기술혁신학회지 (Journal of Korea Technology Innovation Society)

  • 제5권1호
  • /
  • Pages.90-109
  • /
  • 2002
  • /
  • 1598-2912(pISSN)
  • /
  • 2713-8666(eISSN)
한국기술혁신학회 (Korea Technology Innovation Society)
권호 표지

다속성 효용분석을 이용한 원자력연구개발과제 사후평가지표 개발

A multi-attribute index for evaluating of national nuclear R&D prniects in Korea: multi-attribute utility analysis

  • 발행 : 2002.03.01
PDF 다운로드
⟨ 이전 논문 다음 논문 ⟩

초록

The national nuclear R&D projects have been implemented for the purpose of supply of nuclear power which was proved to be safety and stability. Evaluating the national nuclear R&D projects has critical importance in nu-clear energy management aspect. This paper employs multi-attribute utility analysis as a basis for obtaining an evaluation index to assess the national nuclear R&D projects using a specific case study of Korea. To structure and quantify basic values for the evaluation, we elicited important attributes, then refined and structured them into a hierarchy. A multi-attribute index is constructed as a multi-attribute utility function, based on value judgments provided by a group of technical experts, policy makers, and faculties. As a result, the objective of attainment of a proposed object is given the highest priority, followed by appropriateness of project and research strategy, utilization of research output, within attribute ranges defined for the attributes. We found that the work and results of this study can provide valuable insights and decision opportunities for virtually all major decision making in evaluation of the national nuclear R&D projects in Korea.

키워드

참고문헌

  1. 1999년 원자력산업 산업실태 조사보고서 과학기술부
  2. 선도기술개발사업 성과분석 및 추진방향에 관한 연구 과학기술부
  3. 원자력진흥종합계획 2001 세부사업추진 계획 과학기술부
  4. 연구기관 종합평가를 위한 평가요소의 개발과 가중치 설정 연구 과학기술정책연구원
  5. 기술혁신학회지 v.2 no.2 연구개발사업 우선순위 설정에 있어서 다속성 효용이론과 계층분석과정의 비교 박주형;김정흠
  6. 에너지정책 Highlight 산업자원부
  7. 정보통신정책연구 v.7 no.1 전파자원 관리에 대한 의사결정분석: 다속성 효용이론의 적용을 중심으로 유승훈;김준상;김태유
  8. 의사결정론 이윤종
  9. 박사학위논문 연구개발사업의 메타 평가에 관한 연구 이찬구
  10. 다기준 의사결정론 이창효
  11. 국가혁신시스템 강화를 위한 국가연구개발사업 평가방법 연구 임윤철;이철원;이정원
  12. 예비타당성조사 수행을 위한 다기준분석 방안 연구 한국개발연구원
  13. 첨단기술의 기술가치 평가방법론에 대한 연구 한국과학기술평가원
  14. IIE Transactions v.24 A Comparison of the analytic hierarchy process with multiattribite utility theory: a case study Bard,J.F.
  15. Operations Research v.36 Sensitivity analysis of additive multiattribute value models Barron,H.;Schmidt,C.P.
  16. Research Policy v.24 Evaluating technology innovation program: the use of comparison groups to identify impacts Brown,M.A.;Curlee,T.R.;Elliott,S.R.
  17. Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis v.6 A simple trade-off condition for additive multiattribute utility Delquie,P.;Luo,M.
  18. Risk Analysis v.7 Public values in risk debates Edwards,W.;D.von winterfedt
  19. Management Science v.30 State of the art: utility assessment methods Farquhar,P.H.
  20. Medical and Pediatric Supplement v.1 Multiattribute approach to the assessment of health-related quality of life: health utility index Feeny,D.;Furlong,W.;Barr,R.D.
  21. Operation Research v.13 Independence in utility theory with whole products sets Fishburn,P.C.
  22. Energy Policy v.27 Computational methods for planning and evaluating geothermal energy projects Goumas,M.G.;Lygerou,V.A.;Papayannakis,L.E.
  23. IEEE Transactions on System, Man and Cybernetics v.SMC-16 no.3 What can we learn from experiments in multiobjective analysis? Hobbs,B.F.
  24. Energy decisions and the environment: a guide to the use of multicriteria methods Hobbs,B.F.;Meier,P.
  25. Journal of the Operational Research Society v.41 A multiattribute value model for the study of UK energy policy Jones,M.;Hope,C.;Hughes,R.
  26. Energy v.22 Methodology and evaluation of priorities for energy and environmental research projects Kagazyo,T.;Kaneko,K.;Akai,W.;Hilikata,K.
  27. Operation Research v.30 Decision analysis: an overview Keeney,R.L.
  28. Value-focused thinking: a path to creative decisionmaking Keeney,R.L.
  29. Risk Analysis v.14 Managing nuclear waste from power plants Keeney,R.L.;von Winterfeldt,D.
  30. Journal of Environmental planning and Management v.41 Applying multi-attribute utility theory to decision-making in environmental planning: a case study of the electric utility in Korea Kim,T.Y.;Kwak,S.J.;Yoo,S.H.
  31. Environmental Management v.29 A multiattribute index for assessing environmental impacts of regional development projects: a case study of Korea Kwak,S.J.;Yoo,S.H.;Shin,C.O.
  32. Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis v.6 Decomposition, interdependence and precision in multiattribute utility measurement Lam,P.;Moskowitz,H.;Eppel,T.;Tang,J.
  33. Research Policy v.25 Evaluation of national R&D projects in Korea Lee,M.;Son,B.;Om,K.
  34. Energy Policy v.22 Sustainability, value trade offs, and electric utility planning McDaniels,T.L.
  35. Journal of Environmental Management v.46 A multiattribute index for evaluating environmental impacts of electric utilities McDaniels,T.L.
  36. Electric Power Systems Research v.46 Multiattribute utility analysys with imprecise information: an enhanced decision support technique for the evaluation of electric generation expension strategies Pan,J.P.;Rahman,S.
  37. Report to Environment Canada, DOE FRAP 1994-08 A critique of analytical approaches for full cost accounting Roessler,C.;McDaniels,T.L.
  38. Ecological Economics v.36 Experimenting with multi-attribute utility survey methods in a multi-dimensional valuation problem Russell,C.;Dale,V.;Lee,J.;Jensen,M.H.;Kane,M.;Gregory,R.
  39. Journal of Multicriteria Decision Analysis v.5 Robustness of additive value function methods in MCDM Stewart,T.J.
  40. Decision Analysis and Behavioral Research von Winterfeldt, D.;Edwards,W.
  41. Telecommunications Policy v.25 Value-focused thinking about strategic management of radio spectrum for mobile communications in Korea Yoo,S.H.;Kim,J.S.;Kim,T.Y.