Journal of Korea Technology Innovation Society (기술혁신학회지)

Korea Technology Innovation Society (한국기술혁신학회)
권호 표지

Comparative Analysis on the Evaluation Systems of the Public R&D Programs in the Developed Countries

선진국공공연구개발프로그램 평가시스템의 비교분석

  • 홍형득 (국립 밀양대학교 행정학과)
  • Published : 2001.12.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The frameworks for evaluation of national R&D programs reflect their various political and administrative cultures(Gibbons & Georghiou, 1987), and the structure of national R&D system. In this research the core research questions are : what is god evaluation\ulcorner What is being evaluated, by whom, by which criteria, for whom and what purpose\ulcorner In order to examine these general aims and answer these questions, in detail several objectives can be proposed on the process of this research. In this research, the national R&D programs will be considered in terms of the interface between evaluation and the wider policy-making process. The programs for case study are the Alvey program(UK), the Advanced Technology Program (US) and the Framework program(EU) . One of the characteristics of these programs is the well established evaluation systems they have. From the comparative analysis, we can withdraw some useful implication for Korean evaluation practice for national R&D programs. Evaluation system is social process and the way in which it is organized is critical to its outcome.

Keywords

References

  1. 정부연구개발프로그램체계의 비교분석과 향후평가체계구축방안 황용수(외)
  2. General Terms and Conditions - Advanced Technology programme ATP
  3. Programme Evaluation: a Practitioner's Guide for Trainers and Educators Brinkerhoff,R.O.;D.M.Brethower;T.Hluchyj;J.R.Nowakowski
  4. EU RTD Programmes Impacts/Results Assessment: a Manifold Task in a Complex System. Evaluation of Science and Technology in the New Europe Dumont,Y.;L.Durieux;L.Karatzas;L.O'Sullivan;H.Teuber;G.Stroud;G.Fayl
  5. IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management v.30 no.3 Quantitative Indicators for Evaluation of Basic Research Program and Project Frame,J.D.
  6. The Evaluation Synthesis GAO
  7. Measuring Performance: the Measuring Performance: the Advanced Technology Program and Private-Sector Funding GAO
  8. Orgaization of Evaluation. the Evaluation of Scientific Research-Ciba Foundation Conference Georghiou,L.
  9. Evaluation of Research Georghiou,L.
  10. Research Evaluation v.5 no.1 Research evaluation in European National Science and Technology Systems Georghiou,L.
  11. Research Policy v.30 Evaluating Technology Programs: Tools and Methods Georghiou,L.;D.Roessner
  12. The Advenced Technology Programme: Challenges and Opportunities Perspectives on the Programme Goldston,D.;Wessner.C.W.(ed.)
  13. Evaluation of Alvey Programme for Information Technology Guy,K.;P.Georghiou;L.Quintas;M.Hobday;H.Carmeron;T.Ray
  14. Evaluation of the Alvey Programme-Interim Report Guy,K.;L.Georghiou;L.Quintas;M.Hobday;H.Cameron;T.Ray
  15. The Advanced Technology Programme: Challenges and Opportunities An Overview of the ATP's History and Objectives Hill,C;Wessner,C.W.(ed.)
  16. Technovation v.8 Evaluation Collaborative R&D Programmes in Information Technology: the Case of U.K. Alvey Programme Hobday,M.
  17. Journal of Technology Transfer v.23 no.2 The Importance of Spillovers in the Policy Mission of the Advanced Technology Program Jaffe,A.B.
  18. The Programme Evaluation Standards Joint Committee on Standard for Educational Evaluation
  19. Advanced Technology Program: Economic Study Printed Wiring Board Joint Venture After Two Years Link,A.N.
  20. The ITPS Report Additionality of Publicly-Funded RTD Programmes Luukkenen,T
  21. Alvey: Britain's Strategic Computing Initiative Oakley,Brian;Kenneth Owen
  22. Research Policy v.18 no.6 Evaluating Government Innovation Programmes: Lessons from the US Experience Roessner,D.
  23. Guidlines for Economic Evaluation of the Advanced Technology Program Ruegg,R.
  24. The Journal Technology Transfer v.23 no.2 The Advanced Technology Programme, Its evaluation Plan, and Progress in Implementation Ruegg,R.
  25. Evaluation Thesaurus(4th) Scriven,M.
  26. Evaluating Action Programs Action for What? A Critique of Evaluative Research Suchman,E.A.;Weiss.C.H.(ed.)
  27. Evaluation Research: Methods of Assessing Program Effectiveness Weiss,C.H.
  28. Using Social Research in Public Policy Making Weiss,C.H.(ed.)
  29. Evalultion-Methods for Studying Programs amd Policies Weiss,C.H.