three-day 24-hour recall was administered twice at an interval of approximately 6 months. The first data were collected and a corrective procedure was performed by interviewing of the subjects and a trained dietitian. The second data were collected by mail from the subjects without the performance of any corrective procedure. The mean age of the subjects was 53.5 $\pm$ 9.6 for the males and 52.2 $\pm$ 8.9 for the females. The subjects who had above college education were 95% in the case of the males and 60% in the case of the females. The characteristics of the male subjects in this study were that they were highly educated and held professional jobs and were from the middle or upper class. Comparing the first and second 24-hour recall data, the second data showed relatively lower intakes of all nutrients, except vitamin A, vitamin Bi and cholesterol. There was no difference in the nutrients of the first and the second data with respect to vitamin A, vitamin B$_1$ and cholesterol in the males and calcium, iron, sodium, vitamin A, vitamin B$_1$, vitamin B$_2$ and cholesterol in the females. This data may indicate that the 24 hour retail method without a dietitian's help may result in lower reporting of the subject's intakes. The men had a tendency to remember less than the women. Pearson's correlation coefficients with unadjusted nutrient intakes values were ranged from 0.24 to 0.66. When energy intake was adjusted, there was a slight increase (from 0.26 to 0.71). Intra-class correlation coefficients with nutrient-unadjusted values ranged from 0.22 to 0.66, and the energy-adjusted values were ranged from 0.23 to 0.69. The weighted Kappa statistical values ranged from 0.10 to 0.40. On the average,46.3% of the subjects who were found in the lowest quartile of the nutrient intake levels based on the first 24-hour recall, were in the lowest quartile based on the second 24-hour recall. Therefore, there was a low reproducibility between the first and the second 24-hour recall. We should examine the factors influencing low reproducibility. Also, strategies should be developed to maximize the reliability of the assessment, with regard to portion-size training and telephone validation. (Korean J Community Nutrition 8(4) : 603∼609, 2003)

Keywords

References

  1. Baxter SD, Thompson WO (2002): Accuracy by meal component of fourth-graders' school lunch recalls is less when obtained during a 24-hour recall than as a single meal. Nutr Res 22: 679-684
  2. Beaton GH, Milner J, McGuire V, Feather TE, Little JA (I983): Source of variance in 24-hour dietary recall data: implications for nutrition study design and interpretation. Carbohydrate sources, vitamins, and minerals. Am J Clin Nutr 37: 986-995
  3. Biro G, Hulshof KF, Ovesen L, Amorim Cruz JA (2002): Selection of methodology to assess food intake. Eur J Clin Nutr 56 (suppl 2): s25-32
  4. Buzzard IM, Stanton CA, Figueiredo M, Fries EA, Nicholson R, Hogan CJ, Danish SJ (2001): Development and reproducibility of a brief food frequency questionnaire for assessing the fat, fiber, and fruit and vegetable intakes of rural adolescents, J Am Diet Assoc 101 (12): 1438-1446
  5. Ervin RB, Smiciklas- Wright H (I998): Using encoding and retrieval strategies to improve 24-hour dietary recalls among older adults. J Am Diet Assoc 98 (9): 989-994
  6. Ferguson EL, Gibson RS, Opare-Obisaw C (I994): The relative validity of the repeated 24h recall for estimating energy and selected nutrient intakes of rural Ghanaian Children. Eur J Clin Nutr 48: 241-252
  7. Imaeda N, Fujiwara N, Tokudome Y, Ikeda M, Kuriki K, Nagaya T, Sato J, Goto C, Maki S, Tokudome S (2002): Reproducibility of a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire in Japanese female dietitians. J Epidemiol 12 (1): 45-53
  8. Jeor ST, Guthrie HA, Jones MB (I983): Variability in nutrient intake in a 28-day period. J Am Diet Assoc 83 (2): 155-162
  9. Jonnalagadda SS, Mitchell DC, Smiciklas-Wright H, Meaker KB, Heel NA, Karmally W, Ershow AG, Kris-Etherton PM (2000): Accuracy of energy intake data estimated by a multiple-pass, 24-hour dietary recall technique. J Am Diet Assoc 100 (3): 303-311
  10. Kim MK, Lee SS, Ahn YO (I996): Reproducibility and validity of a self-administered semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire among middle-aged men in Seoul. Korean J Comm Nutr 1(3): 376-394
  11. Lee HJ, Park SJ, Kim JH, Kim CI. Chang KJ, Yim KS, Kim KW, Choi HM (2002): Development and validation of a computerized semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire program for evaluating the nutritional status of the Korean elderly. Korean J Comni Nutr 7 (2): 277-285
  12. Lee MS, Woo MK (2001): A study on the factors influencing food consumption by food frequency questionnaire for the middle aged and elderly living in the Chonju area. Korean J Comm Nutr 6 (5): 789-797
  13. Lee RD, Nieman DC (I998): Nutritional assessment 2nd ed., pp.1I6126, Mosby
  14. Lee SH, Shim JS, Kim JY, Moon HA (I996): The effect of breakfast regularity on eating habits, nutritional and health status in adults. Korean J Nutr 29 (5): 533-546
  15. Oh SY, Hong MH (I998): Repeatability of a semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire for the Korean elderly. Korean J Nutr 31(7): 1183-1191
  16. Park YS, Han JL, Lee JW, Cho HS, Koo J, Kim JH, Yoon JS (2002): The development of a simple evaluation questionnaire for screening the overweight-iype dietary pattern in 30 to 49 year old adults. Korean J Comm Nutr 7 (4): 495-505
  17. Report on 1998 National Health and Nutrition Survey (Dietary Intake Survey) (I999): Korea Health Industry Development Institute In Ministry of Health and Wealth
  18. Rimm EB, Giovannucci EL, Stampfer MJ, Colditz GA, Litin LB, Willett WC (I992): Reproducibility and validity of an expanded selfadministered semiquantitative food frequency among male health professionals. Am J Epidemiol Ysb: 1114-1126
  19. Sauvaget C, Allen N, Hayashi M, Spencer E, Nagano J (2002) Validation of a food frequency questionnaire in the Hiroshima/Nagasaki Life Span Study. J EpidemioI 12(5): 394-401
  20. Sempos CT, Johnson NE, Smith EL, Gilligan C (1985): Effects of inttaindividual and interindividual variation in repeated dietary records. Am J Epidemiol 121 (1): 120-130 https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a113974
  21. Toki.dome S, Imaeda N, Tokudome Y, Fujiwara N, Nagaya T, Sato J, Kuriki K, Ikeda M, Maki S (200I): Relative validity of a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire versus 28 day weighed diwt records in Japanese female ietitians. Eur J Clin Nutr 55 (9): 735-742
  22. Vucl.ovic N, Ritenbaugh C, Taren DL, Tobar M (2000): A qualitative study of participants' experiences with dietary assessment. J Am Diet Assoc 100(9): 1023-1028
  23. Willett WC, Samposn L, Brown ML, Stampfer MJ, Rosner B, Hennekens CU, Speizer FE (1988): The use of a self-administered questionnaire to asses diet four years in the past. Am J Epidemiol 127: 188-199 https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a114780
  24. Yanek LR, Moy TF, Raqueno JV, Becker DM (2000): Comparison of the effectiveness of a telephone 24-hour dietary recall method vs an in-person ethod among urban African-American women. J Am Diet Assoc 100(10): 1172-1177
  25. 이정원，이미숙，김정희，손숙미，0]보숙 (2001) : 영양판정， 교문사