Diagnosis of Ictal Hyperperfusion Using Subtraction Image of Ictal and Interictal Brain Perfusion SPECT

발작기와 발작간기 뇌 관류 SPECT 감산영상을 이용한 간질원인 병소 진단

A robust algorithm to disclose and display the difference of ictal and interictal perfusion may facilitate the detection of ictal hyperfusion foci. Diagnostic performance of localizing epileptogenic zones with subtracted SPECT images was compared with the visual diagnosis using ictal and interictal SPECT, MR, or PET. Ietal and interictal Tc-99m-HMPAO cerebral perfusion SPECT images of 48 patients(pts) were processed to get parametric subtracted images. Epileptogenic foci of all pts were diagnosed by seizure free state after resection of epileptogenic zones. In subtraction SPECT, we used normalized difference ratio of pixel counts(ictal-interictal)/interictal ${\times}100%$) after correcting coordinates of ictal and interictal SPECT in semi-automatized 3-dimensional fashion. We found epileptogenic zones in subtraction SPECT and compared the performance with visual diagnosis of ictal and interictal SPECT, MR and PET using post-surgical diagnosis as gold standard. The concordance of subtraction SPECT and ictal-interictal SPECT was moderately good(kappa=0.49). The sensitivity of ictal-interictal SPECT was 73% and that of subtraction SPECT 58%. Positive predictive value of ictal-interictal SPECT was 76% and that of subtraction SPECT was 64%. There was no statistical difference between sensitivity or positive predictive values of subtraction SPECT and ictal-interictal SPECT, MR or PET. Such was also the case when we divided patients into temporal lobe epilepsy and neocortical epilepsy. We conclude that subtraction SPECT we produced had equivalent diagnostic performance compared with ictal-interictal SPECT in localizing epileptogenic zones. Additional value of these subtraction SPECT in clinical interpretation of ictal and interictal SPECT should be further evaluated.

수술로서 간질 병소가 확인된 환자들을 대상으로 한 이 연구에서 발작기-발작간기 SPECT를 비교 판독하여 간질병소를 국소화한 것과 영상을 위치 이동하여 좌표를 일치시키고 정규화 하여 감산하여 얻은 감산 SPECT로 국소화한 것이 대등한 진단성능을 지니고 있으며 감산 SPECT로부터 MR이나 PET과 같은 수준의 정보를 얻을 수 있음을 확인하였다. 감산 SPECT에서 발작기 혈류 증가를 범위와 강도를 고려한 적절한 역치를 설정하여 발작기-발작간기 SPECT에 더하여 감산 SPECT가 얼마나 부가적 진단가치를 가지는지 확립하여야 한다고 생각하였다.