Research on the Relation between Musculoskeletal symptoms and Diagnosis using Moire Topography among Workers at an Automobile Manufacturing Plant

자동차회사 근로자를 대상으로 한 근골격계 자각증상과 moire 영상 진단과의 관계 연구

  • Chun Eun-Joo (Dept. of Third Medicine, Professional Graduate School, Wonkwang University) ;
  • Lee Young-Gil (Environment & Safety Team, Hyundai Motor Company) ;
  • Jahng Doo-Sub (Institute of industrial Ecological Sciences, University of Occupational & Environmental Health) ;
  • Lee Ki-Nam (Dept. of Third Medicine, Professional Graduate School, Wonkwang University) ;
  • Song Yung-Sun (Dept. of Third Medicine, Professional Graduate School, Wonkwang University)
  • 천은주 (원광대학교 한의학전문대학원 제3의학과) ;
  • 이영길 (현대자동차 진주환경안전팀) ;
  • 장두섭 (일본 산업의과대학 산업생태학연구소) ;
  • 이기남 (원광대학교 한의학전문대학원 제3의학과) ;
  • 송용선 (원광대학교 한의학전문대학원 제3의학과)
  • Published : 2001.12.29

Abstract

The purposes of this study were to offer foundation making more certain standards of musculoskeletal disorder diagnosis, We researched musculoskeletal symptoms degrees, frequencies, and cares and then examined relation between musculoskeletal symptoms and diagnosis of musculoskeletal conditions using moire topography among workers at an automobile manufacturing plant. Therefore we propose the possibility of moire topography as diagnosing utilities of musculoskeletal disorders. Methods: This study was to examine the general characteristics, complaints of musculoskeletal symptoms, and work-related musculoskeletal disorder rates of cervicobrachial and lumbar area by survey among 435 workers at an automobile manufacturing plant and then to show each frequency and percentage, In the diagnosis using moire topography, we studied pain control necessity of cervicobrachial and lumbar area, 435 subjects were classified by 5 levels: A(no symptoms), B(need management), C(need treatment) and then more divided by B1(light symptoms)/B2(heavy symptoms), C1(light symptoms)/C2(heavy symptoms), And musculoskeletal areas were divided by 2 parts, cervicobrachial area(neck, shoulder, arm&elbow, and wrist&hand) and lumbar area, Then, frequency and percentage of each musculoskeletal areas(cervicobrachial and lumbar area) were appeared. At last, Pearson's chi-square test analysis was utilized to observe the relation between diagnosis using moire topography and general characteristics and the relation between diagnosis using moire topography and work-related complaint of musculoskeletal symptoms of cervicobrachial and lumbar area, Results: The subjects employed for this research were categorized into; by gender, all of them were males(l00%): by age, under 35 years 12 %, 36-40 years 56.3%, 41-45 years 26.3 %, and above 46 years 5.3% with 36-40 years accounting for most of it. By living location, owned houses represented 69.7%, rented houses 23.4%, monthly-rented 1.6%, the others 5.3%; by education, middle school and lower represented 3.0%, high school 89.4%, and junior college and higher 7.6% with high school occupying most of the group. By marital status, married represented 95.2%, unmarried 4.1%, and the others 0.7% with most of them married; by alcohol, drinking represented 81.8% and non-drinking 18.2%; by smoking status, smoking represented 53.6%, non-smoking 46.4% with no