Journal of Nutrition and Health

The Korean Nutrition Society (한국영양학회)
권호 표지

Comparison of Dietary Intakes by 24-hr Dietary Recall, Dietary Record and Food Frequency Questionnaire among Elderly People

회상법, 기록법 및 식품섭취빈도조사법을 이용한 노인의 영양소 섭취 수준의 비교

  • Published : 2001.09.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Nutrient intakes estimated using a 24-hr recall, a dirt record and a food frequency questionnaire(FFQ) were compared in a group of ninety-four elderly people(21 males, 73 females) in Cheongju, a city in Chung-Buk province. Mean intakes for energy, protein, Ca, p, Na, K thiamin and niacin obtained from the diet record were higher than those from the 24-hr recall. Mean intakes for energy, protein, Ca, P, Na, K thiamin, niacin and vitamin C from the FFQ were higher than those obtained from the 24-hr recall or the diet record. Correlation coefficients between the nutrient intake values from the 24-hr recall and those from the diet record ranged from 0.84 to 0.95 and were significantly correlated(p < 0.001). About 80% of the subjects in the lowest quintile by the 24-hr recall were also in the lowest two quintiles by the diet record. While the percentage fallen into the opposite category ranged from 0% to 15%. For most nutrients, at least 65% of the subjects when classified by the 24-hr recall fell into the same quintile when classified by the diet record, and the mean kappa value was 0.7. About 52% of the subjects in the lowest category by the 24-hr recall fell into the lowest two categories by FFQ. The mean percentage of the subjects in the lowest quintile by the diet record or in the lowest two quintiles by the FFQ was 51%. For most nutrients, at least 24% of each of the subjects when classified by both the 24-hr recall and the diet record fell into the same category when classified by the FFQ. The kappa values between the 24-hr recall or the diet recall and the FFQ were 0.17. These data indicate that in elderly subjects the 24-hr recall can provide very similar information to that obtained from the diet record but the FFQ can not provide good information if the right FFQ method is not used for only elderly subjects.

