A Comparison of Restoration Schemes in Multiprotocol Label Switching Networks

MPLS망의 보호 복구 기술의 비교

  • 오승훈 (숭실대학교 정보통신공학과) ;
  • 김영한 (숭실대학교 정보통신전자공학부)
  • Published : 2002.04.01

Abstract

This paper investigates the restoration schemes which are applied to the MPLS domain upon a network failure. We define the following three restoration service models by combining the various restoration schemes: "FIS-based protection service" (FIS: failure indication signal), "inversion traffic protection service" and "1+1 protection service". After a qualitative analysis of the performance in them, we have analyzed it on quantitative basis by the simulation. According to the simulation results, "1+1 protection service" guarantees the fastest and most lossless restoration service among them; however, it results in consuming considerable bandwidth and producing an amount of control traffic, which means poor network utilization. On the other hand, "FIS-based protection service" spends less bandwidth and generates less control traffic, which means better network utilization, but produces poor restoration service. "Inversion traffic protection service" provides the medium restoration service and utilization between "1+1 protection service" and "FIS-based protection service."

Keywords

References

  1. Li Mo, 'General Considerations for Bandwidth Reservation in Protection,' IETF Draft, Jul. 2000. draft-mo-mpls-protection-00.txt
  2. Dimitry Haskin, et.al., 'A Method for setting an Altemative Label Switched Paths to Handle Fast Reroute,' IETF Draft, Nov. 2000. draft-haskin-mpls-fast-reroute- 05.txt
  3. Ken Owens, Srinivas Makam. et. al., 'A Path Protction/Restoration Mechanism for MPLS networks,' IETF Draft, Nov. 2000. draft-chan-mpls-path-protction-02.txt
  4. Thomas M. Chen and Tae H. Oh, 'Reliable Services in MPLS,' IEEE Comm Magazine 11 1999, pp. 58-62
  5. Vishal Sharma, Ben-Mach Crane, et. al., 'Framework for MPLS-based Recovery,' IETF Draft, Jul. 2001. draft-ietf-mpls-recovery-frmwrk-03.txt
  6. Andrea Fumagalli and Luca Valcarenghi, 'IP Restoration vs. WDM Protection Is There an Optimal Choice?,' IEEE Network Magazine, Nov 2000, pp. 34-41
  7. D. Awduche et al., 'Multi-Protocol Lambda Switching: Combinging MPLS Traffic Engineering Control With Optical Crossconnects,' IETF Draft, Nov. 1999. draftawduche-mpls-te- optical-03-txt
  8. Fiffi Hellstrand, et.al., 'Extensions to CR-LDP and RSVP-TE for setup of pre-established recovery tunnels,' IETF Draft, Nov. 2000. draft-hellstrand-mpls- recovery-merge-01 .txt
  9. Robert Goguen, Geoge Swallow, et. al., 'RSVP Label Allocation for Backup Tunnels,' IETF Draft, Nov. 2000. draft-swallow-rsvp-bypass-label-01.txt
  10. John Bicknel, C.Edward Chow, and Sami syed, 'Performance Analysis of Fast Distributed Network Restoration Algorithms,' Globecom '93 IEEE vol. 3, 1993 pp. 1596-1600