big difference between them. By working time(hours/week), below 50 represented 26.9%, 50-60 67.6%, above 60 5.5%; by working time(hours/day), below 9 represented 21.6%, 10-12 73.1%, above 13 5.3%; by job tenure(years), below 10 represented 25.1%, 11-15 54.3%, 16-20 15.2%, above 21 5.5%. By personal income per year, below 30 million won represented 11.0%, 30-40 84.8%, above 40 4.1%; by sleeping hours, below 6 hours represented 26.7%, 7-8 hours 69.9%, above 9 hours 3.4%. Complaint rates of musculoskeletal symptoms and work-related musculoskeletal disorder rates were 63.9% and 54.9% with shoulder area occupying most of both them. By pain degree of musculoskeletal symptoms, shoulder area represented $2.73{\pm}0.84$, lumbar area $2.66{\pm}0.86$, wrist and hand area $2.59{\pm}0.86$, neck area $2.55{\pm}0.74$, and arm and elbow area $2.48{\pm}0.71$. By cares about musculoskeletal symptoms, taking medication or care represented 34.4%-46.7%, absence or leave 15.4%-28.7%, and job transfer 6.3%-11.5%. So experienced cases more than one thing among cares about musculoskeletal symptoms represented 39.6%-54%. In the diagnosis using moire topography, pain control necessity of cervicobrachial area was shown below; A(no symptoms) 20.7%, B1(need management/light symptoms) 64.6%, B2(need management/heavy symptoms) 11.5%, C1(need treatment/light symptoms) 3.0%, C2(need treatment/heavy symptoms) 0.2%. By lumbar area, A(no symptoms) 8.7%, B1(need management/light symptoms) 52.2%, B2(need management/heavy symptoms) 30.3%, C1(need treatment/light symptoms) 8.7%, C2(need treatment/heavy symptoms) was none. In the relation between pain control necessity and general characteristics, age(P=0.013), education(P=0.000), and job tenure(P=0.012) with pain control necessity showed differences with significance. The relation between pain control necessity and complaint of musculoskeletal symptoms of cervicobrachial and lumbar area showed no difference with significance; in cervicobrachial area represented P=0.708, lumbar area P=0.318 Conclusions: This study for musculoskeletal symptoms on workers at automobile manufacturing plant showed that complaint rates of musculoskeletal symptoms for cervicobrachial and lumbar area were so high, 63.9%. But Pearson's chi-square test analysis was utilized to study the relation between musculoskeletal symptoms and the diagnosis using moire topography, showed no differences with significance. They have no differences with significance, but the prevalence rates of diagnosis using moire topography for cervicobrachial and lumbar area were more higher than complaint rates of musculoskeletal symptoms; complaint rates of musculoskeletal symptoms were 52.4%, 34.5% and the diagnosis using moire topography were 79.3%, 91.3% for cervicobrachial and lumbar area. The results of this study indicate that the diagnosis using moire topography can find weak musculoskeletal disorders that an individual can not feel, not be judged work-related musculoskeletal disease. Therefore, this study has an important meaning that diagnosis using moire topography can predict and control own physical condition complete musculoskeletal disorders beforehand, since oriental medicine theory considers that prevention is important.