Keywords

References

  1. Korean J Nutrition v.26 no.6 Nutritional status of korean elderly people Kang,M.H.
  2. National Health & Nutrition Survey Report The Ministry of Health & Welfare
  3. Am J Clim Nutr v.47 Methodologic consideration for investigating the diet-cancer link Hebert,J.R.;Miller,D.R.
  4. J Am Diet Assoc v.87 Improving the use of dietary survey methodology Karkeck ,J.M.
  5. J Am Dietet Assoc v.84 Two year dietary survey of middle-aged women:Reported dietary records as a measure of usual intake Sempos,C.T.;Johnson,N.E.;Smith,E.L.;Gilligan,C.A.
  6. Am J Clin Nutr v.36 Evaluation of a self-ad-ministered dietary questionnaire for use in a cohort study Jain,M.G.;Harrison,L.;Howe,G.R.;Miller,A.B.
  7. J Am Diet Assoc v.78 Validity of a dietary score for assessing nutrient adequacy Guthrie,H.A.;Scheer,J.C.
  8. J Am Diet Assoc v.93 Reproducibility and validity of food intake measurements from a semiquantitativefood frequency questionnaire Feskanich,D.;Rimm,E.B.;Grovannucci,E.L.;Colditz,G.A.;Stampfer,M.J.;Litin,L.B.;Willett,W.C.
  9. Am J Clin Nutr v.36 The validity of a telephone-administered 24-hour dietary recall methodology Posner,B.M.;Borman,C.L.;Morgan,J.L.;Borden,W.S.;Ohls,J.C.
  10. Am J Clin Nutr v.38 Validation of a dietary questionnaire with plasma carotenoid and α-tocopherol levels Willett,W.C.;Stampfer,M.J.;Underwood,B.A.;Speizer,F.E.;Rosner,B.;Hennekens,C.H.
  11. J Am Diet Assoc v.92 Validity of the estimated food diary: Comparison of 2-day recorded and observed food and nutrient intakes Karvetti,R.L.;Knuts,L.R.
  12. Am J Clin Nutr v.39 Validity of a food frequency questionnaire for the determination of individual food intake Mullen,B.J.;Krantzler,N.J.;Grivetti,L.E.;Schutz,H.G.;Meiselman,H.L.
  13. Korean Journal of Epidemiology v.16 no.1 Semiquantitative food frequency method as an epidemiological tool in a rural community Stuff,J.E.;Lee,S.S.;Choi,B.Y.;Shin,Y.J.;Cho,Y.S.;Ahn,Y.O.
  14. Korean J Nutrition v.28 no.9 Development and validation of food frequency questionnaire for dietary assesment of Korean adults in rural area Paik HY;Ryu JY;Choi JS;Ahn YJ;Moon HK;Park YS;Lee HK;KimYI
  15. Korean J Community Nutrition v.2 no.3 The development and evaluation of a simple semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire to assess the dietary intake of adults in large cities Lee,H.J.;Lee,H.S.;Ha,M.J.;Kye,S.H.;Kim,C.I.;Lee,C.W.;Yoon,J.S.
  16. Korean Journal of Epidemiology v.16 no.1 Semiquantitative food frequency method as an epidemiological tool in a rural community Kim,M.K.;Lee,S.S.;Choi,B.Y.;Shin,Y.J.;Cho,Y.S.;Ahn,Y.O.
  17. J Korean Soc Food v.24 no.6 Differences in Nutrient intakes analysed by using food frequency and recall method Kim,Y.O.
  18. Korean J Nutrition v.31 no.2 A study on development and validation of food frequency questionnaire for Koreans Kim,W.Y.;Yang,E.J.
  19. Korean J Community Nutrition v.3 no.2 Validity of self-administered semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire by conditions of one portion size Kim,M.J.;Kim,Y.O.;Kim,S.I.
  20. Korean J Nutrition v.24 no.2 Comparison of dietary methods for the determination of energy intake Kim,S.Y.;Yoon,J.S.
  21. Korean J Nutrition v.22 no.1 Comparison of dietary method in nutritional studies Kim,H.K.;Yoon,J.S.
  22. Korean J Nutrition v.25 no.2 Evaluation of methods used in nutrition surveys in Korea(1960-1990) Choi,Y.S.;Park,M.H.
  23. Master's thesis,Sookmyung Women's University Assessment of dietary intake pattern by recall, record and frequency method in female university Lee,H.Y.
  24. Nutritional epidemiology Food Frequency methods Willett,W.C.;Willett,W.C.(ed.)
  25. Korean J Community Nutrition v.1 no.3 Reproducibility and validity of a self-adminitered semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire Kim,M.K.;Lee,S.S.;Ahn,Y.O.
  26. Korean J Nutrition v.22 no.3 A study on the nutritional status and health condition of elderly woman living in urban community Kim,H.K.;Yoon,J.S.
  27. British Journal of Nutrition v.70 Validity of a short food frequency questionnaire for estimation nutrient intake in elderly people Horwath,C.C.
  28. Korean J Community Nutrition v.3 no.2 Validity of self-administered semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire by conditions of one portion size Kim,M.J.;Kim,Y.O.;Kim,S.I.
  29. Korean J Nutrition v.29 no.9 Comparison of the levels of nutrient intakes by different dietary methods and days of dietary studies among young females in Korea Oh,S.Y.;Lee,H.Y.;Paik,H.Y.
  30. J Korean Soc Food Nutr v.24 no.6 Differences in nutrient intakes analysed by using food frequency and recall method Kim,Y.O.
  31. Korean J of Home Economics v.36 no.1 Comparative assessment of nutrient intake and quality obtained by food frequency questionnaire and 24-hour recall method in Korean adults living in rural area Lee,S.Y.;Paik,H.Y.
  32. J Am Diet Assoc v.68 Validity of the 24-hr recall: analysis of data obtained from elderly subjects Madden,J.P.;Goodman,J.S.;Guthrie,H.A.
  33. J Am Diet Assoc v.74 Nutrient estimates from computerized questionnaires vs 24-hr. recall interviews Hunt,I.F.;Luke,L.S.;Murphy,N.J.;Clark,V.A.;Coulson,A.H.
  34. Am J Epidemiol v.124 Total energy intake: Implications for epidemiologic analysis Willett,W.C.;Stampfer,M.J.
  35. Korean J Nutrition v.28 no.8 Study on the agreement of food frequency questionnaires according to the methods of collecting portion size Han,M.H.;Kim,M.K.;Lee,S.S.;Choi,B.Y.
  36. J Am Diet Assoc v.87 Validation of a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire: Comparison with a 1-year diet record Willett,W.C.;Reynolds;Cottrell-Hoehner,S.C.;Sampson,L.;Browne,M.L.
  37. Am J Epidemiol v.125 Author's response to invited commentary:Some limitation of semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire Rimm,E.B.;Edward,L.;Giovannucci,E.;Stampfer,M.J.;Colditz,G.A.;Lintin,L.B.;Willett,W.C.
  38. Am J Epidemiol v.134 Variability and tracking of nutrient intakes of preschool children based on multiple administration of the 24-hour dietary recall Stein,A.D.;Basch,C.E.;Contento,I.R.;Zybert,P.
  39. Am J Epidemiol v.135 Reproducibility and validity of an expanded semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire among male health professionals Rimm,E.B.;Giovannucci,E.L.;Stampfer,M.J.;Colditz,G.A.;Litin,L.B.;Willett,W.C.
  40. Am J Epidemiol v.122 Reproducibility and validity of a semiquantitative food frequency questionnaire Willett,W.C.;Sampson,L.;Stampfer,M.J.;Rosner,B.;Bain,C.;Witschi,J.;Hennekons,C.H.;Speizer,F.E.
  41. Statistical methods for rates and proportions(2nd ed.) Fleiss,J.L.
  42. Am J Epidemiol v.128 Reproducibility and validity of dietary assessment instruments Pietinen;Hartman,A.M.;Haapa,E.;Haapakoski,J.;Palagren,J.;Albanes,D.;Virtamo,J.;Huttunen,J.K.