Clinical Study for Herbal Medicine Therapeutic Effect on the Pediatric Chronic Sinusitis using Plain Radiography and Computed Tomography

소아(小兒) 축농증(蓄膿症)의 한방(韓方) 치료효과(治療效果)에 대한 단순촬영(單純撮影) 및 CT(전산화단층촬영(電算化斷層撮影))를 이용한 임상적(臨床的) 연구(硏究)

  • 이해자 (원광대학교 전주 한방병원 소아과) ;
  • 박은정 (원광대학교 한의과대학) ;
  • 진공용 (전북대학교 진단방사선과)
  • Published : 1999.12.15

Abstract

Background: In recent years, pediatric chronic sinusitis patients who don't respond with antibiotics are increasing, but there are a few reports on the herbal medicine therapy treating pediatric chronic sinusitis, so this report was studied. Objective: To demonstrate the effect of herbal medicine therapy in the chronic sinusitis before and after treatment using computed tomograpy (CT) and plain radiograpy. Materials and methods: Ninty patients (45 mail and 45 femail) treated in our hospital between February 1998 and August 1999 were studied. Ages ranged from 3 to 13 years (mean age :6.5 years). Sixty two patients had a underlyiing family history (allergy or sinusitis of parents or brothers), In the past history, 68 patients had asthma, allergy of milk, atopic dermatitis, bronchiollitis and irritable bowel syndrom. Illness period was from 10 days to 96 months (mean period:12.4 month). Duration of treatment were from 25 days to 200days (mean:96 days). To ascertain the efficacy of treatment, CT in the 42 and plain radiopgrapy in the 48 patients were checked out. In the CT, three images were obtained 2cm interval on the coronal and axial plan. CT findings of the chronic sinusitis were analyzed for mucoperiostal thickening before and after treatment using 4 grades;(normal, mild, moderate, severe). Normal was defined as below 3mm thickening of mucoperiosteum; mild was 3-5mm thickening; moderate was 5mm-1cm thickening; severe was above 1cm thickening. Plain radiograpy using Water's view provided maxillary sinus, anterior ethmoid sinus, frontal sinus. Normal was defined as simillar to density between sinus and oronasal cavity; mild was defined as generally increased density with no significant mucoperiosteal thickning; moderate was partial mucosal thickening without bony hypertropy; severe was total haziness with mucoperiosteal thickening. Gamihyunggyeyungyo-tang was administered mainly. Gamigwaghyangjeungki-san, Gamizwakwi-eum and Gamihyangso-san were administered for through oral route additional symptoms Results: Of the 90 patients, 84 patients showed complete recovery (93%), 4 patients showed no significant interval change(4%) and 2 patients were aggrevated (2%). Sixty patients were severe(67%) and 26 patients were moderate (29%), 4 patients were mild(4%) The duration of treatment was varied with patient conditions (91 days in average); severe were 101.7 days, moderate were 70 days and mild were 63 days. Fifty three patients with maxillary and ethmoid sinusitis were 114 days, 35 patients with maxillary sinusitis only were 71.5 days. Fifty eight patients with both maxillary sinusitis were 94.6 days, 26 patients with either maxillary sinusitis were 65 days. The symtoms of chronic sinusitis were nasal obstruction(75%), cough(69%), purulunt or mucosal discharge(62%), lymphoid follicle(54%), postnasal dripping(49%), headache(23%) and nose bleeding(22%). Conclusion: We know that herbal medicine therapy is the effective treatment of pediatric chronic sinusitis using plain radiograpy and CT. The duration of treatment may be significant assosiation with the location and degree of chronic sinusitis.