Keywords

References

  1. Scand J Work Environ Health v.11 no.6 Work with video display terminals among office employees : III. opthalmologic factors Boose, S.R.;Calissendorff, B.M.;Knave, B.G.;Nyman, K.G.;Voss, M.
  2. 원광대학교 석사논문 미용사들의 직업관련성 근골격계 장애에 관한 조사 김성천
  3. 모아레무늬의 영상해석에 관한 고찰 박영회;이종수
  4. 대한산업의학회지 v.1 no.2 여성 국제 전화 교환원들에 있어서의 경견완장애 -자각증상- 박정일;조경환;이승한
  5. J Occup Med v.23 Personal and occupational factors associated with carpal tunnel syndrome Cannon, L.J.;Bernacki, E.J.;Walter, S.P.
  6. Jour Occup Med v.34 Prevalence of back pain and joint problems in a manufacturing company Cecil, M.;Burchiel, C.M.;John, A.;Boice, J.A.;Beth, A.;Stafford, B.A.;Gregory, G.;Bond, G.G.
  7. AJPH v.74 no.6 Epidemiology of musculoskeletal impairments and associated disability Cunningham, L.S.;Kelsey, J.L.
  8. Annu Rev Publ Health v.12 Upper-Extremity musculoskeletal disorders of occupational origin Gerr, F.;Letz, R.;Landrigan, P.J.
  9. Design of VDT workstations. Handbook of human factors Grandjean, E.
  10. Br Jour Ind Med v.44 Prevalence rates and odds ratio of shoulder-neck disease in different occupational groups Hagberg, M.;Wegman, D.H.
  11. Am J Phy Med v.60 no.3 Electromyographic signs of shoulder muscular fatigue in two elevated arm position Hagberg, M.
  12. Ergonomic v.37 no.10 Musculoskeletal disorders among visual display terminal rsers in telecommunication company Hales, T.R.;Sauter, S.L.;Peterson, M.R.;Fine, L.J.;Putz-Anderson, V.;Schlefier, L.R.;Ochs, T.T.;Bernard, B.P.
  13. Scand J Work Environ Health v.9 Neck and upper limb disorders among slaughter house workers Juntura, E.V.
  14. Scan J Work Environ Health v.11 no.6 Work with video display terminals among office employees : I. subjective symptoms and discomfort Knave, B.G.;Wibom, R.I.;Voss, M.;Hedstrom, L.D.;Bergqvist, U.O.
  15. JOM v.22 no.12 Socalized fatigue in accounting machine operators Maeda, K.;Hunting, W.;Grandjean, E.
  16. Industrial Medicine v.39 no.11 Investigation of the relation between low back pain and occupation Magora, A.
  17. NIOSH report NO. PB 93-188-456 NIOSH health hazard evaluation report National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health(NIOSH)
  18. Scand J Work Environ Health no.2 Musculoskeletal symptom among sewing machine operators Schibye, B.;Skov, T.;Ender, D.;Cristiansen, J.U.;Suogard, g.
  19. Aviat space Environ Med v.67 no.5 Back pain in aircrew: An initial survey Sheard, S.C.;McMillan, G.H.
  20. Am J Ind Med v.11 Occupational factors and carpal tunnel syndrome Silverstein, B.A.;Fine, L.J.;Armstong, T.J.
  21. Ame Ind Med v.15 Self-reported musculoskeletal complaints among garment workers Sokas, R.K.;Spiegelman, D.;Wegman, D.H.
