Comparison of Thallium-201 Scan and Tc-99m Sestamibi Scan in the Differential Diagnosis of Breast Mass

유방암 진단에 있어서 탈륨스캔과 Tc-99m MIBI 스캔의 비교

Purpose: We performed this study to compare T1-201 and Tc-99m MIBI scans for the differentiation of malignant from benign breast mass. Materials and Methods: Thirty-eight female patients underwent T1-201 breast scan and thirty-two of them also underwent Tc-99m MIBI scan of the breast. After intravenous injection of 74-111 MBq of T1-201, early (10 minutes) and delayed (3 hours) images were obtained. Then, 555-740 MBq of Tc-99m MIBI was injected and images after 30 minutes were obtained. We compared T1-201 and Tc-99m MIBI scans with pathologic results. Results: Twenty-three patients were confirmed to have infiltrating duct carcinoma and fifteen patients to have benign breast mass by excisonal biopsy. The sensitivity of early and delayed T1-201 scan and Tc-99m MIBI scan in the detection of malignant breast lesion were 100% (23/23), 82% (18/22), and 90% (18120), respectively. The sensitivity of early T1-201 scan was significantly higher than that of delayed T1-201 scan (p<0.05). The specificity of early and delayed T1-201 scan and Tc-99m MIBI scan were 73% (l1/15), 73% (l1/15) and 83% (10/12), respectively (p: not significant). Three patients out of nine with fibroadenoma and one patient with atypical duct hyperplasia were false positive in both early and delayed T1-201 scans. The size of fibroadenoma with false positive in early and delayed T1-201 scan (4 cases) was larger than that of 11 fibroadenoma with true negative scan (p<0.01). Metastatic axillary lymph node involvement was present in fifteen patients. The sensitivity to detect metastatic nodes was 38% (5/13) for early T1-201 images, 15% (2/13) for delayed T1-201 images, 58% (7/12) for Tc-99m MIBI planar images and 67% (4/6) for Tc-99m MIBI SPECT. The sensitivity of Tc-99m MIBI planar or SPECT was significantly higher than that of delayed T1-201 images (p<0.05). Conclusion: Early T1-201 and Tc-99m MIBI scan are useful noninvasive methods to differentiate malignant from benign mass of breast Tc-99m MIBI scan was sensitive in detecting axillary lymph node metastasis in patients with breast cancer.

목적: 유방종괴의 악성과 양성을 구별하는 데 사용되고 있는 탈륨스캔의 조기스캔 및 지연스캔과 함께 Tc-99m MIBI 스캔을 시행하여 이들을 비교하였다. 대상 및 방법: 유방종괴를 호소한 환자 38명을 대상으로 탈륨의 조기스캔과 지연스캔 및 Tc-99m MIBI 스캔을 얻었다. 탈륨스캔은 74-111 MBq의 탈륨을 정맥주사한 후 10분과 3시간에 촬영을 하고, 이어서 555-740 MBq의 Tc-99m MIBI를 정맥주사하고 30분 후에 전면상과 측면상을 얻어 서로 비교하였다. 결과: 38명의 환자 중 23예가 악성 종양으로, 15예가 양성 종양이었다. 유방암 진단의 민감도와 특이도는 탈륨 조기스캔이 100% (23/23)와 73% (11/15), 탈륨 지연스캔이 82% (18/22)와 73% (l1/15), Tc-99m MIBI 스캔이 90% (18/20)와 83% (10/12)로서 탈륨 조기스캔의 민감도가 탈륨 지연스캔보다 유의하게 높았으나(p<0.05), 다른 지표의 유의한 차이는 없었다. 탈륨 조기스캔과 지연스캔에서 위양성을 보인 섬유선종 3예와 비정형 상피세포증식증 1예의 종괴의 크기는 음성으르 나온 11예의 양성 종양보다 유의하게 컸다(p<0.01). 액와부 림프절 전이의 진단적 민감도는 탈륨 조기스캔이 38% (5/13), 탈륨 지연스캔이 15% (2/13), Tc-99m MIBI 평면스캔이 58% (7/12), 단층영상이 67% (4/6)였다. Tc-99m MIBl 평면, 단층영상이 탈륨 지연스캔보다 높았다. 결론: 유방암 진단에서 탈륨의 조기스캔과 Tc-99m MIBI스캔은 진단능에서 차이가 없었으나 탈륨 지연스캔은 민감도가 낮았다. 액와부 림프절 전이의 진단에는 탈륨스캔보다 Tc-99m MIBI 스캔이 우수하였다.