Keywords

References

  1. 黃帝內徑 張隱庵;馬元臺(編)
  2. 醫學入門 李挺
  3. 東醫寶鑑 許浚
  4. 景岳全書 張景岳
  5. 醫宗金鑑 卷下 虞搏
  6. 中醫 臨床 大系 北京 中醫學院
  7. 大韓 韓方 小兒科 學會誌 v.3 小兒 鼻淵에 관한 文獻的 考察 朴恩貞
  8. 蒼耳 合濟 治療 慢性 化 膿性 鼻竇炎 628例 v.12;4기 遲玉葉
  9. 實用中西醫結合 雜誌 v.10 中西醫 結合 治療 慢性 鼻膿炎 35例 蔡曉萍
  10. Core Text book of Pediatrics Robert, K.
  11. Pediatrics Maurer, H.M.
  12. New Engl J Med Sinusitis in children Ellen, R.
  13. Otorhinolaryngology Farb, S.N.
  14. Harison's 내과학 Isselbacher, K.J.
  15. Disease of the nose, thraots, ear, head and neck Ballenger, J.J.
  16. Pediatr Infect Dis J. v.23 Sinusitis in Children and Adolescensts Netroton, D.A.
  17. Otolaryngol Clin North Am v.29 Chronic sinusitis Parson, D.S.
  18. Pediatr Clin North Am v.43 Sinusitis in Chlidhood Isaacson, G.
  19. 알레르기와 韓方 丁奎萬
  20. 奇效良方 方賢
  21. 醫學正傳 虞搏
  22. 濟生方 嚴用和
  23. 續名醫類案 魏之琇
  24. 萬病回春 공廷鉉
  25. 類證治裁 林파琴
  26. 古今醫統 秘方 大全 徐春甫
  27. 新刊 濟世全書 공廷賢
  28. 六科准繩 王肯堂
  29. 華佇 神醫 秘典 華佇
  30. Pediatrics Dworkin, P.H.
  31. 中醫 臨床大典 楊思澍
  32. Textbook of otolaryngology Deweese, D.D.
  33. J Pediatr v.127 Chronic sinusitis in Children Warld, E.R.
  34. 荊芥連翹湯과 加味荊芥連翹湯이 消炎,鎭痛 및 항알레르기에 미치는 影饗 申素英
  35. 大韓 韓方 小兒科 學會誌 v.12 小兒鼻淵에 관한 臨床的 硏究 朴恩貞
  36. 河北 中醫學院 學報 v.11 no.1 辯證 治療 慢性 鼻竇炎 80例 賈春芒
  37. 江蘇中醫 v.17;8기 中西醫 結合 治療 鼻息毓 伴 慢性 鼻竇炎 治療 觀察 徐成云
  38. 山西中醫 v.12;4기 中西醫 結合 治療 慢性 鼻竇炎 62例 周德文
  39. 實用 中西醫 結合 雜誌 v.9 中西醫 結合 治療 急慢性 鼻炎 鼻竇炎 100例 治療 觀察 孔紅英
  40. Current medical diagnosis Lawrence, M.
  41. 實用 中西醫 結合 診斷 治療學 陳貴廷;楊思澍
  42. 濟生方 v.56;57 朱숙
  43. 萬病 醫藥 順間 陸靑節
  44. 河南 中醫藥 學刊 v.12 黃芩湯 合 蒼耳子散 治療 慢性 鼻淵 108例 治療觀 察 李景昌
  45. 新編 中醫 臨床手冊 周文川
  46. 中醫 耳鼻咽喉口腔科學 王德監
  47. 幼幼集成 陳復正
  48. 醫學綱目 樓英
  49. 醫方類聚 朝鮮國 集賢殿
  50. 中醫學 南京中醫學院
  51. 臨床診斷治療 楊思澍;陳貴廷
  52. 東洋醫學叢書 卷2 中醫耳鼻咽喉科 交稟廷
  53. 中國中醫秘方大典 中卷 胡信明
  54. 韓方 眼耳鼻咽喉科學 蔡炳允
  55. 大韓 韓醫學會誌 v.15 鼻淵 疾患 (副鼻洞疾患)의 韓方 治驗 12例 金中鎬
  56. Text book of pediatric infectious disease Feigin, R.D.
  57. Clinical otolaryngology Dayal, V.
  58. Text book of pediatric infectious disease Feigin, R.D.
  59. Logan turners disease of nose, throat and ear Birrell, J.F.
  60. Boies Fundermentals of otolarynglogy Adams, G.L.
  61. J Laryngol Otol v.109 Antimicrobial management of chronic sinusitis in children Brook, I.
  62. Synopsis of Pediatrics Hughies, J.G.
  63. Laryngoscope v.107 Clinical Classification as a guide to treatment of sinusitis in children Weinberg, F.A.
  64. Otolaryngol Ciin N A v.29 Anatomic Variation in Pediatric Chronic sinusitis Lusk, R.P.
  65. 蘇氏諸病源後論 v.29 蘇元方
  66. 外臺秘要 (下) 王憙
  67. 小兒科 診療 洪彰義
  68. Diagnosis imaging of the nose and paranasal sinuses Glyn, A.S.
  69. Laryngoscope v.106 Endoscopic sinus surgery in the Developmentally Delayed Child Ramadan, H.H.
  70. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg v.33 The endoscopic endonasal surgical Technique in the treatment of chronic recurring sinusitis in children Wolf, G.
  71. 大韓 韓方 小兒科學會誌 v.10 加味通竅湯의 亢炎鎭痛 항알레르기 抗菌 에 대한 實驗的 硏究 金成煥