  22. Appl Occup Environ Hyg v.10 no.10 Evaluation of work-related musculoskeletal disorders and job stress among teleservice center representatives Tharr, D.;Editon, C.
  23. Applied Ergonomics v.19 no.3 Musculoskeletal Symptoms as related to working conditions among Swedish professional fishermen Torner, M.;Blide, G.;Efiksson, H.;Karlsson, R.;Petersen, I.
  24. Jour Accup Med v.34 no.6 Personal and job Characteristics of musculoskeletal injuries in an Industrial population Tsai, S.P.;Gilstrap, E.L.;Colwes, S.R.
  25. British Jour of Ind Med v.49 Individual and work related factors associated with symptoms of musculoskeletal complaint II: Different risk factors among sewing machine operators Westgaard, R.H.;Jansen, T.
  26. Visual Display Terminals and Worker's Health World Health Organization
  27. 대한산업의학회지 v.8 no.3 VDT작업자에서 업무로 인한 정신사회적 스트레스에 대한 인지가 근골격계 장애에 미치는 영향 권호장;하미나;윤덕로;조수헌;강대희(등)
  28. 대한산업보건협회지 v.6 직업성 근골격계질환(I) 김규상
  29. 산업보건의 이해 김남송;이종섭(편저)
  30. 대한산업의학회지 v.10 no.2 VDT작업자에서 어깨 근육 장애와 혈청 CPK의 관련성 김수근;정해관
  31. 대한산업의학회지 v.9 no.2 전자렌지 조립작업자에서 발생한 경견완증후군의 조사연구(III)-작업자세를 중심으로- 김양옥;박종;류소연;이철갑
  32. 대한산업의학회지 전자렌지 조립작업자에서 발생한 경견완증후군의 조사연구(I)-설문증상을 중심으로 김양옥;박종;류소연
  33. 대한산업의학회지 v.7 no.2 전자렌지 조립작업자에서 발생한 경견완증후군의 조사연구(II) 김양옥;박종;류소연
  34. 예방의학회지 v.32 no.1 자동차 조립 작업자들에서 상지 근골격계의 인간공학적 작업평가(Rapid Upper Limb Assessment)결과와 자각증상과의 연관성 김재영;최재욱;김해준
  35. 대한예방의학회지 v.31 no.1 상선 승무원들의 근골격계 증상 경험률과 관련요인 김재호;이종영
  36. 보건교육 및 건강증진 남철현
  37. 환자조사보고서 노동부
  38. 노동부고시 제98-15호 단순 반복작업 근로자 작업관리지침
  39. 통증의학 대한통증학회;오흥근(편저)
  40. 영남대학교 석사학위논문 모아레 간섭에 의한 비틀림 응력 측정에 관한 연구
  41. 예방의학회지 v.24 no.3 VDT증후군 자각 증상에 영향을 미치는 인자들에 관한 연구 문재동;이민철;김병우
  42. 대한산업의학회지 v.9 no.1 VDT 작업자의 자각증상에 영향을 미치는 요인 박계열;백기주;지중근;이연수;노재훈
  43. 버스 운전 기사의 요통 위험 요인 분석 연구 박소연
  44. 대한산업의학회지 v.12 no.3 미용사들의 작업관련성 근골격계 장애에 관한 연구 박수경;최영진;문덕환;전진호;이종태;손혜숙
  45. 서울대학교 보건대학원 보건학 석사학위논문 일부 영상단말기(VDT) 작업자의 작업자세에 관한 조사연구 박정근
  46. 대한산업의학회지 v.1 no.1 여성 국제 전화 교환원들에 있어서의 경견완장애 2. 이학적 검사 박정일;조경환;이승한
  47. 대한산업의학회지 v.1 no.2 여성 국제 전화 교환원들에 있어서의 경견완장애. I. 자각적증상 박정일;조경환;이승한
  48. 한방재활의학회지 v.7 no.1 직업병에 대한 연구 서해경;이철완
  49. 산업보건협회지 v.10 보건관리자의 역할과 과제 송인혁
  50. 원색 최신의료대백과사전 신태양사 편집부
  51. 원광대학교 석사학위논문 Moire 영상을 이용한 근골격계 질환의 진단법 연구 유승현
  52. 대한산업의학회지 v.11 no.4 자동차 관련직종 근로자에서 상지 근골격계 증상 호소율과 관련요인 윤철수;이세훈
  53. 예방의학회지 v.25 no.1 모 사업장 포장부서 근로자들에서 발생한 수근터널증후군에 대한 조사연구 이원진;이은일;차철환
  54. 대한예방한의학회지 v.3 no.2 산업보건에의 한의학적 참여방안에 관한 연구 이은경;정명수;천은주;김삼태;강성호;이수경;한종민;김성천;유택수;정재열;송용선;이기남
  55. 대한산업의학회지 v.9 no.1 은행창구작업자의 관한 연구 임상혁;이윤근;조정진;손정일;송재철
  56. 한국과학기술원 박사학위논문 Oder determination and visibility enchancement of moire topographic fringes 임재선
  57. 동의재활의학과학 전국한의과대학 재활의학과학교실(編)
  58. 직업성질환 정규철
  59. 근형상 추나학 정희완;강성호
  60. 인하대학교 석사학위 논문 모아레 토포그라피를 이용한 작물의 Seam Puckering의 정량적 해석에 관한 연구 조성호
  61. 대한산업의학회지 v.8 no.2 반복작업 근로자들에서의 경견완장애에 관한 연구 최재욱;염용태;송동빈;박종태;장성훈;최정애